10 Character Designs That RUINED Video Games
From Bomberman to Shadow the Hedgehog and human Shelob, these character designs were big mistakes!
What makes a video game character bad? Well, all sorts of factors go into that. Maybe it’s just a matter of morality (they’re the ‘baddie’), maybe they’re a weaker party member in an RPG or a low-tier pick in a fighting game. Perhaps they’re an NPC who only offers up the most feeble sidequests. There are all kinds of criteria.
Still other characters are simply annoying. Ashley Graham’s continuous banshee-howls of “LEEEEEEON! HEEEEEELP!” In Resident Evil 4 did nothing to endear her to the player, neither did Navi’s repeated exhortations to “Listen!” in The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. In both characters’ defence, though, they were pretty well on the money design-wise. Bad characters and characters with bad visual designs aren’t necessarily the same thing.
To illustrate this fact, we’re going to take a look at some party members, fighters and NPCs that just don’t cut the mustard in the visual sense. From The Witcher's identikit NPCs to the worst rendition of Bomberman ever conceived by humankind, you’d better strap in: this is going to be one wild ride.
10. Crash Bandicoot - Crash: Mind Over Mutant
By 2008, long-time fans of the Crash Bandicoot series had a darn solid idea of what the fuzzy orange marsupial looked like. After all, the original trilogy offered some of the most beloved and technically solid platforming action anywhere on the PS1. The little guy had become a household name, and had quite a reputation to uphold as a result.
Sadly, after Crash Bandicoot 3: Warped (1998) and Crash Team Racing (1999), he never really reached those heights again. This wasn’t for the want of trying, as several Crash titles emerged in the following years, but they seemed to make one of two mistakes: either straying too far from the formula that made Crash a star in the first place, or rigidly clinging to it like a furious toddler who wants those sweets in the supermarket.
Crash of the Titans and Crash: Mind Over Mutant both updated the bandicoot’s model, which is always a perilous thing to do. If there’s one thing gamers don’t take kindly to, it’s a heavy-handed revamp to a super popular design. This new stylized furball failed to strike a chord with many, and became emblematic of Crash's 'edgy' teenager years.
9. Spyro The Dragon - Skylanders
Being a spin-off of the Spyro the Dragon series, it was inevitable that the scaly little purple legend himself would appear prominently in Skylanders. True enough, he serves as the team’s leader in the absence of Master Eon, making him a crucial member of the crew. Sadly, though, this isn’t Spyro the Dragon as nostalgic fans remember him.
Again, those of us who grew up with this PlayStation legend have a special place in our hearts for him. They remember him as he was. Spyro was a huge part of Skylanders’ appeal, so it was crucial that they represented him accurately in the game itself. Where, then, did this little anti-Spyro abomination come from?
The design brief seemed to have been to make Spyro more threatening, more draconic. Perhaps I can see the reasoning behind this, but… that voice! Those scales! His all-around sinister nature! Far from the lovable little dragon-in-training from the original series, this take on Spyro looks more like the hideous lovechild of Barney the Dinosaur and Gollum from The Lord of the Rings. That’s not a thought we want to dwell on, so let’s move swiftly on.
8. Chris Redfield - Resident Evil 5
As we all know, the Resident Evil franchise experienced one heck of a paradigm shift on Resident Evil 4’s release. After this game’s success, the following two releases continued a trend towards third-person shooter sensibilities. Who needs slow, atmospheric survival horror when you can simply blast your way through all monsters with a huge array of silly weapons? Less Alone in the Dark, more Commando (or Commando Directors Cut: Now Arnold Schwarzenegger Has Even More Darn Guns).
Resident Evil 4 may have seen Leon S. Kennedy suplexing his foes so hard that their heads exploded on the ground, but that was nothing compared to our muscular friend Chris Redfield. The iconic co-star of the original game has clearly been working out, because he suddenly has monstrous, ham-like arms that even Umbrella’s most hideous B.O.Ws probably fear.
As serious (well, downright melodramatic) as the Resident Evil games tend to be, tone-wise, some of Chris’ feats of strength throughout the fifth title are utterly absurd. The series will probably never live down the whole ‘punching that boulder into pebbles’ thing. Judging by the many memes on the subject, fans will never forgive it either.
7. Samus Aran - Metroid: Other M
Of course, this isn’t to say that some of our favorite characters can’t change, evolve and look radically different. Take the Metroid series, for instance. Nintendo icon Samus Aran is most frequently seen in her Power Suit getup, exploring desolate, hostile planets wiping out intergalactic threats like the unstoppable heroine she is. At the same time, though, she’s equally at home in something a little less cumbersome, infiltrating and exploring as the equally-beloved Zero Suit Samus.
That’s the key thing to keep in mind, though: whether clad in her armor or not, she’s the same tenacious, formidable, consummate professional. We know who she is and what she’s capable of, so every Metroid title worthy of the name needs to deliver that.
This was the issue with Metroid: Other M, which arrived on Nintendo’s Wii in 2010. With this title, Samus offered up some voice-acting for the very first time, and fans were dismayed by what they heard. She was fearful and emotionally fragile throughout. While a lot of this is perfectly natural, considering the harrowing nature of her past experiences, this does more than add nuance to the character: it casts everything we thought we knew about her into doubt. After such a long wait for another instalment, Other M was considered a betrayal of fans.
6. Shadow The Hedgehog - Shadow The Hedgehog
We can appreciate Shadow the Hedgehog, we really can. A bit of a dark and edgy vibe never hurt anyone, as all those players who immediately opt for Link’s black costume with the red eyes in Super Smash Bros. (which is everybody) will tell you.
You’ll notice, though, that we specified a bit of an edgy vibe. When Shadow’s at his dark and brooding anti-hero best, he’s exhibiting just the right amount. In his own game, sadly, he was clearly trying much, much too hard. You can tell just by looking at him.
While 2005’s Shadow the Hedgehog deserves praise for its replayability (there are over 300 different routes to take through the game, depending on mission choices the player makes) and bold genre-blending, some of these decisions just didn’t pay off. The G.U.N. soldiers, the TPS elements, the firearms Shadow totes and cheesy lines he spouts throughout... I totally get that he’s meant as an anti-hero foil to Sonic himself, but his characterization in the game went way over the top.
5. Several Re-Used Models - The Witcher
Granted, all kinds of titles in a range of genres are guilty of this, but The Witcher offered one of the higher-profile (and so most egregious) examples. The fact is, huge, bustling RPGs and open-world titles have many, many NPCs to populate their worlds with. They can’t all be entirely distinct. However, there are ways of downplaying this and there are ways of making it super obvious.
In The Witcher, it wasn’t just that the same body types were reused in a subtle way. The same faces cropped up time and again, and not just in the background either. Some more important characters were ‘recycled’ in this way, which was a real shame.
Things have improved and intrepid modders have provided work-arounds for this issue, but there’s no denying that this really hurt the first game’s sense of immersion. The Witcher franchise is renowned for its atmosphere and worldbuilding, quite rightly, which makes issues like these all the more troublesome.
4. Bomberman - Bomberman: Act Zero
If you’re a gamer of a certain age, you’ve almost certainly had some experience with Bomberman. The long-running franchise made its debut in the 1980s and the core formula has remained largely unchanged ever since.
The key concept is to gradually destroy parts of a maze with your bombs, with a later focus on multiplayer (reaching your friends with your bombs and immolating them in a loving yet often rage-inducing way). This popular party game was expanded with all kinds of silly rules, modes and concepts along the way, but has always been defined by the cartoony, adorable nature of it all. Most importantly, of Bomberman himself.
Sadly, though, this is another instantly recognisable character who has been subject to an entirely unrecognisable ‘edgy’ redesign. 2006’s Bomberman: Act Zero took everything fans knew and loved about the cutesy franchise and regurgitated seventeen tons of sci-fi drama all over it. While it played in a remarkably similar fashion, the futuristic and super serious vibes just didn’t gel with the concept at all.
Throw in its technical problems, excessive time to load and bland, repetitive presentation and you’ve got a real mess of a Bomberman game.
3. Cole McGrath - Infamous 2
A lot of the time in the gaming industry, developers and publishers stick to their guns and go right ahead with what they’re doing, despite the backlash. This, however, can be hugely detrimental. It’s always the bigger person who admits that they screwed up and rectifies their mistakes. This humble attitude saved the Sonic the Hedgehog movie (man was that a terrible character design originally, but that’s a different article) and also did wonders for InFamous 2.
Fans of the original came to know and love Cole McGrath, a young man given unique powers after an explosion rocks Empire City. Depending on the moral choices the player makes over the course of the game, McGrath can become a hero, a bit of an anti-hero or a quite the villain. Either way, players became very attached to this unique protagonist, being as satisfying to play as he was.
For the sequel, Sucker Punch rejigged his design, giving him more of a ‘lived-in’ action star look. The version of the character originally shown off to fans (at E3 2010) did not go down well at all, to the extent that the team were seeming forced to relent and re-work him again. The Cole seen in Infamous 2 is one of three different versions of him the team went through!
2. Quiet - Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain
Metal Gear Solid maestro Hideo Kojima has never been afraid of a little controversy, of stepping way the heck off the beaten track whenever and wherever he can. While he was at the helm of the series, it was well known for tempering its super serious plots and three-month-long Codex conversations with a little silliness.
Kojima’s eccentricity was always at the forefront, giving us priceless moments like that endless ladder climb to nowhere in Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater. Later in the series, though, he’d take that penchant for wackiness a little too far.
Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain courted controversy for the character of Quiet and her… well, less is more approach to clothing. We later learn that Quiet’s design is the way it is because she was treated by the parasite “the one that covers” after sustaining terrible injuries. She drinks and photosynthesises through her skin, hence that one notorious scene where she dances in the rain like Gene Kelly.
Sounds entirely legitimate to me.
1. Shelob - Middle-earth: Shadow of War
Needless to say, the world and lore of the Lord of the Rings is some of the deepest and most intriguing in literature. The sheer depth and breadth of this world, its backstory and the fascinating beings within it is mind-boggling. Nobody, not even superfans, can come remotely close to knowing everything there is to know about Middle-earth. It’s a wonder Tolkien did.
Having said that, though, we all know the basics. Hobbits, for instance, are tiny, adorable creatures with feet hairy enough to serve as in-built slippers. Gandalf has the most glorious wizard beard this size of Albus Dumbledore (Michael Gambon gets bonus points here for accessorising his with stylish beard bands in the movies). Shelob, meanwhile, is a gigantic, horrifying spider-thing.
What is Shelob not? A human woman. Still, Middle-earth: Shadow of War doesn’t seem to have gotten that memo.
In the game, Shelob is able to transform at will into an attractive human woman with dark hair and darker robes. Developer Monolith have explained that these shapeshifting shenanigans came about as a way of expressing the duality between Shelob and Galadriel, but the fact remains: this decision came as a heck of a shock. We all know what sticklers fans can be towards source material.
Watch Next
Metal Gear Solid Quiz: How Well Do You REALLY Known The Games?