10 Controversial Video Games Everybody Totally Misunderstood

When in doubt, implicate a game in a murder. That always goes down well...

Bully T
Rockstar Games

Not even the most gasoline-aided wildfire will spread like a good ol' media controversy. Those behind the actual information are purportedly fighting for a specific cause, whilst whoever's on the opposing side are curious and seeking information - all while anyone in between just wants it to be over. Regardless of where you sit, either way, you're receiving updates as to what's going on at all times.

So, take a newsworthy angle that always guarantees traction, add in the most passionate and loyal bunch of fans this side of a wrestling pay-per-view, and you've got a hearty recipe for guaranteed headline-grabbing attention.

That said though, in the pursuit of creating said headlines, too many - far too many - outlets don't arm themselves with all the facts before kickstarting the most controversial angle possible. It's always far easier to scream "Hey, look at this!" than it is to know what you're looking at in the first place, and the following games most definitely benefit from the value gained in retrospection and hindsight.

10. Hotline Miami 2: Wrong Number - The 'Graphic Rape' Scene

Hotline Miami
Devolver Digital

Whether or not Hotline Miami's graphic violence is in bad taste or not (personally, I'm going with it being f*cking glorious) isn't the point - what is, comes from the fact that at the very beginning of the game, there's an implied rape scene about to take place, which is quickly revealed to be on the set of a film.

Obviously, all many media outlets needed to run with were the words 'rape' and 'video game', and as such, to this day thousands of gamers still think Dennaton's sequel opens with the aforementioned act. In actual fact, the scene plays out as such: Your character knocks a woman to the ground, gets on top of her, drops his trousers - then the off-set director yells "Cut!"

That's it.

Again, whether even putting such a scene in a game is defensible at all is purely subjective - the reality is that HM2 has been saddled with something that wasn't even true - even resulting in a ban in Australia. Their ratings board described the scene as such; "He is viewed pinning the female down by the arms and lying on top of her thrusting, implicitly raping her (either rear entry or anally) while her legs are viewed kicking as she struggles beneath him."

As you can see above, this is simply not true. A horrific attempted act, sure, with questionable intentions even if you really like Dennaton as a studio - but an actual rape scene, it is not.


9. Mass Effect Was A 'Sex Simulator'

mass effect liara sex scene
Bioware

Chances are there's going to be a lot of Fox News popping up in this list - they're simply the kings of taking a completely threadbare news story and running with it until the resulting patchwork is suffocating the Western hemisphere.

Case in point: Mass Effect's seemingly random portrayal as a 'sex simulator', coming from a good, ooh, say two at the most sex scenes? Anyone who'd played Bioware's sci-fi magnum opus knew the idea of watching characters shack up was the last thing the game was being sold on, but Fox News dug their talons in deep. Across the game's launch they literally printed and repeatedly supported their own lies, describing the game having "full digital nudity and the ability for players to engage in graphic sex".

What was the scene they were referring to though? Well, all of them in theory, but the one that got the most airtime was this 'raunchy' clip between Shepard and Liara:

'Graphic', right? Player participation, yes? Well...

It came to a head across 2008, when EA themselves had to step in and quell the false reporting, to which they eventually abated as only a couple anchors and 'specialists' apologised off air. Lastly, if you're questioning just how many people took it all seriously, just look at the very fact Donald Trump is even doing anything in a political context.


8. Tomb Raider - The 'Attempted Rape' Sequence

Sometimes the want and need to tread lightly around certain subject matters ends up leading to some of the most leaden footwork you can hear a mile off. Tomb Raider's 2013 reboot was supposed to be a revamped look at the world's most famous female archaeologist, but instead was overshadowed by some cack-handed comments from the developers themselves.

In just one quick interview with Kotaku, years of pre-production work was thrown to the wayside, as producer Ron Rosenberg painted a picture of Lara not as the twin pistol-toting badass of yesteryear, but as a "cornered animal you'd want to protect". He then went on to describe a scene where the enemies on the island would attempt to rape her, despite it not being in the game whatsoever.

This then turned into speculation around what the scene in question was, leading to launch day as we all found out it couldn't be further away from a 'rape scene' if it tried. A male character certainly does get very close in Lara's personal space, but nothing else of any sexual nature occurs. The scene is pegged more as Lara fighting against a physical force she cannot overcome, and whilst that does play into a description akin to rape, the fact it was so far away from Rosenberg's comments speaks volumes as to how things can be blown out of proportion by all involved.

Naturally the rest of the world didn't care, and 2013's Lara remains one of the most overlooked and underrated third-person action adventures of all time, forever damned by an image problem it would completely avoid in-game.


7. Bulletstorm - "The Worst Video Game In The World"

You what? It's been longer than a few moments since Fox News freaked out about something? Very true, let's remedy that, shall we?

In a story that's even weirder now that time has passed and it's vanished into the ether altogether, Fox decided to go after Epic Games' Gears of War-followup, Bulletstorm, in 2011. Why? Probably because the name sounds like something 90s Bart Simpson would play when Marge and Homer are away, but mostly because the game's way of making combos out of violent acts struck a chord with their production team.

They even went as far as relating the ease of which players could settle into violent acts with sexually-fuelled labels (killing groups of enemies is called a 'Gang Bang') to claiming that was why a rise in reported rapes was happening across the country.

Now THAT, is some sensationalised 'journalism'.


6. Bully 'Glorified' Bullying

Rockstar can't seem to stay out the firing line for too long either, but they're most definitely aware of the sorts of controversies coming their way when designing something called Bully, that just happens to have been built with GTA III's engine.

However, as is the case with all of these entries, if the outlets and outraged parents actually spent hands-on time with the product itself, they'd have realised the reality was a far cry from what was being shouted about at the time. Playing as one Jimmy Hopkins and attempting to survive in Bullworth Academy, you were thrown into the same sort of hierarchal public school structure millions of us endured every day.

At no point were you encouraged or told to 'bully' anyone, any more than GTA III let you kill prostitutes if you decided that's how you wanted to spend your time. No part of the game was scored on causing misery to those less fortunate than yourself - actually quite the opposite, as you occasionally worked with all the various factions to gain the upper hand on the Bullies themselves, who were portrayed as monosyllabic neanderthals.


5. DOOM - Blamed For Columbine Massacre

Everyone from video games to Marilyn Manson was blamed for the abhorrent Columbine shooting of 1999, following America (and by proxy, the world) struggling to understand how such a disgusting attack could happen on their own soil.

Pretty much everything the shooters Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold showed an interest in became the go-to accused properties of choice, with one game in particular standing out from the rest - the gore-filled Doom, of which Harris noted he'd used a shotgun in the attack, specifically because of how much he enjoyed the one in the game.

Obviously in reality, this falls under the same interpretation banner as any maniacally-minded individual taking 'influence' from something and developing their own twisted read on it. Literature has Catcher in the Rye implicated as the reason Mark David Chapman shot John Lennon, and across gaming history, Doom stands out as one of those times thousands of people needed something to blame, only for Doom's blood-soaked exterior to be the perfect candidate.


4. Grand Theft Auto III - 'Encouraged' You To Kill Prostitutes

gta 3 prostitues
Rockstar

"Have you heard about that game where you can kill prostitutes?" became a byline for GTA III in the early noughties, they'd say - as if somehow Rockstar's world-changing release only gave you one thing to do.

It's certainly easy to look back on it now and brush all the reactionary criticisms and 'in-depth studies' under the rug, but at the time, the sheer amount of stories centring not on the fact you could pilot a flaming car into a squad of innocent people - but that you could rob a hooker, now thatwas news.

The whole thing still reverberates around the cosmos to this day, as writer and journo-legend Adam Sessler once noted in a recent radio interview that he'd been asked about that game where you "kill hookers for points", proving there are those who still characterised their first open-world experience by targeting prostitutes, rather than, say, exploring the freakin' world itself?!


3. Call Of Duty 4 - Branded A 'Terrorist Simulator'

Call Of Duty 4 Modern Warfare
Activision

Tackling the No Russian mission a few years later is a bit of a mixed bag - however, one thing Infinity Ward didn't do back in 2009 was put together what became known as a 'terrorist simulator'.

The context of the level came in the form of maintaining your cover as an American agent pretending to be a Russian terrorist, who as part of a group, were attempting to frame the US by using American firearms, hence the phrase "No Russian" referring to not speaking. Let's avoid the fact it came across as being in spectacularly bad taste, as objectively you were put in the shoes of a person with a gun in an airport, and the only gameplay options involved massacring scores of innocent people or walking through the level and watching it all unfold.

In an interview with PCGamer, designer Mohammed Alavi stated the intent was "to do three things". Infinity Ward wanted to "sell why Russia would attack the US, make the player have an emotional connection to the bad guy Makarov, and do that in a memorable and engaging way."

Naturally there was enough controversy here to kickstart a few year's worth of right-wing news bulletins, and the press had a field day drawing parallels between the level and real-world terrorist attacks that happened at the time - not to mention doing the standard "Won't somebody think of the children" dance. In the end though, the team - although going way overboard in doing so - just wanted you to really care about shooting the dastardly Makarov at the close of the story.

Mission... accomplished?


2. Grand Theft Auto V - Trevor's Torture Scene Was Supposed To Be Fun

GTA Torture
Rockstar Games

Another one that's really too brazen for its own good, Trevor's torture scene in GTA V was more cack-handed than a sewage worker who's dropped his watch. Rockstar came across as a group of multi-millionaires trying desperately to court controversy for the sake of it, but that said - there's a bit more going on than just overindulgent violence.

Rockstar were intentionally drawing comparisons to the American military's well-documented use of torture techniques to gain confessions and information, a point that gets lost when the mission gets finished regardless, your victim sputtering out a brief description of a target that gets taken out by some candid American officials. Following this mission the world just keeps on turning, as Trevor certainly doesn't care about what he's involved in, and despite the person you're torturing being taken to an airport, there's no mention whatsoever of their survival for the rest of the game.

With all that said though, the general reception of such an immaturely framed scene completely centred around the aesthetics of torture, as oppose to the reasoning behind it - even if was done poorly.


1. Manhunt - It Was Implicated In A Real Murder

manhunt video game
Rockstar North

As DOOM was the go-to for pent-up Columbine anger, Manhunt got listed during the unfolding of another truly saddening crime; one of 14 year-old Stefan Pakeerah being brutally murdered by Warren LeBlanc. LeBlanc was reported multiple times to be a fan of the game, so much so that the label for the act became the 'Manhunt murder', the entire thing being reinforced by the fact a hammer could be used to bludgeon gang members in the game, and was also used for the crime itself.

Rockstar must have known what they were walking into with a game literally about murdering people in as many gory ways as possible, but when all was said and done, the media got one massive thing wrong - it wasn't LeBlanc who owned a copy of the game, it was Pakeerah.

This blew a rather large hole in the entire "blame the game" ideology, and it was revealed Manhunt was merely reported as being part of the case, the majority of the association between it and the killer being entirely the product of media sensationalism.

Because of course it was.

Were there any other games commonly labelled as controversial for the wrong reasons? Let us know in the comments!


In this post: 
Mass Effect
 
First Posted On: 
Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.