10 Brilliant Video Games With TERRIBLE Endings

Games that had us hooked right up until the end, then completely lost us. Shame, that.

Deus Ex human revolution
Eidos

Flaws are inherent to storytelling. No matter how good of a product you produce, there's always going to be something wrong with it that some folks will demand that you be hanged for. Sometimes it's a bit of character writing, sometimes your pacing is just too off for some people to be able to deal with. And sometimes you screw up big time with your story by lagging on a non negotiable aspect of the story: the ending.

Whether you're talking about books, movies, or in this case, video games, the ending is considered by many to be absolutely paramount. It's the last moment we're getting to spend with these characters and this story, so you'd best make it memorable. In the case of video games, this is even more daunting since you not only have to make it satisfying from a story perspective, but gameplay as well.

Sure enough, not every game gets this right. But what about those games that had you hooked right up until the last moments when it completely lost you? What about those terrible endings to otherwise stone cold classic games? Well, then you get one of these very unfortunate cases of leaving your audience with whatever the video game equivalent of blue balls is.

10. Batman Arkham Asylum

batman arkham asylum titan joker
Rocksteady

Putting this at the bottom of the list, because it's more of an example of a bad final boss as opposed to a bad overall ending. But make no mistake, this was one disappointing end to an otherwise landmark title.

Granted, we're not sure how you could've done this right - seeing as how Batman: Arkham City proved that when the Joker and Batman go head to head, the Joker kinda has the cards stacked against him when it comes to actual fisticuffs. So if the Joker wanted a proper boss fight, he'd have to do something to tip the scales in his favor.

Which, according to Rocksteady Studios, means turning himself into a big lumbering monster with Freddy Kruger claws and a stupid ass mohawk.

The boss fight with him isn't even all that bad, it's just so underwhelming, especially compared to the awesomeness that had come before in the other 99% of this game. You just punchy him a bunch, then fight goons, then yank the Joker down with your grappling hook. Rinse and repeat for about three times until he stays down.


9. Borderlands

Borderlands 1
2K

When your own sequel refers to the end of your game as - and I quote - "tentacles and disappointment" then you know you have a problem.

Throughout the game, you're being hounded by the typical Borderlands super charismatic baddie that wants your ass on a silver platter for various reasons that ultimately don't matter. You are given every reason by the end to want these guys dead, especially when they get to your goal - the vault - before you do.

And then a giant monster pops up out of the vault and tentacles the villain you're actually invested in through the chest. Like we said, tentacles and disappointment.

The fight itself isn't even all that interesting to make up for it. Unlike the other bosses and baddies, this guy just stays in one plays taking damage like a sponge. So as long as you have somewhere to hide, you're safe. Bringing this fight down a numbers game, something the series bends over backwards trying to keep itself from becoming.

Is it any wonder that 2K clearly doesn't look back on this first outing with any kind of fondness?


8. Halo 2

Halo 2 Thumb
Microsoft

There are some entries that you probably knew from the start were gonna make their way onto this list somehow, and that the only shocking part would be where we actually put them. So it must be rather perplexing that one of the most infamously infuriating endings in gaming history is so low on the list.

Rest assured, we tried. But we just found the ones that come after this to be even more teeth grinding. But that doesn't make the ending to this game any less frustrating. After all, it's just four words: "Sir, finishing this fight" then bam, end credits. No indication of what he means by that or how he plans to achieve it. In fact, Halo 3 opens with him falling to Earth, with no signs that this takes place immediately after the end of Halo 2.

For a story that was easily one of the best paces Halo game stories up until that point, this was definitely disappointing to fans. Especially considering how long they had to wait until the third game actually let you make good on John 117's promise.


7. Vanquish

Vanquish game
Platinum Games

Nothing makes a game's ending worse than the assumption that you're going to get a sequel, and then molding your game's ending accordingly. In general, you should never do this, as even the most sure of sure things may not catch on depending on certain factors out of your control (just look up Osamu Tezuka's Steam Boy for proof of that).

Platinum Games' Vanquish is easily one of the most viscerally fun games ever made by a game company that specializes in viscerally fun games. Fast, action packed, with awesome mechanics like speeding up or slowing down time, and satisfying shooting. While the story is never the main reason that you play a Platinum game, the ending is still the ending, so you should at least try to make it a good one. That is NOT what happened here. At all.

Besides the many, MANY plot threads left hanging in the air by the end, the ending just feels a bit empty compared to the rest of the game. Not only does the main villain escape, the hero, Sam Gideon, is left adrift in space. With naught but the game's horrible voice acting to keep him company. Ad unlike Halo 2, there's no next game coming to answer those lingering questions.


6. Far Cry 2

Far Cry 2 Thumb
Ubisoft

Far Cry is known for its debbie downer endings, pretty much across the board. The most optimistic ending is probably 3's true ending, where Jason Brody returns home after his little extended vacation. And even then, if you'd actually played through the rest of the game, you're probably counting down to when he has to go to the DMV, and then proceeds to make a lovely summer home from the bones of his fellow citizens.

I was thinking of putting Far Cry 4's ending here, where you're either tricked into helping a religious militia or a child soldier fueled despot take over the country of Kyrat. But at least that one has an alternate ending where you learn the truth without being bamboozled.

No for this list, I chose the ending to Far Cry 2, where no matter which ending you choose, you die horribly, while the main bad guy, arms dealer The Jackal, gets away scot free. It's just a really anticlimactic end to what was otherwise an excellent survival shooter.


5. Dark Souls

Dark Souls Lord Vessel
From Software

It only makes sense that a series whose approach to storytelling can be summed up as noncommittal at the best of times, isn't really the best at making an ending.

Ask anyone who never got into Dark Souls (and even some fans) what their problem with the game's story is, and you'll usually get the same answer: nothing you do really matters. And they aren't wrong, as the game's ending so helpfully demonstrates. At the end of it all, you aren't really accomplishing or changing anything. You're just prolonging an already S$!&*# world state where everyone is either dead or insane, because the alternative is removing the latter of those two so that everything is just dead.

Nihilism can be fun if played for a joke, but if you're actually trying to make a point, and the only point you can make is pointlessness, that doesn't exactly make you smart. You can make a dark depressing story without making it utterly pointless, just look at Sekiro, which is just as dark, but is actually about something.


4. Knights Of The Old Republic 2

Star Wars Knights Of The Old Republic 2
Disney

If there's one series that is solely responsible for putting Bioware on the map, it would be Knights Of The Old Republic. However, they only really did one of the two KOTOR games, while the other one was handled by New Vegas devs Obsidian Entertainment. Which is fine, as they're immensely talented as well. However, you can clearly tell if you know the two companies well enough which did which.

For one, KOTOR 1 has a far superior ending. While KOTOR 2 will more than keep you hooked with its excellent update to the KOTOR formula and engaging story and characters, all of which center around calling into question everything the Jedi stand for, its ending is literally just a Q&A.

You defeat Kreia after either sacrificing or saving your entire crew and beating Kreia's little psycho Sith boytoy, and as a reward she chooses to tell you what becomes of your friends after this story is concluded. That's right, the epilogue to this game is straight up told step by step to you instead of actually showing you anything. At least Dragon Age: Origins let you read it for yourself set against some interesting imagery.


3. Deus Ex: Human Revolution

Deus Ex
Eidos

One type of game that can definitely rub people the wrong way with its ending are RPG's. Because of how story heavy they are, your ending to that story had better be damn good or people are going to get pretty rightly pissed.

Which brings us nicely to Deus Ex: Human Revolution. While the devs definitely learned their lesson in the next game, as Mankind Divided actually had a pretty decent ending, Human Revolution did what all bad RPG endings do and gave you a multiple choice question that resulted in different endings. Not based on your previous choices or anything, in fact they're completely cut off from the choices you made in the rest of the game, barring a few details here and there.

It's not the worst offender of this - oh no that's for the next entry - but it's still pretty disappointing compared to the rest of the game, which was one of the best RPG experiences of the last ten years. So to end on such a simplistic note was such a let down. Nowhere near as much as the next one, though.


2. Mass Effect 3

Mass Effect 3
BioWare

You ALL knew that this one was coming, don't act like you didn't.

The ending of Mass Effect 3 is so infamous that fans threw a hissy fit strong enough to actually make Bioware change it to please people. Whether sating the cries of angry fanboys was a good or bad thing in the long run is up to you to decide, but it speaks to how bad this ending was that it didn't really happen until this game hit the shelves.

And it WAS bad, despite my snark. It's basically what happened in Deus Ex, but somehow worse, since at least Human Revolution was the first game so it was starting things rather than ending them. This is the big finale of the series, the final battle with the eldritch reapers. This was the death of Commander Shepard and the destruction of the reapers. And it all boiled down to "do you want this ending, this ending, or this ending?"

Rather than achieving an ending based solely on the player's decisions (your decisions just decide how well the battle up until then actually goes for you, not the ending itself), Mass Effect 3 boiled down the fate of the universe to a multiple choice question. Which yes the rest of the game did, but this part made it more stark and apparent than ever before.


1. Half Life 2 Episode 2

Half-Life 2 Episode 2 Eli Dead
Valve

But then, at least Mass Effect 3 HAD an ending. Say what you will about it, it WAS an ending. Meanwhile Valve didn't even feel like giving us that much.

The reason everyone wants Half Life 3 so badly, and are so angry that they are definitely never, EVER going to get it, is because of the blue balls that Half Life 2 Episode 2 left us on. It ends on about as searing a cliffhanger as you can get, with major character Eli dead, you lying there one foot in the grave, and Alyx kneeling and weeping over Eli's dead body.

Roll credits! Yep, that is the last you ever see of these characters, this story, and indeed the entire franchise. With a major character dead and the bad guys victorious. Because Valve are basically printing money these days with steam, they have no reason to actually make anymore games. One of the most revolutionary game titles out there, will forever remain unfinished because the company behind it would rather make TF2 hats for the rest of time.

The other endings on this list may be bad, but they were endings, no doubt about it. This? This is nothing.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

John Tibbetts is a novelist in theory, a Whatculture contributor in practice, and a nerd all around who loves talking about movies, TV, anime, and video games more than he loves breathing. Which might be a problem in the long term, but eh, who can think that far ahead?