10 Brilliantly Written Characters Ruined By Game Mechanics

Dutch's camp made zero sense.

Red dead redemption 2 dutch
Rockstar

Video games are an interesting medium. They combine things like music, cinematography, world-building, and many other types of expression into one interactive experience. Because of this, you could say that video games have a certain narrative advantage when compared to other media like cinema or literature.

However, their impressive collection of narrative devices can clash with other elements across production.

Games don't just tell stories, after all. They are primarily designed to be played. And sometimes, those interactive aspects of a game can hinder its ability to present the narrative, including the way in which characters are portrayed.

A simple mechanic might turn a feared villain into a laughable joke, or a sympathetic companion into a blood-boiling quest giver that never shuts up.

And yes. There are obviously plenty of examples of game mechanics complimenting the story, but it is important to remember that this type of symbiosis isn't a guarantee.

Let's look at some examples of great characters ruined by game mechanics as a cautionary tale for all who dabble in video game writing.

10. Roman Bellic - Grand Theft Auto IV

Roman Bellic GTA IV
Rockstar

When people hear the name Roman Bellic, the first thing they think of isn't Niko's cousin, but an inconvenient phone call in the middle of a police chase asking you to go bowling.

Like any other character in the Grand Theft Auto series, Roman Bellic is neither a good man nor a bad man. He's a gambling addict and gets people in trouble, but at the end of the day, he truly cares about his friends and family.

Portraying this type of dynamic through cutscenes alone is tricky, which is why the makers of GTA IV decided to use one more mechanic to really drive Roman's affability home. The only problem is that their solution backfired horribly.

Early in the story, Roman will call the player and invite them to hang out, with bowling being his go-to activity. The intention here is to show that Roman cares about Niko and wants to help him get accustomed to living in America.

However, in practice, the calls get really annoying really quickly, especially if you are already busy with something else and have to make room for Roman, just so he won't get mad at you.

Well, at least we got some great memes out of it.


9. Brynjolf - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

Skyrim Dialogue
Bethesda

Brynjolf's character in Skyrim plays the perfect supporting role throughout the entirety of the Thieves Guild questline. He starts off as the man who introduces Dragonborn into the guild, then becomes a sort of mentor figure for them, and then finally a trusted companion that will follow you anywhere, no matter how ridiculous or crazy things can get.

Brynjolf's development throughout the quests is honestly one of the better parts of the Theives Guild storyline. When you finish all of it, it feels as though the two of you have gone through a lot together, and you can count Brynjolf among your closest friends in all of Skyrim.

Well, expect that you can't because he cannot be your companion, and since he's not a quest-giving NPC either, every time you talk with him, he will just respond with a quick "I'm busy" and then proceed to ignore you. In fact, because Brynjolf doesn't have a lot of voicelines after you become the leader of the Thieves Guild, he'll be telling you that he's too busy to talk to you all the time.

And just like that, the guy who literally joined a cult just to help you becomes an insufferable tool.


8. Colonel Autumn - Fallout 3

Fallout 3
Bethesda

Colonel Autumn is a brilliant villain for the story of Fallout 3 and a character that, even if you hate him, you have to commend his dedication to his cause.

As the Colonel of the genocidal Enclave, Autumn is a fearsome soldier who has earned quite the reputation for himself, both in terms of his combat abilities and his resourcefulness. This, combined with his absolute obsession over his faction's mission of "purifying" the wasteland, makes him a truly intimidating and worthy adversary for the player.

Unfortunately, it all falls apart right at the grand finale of the game, and it is all due to Fallout 3's combat system. Mainly, that it's as derpy as a kid on anesthesia after having their wisdom tooth pulled out.

If the player decides to have a final showdown with Colonel Autumn in the Project Purity chamber, the man certainly doesn't live up to his reputation. Instead of being a cold and calculated military man, Autumn will simply stand there, letting you unload a full magazine on him using your VATS and turn his brain into goop.

The man goes down so fast, it's almost insulting. A random raider would likely put up more of a fight than him.


7. Destroyer - Borderlands

Borderlands Destroyer
2K Games

The Destroyer is an interesting figure in the world of Borderlands.

It's a gargantuan Eldritch monster that was locked away by an ancient civilization and unknowingly released by the Vault Hunters. It is supposed to serve as an existential threat that raises the stakes in what is otherwise a lighthearted, if violent, story.

The cutscene that introduces the Destroyer really hypes the creature up to be the ultimate doom of reality, describing it as an immortal being that can only be temporarily stopped and locked away. If that was truly the case, the Destroyer would have been the best plot twist at the end of the game, but the problem is that the boss fight with the creature is just too easy.

Frustratingly easy.

The destroyer barely does anything throughout the fight, and the mechanic used to damage it is like something straight out of kindergarten. You need to shoot these massive purple sacs that are placed all over its body, and it would honestly be harder to miss them. The fight doesn't really take more than five minutes to finish.

Thankfully, the remastered version of Borderlands has improved the difficulty of the encounter and made the Destroyer's doomsday awakening slightly more believable.


6. Hoyt Volker - Far Cry 3

Hoyt Far Cry 3
Ubisoft

Although Hoyt Volker was supposed to be the main antagonist of Far Cry 3, his spotlight was taken from him by Vaas in the first half of the game. This said, Volker could've still been a pretty good villain in the second act if it weren't for how poorly his final altercation with Jason was handled.

After all, just like Vaas, Hoyt had the perfect qualities to be an intimidating but intriguing adversary. He was equally psychotic and ruthless, but unlike Vaas, Hoyt had his eyes set on more than just the Rook Islands, which made him a more concerning threat as well as a more satisfying target to kill.

Unfortunately, the final confrontation with Hoyt was anything but satisfying. Though the poker scene preceding it was genuinely intense, the actual knife fight with Hoyt was an uninspired and laughably easy sequence of quick-time events that was over in less than two minutes. The fight was an absolute joke, and it really undermined Hoyt's status as the mastermind behind the pirate activity on the Islands.

It's a real shame, considering that Vaas had a whole drug-fuelled narrative sequence attached to his death. It just shows that the developers could've done better with Hoyt.


5. Arceus - Pokémon

Arceus Pokemon
Nintendo

The sole concept of catching legendary Pokémon has always been pretty silly. It just doesn't seem right that ten-year-olds could capture creatures responsible for things like world-ending tsunamis or the actual space-time continuum and then pit them against Rattatas of random preschoolers.

However, there is one legendary Pokémon that really suffers from the battle and capture mechanics of the games: the literal god of the Pokémon world, Arceus.

Throughout the entire Pokémon franchise, Arceus has been portrayed as this enigmatic entity that created the universe. It's a figure of actual worship within the world, and he has always been shrouded in mystery.

That is, until a ten-year-old stuffs him into a Pokéball.

After that, Arceus is no better than your average Pokémon that can get hurt, poisoned, run out of moves, faint, and do many other not-so-godlike things.

There are so many questions that Pokemon mechanics raise when applied to Arceus. How does nurse Joy know how to heal a god? What impact would storing him on your PC have on the world?

Perhaps it's better not to look for answers, and perhaps Pokemon would be better off if Arceus remained just a myth.


4. Fi - Legend Of Zelda: Skyward Sword

the legend of zelda skyward sword
Nintendo

Back when Skyward Sword first came out, most critics were quick to point out the annoyance that was Fi. Her constant interruptions to give the player useless hints were somehow even more obnoxious than Navi's back in Ocarina of Time.

It also didn't help that the game would force her help onto you during pivotal moments, grinding the pacing to a painful halt.

The way in which Fi's character was handled is quite a shame, as according to some interviews with developers, Fi could've been to Link what Cortana is to Master Chief.

Nintendo's Hidemaro Fujibayashi said in 2011 that he envisioned Fi as the perfect companion for a silent protagonist like Link. She was supposed to be an all-knowing spirit of the Master Sword that would serve as both an assistant to Link, as well as a storyteller, providing context for newly visited locations and driving the narrative forward.

If these two functions were the only things Fi did in the game, her character would have complemented the story perfectly, instead of hindering it. She could have become just as likeable as Midna from Twilight Princess, but alas, what we got felt like an endless tutorial.


3. Preston Garvey - Fallout 4

Preston Garvey Fallout 4
Bethesda

Preston Garvey was easily one of the most hated characters in Fallout 4. His voice actor's line delivery was very un-ethusiastic, his faction felt very one-dimensional, and most importantly, he would never shut up about settlements that needed help. What his character ended up being for most players was an insufferable quest dispenser that constantly urged you to rescue nameless settlers all over the Commonwealth.

This didn't really have to be the only quality of Preston's character, though. You see, if Preston liked you well enough, he would open up to you and reveal an interesting struggle in his character.

It makes sense that Preston sounded so detached in the game, as the man was suffering from severe depression. As the last Minuteman, he understood that he was the last glimpse of hope for the people of the Commonwealth, but at the same time, it was hard for him to fulfil this role, as he himself stopped believing the Minutemen's cause could ever succeed.

Preston's inner conflict adds a lot of depth to not just his character but also his faction. However, because he was the Minutemen's go-to quest giver, the players didn't really get to see and appreciate this side of him.


2. The Gray Prince - The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion

Elder Scrolls Oblivion Arena
Bethesda

Although Bethesda's writing in Oblivion is quite robotic, sometimes it can surprise the player with an unexpected level of depth. The quest for the Grand Champion of the Cyrodiil Arena, the Gray Prince, does exactly that, though it doesn't quite stick the landing.

In the quest, the Gray Prince asks the player to find proof of his noble birthright. When the player investigates the prince's family castle, they discover he's actually half-vampire.

The revelation will horrify the Prince. He will consider his very existence a thing of evil and decide that he is not worthy of being the Grand Champion. After that, when the player challenges him for the title, the man will throw the fight and let you kill him.

This is a dramatic set-up that has the potential to make the player really question their actions. However, any sense of remorse is lost as due to Oblivion's stiff combat mechanics, the Gray Prince just sort of stands there as you slowly pummel him to death.

It removes any element of drama from the situation and makes the champion look like he's wondering what to eat that evening than anything worthwhile.


1. Dutch Van Der Linde - Read Dead Redemption 2

Dutch van der Linde
Rockstar

The core conflict of Dutch van der Linde's personality lies in his relationship with the members of his own gang. He is supposed to be a leader they look up to and trust with their lives. However, as time goes on, they start to notice the cracks in his confident facade, realising Dutch's vision of a free life in the Wild West is just a hopeless dream.

The way this conflict is showcased in Red Dead Redemption 2 is through Dutch's promise to use the robbery money to let everybody retire in Tahiti by buying a mango farm. The player is supposed to donate money to Dutch's fund in the hopes of realizing this dream, only to slowly come to the conclusion that their contribution is being wasted.

The problem here is that the in-game economy is completely busted. Doing side quests, treasure hunts, collecting bounties, and even receiving huge cash rewards by completing the main story missions will easily earn you tens of thousands of dollars by the end of even Chapter 3. You'll be able to donate an absurdly high figure to Dutch's fund like it's nothing, so his incessant whining about needing to do "one more score" seems like a bad joke at best.

How about having "some goddamn faith" in yourself for a change?


Watch Next


Contributor

Video games enthusiast with a love for bizarre facts about his favorite titles. Really into old-school strategies and RPGs of all shapes and sizes.