10 Controversial Video Games That Are Insanely Tame Today
From fatalities to friendships.
Violence in video games seems to be a nearly-evergreen debate, and just when it seems to have gone away, fresh controversy or political posturing will force it back into the spotlight. Not long ago, the official White House YouTube channel posted a montage of apparently heinous violent video game scenes, and it was ludicrous.
Yet, while Trevor Phillips and Master Chief draw the perpetual ire of middle-aged soccer moms, it's tough for many to take theses arguments seriously. Pac-man may munch on ghosts, and Mario may stomp on goombas, but neither of them have ever wrought any serious societal ills.
The anger of the non-gaming populace may seem totally misplaced, but, in earlier eras of gaming history, it was even more so. Games like Street Fighter, Castlevania, and Megaman may seem like some of the most benign media entities available today, but there was once a time during which politicians and activists alike considered them to be a major issue.
It's hilarious to go back and recognize just how totally inane some of the public outcry leveled against gaming truly was. The White House's video may seem out of touch, but it can hardly compare to these ten squabbles from yesteryear.
10. Doom (1993)
Id Software's 1993 hallmark FPS title Doom is recognized as one of the pioneering games of its genre, and many respect it today for boldly going where no game had gone before. Sure, it doesn't look like much today, but it was a big deal 25 years ago.
Disgustingly realistic in that it forced the player into a first-person view, Doom quite literally shoved the violence right in the faces of those who booted it up. Those blocky, pixelated imps and gruff, unrefined gore effects may look beyond tame today, but lots of kids in 1993 had to take great care to ensure that their parents never caught them playing this game.
The outcry was, to a point, understandable, as a game of such dark and mature subject matter had never been so fully realized up until that time, and, compared to most PC games of the era, it was downright true-to-life in terms of visual fidelity.
Clunky MIDI files and red and pink pixel meshes don't make for realistic violence, however, and it's doubtful that Doom was ever the cause of most of the issues for which it was blamed.
9. Perfect Dark (2000)
During their tenure as a third party developer for Nintendo during the heydays of the fifth console generation, Rare produced what would go on to be some of the most beloved Nintendo 64 games ever released. Though they would later be bought by Microsoft and forced into obscurity, games like Banjo-Kazooie, Donkey Kong 64, and Goldeneye are still fan favorites and industry highlights.
2000's Perfect Dark is one of the lesser-known Rare titles, though that isn't for a lack of publicity. In fact, the game stirred up quite a bit of controversy when it was first released, as it was the first ever M-rated game released on a Nintendo console. Granted, the ESRB rating system was still a pretty new thing at the time.
Though certainly serviceable for the era, Rare's Perfect Dark seems so incredibly dated today that it's difficult to believe that anyone would find it objectionable. If James Bond's unique brand of flirtatious espionage didn't raise any eyebrows when translated to Nintendo's hardware, it doesn't make sense that Perfect Dark would have.
8. Leisure Suit Larry: Land Of The Lounge Lizards (1987)
Western culture is often criticized for normalizing hyper-violence in media while lambasting anything remotely sexual: red spatter and gray matter have been blockbuster staples for years, but anything below-the-belt is still pretty much a no-go in most circumstances.
The utterly crude, half-human facsimiles computers could be made to render in the mid 1980s hardly allowed for anything even remotely raunchy, but Sierra challenged these limitations with the 1987 release of Leisure Suit Larry: Land of the Lounge Lizards. Though the game's NPCs were made almost unrecognizable thanks to the primitive VGA cards of the time, they can at least be credited for their efforts.
The subject of inevitable controversy, the Leisure Suit Larry series can, in some strange way, be thought of as a sleazy pioneer, a perverse trendsetter. Today, however, these early titles are downright hideous and borderline hard to look at, and Larry and his exploits are just as irrelevant as the rest of his 1980s home-computing ilk.
7. Hatred (2015)
2015's relatively unknown top-down murder simulator Hatred has, a mere three years after release, been consigned to the forgotten annals of indie video game obscurity. Boring, clunky, and so visceral and malicious as to be overtly inane, few had anything good to say about this black-and-white shooting spree when it first released.
However, at one point, the game looked as if it might never see the light of day as an adults only ESRB rating meant that Steam wouldn't sell it. The premise and imagery included in the game were enough to shock and offend much of the gaming populace, but the outrage was quickly outed as having been manufactured by an indie studio eager to drum up some press coverage.
Artistically bereft and wholly uninteresting, Hatred may have a small cult following today, but it certainly didn't live up to the likes of its controversial video game forefathers. It can be picked up for pennies on the dollar today, though even curious Steam users should think twice before wasting their time with this waste of digital space.
6. Death Race (1976)
Video gaming formed essentially from nothing: though intricate and robust enough to be considered as a form of art these days, the earliest games were quite literally nothing more than a set of bleeping, blooping dots. Seriously, those who grew up in the 1970s and 1980s had it rough.
Yet, even with such underdeveloped tech, game designers still managed to cause outrage. One of the first games to ever bare the brunt of parental and political anguish came in the form of 1976's Death Race. An arcade cabinet containing nearly neolithic technical specs, the on-screen renderings only offered players the most vague approximation of what was supposed to be taking place in-game.
The goal was, shockingly enough, to run over as many human-looking gremlins as possible. A small, cross-shaped gravestone would mark the spot of each collision, and the game was so totally tame that tapping out numbers half-resembling rude words on an old calculator would seem more offensive by comparison. If only the people of 1976 could get a load of some of the games today.
5. Carmageddon (1997)
Something of a spiritual successor to Death Race, 1997's PC classic Carmageddon was, among a slew of other violent titles of the time, helping to usher in a new era of polygonal gore and viscera. Not even close to shocking compared to what's been made in the twenty-odd years since its release, this darling of a bygone era was once considered to be completely inappropriate for most audiences.
Heavily censored in multiple countries and outright banned in Brazil, Carmageddon was found to be objectionable based on the game's premise: players were sometimes tasked with running over every single civilian present on a given track. A shower of poorly rendered red fluid would follow every successful collision, but the game was so over-the-top and tongue-in-cheek that only those looking to be offended ever really were.
Remastered and re-released on more consoles and devices than could possibly be concisely surmised, this game still stands as a bit of an icon for late 1990s gamers. Those who found it utterly vile would later focus their attentions on DMA Design's Grand Theft Auto, which would release in October of that same year.
4. Chiller (1986)
It must be said that, though totally banal today, 1986's cult arcade hit Chiller would have been pretty horrific at the time. Reminiscent of a romp through a new Field of Screams attraction really looking to earn a reputation, this arcade lightgun game may have caused more than a few sleepless nights.
However, the content presented in this game could hardly be said to rival the likes of movies like The Texas Chainsaw Massacre or Nightmare on Elm Street, and yet this piece of interactive media was somehow considered to be far more offensive. The bulk of the game does revolve around flaying the skin from the bodies of the on-screen targets, but the artwork is so crude that this fossil of a game would have a tough time getting a rise out of anyone today.
It is impressive to think that this blood-soaked experience made the rounds in arcades more than thirty years ago—not to mention it's unofficial NES port—but Chiller is so laughably dated these days that the ESRB would probably rate it 'T' for teen.
3. Night Trap (1992)
1992's Sega CD sleeper hit Night Trap was possibly one of the most inoffensive games to ever cause public outrage. For starters, the Sega CD was a failure of a Genesis peripheral that would be forgotten mere months after its initial release. Plus, the game's heavy use of FMV reeked of burgeoning 1990s tech trends and polluted the overall experience.
The game was initially flagged for its depiction of violence against women, but that accusation is so shallow that the Mario Brothers may as well be banned for violence against animals. Even through the eyes of a young and impressionable child, Night Trap still would have been a total yawn-fest.
Much of the backlash likely stemmed from the fact that, for the first time, the acts depicted in a game weren't compeltely digital—they were real actors, and the game brought a sense of authenticity which the crude hardware of the time could never replicate. However, those outraged by the game likely never played it—if they had, they probably wouldn't have been nearly as worked up about it.
2. Grand Theft Auto (1997)
Briefly and inaccurately surmised by politicians at the time as a game in which players kill strippers to earn points, the original Grand Theft Auto was, alongside games like Carmageddon, totally offensive to the non-gaming populace of the day.
We've made a ton of progress since DMA Design—now known as Rockstar Games—released the first top-down entry into what would become one of the most recognizable and profitable franchises in video game history. Yet, the game almost requires a microscope to make out any identifiable human characters, and much of the gameplay is far too over-the-top to be taken seriously.
While movies and books have been capitalizing on the genre for ages, video games centered around crime or illicit activities of any sort seem to be, for whatever reason, inexcusable. Few chose to point the finger at masterpieces like The Godfather, Goodfellas, or the Sopranos, but when a computer is forced to render such apparently vile imagery, that's where the line is crossed. If only the concerned parents of 1997 could have known what the Grand Theft Auto series would eventually grow to become (or if they'd realised it had been slapped with an 18 rating).
1. Mortal Kombat (1992)
1992 must have been a year fraught with more moral panic than the red-baited era of McCarthyism: both Night Trap and Mortal Kombat saw release that year, and it must have made many a Sunday school teacher shake their fists in anger.
Mortal Kombat might have been the most publicly vilified video game to ever exist. It offered some of the most visceral gameplay available at the time, and the digitized actors utilized by the game made the whole thing seem incredibly 'realistic'. Today, Mortal Kombat X seems infinitely more real, even without the use of actors, and it puts the crude renderings used in the series' debut arcade outing to shame.
However, at the time, parents and government officials lost their minds, and we can only assume the serious demeanor Reagan might have affected were he in office during this digital epidemic. It's a wonder that awful, corrupting interactive media like Splatterhouse, Doom, and Mortal Kombat didn't turn the nation's youth into a bunch of psychopaths. Wait, on second thought, it really isn't.