10 Cruel Tricks Video Games Played On Co-Op Players
These co-op games all pulled the rug out from players in creatively cruel ways.
As much as we all love a great single-player game, there's nothing quite like sitting down with a couple of friends for some co-operative play. If games are meant to bring us together, what could be better than that?
While co-op is typically intended to be a joyous, uniting experience, that isn't always the case, and sometimes developers decide to think a little outside the box, to challenge our preconceptions of what co-op play is and basically reinvent the wheel.
These 10 video games, all of them featuring co-op multiplayer in one way or another, clearly relished toying with player expectations and turning the co-op experience into a bit of a cruel joke.
Whether forcing players to battle one another at a pivotal moment, making them team up to do something truly horribly, or simply giving them the opportunity to thoroughly troll each other, these co-op modes are all absolutely soaked in playfully mischievous intent.
In some cases these cruel sleights of hand left us all thoroughly pissed off, while in others it was tough not to respect the creativity - harsh though it was...
10. Killing Off One Player's Character Near The End - Brothers: A Tale Of Two Sons
Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons is just one of several Josef Fares-directed games on this list, and that's because the guy sure knows how to create co-op games that thoroughly press the player's buttons.
Though Brothers was originally conceived as a single-player game in which the player controlled two brothers - using a different thumbstick for each brother - there was nothing stopping two people playing the game together by handling a side of the controller each.
The 2019 Nintendo Switch version, however, did finally introduce official multiplayer support.
The game is focused around two brothers co-operating in order to complete puzzles and advance their journey to find a cure for their father's illness. The older brother, Naia, is the stronger of the two while the younger, Naiee, is smaller and more agile.
Yet near the end of the game, the rug is well and truly pulled out when Naia is mortally wounded by a giant spider and dies.
For the remainder of the story, Naiee is naturally the only playable character, and worse still, you're saddled with the task of dragging his corpse around and burying him.
As a single-player experience this was absolutely devastating, and in co-op, it forces the player controlling Naia to awkwardly sit around for the final 20 minutes of the game while their friend finishes it. Or for true dramatic effect, just leave the room.
9. Making Players Fight Over Loot - Borderlands 2
Though Borderlands 2's four-player co-op multiplayer was widely praised by critics, players absolutely loathed the game's bizarre shared loot system.
After felling a large boss, for example, the resulting loot would be left for players to divide by themselves, rather than giving each member of the party their own walled-off loot.
Human nature being what it is, even good friends playing together would try and pilfer the best legendary loot before anybody else could, as made for a hugely frustrating experience - especially if you were a sniper in position far away from your targets.
Gearbox claimed that the shared loot feature was a design choice intended to encourage co-operation, yet it was ultimately hilariously naive to expect people - especially randoms on the Internet - to be courteous about basically anything.
Thankfully they listened to the vocal feedback for Borderlands 3, with each player getting their own singular loot drop during co-op play, prompting the game's art director Scott Kester to proclaim, "No more loot ninjas!"
8. One Player Has Reality-Warping Schizophrenia - Kane & Lynch
IO Interactive's cult fave third-person shooter Kane & Lynch: Dead Men features a co-op version of its campaign in which two players can play as each of the titular violent criminals.
While in the single-player campaign players control the more level-headed of the duo, Kane, in co-op the second player takes the reins of his psychotic, schizophrenic, murderous pal Lynch.
If the single-player game made it abundantly clear that Lynch was prone to violent outbursts without medication, co-op explains why in the most twisted way possible.
While playing as Lynch, player two will experience hallucinations as part of his "psychotic fear filter," meaning that on occasion - during story points and when you chain together kills - harmless civilians will resemble police officers, and female civilians will often even have a pig's head.
Believing the civilians to be members of the police, this gives Lynch the ability to melee execute the "cops," no matter that they're actually just regular, unarmed folk.
It's certainly a clever and unique way of putting players in a tortured character's mindset, even if anyone who loaded up the co-op for some brainless, violent mayhem got a more disturbing experience than they ever imagined.
7. Giving You A Trophy For Killing Your Own Teammate - Rogue Trooper Redux
Who among us doesn't love trophies and achievements? The thrilling dopamine surge of a hard-earned 'cheev speaks for itself, and of course, if players need to do something sketchy to get their latest hit, they're more than likely going to.
And so we have 2017's Rogue Trooper Redux, which received flak upon release for offering up a secret achievement called "Accidental Killer." It could be unlocked by killing any of your teammates during an online match with friendly fire turned on.
Obviously encouraging you to teamkill in a competitive game makes this a rather unsporting achievement, and though it left some players rather miffed, developers Rebellion never revised or removed it, instead offering up a wafer-thin rationale for the accolade's inclusion:
"The game's about betrayal of your own kind after all, so we figured it would be fun to have a trophy where you betray your teammates - perhaps unintentionally, perhaps not!"
Obviously the Christian way to get the achievement is by playing with a friend and willingly killing each other, but let's be honest: most of us just entered a random lobby and let rip.
6. Boost Mode Lets Players Help (Or Troll) Their Friends - New Super Mario Bros. U
New Super Mario Bros. U introduced one of the most brilliantly innovative co-op multiplayer features in the history of the Mario franchise, with the fantastically creative Boost Mode.
In addition to four players playing the game like a typical co-op Mario platformer, Boost Mode allowed a fifth player to use the Wii U gamepad to manipulate gameplay on-the-fly.
In theory this would allow the omniscient fifth player to spawn blocks that helped players advance while also disabling enemies, but in reality many took this opportunity to screw with their friends instead.
The fifth player could spawn blocks to block paths, prevent teammates from picking up power-ups, and even manipulate interactive parts of the environment to work against the other players' movements.
Hilariously, Nintendo came up with this mode to encourage a different kind of co-operative play, yet they overlooked the major potential for trolling, much to the chagrin of those simply trying to make it to the end of a level.
Sadly Boost Mode was removed for the 2019 Nintendo Switch re-release due to the console's lack of a dedicated gamepad.
5. Making You Both Murder An Adorable Stuffed Elephant - It Takes Two
Josef Fares strikes again, this time in his most recent co-op offering, It Takes Two.
The two-player multiplayer game puts players in the shoes of Cody and May, a married couple imminently planning to get a divorce who are magically transported into the bodies of two handmade dolls created by their distraught daughter, Rose.
Together, the pair must co-operate in order to complete a series of relationship tests while making their way back to Rose, and for the most part the co-op gameplay is both absurdly entertaining and wonderfully creative.
Except, that is, for that scene.
Mid-way through the game, Cody and May reason that making Rose cry on them - the very act that turned them into dolls in the first place - will undo the spell, and decide upon one sure-fire way to wring tears from her eyes.
Players are then tasked with teaming up to take down Cutie, Rose's adorable, sweet-voiced stuffed elephant. And when we say "take down," we mean kill, as the sequence requires players to drag the poor creature over the edge of a cabinet to her doom.
Making this act mandatory to progress the story is harsh enough, but Fares clearly relished making players feel like absolute garbage, given Cutie's desperate pleas for help throughout the prolonged sequence.
4. Movie Night Mode Encourages Players To Save Their Own Skin - The Dark Pictures Anthology
With the launch of their Until Dawn spin-off series The Dark Pictures Anthology, Supermassive Games introduced a novel new feature called "Movie Night" - effectively a form of pass-the-controller co-op multiplayer.
Between two-and-five players can take part, with each player controlling a number of characters throughout the story, the controller simply being passed between players when the perspective shifts to one of their characters.
While in theory the idea is that a group of friends will work together to ensure all of their characters' collective survival, the Dark Pictures games naturally make it rather difficult to get everybody to the end in one piece.
Beyond the split-second QTE sequences, players are regularly forced to make some tricky decisions, often having to weigh up whether they want to risk their own character's fate in order to save another.
Basically, to stay in the game and not become a passive observer, you're encouraged to keep your own characters alive above all others.
This sometimes requires you to make decisions which either cause the death of other characters or at least increase the likelihood. It's quite brilliant, really.
3. Grief Mode Indirectly Pits You Against Others - Call Of Duty: Black Ops 2
Call of Duty: Black Ops II's Grief Mode was an intriguing mash-up of co-op and competitive multiplayer that's bafflingly never appeared in a Call of Duty game since.
While technically a competitive 4v4 multiplayer mode, the beauty of Grief is that there isn't any way for players to directly harm their opponents on the other side.
The goal is to outlast the rival team amid a zombie outbreak by any means necessary, and because you can't just gun the other side down, you have to get pretty creative about it.
You can hinder the other team by blocking paths, refusing to open doors, funnelling zombies towards them, and even shooting at them, which while not causing any physical harm will slow their movements to a crawl.
It's an hilarious and frankly underappreciated mode which tests the player's capacity for underhanded, troll-y tactics in the pursuit of victory, even if the real enemies are still the undead horde.
After all, a side can only claim victory if the other team is dead and at least one member of their own manages to survive the rest of the round. If everybody succumbs to the zombies, the round restarts without a winner.
2. Making You Fight To The Death At The End - A Way Out, Splinter Cell: Conviction & More
There's perhaps no single crueller trick a co-op game can play than eventually forcing teammates to turn on one another in the final stretch.
This most infamously happened in yet another Josef Fares game, A Way Out, where players take control of escaped prisoners Leo and Vincent, only for the end of the game to reveal that Vincent was an undercover cop the whole time.
And so, the finale sees the two battling one another in an epic shootout, with it made explicitly clear that only one of them can survive, the players forced to turn their combat chops upon each other.
This is just the most recent example, though: Splinter Cell: Conviction's co-op campaign similarly forced players to duke it out at the end, as did classic beat 'em up Double Dragon.
It's an especially insidious trick considering that players have spent hours building up an in-game camaraderie together, only for the dynamic to be flipped on its head in the most violent and ultimate way, with there being no alternative method for beating the game no less.
1. No Respawns Until Both Players Die - Contra
1987's arcade classic shooter Contra is infamous for being one of the most challenging games of its era - if not ever - and even the inclusion of a two-player mode doesn't do much to reduce the stress.
Whether you're playing solo or together, you've got a maximum of three continues to make it through the game with, but if you're playing co-op and your teammate runs out of lives, you're forced to continue alone until you yourself run out of lives too.
There's no checkpoint respawn for your partner, nor any means in-game to resurrect them: you have to try and push ahead solo until you can't make it any further, at which point you can both cash-in one of your three continues together.
Needless to say, it rather undermines the appeal of co-op if you have to spend potentially lengthy sections of the game trying to plow on without your backup. Then again, most players probably won't last all that long on their own, at least.