10 Common Misconceptions About Accessibility In Video Games

In a handy list format, for ease of access.

Sekiro Shadows Die Twice
FromSoftware

Accessibility is a topic that’s only going to get more and more prevalent and important as time goes on.

What, you thought human hardship and physical disability was a flash in the pan-type deal?

Recently, however, I’ve noticed a truly disturbing trend of slamming accessibility on social media, as if it’s something to be demonised, or even feared. Why have we reached this point?

I am, personally, disabled. Though my disability isn’t a severe one by any stretch of the imagination (grade 3 osteoporosis - think of my bones as being like Cadbury Crunchie), it does inhibit my ability to do certain things, and that includes long stretches of playing particularly stressful games.

(By the way, I did finish Sekiro, and no, I didn’t find the lack of accessibility options “refreshing” - I found it tedious having to stop playing every 30 minutes whilst my wrists stopped being inflamed. Why do people keep insisting that I should enjoy “the satisfaction” of getting through a video game despite the physical pain?!)

But, maybe you are one of those people! Maybe... you believe one or more of these misconceptions about accessibility in video games?

10. Making A Game Accessible Makes It Too Easy

Overwatch lucio
Blizzard

If you’ve been gaming for a while, you might know about “skill floors” and “skill ceilings”. They refer to the initial barriers to entry (the “floor”) and the overall potential (the “ceiling”).

Take Overwatch, for example - a character like Widowmaker needs extremely high accuracy and game sense in order to get value from, so her skill floor - or her minimum level of ability - is high.

A character like Lucio, however, can have value to his team by merely existing, so his skill floor could be regarded as very low. Players of significantly differing natural aptitude levels can play in the same game of Overwatch, then, and have equal levels of value (despite Widowmaker mains being smelly jobby-jaws).

This is true to reality, too, believe it or not - some people are just intrinsically stronger, faster, more charismatic... and find life really easy.

Other people, though, find even more banal or simplistic tasks a trial. And, when it comes to someone with a disability, those tasks might, in a normal situation, actually turn out to be impossible (without any sort of accessibility intervention).

And that’s all this is - it’s recognising that some individuals have far higher innate barriers in their way than others. That it’s not just about “getting over it” and “enjoying the same difficulty together” - we all have our own privileges, circumstances, and of course... personal skill floors and ceilings.


9. Accessibility Options Create An Unfair Multiplayer Space

Counter Strike
Valve

You know what makes you a total loser? Playing online whilst using an aimbot.

Playing a game of Counter Strike and you’re locked on to KillaBluntzz420 for the whole five minutes and still have the nerve to gloat about your win in the chat window afterwards? Not cool.

However, is the situation any different if your opponent has a neurological condition and can’t move the mouse rapidly? Or what if they have a motor dysfunction and need a little software/hardware-based helping hand to assist with that aim?

The huge difference? The first individual is just being a a-hole and getting an unfair advantage, whilst the latter wants to get onto a relatively level playing field with their peers.

There’s quite a distinction between wanting to outright cheat, and wanting to have the option to compete at a mechanically-similar level.

”Well, if there are options there, some people will just abuse them!” Said one angry Redditor, perpetually replete with rage. Well, my furious friend - perhaps you have more of a problem with bad people that abuse power than you do with options to facilitate the needy and differently-abled?

Something to think about.


8. Accessibility Sacrifices The Director’s Vision

Sekiro Shadows Die Twice
From Software

One of the more strange arguments against accessibility options is that “it sacrifices the vision of the creative director” to include them.

Accessibility options exist as a way to facilitate as many people as possible playing your game. By that logic, the “creative vision” is... limiting how many people can play it? Is that a creative vision?!

During the backlash after the release of Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice, many people were totally against accessibility options, claiming that “anything that makes the game any easier or mechanically simple to play would ruin the original vision”.

Of course, this is a totally insane thing to say, because, as mentioned - the vision for Sekiro was not elitism or exclusion - it was to create a pseudo-fantastic feudal Japanese action game with tense, aggressive combat.

To say that the vision of that game is nothing more than... well, exclusive mechanical difficulty... is totally reductionist, and does a huge disservice to the whole, rich and varied Sekiro experience.

Hell, if you’re a creative director and your vision is just “only a handful of people deserve to play this game”, then your vision’s crap, and you’re a crap person, with a crap face.


7. “Nobody Is Interested In That Feature”

Forrest Gump Ice Cream
Paramount Pictures

How often do you hear this? I hear it a lot, but then again, I visit Gamefaqs.

It’s perhaps the most daft one on this list, because it could really apply to anything - like,“why does the Ben and Jerry’s counter at the cinema have rum raisin as an option? Nobody wants rum raisin!”, or “why do they even offer that channel in standard definition? Nobody watches that!”

Yet, without ever having met any of these people, I know that some guy’s watching the latest Fast and The Furious and chowing down on a dehydrated grape treat, and some little grandma's cracking into a one-hour-late fuzzy omnibus of Come Dine With Me.

Why is it that people insist, because they don’t use something, nobody does?

I reckon it has to be a part of this hyperbolic world we now live in - it’s either “best thing evarr”, or “worst thing in the universe”. It’s either “everyone’s doing it” or “nobody does that!”.

Sometimes, it’s just... sometimes. Sometimes, only some people are interested. And it’s fine if that doesn’t include you. Sometimes.


6. Accessibility Is All About Big Changes

Cyberpunk Changes
CD Projekt

Accessibility is all about making small changes and/or additions which go a long way. It’s strange to me that there’s still people who challenge me on social media, insisting that accessibility’s going to somehow require some major structural overhaul of an experience.

The chances are, you’ve almost certainly already encountered accessibility options for far longer than you were aware. For example, have you ever heard of a little something called... subtitles?

Accessibility options are everywhere, like woodlice in a soggy table shop. You might not see them all the time, but you know they’re there, under the surface, creeping around and serving purposes most people don’t understand. And, unlike woodlice, they’re not abhorrent perversions of the natural order.

It’s not all overhauling game design documents - accessibility is, quite often, about tiny little features which, for certain individuals, change a great deal. If you’ve ever played a game without the option to invert the Y-axis (and you’re one of those folk who seek out such sordid affairs), you can appreciate all those other games that do offer it.

Little options that change a lot.


5. You Need Special Hardware To Make A Game Accessible

Special Effect
Special Effect

If you’ve looked into game accessibility before, the chances are you’ll have run into Special Effect - a UK-based charity that does some phenomenal work in allowing the disabled gaming community to play the games they love, often creating bespoke controllers, armatures and chairs tailored to individual circumstances.

However, as incredible as the work they do is, sometimes (and when I say, “sometimes”, I actually mean... most of the time) accessibility options are a lot more subtle, and entirely design/software-based.

At a far more fundamental level, accessibility options can be considered when creating a game - things like, “does this UI element only change its colour to show its state? That’s no good for the colourblind”, or “does this action offer haptic feedback that rumbles differently to other actions? That’ll be good for the sight-impaired”.

Though special hardware isn’t always required for accessibility options (and in the majority of cases, clever design is more than enough to suffice), when hardware is required, we’re all very lucky we have Special Effect (and, more recently, Microsoft’s Adaptive Controller team) to lend an additional hand.


4. Accessibility Features Are Not Cost-Effective

Tony Stark Rich
marvel

Did you know that around 15%-20% of gamers are disabled? 14% of the adult population read at a mental age of 11 or younger. And, up to 10% of the gaming population have some form of red-green perception difficulties.

So, if you just take that top number - a fifth - that’s one out of every five gamers that may need additional accessibility options. Can you imagine not catering to one out of every five potential customers in any business?

Heck, I’m useless at business and even I know you don’t alienate every thumb out of a hand!

During my time in the Agency at Ubisoft Reflections (an internal art team focused on presentations and marketing), I was approached to do some art for a colourblindness presentation.

The developer presenting it blew my mind - with about a week’s work for two people in a AAA studio, all four main colourblindness options could be covered via carefully-chosen palettes.

And, at a design/software level, the costs are all considerably low for the majority of more frequent maladies (hearing impaired, colourblindness, partial motor dysfunction), and let’s be honest - even if they weren’t... would you really want to ostracise every cello player in a quintet?


3. Not All Genres Are Suited To Accessibility Options

team sonic racing
Sega

This one tends to gain traction not because of genres, but those specific titles within those genres used as gatekeeping tools.

For example, you could say “action-adventure or racing games can’t be accessible because of their presumed difficulty and intricacy, because Bloodborne and Assetto Corsa are both demanding and relentless in terms of input”, but that’s fallacious on two different levels.

For starters - those games do have accessibility options (with Assetto Corsa in particular offering some screen and button remapping options for a more tailored play).

What those individuals mean isn’t that it can’t be accessible, but rather that this isn’t a game for more casual players. The distinction isn’t subtle - the two aren’t synonymous, you silly wee goosles. You can make a hardcore game accessible.

Secondly, that’s generalising - there are more games in a genre than just those at the extreme end of the hardcore-o-spectrum. Ratchet and Clank sits in the same genre as Bloodborne. Sonic and Sega All Stars Racing Transformed sits in the same genre as Assetto Corsa. To say that a single game typifies an entire genre is bonkers - can you imagine deciding you didn’t like comedy films just because you watched Jack and Jill?

Actually, come to think of it, in that specific scenario, I wouldn’t actually blame you.


2. Not All Games Are For All People

Batista Wheelchair 2010
WWE.com

And no, smartass, I’m not talking about personal preference.

What I’m talking about is, when an individual wants to play a game, but physically can’t, and some Allen Key (a person who is a tool who just exists to wind things up) says, “well, I guess that isn’t for you, go do something else”.

I’ve spoken to so many individuals who were limited by their disabilities - from women suffering from debilitating fibromyalgia to a man without the use of his legs - that have, at some point, been told by an Allen Key that the thing they wish to do... exists in a world that excludes by default.

How sad is that?

Yet, those same individuals who were told they couldn’t (and shouldn’t) do roller derby or basketball, respectively, ended up doing exactly those things. The roller derby league started doing a limited-contact version, and a local gym started up its on wheelchair basketball. Those games they wanted to play were never impossible for them, so long as the accessibility options existed.*

*It’s worth noting that, when posing this question on Reddit, I was stunned that some individuals saying “they’re not the same games, it’s not the real version”. Guys, is that really going to be the hill you die on? Fighting against accessible gaming options... because of technicalities?


1. Accessibility Features Are Just For Disabled Gamers

Captain America Civil War Police
Disney

“But, how will we POLICE it?!”, said the gamer who was disturbingly over-interested in the personal hobbies of another person he’d never met before. “How do we KNOW it’s only the disabled people that are using these features? People could ABUSE those options!”

Have you ever taken the lift when you could have taken the stairs? Like, ever? Or bought pre-chopped onions instead of buying them whole, even though you have the chopping arm of a lumberjack?

My disability is, in the grand scheme of things, pretty minor. I get to enjoy most of my life just fine (with a few special caveats and a lot of extra resting). But y’know what? If given the option, I’ll play games on easier difficulties, or if the game allows for gameplay parameter tailoring (like the recent Star Wars: Fallen Order and its option to allow you to extend the window for parrying), I’ll do that too.

And, even if I didn’t have to play Pain Roulette(tm) and woke up tomorrow completely healed - I reckon I’d keep doing it.

You know why? Because gaming is my release. It’s my escapism. It’s fun, it’s relaxing, and it’s a bit of peace. Of course, yes, these features exist to help those that need them, first and foremost... but, just like the Vegan Fillet Burger at KFC, you don’t need to be an insufferable Turbo Vegan to enjoy one.

After all, they’re optional. That’s why they’re called options.


Contributor
Contributor

Hiya, you lot! I'm Tommy, a 39-year-old game developer from Scotland - I live on the East coast in an adorable beachside village. I've worked on Need for Speed, Cake Bash, Tom Clancy's The Division, Driver San Francisco, Viva Pinata: Trouble in Paradise, Kameo 2 and much more. I enjoy a pun and, of course, suffer fools gladly! Join me on Twitter at @TotoMimoTweets for more opinion diarrhoea.