10 Broken Games That Are GOD-TIER Now

Halo is back to how well it played in 2007.

Halo Infinite
343 Industries

It is a sad fact of the games industry today that games tend to come out in a, to use the most generous term possible, utterly f%#king broken, insultingly unplayable state that makes you want to tear your own brain out with a plastic spork. Don't ask what the least generous term is, some things are better left unsaid. 

It unfortunately appears to be the norm that games be released unfinished and be fixed after release with day 1 patches. And that's if you're lucky. Some games are so broken upon their release that fixing the problems and making the game the devs wanted at the start can take months or even years. 

But some do manage to come back. And they do it so well that they're now regarded as stone-cold masterpieces. 

They say you never get a second chance at a good first impression, but these 10 games do the best out of all of them to prove that notion wrong. Whether releasing with key features missing or just being flat out unplayable at launch, these games fell flat on their faces, yet still somehow took home the gold. 

10. Street Fighter V

Ryu Street Fighter V
Capcom

It is hard to imagine a bigger bag fumble than Street Fighter V when it first released. Mainly due to it being a follow-up to Street Fighter IV, which many fans consider to be the savior of the entire fighting game genre.

So anything less than "savior of its entire genre" was bound to be a disappointment. But even with that olive branch being extended, that doesn't change the fact that SFV was just flat-out not finished upon release.

On the single-player front, Street Fighter V shipped with no campaign, no arcade mode, and a survival mode that one would call barebones if they felt inclined to be insulting to bones. And then there was the multiplayer, which was the most egregious insult to fans. the standard number of player hosting for multiplayer lobbies in a fighting game is around 8, but SFV could only host 2. And that's if the lobbies worked at all.

This was a bit beyond what a simple Day 1 Patch could fix, and sure enough, Street Fighter V took 3 entire years before it entered a state that fans consider to be decent.

Nowadays, SFV has an entire fanbase, who - shock of shocks - are absolutely willing to pay money for it, now that it's an actual finished game.


9. Halo: Master Chief Collection

halo master chief collection
Microsoft/343 Industries

Halo has been around as long as the Xbox, so it was inevitable that Microsoft and 343 Studios would try to make sure that current-gen players can access all of the previous games without having to spend hundreds of dollars on multiple previous-gen systems. 

Unfortunately, Halo: The Master Chief Collection really could've used more time in the oven. 

Upon release, the game was panned across the board by both fans and critics for being virtually unplayable. The game came out of the gate riddled with technical issues, both on the single-player and multiplayer front. Trying to improve the framerate for the original trilogy from 30 to 60fps ironically just made the framerate worse, if you played co-op, but weren't the host, then you'd get a full second of input lag, and that's on top of the usual stuff like constant crashes. 

But the multiplayer - the thing Halo fans buy a Halo game for - was the part that got hit the hardest. Matchmaking was an absolute nightmare, with teams being obscenely uneven, assuming matchmaking even connected you to a game at all. 

It wasn't until the PC port that things began to improve. After that, and a bunch of heavy patching, The Master Chief Collection has finally seen the success it should have had from the beginning. 


8. Fallout: New Vegas

Fallout: New Vegas Ultra Luxe
Bethesda

Obsidian's reputation is a double-edged sword. On one hand, they're known for being one of the best western RPG developers in gaming history, making RPGs that stand the test of time. But on the hand, their games can often come out...undercooked. 

One of the funniest offenders of this is, ironically, their magnum opus: Fallout: New Vegas.

Fallout: New Vegas wasn't unplayable upon release, but it was damn close to it. Even looking past the occasional glitch like the infamous rotating head, the launch version of New Vegas also suffered from obscenely long load times, low FPS, and constant crashing. The CTD problem is still an issue for many PC players, to this day. 

Fortunately, after a lot of patching, the biggest holes in Obsidian's proudest ship were plugged, and New Vegas has since gone on to be widely accepted as the best Fallout game in the entire franchise. While it may have had an incredibly rough first year, barely anyone remembers it anymore, allowing New Vegas to thrive as it deserves.


7. Sea Of Thieves

Sea of Thieves
Microsoft

When you are making a purely online game, the first thing - the primary thing, one could say - that you have to get right is making sure the connection remains stable across the board. Especially for an online game like Sea of Thieves, which requires you and your friends to be working in tandem to keep your ship running. Unfortunately, that was the biggest issue many players had with Rareware's pirate title upon release. 

But even beyond that, the game was just flat-out empty for the first few months of its life. The primary goal of becoming a pirate legend required months of boring grinding through repetitive battles. Sea of Thieves was just not interesting enough to commit to for the first stretch of its life. 

Fortunately, the game has more than turned things around in the time since. Now, not only are the connection issues basically fixed across the board, but the updates have stuffed the game to bursting with things to do with your pals as you traverse the seven seas. It helps that the core gameplay loop of Sea of Thieves was always solid and fun, unlike the more recent Skull and Bones - which is missing many features that Sea of Thieves had at launch. 

With better online connection and loads of more stuff to do, Sea of Thieves is one of the most fun online games out right now. 


6. Battlefield 2042

Battlefield 2042
EA

2021 was not a good year for Battlefield, and this game is unfortunately why. Upon release, 2042 almost immediately took the crown as the worst Battlefield game in the entire franchise, and for a series that stretches back to 2002, that's an accomplishment in and of itself. 

Battlefield 2042 drew ire almost immediately for that most unforgivable sin of FPS games in today's world: awful online. Not only were the maps way too big and the combat not as interesting as it could've been, but those two critiques require you to even be able to get into a match at all - which most players couldn't. It was also missing multiple industry-standard features at launch, such as a scoreboard. And then there were the glitches, many of which screwed up player XP progression. 

And if you wanted to give the single-player campaign a try instead, well, too bad. Because there wasn't one. 

In the two years since, though? Battlefield 2042 has more than turned it around. Not only is the online play stable, it's a marked improvement over previous entries in a lot of ways. A single-player campaign has been added, and online matches are made infinitely more fun with a variety of QoL improvements. 

Battlefield 2042 has gone from one of the worst entries in the entire series, to one of the best by a considerable distance. 


5. Pokemon Scarlet & Violet

Scarlet Violet Picnic
The Pokémon Company

Pokemon games, though as financially successful as they've ever been, have seen a decline in quality over the last decade - mainly due to Game Freak's stubborn refusal to use that money to expand their development staff. Sword and Shield's less-than-consistent textures almost immediately became a meme, and then Scarlet and Violet came along. 

While not materially worse than Sword and Shield, it wasn't a marked improvement either, and on a technical front, it was even worse. Upon release, the game was plagued by graphical and performance issues from top to bottom. Some of them were just annoying, like an inconsistent draw distance, while others were actual game-breaking bugs. 

Fortunately, in the two years since its release, Game Freak has implemented multiple patches to fix the worst of the issues. As for the lack of content, the game has seen multiple expansions with new areas, battles, storylines, and Pokemon. Scarlet and Violet have just released their last DLC expansion earlier this year, bookending a rocky beginning with a rock-solid finale. 


4. Star Wars Battlefront 2

Star Wars Battlefront 2 Jakku
EA

One of the most reviled game releases of its time, Star Wars Battlefront 2 was - ironically - mostly solid from a gameplay standpoint. No, if you want to know what made folks despise this game so much, it all lies in the microtransactions. 

Every online game has some form of microtransaction, but Battlefront 2 went over the line by locking incredibly powerful characters and weapons behind its loot boxes. This one tiny detail more or less broke the entire game over its knee, as it allowed players to essentially buy their way to victory (since the biggest flaw with this game is that the side that unlocks the most heroes will always win). 

This not only turned the entire fanbase on the game, but even got EA in trouble with the law on accusations of gambling. 

As you can imagine, backtracking was inevitable. The loot box system was completely reworked, and hero characters were unlocked for everyone. The tide turned in Battlefront 2's favor practically overnight, because shock of shocks, remove the thing keeping the game from being fun, and it becomes...fun. Who could've guessed?


3. No Man's Sky

No Man's Sky
Hello Games

These last three entries are the gold standard for games coming back from the worst possible first impression, and no better way to start than with No Man's Sky.

Words cannot adequately describe the hype that No Man's Sky produced with that original trailer. But due to multiple incidents along development, the worst of which was their office flooding, the game that was shipped was far from the game that was promised. 

To be blunt, more or less the entire game was missing. While perfectly stable and without any major glitches, the game was just flat-out empty. None of what makes the game great nowadays was there, and what was there was nowhere near enough to satiate an increasingly irate audience. The backlash to NMS' release was immense, the game becoming a universal symbol for empty promises by a developer. 

But, obviously, that wasn't the end of the story. Over the next few years, Hello Games set about putting in all of the stuff that was meant to be there from the start, and some more on top of it while they were at it. No Man's Sky is now considered one of the best open-world games out right now, with a litany of new features that enhance the experience without taking away from the core idea of exploration. 


2. Cyberpunk 2077

cyberpunk 2077
CD Projekt RED

The ultimate evolution of the hype/backlash phenomenon of No Man's Sky was Cyberpunk 2077. I distinctly remember seeing that first teaser trailer for the game when I was a kid, and almost a decade later, Cyberpunk 2077 came out to universal, unrepentant, overwhelming HATE.

Yeah, turns out that, with a development time that long, and with The Witcher 3 having just put a bow on their biggest IP, CD Projekt RED's bosses were pretty dogged about getting this game done as soon as possible. Which meant a lot of crunch to get it over the finish line. This resulted in the game being almost unplayable upon release from how broken it was. While the glitches were more funny than game-breaking, they were so numerous as to be unacceptable. 

However, ask an RPG fan what their favorite game is these days, and Cyberpunk 2077 will be pretty high up that list. This is because CD Projekt RED have dedicated the past several years to repairing the game and turning the narrative around. A seemingly impossible task, to anyone who was there when the game dropped originally. But god damn if they didn't do exactly that. 

Cyberpunk 2077 is now one of the most lauded games of the last several years, with its latest DLC, Phantom Liberty, receiving near-universal acclaim. 


1. Final Fantasy XIV

FFXIV Shadowbringers
Square-Enix

All of the previous entries pale in comparison to the utter disaster that was FFXIV when it first launched. A bomb so complete and overwhelming that the president of Square Enix admitted to it having done great damage to the brand. The worst major MMORPG on the market by some considerable distance. 

So how did we get to today, where not only is FFXIV still going, but running rings around whatever MMOs are still standing over a decade later? Well, simply put, they burned the whole god-forsaken thing to the ground.

When the current director, Naoki Yoshida, took over, his first edict was to reboot the entire thing. FFXIV 1.0 just had too many fires to put out as is, so the better plan was to just start from scratch. And so 1.0 died in a glorious CGI cutscene fire, and what came after was 2.0 - better known as A Realm Reborn. 

A Realm Reborn relaunched the entire thing with a new UI, a brand-new storyline, and completely overhauled combat. From there, FFXIV has only built on itself, until it has become the epic, fast-paced action MMORPG it is today. Final Fantasy XIV Online is now the most profitable game in the franchise - and if we're being honest - probably the only thing really keeping the lights on at Square Enix these days. 


Contributor
Contributor

John Tibbetts is a novelist in theory, a Whatculture contributor in practice, and a nerd all around who loves talking about movies, TV, anime, and video games more than he loves breathing. Which might be a problem in the long term, but eh, who can think that far ahead?