10 Brutally Hard Decisions Video Games Forced You To Make

To chop off your own arm or not. That, is the question.

For a while in the late 2000s, it felt like moral choices in games were only going to be a flash-in-the-pan type deal. Mass Effect and GTA IV showcased some of the most meaningful, as various pivotal scenes played out in strikingly different ways depending on what you'd done beforehand.

Then things went pretty quiet... until 2012's The Walking Dead decided the act of choosing dialogue options was the game itself. Telltale's narrative gem came out of nowhere and changed everything all over again, and although the act of branching the experience had existed in games before, The Walking Dead became a definitive step up - one that you can feel the ramifications of in every narrative-driven game to this day.

Back to the choices themselves though; although modern titles feature more branching options than ever, if we're talking about the most meaningful, most gut-wrenching, and most timeless in gaming history, well... they're not going to be pleasant.


10. Killing Dwayne Or Playboy X - Grand Theft Auto IV

Rockstar

GTA IV's car handling might have been so hard to get a handle on that it retains its status as the outlier in an otherwise solid canon of video games. One thing it absolutely nailed, however, was atmosphere and tone.

Niko's bleak tale of seeking 'the American Dream' off the back of broken promises from his cousin was a very interesting one, as well as the situations he found himself in because of it. Enter Dwayne, a former high-profile gangster who emerges from a considerable stint in prison, only to find one Playboy X has overtaken what was once his. Out of sheer pride and dissatisfaction for the way things now are, he's an incredibly dour individual - but one that Niko gets on with.

There comes a point where both Playboy and Dwayne decide the other must be taken out, but as you're an associate of both, the game leaves the decision up to you. Do you take out the wounded, respected old dog who looks to be on a downward spiral, or the peppy young upstart who's more cocky than a KFC production line? Blowing Playboy's brains out nets you his swanky condo pad, whereas killing Dwayne only results in more sorrow for Niko, and you can only choose one...


9. Save The City, Your Family, Or Be Rich? - Fable II

Lionhead Studios

Quite possibly the worst 'would you rather?' question ever. The close of Fable II has you answering a question set by the all-powerful Theresa - one that can reverse all the ills of the world done by Lucien - or one that can make you the true monster of the adventure.

It's literally laid out in front of you with three cards, denoting that either all the people who have lost their lives at the hands of Lucien's Spire can be resurrected (sans zombie features, presumably), your family can come back alongside your beloved dog who's only just perished at this point in the story - OR, you can be rich beyond your wildest dreams.

Later DLC would actually take some of the weight out of these decisions as you could get your dog back a different way, and thinking outside the box for a moment highlights the fact that untold riches essentially breaks a ton of progression for the endgame - however, taken at face value, this is one hell of a meaningful choice that exists only in a sea of grey morality.


8. Withstand Torture And Be The Hero, Or Let Your Companion Die - Metal Gear Solid

Konami

Now, you can totally argue that this wasn't too hard - if you were playing on a lower difficulty. The very setup of having you bash buttons, Track & Field-style to save your lover-to-be was a great one no matter what, but on any of the higher levels, it was almost impossible.

The scene is set up to essentially let Ocelot have some fun in torturing you, and he repeatedly mentions that it'd be easier if you just gave up. Doing so means he will kill Meryl, whereas hanging on meant you'd both find a way of getting out alive. The great part was that back in 1998, we'd never seen such a cinematic presentation from a game before, let alone the notion that we actually had a choice in the matter. Hammering away at those buttons like your life depended on it, effortlessly and intrinsically connected you to the action onscreen, with consequences that - thanks to the time MGS was released - felt just as uncertain as to you as they did to Solid Snake.

Hideo Kojima would later repeat this 'smash the d-pad to stay alive' idea in MGS 4 during Solid Snake's corridor crawl, but this first time remains the best - especially if you're unaware of how the story is going to go. Let us know in the comments whether you saved Meryl, or gave up just to see what would happen!


7. Not Having The Courage To Tell Someone You Love Them - Emily Is Away

emily is away
Kyle Seeley

Developed by Kyle Seeley and actually available for free on Steam, Emily is Away is a narrative-focused game all set within an old-school instant-messaging client. Now, that description might make some people leap out the nearest window, but its execution of what a certain generation's furtive exploration of digital interaction was like works wonders in retrospect for anyone in their mid-twenties and up.

Framed across a number if interactions over time, you talk to the titular Emily across high school and college, going through the motions of flirting with the idea of being with her, hearing about her other relationships, having some of your own, and gradually growing apart. It's a great comment on how we change and slowly lose many of the friends we grow up with, and if you've ever been in the position of falling for someone, only to have life's circumstances get in the way, it'll play your heartstrings like a violin. Why? Because near the close of the game you have the option - depending on other things you've said to this point - to tell Emily how you really feel. However, in typing out the appropriate sentiment, your character will delete the sentence and reply with something far more mundane.

You realise you don't have the courage to say what's needed despite everything, and one by one the dialogue options get more and more pedestrian, until you must decide to say goodbye to her for good.


6. Chopping Off Your Own Arm - The Walking Dead: Season 1

Season 1 of TWD had a huge amount of grey area choices to get through, whether it be putting the child, Duck, out of his misery as he slowly turned into a walker, taking the food of a family away from their car - or here, deciding to try and stymie the spread of infection by hacking off a much-needed limb.

Rather like Metal Gear Solid's choice earlier, this was the first time the game had given you a choice with an unknown mechanical outcome. If you lost the arm, would that impact Lee's ability to survive later down the line? Perhaps you wouldn't be able to interact with the environment in the same way? We didn't know, but the fact that more walkers were baying for blood in the next room meant you had to make a choice, fast.

Whatever you did, the main thread plays out in the same way, but unlike the TV show that seems to have lost the ability to portray the harsh reality of doing anything to survive a zombie apocalypse, this scene grounded it in an incredibly visceral way that showed Telltale at the top of their game.


5. Which Half Of The Game Do You Want To See? - The Witcher 2: Assassins Of Kings

CD Projekt RED

The flip-side to a choice that feels incredibly hard in the moment, is one given further weight and perspective after the fact. As such, the geniuses over at CD Projekt RED elected to pretty much create two entirely different middle chapters for the second Witcher game, anchoring the reveal of each to a choice between siding with the 'terrorist'/freedom fighter Iorveth, or Geralt's friend, Vernon Roche.

Going with either puts you on opposite sides of a major racial conflict happening across the continent, but frames it differently as you'll journey to totally separate areas, receive wildly altering quests, meet individual NPCs, have contrasting dialogue exchanges, etc. Such a decision is what makes CDPR one of the most underrated developers out there, and although many gamers got through Assassin's of Kings without realising the other path was literally a completely different play-space, going back through and choosing the other is very much an enjoyable, eye-opening experience.


4. Choosing How To Torture An Innocent Man - GTA V

An interview back in 2013 when GTA V first dropped had a member of Rockstar note that if you thought Trevor's torture segment was too strong, you always had the option to "turn the game off." Personally though, if you have to choose to disengage with a given thing to get a desired response, I'd say that product has failed in its delivery.

Regardless, this scene went on to define GTA V, not because you had the option to skip the scene or fight against the people asking you to perform it, but because the only choice present is "What weapon do you want to use?" The bottom line is supposed to be a comment on American foreign policy, or just how ineffective forcing someone to say something really is, but it's lost under the miasma of dark undertones that make the entire scene feel completely disgusting.

Trevor is hardly an arbiter for moral sanctity, so when it's him delivering a speech about how torture is just a way for those enacting it to enjoy themselves rather than 'doing what's necessary', it gets lost under the horror of being forced to play through it in the first place.


3. Using White Phosphorus On 'Enemy Troops' - Spec Ops: The Line

2K Games

Another determinate masquerading as a choice - but that's entirely the point - there's a beat in Yager Development's military shooter that really makes you question just how desensitised we've become to violence in video games. Or have we? Is it all just mindless fun (yes), and is there something worth pointing out about how if you give a player the means to enact carnage on the biggest scale possible, that we'll do it without question?

Spec-Ops attempted to highlight this idea by having your trio of soldiers come up against a closed-off, enemy-filled expanse of land. You quickly notice they have within their possession some hazardous and skin-burning white phosphorus, yet you're given the choice to try and move through the area stealthily, or by other means. Following a few minutes of trying though, it's clear you're going to have to 'bring in the big guns'. That is, if you hadn't leaped at the chance of torching the whole lot of them already, and it's in pursuing this bloodlust that Spec-Ops made a point for the ages.

The mode used to control the phosphorus deployment is not that far away from Call of Duty 4's AC-130 heat-cam, and as you drop the bombs on various platoons, you'll find a group of heat signatures all clumped together, and pull the trigger with glee. Except... they weren't soldiers, they were hostages. If the whole setup played out as intended, the resulting "What have I done?!" sensation is something games very rarely - if ever - get right, and it remains one of the best medium-specific examples of a feeling games can pull off better than anything else.


2. Mass Effect 3's Ending

Bioware

Although in the years past, fans have applied a more positive, retrospective spin on Mass Effect 3's initially godawful ending, if we're talking about what it was like to play through it at the time, there was nothing more mentally paralysing that having to choose between three terrible options that made no sense, hadn't been appropriately set up, and were already completely unfulfilling.

Fans who played were thoroughly disgusted. After hundreds of hours crafting your custom Shepard and guiding him or her towards an eventuality that would save the universe by uniting all the races under one cause, the result was bowing down to a spectral entity who appeared as a small child, dictating you could either destroy the encroaching Reapers, merge with them, or create a new state of being for all life in the galaxy. Such a supernatural-themed idea for the latter two didn't have any weight or place in a series formerly based in hard sci-fi and explanations for literally everything, and the former - although appropriate - still vaporised all of Earth and saw your crew stranded in a new galaxy anyway.

Mass Effect 3's denouement would go down in history as the worst example of publisher meddling in developer scheduling to date, a result that hampered the game overall, and provided an immortal sour taste Bioware are still trying to shake to this day.


1. Executing An Innocent Man To Save Your Son - Heavy Rain

The world needs more creatives like David Cage - providing they have producers to reign them in here and there. Whereas Fahrenheit/Indigo Prophecy and Beyond: Two Souls were far too ludicrous for their own good (you actually fought the internet at one point in the former), Heavy Rain sits nicely in the middle as a murder-mystery spread out across four different protagonists, all contributing to an eventual endgame.

One such character is Ethan Mars, the badly voice-acted but ultimately likable father of Jason ("JAY-SON!") and Sean, the latter of which he gets set on a handful of violent 'trials' by the devious Origami Killer to prove his love for. About midway through the game you'll be asked to kill a man, just seemingly for the sake of it. Heavy Rain always let you resign Ethan's fate to that of the justice department if you so decided, and that was part of the appeal - it was literally asking you, "How far would you go to save your son?" in every respect.

You find out through the course of talking to the guy that he's a drug dealer, but that he also has two children, with the game's visualisation of thought patterns weighing up the 'pros' and 'cons' of the situation in Mars' head in real-time. If you go through with the decision, Ethan will throw up and find out the next piece of the puzzle was in the gun barrel all along, and if you leave, you've failed the killer's demands, reconciling son Sean to an early grave unless you can somehow find his location through other means.

-

What other insanely harsh video game choices have you come across? Let us know in the comments!


Watch Next


In this post: 
Mass Effect 3
 
First Posted On: 
Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.