10 Criminally Overlooked Gameplay Mechanics

These gameplay mechanics are genius, but hardly anyone got to play them!

Punisher game
THQ

It takes a lot of ingredients to make a good video game, but many might argue that the most important is the gameplay. Elements like the storyline, art direction, music, and graphical fidelity play a big part in the flavouring but, at its core, a game needs to wow its audience with mechanics they enjoy.

Some developers take this to heart by sticking to the classics, attempting to finesse features with a proven track record and present them with a fresh coat of paint. However, some venture into braver directions, coming up with new gameplay ideas in the hopes they'll entice players starved for something fresh. Unfortunately, not every game manages to find its audience, and many of these genius mechanics fly under the radar.

This can happen for plenty of reasons, such as a game receiving low sales, corporate meddling stifling the creative direction, or the overall product being lousy. Ultimately, it's the players who suffer, as anyone with a fear of missing out is left pondering what could have been.

These ten mechanics are prime examples of this, as they're so criminally overlooked that someone ought to go to prison for it.

10. Sound Based Gameplay - In Silence

In Silence
Ravenhood Games

The use of microphones in gaming usually goes hand-in-hand with getting screamed at by salty players or gloating after beating your friends -- or sometimes both at the same time. But there's a lot more this tool can bring to the table, and it's rare to find a game that embraces that as ambitiously as this one.

This 2020 multiplayer indie horror revolves around proximity voice chat. You and your friends have to stay as silent as possible while you work together to escape (or fight) a terrifying monster inspired by the Rake creepypasta. If you've got loud friends, then you won't want them on your team!

One lucky player gets to take on the role of the villainous beastie, who must hunt down their human prey with limited eyesight. The best way to find them is through headphones, keeping an ear out for chatting, whispering, or any sort of noise that hints at their location. The human players can manipulate this system themselves by setting off radios, TVs, or other devices to distract the monster.

In Silence got a bit of a spotlight thanks to the YouTube gaming sphere. Still, for as inventive and unique as the gameplay was, it's a shame it has been left in the annals of flash-in-the-pan horror gaming.


9. Only Playable In One Sitting - Paratopic

Paratopic Baltoro Games
Baltoro Games

Even the hardest of games allow players the chance to save their progress. This means you can take a break, calm down and maybe even buy a new controller after breaking the last one during your 100th attempt to beat Malenia Goddess of Rot. But this unique indie title said no to that luxury, forcing you into a whole new type of gaming experience.

Paratopic is a bizarre and obtuse game that throws abstract storytelling and gameplay your way, but one of its most fascinating features is that you have to play it in one sitting. The game doesn't feature a save system, with the roughly 45-minute title forcing you to treat it like an episode of your favourite Netflix show. You put it on and you play it with no distractions; it's that or you don't play it at all.

While some players might find this aggravating, there's no denying that it helps the underground game to stand out and gives it a unique artistic edge. Seeing more narrative adventure games that treat the player like this might even allow for more overlap in the discussion of gaming vs. cinema.


8. The Drawbacks Of Specialized Leveling - Disco Elysium

Disco Elysium boxart
ZA/UM

Those who have played Disco Elysium often give it credit for being one of the most well-written yet chaotic role-playing experiences on consoles. You'll find no arguments here, as the game deserves its illustrious reputation.

One feature that captures its cleverness and twisted psychology is how the protagonist's warped mind manifests in the gameplay. As with many RPG games you might feel the urge to pour all your energy into one of your character's skill tree options. This is usually a smart choice as you can specialize in a reliable trait that carries you through the game. But, if you do this in Disco Elysium, you will end up fighting a losing battle as the lead detective's own sanity will wrestle itself out from under you.

The more you rely on one branch of your skills (categorised as intellect, psyche, physique, and motorics), the more that part of your brain will take over. Soon, that aspect of your psychology will struggle against you, acting out without permission and introducing chaos into your play.

This game is a masterpiece of defying conventions. Punishing you for focusing on one of your skills is a prime example of that.


7. Real Time Healing - X-Men Origins: Wolverine

X-Men origins wolverine
Marvel

One of the biggest immersion breakers in modern gaming is the role of healing. How is it that you can play an FPS and get riddled with bullets only to work your way back to fighting like it was nothing? It's almost like every playable character in games with regenerating health has the power of Marvel's Wolverine. The legendary character seemed to note this, as he said "hold my beer" and did it himself.

2009s X-Men Origins: Wolverine is one of those unique video game adaptations that outdid its cinematic source material -- although that was pretty easy with this lousy X-Men flick. Getting the chance to hack and slash as the iconic Logan felt amazing, and what helped to sell it was the character's real-time healing mechanic.

The Activision title went into immense gory detail, with the titular hero getting torn to shreds the more damage you took. Of course, he would eventually heal back up, which you could watch in full. This mechanic delivered a spectacularly gruesome depiction of what immortality can buy you.

Thankfully Insomniac's upcoming Wolverine game could be the chance for this gory feature to strike back in full glory.


6. Creating Art - Eastshade

eastshade game
Eastshade Studios

Players will often picture a weapon in their hands when thinking of open-world first-person games. This isn't an unfair leap, as almost every title in the medium follows a formula full of combat and action. Still, there are experiences out there that pull back on that aggression, and the criminally overlooked Eastshade is one of them.

Eastshade, which is a sequel to the short game Leaving Lyndow, lets you play as a travelling painter who explores the titular island. Discovery and beauty are at the forefront of this unique IP as you look around the land for scenes you want to put onto the canvas.

Throughout the game, you use the painting mechanic to draw pictures, which you can then use to gain knowledge or items from the NPCs. This encourages you to get to know the people of the island, unlocking various storylines that influence your artistic endeavors.

Players who want a change of pace from wracking up killstreaks or grinding for new armour sets will find everything they want in the peaceful gameplay of this underrated gem.


5. Gravity Manipulation - Gravity Rush

gravity rush
Sony

If you ever encounter a person in the street who screams out conspiracy theories and claims that "gravity is weighing humanity down," then the good news is you can show them a world where it doesn't. Of course, that world is a video game, and that anti-gravitational sentiment is simply an underrated mechanic.

Gravity Rush is an action-adventure game for the PS Vita that puts you in the (very light) shoes of a young girl who can manipulate gravity. If that mechanic sounds fun, then you're right on the money because it is.

The gravity manipulation mechanic allows you to switch the force off, flinging yourself around the map and soaring through the skies. It's the kind of open-world navigation that's so addicting you'll never even consider using fast travel. You can use it to roam about the environment, solve puzzles and produce creative combat attacks, providing hours of fun at the expense of Sir Isaac Newton.

Sadly, Gravity Rush, its sequel, and its remaster, while all very enjoyable, have yet to catch on in the mainstream, meaning that many players have missed out on one of the most fun free-roaming tools available to them.


4. Gardening Based Platforming - The Gardener And The Wild Vines

The Gardener And The Wild Vines
Finite Reflection Studios

People can have many different hobbies, but one often drawn line is the idea of inside and outside activities. Gaming is fundamentally an inside activity, and gardening is absolutely outside. Still, if you love both and want to see them in a beautiful marriage of fun, then this overlooked indie game is the one for you.

In The Gardener and the Wild Vines, you play as a gardener (go figure) who sets out on a journey to rescue their beloved prince. To do so, you scale towers with a deeply creative platforming system that sees you cutting flowers with your sheers to create branching vines. These vines produce leaves you can bounce on, carrying you further to more flowers. It's vine pruning in 8-bit.

The platforming of this game is addicting and smooth, with skilled players able to create mesmerising runs as they scale the towers. You'll encounter more and more challenges as you play on, but the one thing that won't change within the roughly 3-4 hour runtime is the satisfying feeling of mixing platforming with sheering.

This is a cute, creative, and inspired narrative platformer that is certainly deserving of more attention.


3. Deck-Building Turn-Based Combat - Marvel's Midnight Suns

marvels midnight suns
Marvel

Marvel often feels like an insurmountable behemoth that couldn't produce a flop even if it tried. But that isn't the case, as plenty of titles in the iconic company's history have underperformed. Unfortunately, the recently released Midnight Suns is one of them, leaving a strong combat system trapped in a game that is woefully picking up dust.

This tactical role-playing game from Firaxis Games, the developer known for Civilization and XCOM, boasts an impressive roster full of some of the most popular comic-book characters in fiction. On top of that is an excellent combat system that combines the developer's signature turn-based gameplay with deck-building mechanics. This creates a wholly unique system for battling that feels like a healthy combination of XCOM and Marvel Snap.

Each mission sees the player bring three characters into battle. These heroes are decked out with eight customisable cards that grant them attacks and abilities. They are then placed into a deck and drawn per round, making for unique builds, strong strategy plays, and an element of unpredictability.

Despite wracking up a decent critical response, the game fell victim to low sales, even leading to Firaxis having to cut staff. It's a tragic story that shows not every hero gets their time in the sun.


2. The Nemesis System - Middle-Earth: Shadow Of Mordor

Shadow Of Mordor Nemesis System
Monolith

Enemies in video games are usually tailor-made by the developers. This often works great, as well-crafted, memorable villains leave nothing for players to complain about. But what if there was a system where every gamer got to forge their own path with unique rivals and recurring characters? Oh, wait, there is!

Shadow of Mordor (and its sequel Shadow of War) drummed up considerable buzz for its dark take on J.R.R Tolkien's Lord of the Rings mythos and for its incredible "Nemesis System." This unique gameplay mechanic allowed you to run into procedurally generated Orcs and Uruks whose position in Sauron's army would change depending on your interactions. This led to plenty of unique characters as your choices, failings, and wins would make considerable marks on the enemies you faced. Sadly, the "Nemesis System" has gone nowhere.

There should be a whole boatload of Triple-A projects using this fascinating mechanic, yet you won't even use up all your fingers when counting them on your hand. This isn't even a matter of missed opportunity by creators, as the finger of blame can be pointed firmly at WB Interactive Entertainment. The company has patented the system until 2035, meaning no other studio can use it for over a decade. What a waste of potential!


1. Interrogations - The Punisher

The Punisher Knife Environmental Kill
Volition

Marvel might have a reputation for being a mostly fun-loving superhero franchise with bright colours and charming characters, but there's a seething underbelly beneath the costumes and one-liners. Frank Castle, otherwise known as The Punisher, takes up at least 20 percent of this dark side, and his 2005 video game exemplifies that.

This action-packed game puts you in the shoes of the titular vigilante as he murders his way through waves of criminals and meets up with popular Marvel heroes. Violence is a mainstay in the game, giving you plenty of weapons to mow down your enemies with. But, it goes one step further by allowing you to interrogate them in brutal fashion.

The game gives you an absurd array of techniques to squeeze information out of your victims. You can take enemies to interrogation hotspots such as buzzsaws, piranha tanks, hanging knife displays, and more. After getting your information, you can finish the job off with vulgar executions.

These sequences were so brutal that the game was forced to render them in black and white to avoid an adults-only rating. Some games, such as the Batman Arkham series, have implemented similar interrogation features, but nothing has ever managed to go this far.


Watch Next


Contributor

Michael is my name, overanalysing comedy is my game! Anime, wrestling, TV, movies and video games all live in my head rent free!