10 Creative Ways Video Games Fought Cheaters
Dealing with cheating scum in highly imaginative ways.
Though modern gaming has tried its damnedest to stamp out cheats, it's been an undeniable part of the medium's DNA since its inception, with players keenly finding ways to circumvent traditional gameplay with or without the developers' help.
And while cheating in a single-player game is basically a victimless "crime," sometimes developers aren't so keen on having their carefully curated gameplay messed with, and especially not where online multiplayer titles are concerned.
And so, following up our two previous articles on the subject, we come to 10 creative ways that video games managed to combat cheating players.
Developers have proven over the decades that they're a smart bunch when it comes to ensnaring and dealing with cheaters, employing outside-the-box thinking and brilliant subterfuge to catch players out.
The methods range from deliciously devious to almost troublingly harsh, but in each case it's clear that a ton of thought and ingenuity went into the schemes, which served as a warning to anybody else who even thought about some ill-gotten gains.
No matter how tempting it might be to cheat, developers are always coming up with spectacularly clever ways to outfox the hackers...
10. Creating "Honeypot" Data Which Only Cheaters Could Read - Dota 2
Earlier this year, Valve announced that they brought the banhammer down on 40,000 Dota 2 players who had been caught using third-party software to cheat in the hugely popular MOBA game.
And Valve's method for catching them was quite genius indeed. They updated the game with a digital "honeypot" - a segment of data hidden inside the game code which could never be read by regular, honest players not using cheats, but would be read by a player using software to assist them.
This gave Valve absolute certainty that all 40,000 banned players were unambiguously guilty of cheating, while further asserting that they made their methods known to effectively act as a deterrent and assure offending players that they will be caught eventually.
While more ambitious Dota 2 cheaters will likely be looking into ways to circumvent this clever anti-cheat method, it was certainly effective in ridding the game of a large swath of ill-intentioned ne'er-do-wells.
9. Corrupting All Of Your Save Files - Valkyrie Profile 2: Silmeria
Dota 2's anti-cheat crusade feels incredibly generous compared to the utterly savage manner in which Valkyrie Profile 2: Silmeria ruins a cheater's day - in a game without any online functionality, no less.
The game shipped with an anti-cheat software called Gameguard which can detect when players are using cheats, and follows up by corrupting your save file.
If that's not bad enough, the corruption doesn't show up until late in the game, luring players into a false sense of security before having it continually crash. Oh, and it gets even worse than that.
If you're using multiple save files in an attempt to outwit Gameguard, you're also screwed, as the corruption will affect all save files on your memory card, as it's tied to the game's overall system file.
As such, to play a clean run of the game, you need to delete every Valkyrie Profile 2 save, including system files, from your memory card.
On one hand, that's one hell of an aggressive and creative way to fight cheaters, but on the other, it feels like cruel overkill for a game like this.
8. The Receptionist Shames You Over The PA System - Theme Hospital
On the decidedly less-punitive end of the spectrum, we have the utterly delightful Theme Hospital, which rather than threaten the integrity of your save file rather gently shamed you for using cheats.
Now to be clear, Bullfrog's legendary hospital sim has in-built cheat functionality - allowing you to enrich yourself, gain equipment, skip forward in time, and even cause an emergency - so the team clearly wasn't seriously bothered about you using cheats.
Yet as a cheeky admonishment for cheaters, they'll be called out by the hospital's receptionist, who will loudly and enthusiastically announce over the building's PA system, "The hospital administrator is cheating!"
Granted, within the context of the game world itself, you have to wonder what the hell that would even mean to anyone who hears the announcement.
All the same, a small price to pay for being able to increase your bank balance by $10,000 with a single button press.
7. Elements Disappear When The Game Is Paused - Mario Party
Sometimes the most elegantly simple solutions are the most brilliantly effective, and in the case of the Mario Party franchise, Nintendo realised that players could cheese some of the memory-based mini-games by simply hitting the pause button and waiting until they had memorised everything on-screen.
And so, in many of the series' games, the respective visual elements will actually disappear from the screen while the game is paused and only re-appear when it's un-paused, in turn preventing players from abusing the pause feature to net themselves an easy win.
In fact, Mario Party isn't the only Nintendo franchise to do this - pausing the WarioWare games during mini-games will cause the screen to be plunged into total darkness, ensuring you can't take advantage of the paused screen.
On the surface this might seem like an incredibly straight-forward remedy to a most basic level of cheating, and yet, how many other games have ever actually implemented it?
6. Valve Gifted A Golden Halo To Everyone Who DIDN'T Cheat - Team Fortress 2
If gamers en masse have proven anything over the years, it's that they're incredibly susceptible to FOMO, and so when all else fails, developers can exploit that to punish cheaters.
Though perhaps not egregious as cheating goes, Team Fortress 2 did nevertheless have a problem with players using idling programs to exploit the game's item drop system, where weapons or cosmetic items would be regularly given to players while playing online.
Idling programs such as SteamStats were able to mimic the game's engine and allow players to receive item drops while not actually playing the game. These programs proved hugely popular and were ultimately used by a large chunk of the player-base.
In September 2009, however, Valve decided enough was enough and released an update which gave a special item to anyone who hadn't used idling programs - a golden halo hilariously called the "Cheater's Lament."
The halo also came complete with the message, "Congratulations! Your honesty has been rewarded with a new hat!"
Naturally, hackers were a bit miffed that they had to miss out on this shiny treat, and in the years that followed Valve made several changes to the item drop system which made idling decidedly less effective, such as forcing players to confirm a new item before being able to receive another one.
5. Forcing You To Fight Many Versions Of The Final Boss - Crusader: No Regret
Classic isometric action game Crusader: No Remorse allowed players to enter the code "jassica16" in order to activate cheat mode, but players expecting to simply repeat the cheat on sequel Crusader: No Regret were in for a nasty surprise.
Enter jassica16 this time and you'll be greeted with the message, "Of course we changed the cheats... duh."
But because that wasn't enough of an admonishment, the final boss, Chairman Draygan, will suddenly pipe up, saying, "I've been waiting a long time for this!", before you're transported to a giant room where eight versions of a mech suit-wearing Draygan start relentlessly firing rockets at you.
Oh, and you've got no cover at all to speak of, and the battle is scored by a bunch of Christmas-themed songs (because this Easter egg could also be accessed by non-cheating players on Christmas Day).
Defeating the eight bosses is incredibly challenging but not impossible, but to further thumb its nose at players who tried to recycle the previous game's cheats, even if you do triumph, you'll suddenly combust into a pile of gore at the conclusion of the fight.
The sequel did however have its own bespoke cheat code, "loosecannon16." Evidently the devs just wanted to poke a little fun at "lazy" players who figured they'd just use the exact same code again.
4. Lottery Cheaters Get Locked Out (Until They Pay A Fine) - Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
In Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door, players can take part in the Happy Lucky Lottery - a lottery hosted by a Bulky Bob-omb called Lucky.
Tickets can be purchased for 100 coins, and if the RNG gods are smiling down upon you, you just might end up winning.
But because dumb luck isn't enough for some players, the lotto can be cheated by moving the GameCube's clock forward to midnight, allowing players to see the winning number and then move their clock back to normal time.
Yet doing so will result in that day's lotto being suspended, at which point Lucky informs you that "foul play" is afoot, and the lottery's clock has been tampered with.
Lucky will straight-up ask you if you're the culprit, and if you confess, he'll have a full-on breakdown, before insisting that you purchase a new ticket at the princely cost of 500 coins, effectively fining you for your dishonest behaviour.
3. Your Opponents Are Notified If Game Data Is Modified - Spaceward Ho!
Classic sci-fi strategy game Spaceward Ho! came up with an elegantly simple but quite delicious solution to deal with players who tried to do the most dishonourable of things - cheat during multiplayer matches, the scoundrels.
Simply, the game would just drop all the pleasantries and grass you up to the opposing player.
According to the game's chief designer Joe Williams, the dev team worked hard to ensure that, if they couldn't stop players cheating in multiplayer games outright, at least they could ensure the other player knew exactly what they were up against.
And so, if the game detects any sudden change in a player's stats or game data, the other player will be informed that they're playing against a damn, dirty cheater.
Williams amusingly went on to point out that if you're cheating against the CPU, though, there's no such penalty, for obvious reasons. Bless.
2. A Player Hacked The Leaderboards, Begging Nintendo To Implement Anti-Cheat - Splatoon 2
When developers won't deal with cheaters, players may feel compelled to take matters into their own hands, and that's precisely what happened with Splatoon 2.
In 2018, one player became exasperated enough with the game's online multiplayer being so infested with cheaters that they decided to send Nintendo a message. How? By cheating themselves, and cheating big.
The player took it upon themselves to hack the game's online leaderboards, editing their X Power numbers so that they appeared in the top four spots of the leaderboard, with the player names "Please, Add, Anti, Cheat." Get it?
The person responsible even took to Reddit to elaborate that they're a huge fan of the game but were dissatisfied with Nintendo's refusal to implement sufficient anti-cheat measures.
Nintendo predictably responded by banning the individual from Splatoon 2's online play, though their clever gambit actually ended up working, as about a month later the company also began implementing more robust anti-cheat measures.
This also carried through to the recent release of Splatoon 3, where Nintendo took a far more proactive approach in banning cheating players.
1. The Old Money Cheat Gets You A High-Interest Loan Instead - SimCity 2000
1989's SimCity memorably allowed players to receive an instant loan of $10,000 by holding shift and typing "FUND," albeit with the caveat that getting greedy and entering the cheat three times in a single game year would trigger an earthquake.
For sequel SimCity 2000, Maxis decided to have a little fun with players simply expecting to use the money cheat again. This time, typing "FUND" would give players a bond with an excruciating 25% interest rate. Yikes.
It was a clever subversion of player expectations, for sure, albeit one which unintentionally, hilariously backfired for Maxis, given that players soon discovered a way to exploit it for their own material gain.
Basically, if you take out two 25% cheat bonds in a row and then issue a real bond with a 0% interest rate, your total interest rate will be negative, meaning that the bank basically ends up paying you a $1.5 million stipend every game year. Amazing.