10 Cruel Tricks Video Games Played On Horror Players
Thanks. We'll never trust anything again.
A main goal of any horror game is to unsettle and disturb us as much as possible. If a horror game doesn’t succeed in this, then it’s not a particularly good game.
While creating a chilling atmosphere and creeping sense of dread are effective ways of getting under our skin, this usually isn’t enough to satisfy horror game developers’ desire to terrify us senseless.
The problem, though, is that audiences have become well-versed in horror tropes by this. It's become far too easy to tell when one is coming, typically when the sound becomes suspiciously quiet and there's enough empty space on screen for something to appear in. For horror games to really catch us by surprise, developers need to get creative with what they throw at us.
Thankfully, creators have proven themselves to be deviously inventive in overcoming this problem. Alongside catching us by surprise with exquisitely crafted scares along with some carefully calculated misdirection, developers have likewise managed to use the game’s own mechanics against us in wicked ways.
No matter how familiar you believe yourself to be in everything horror, you won't have seen these cruel tricks coming.
10. Kill The Dog To Maintain Cover?! - The Dark Pictures Anthology: The Devil In Me (2022)
Throughout our time in The Devil In Me’s recreation of H.H. Holmes’s “Murder Castle”, developers Supermassive Games ask us to partake in a selection of cruel choices which can determine which of the plucky group of survivors will make it to the end of the night and which will be gruesomely killed. However, no choice you're presented with is as ruthlessly heartless as when you meet the wonderful dog Connie.
While being pursued by Du’Met, you'll encounter the lovable but loud canine in the farmhouse. As the killer approaches, you're presented with the dastardly option of killing Connie to remain undetected. Depending on who’s left alive, this scene can play out slightly differently. But it's the version where only Kate makes it there that's the most mischievous.
Though the game encourages you to kill the pooch with a quick time event, doing so would be the last thing that you'd want to do.
Showing the animal mercy instead will lead to Kate being discovered. the killer swings his axe, and a large blood spatter on the wall signals Kate's demise.
In some deceitful misdirection, the “blood” was nothing more than tomato soup, and both Kate and Connie escape with their lives.
9. The Shabby Doll - Silent Hill 4: The Room (2004)
Being a survival horror game, the fourth entry in the Silent Hill series, The Room, will see you spending a lot of your time searching each area for crucial resources like health, ammo, and puzzle items needed to progress.
Given that each item that protagonist Henry Townshend comes across will likely hold some importance later in his ordeal (why else would the developers include them?), the chances are that you'll jump at the chance to add something new to Henry's inventory.
When Henry is offered a shabby doll during the apartments level, it would therefore seem in our best interest to accept the gift. It might be needed to solve a future puzzle or possibly even be connected to a secret ending.
However, this item serves no useful purpose whatsoever.
In a sly trick from the developers, the only thing that happens when this doll is in Henry's possession is that his apartment (a key location that's used as a safe room between levels) becomes haunted by nightmarish doll faces that appear on the wall.
It's as unpleasant as it sounds, so it's best just not to collect this nightmarish doll.
8. Don't Pick It Up - The Dark Pictures Anthology: Man Of Medan (2019)
Being a loving homage to schlocky teen horrors, Man Of Medan is full to the gunnels with jump scares. Throughout your time on the derelict ship, you'll be treated to a parade of things jumping out at you to the accompaniment of loud musical stings.
While it's typically easy see these fun little scares coming from a mile away, Man Of Medan is most effective when it gets creative with its gameplay mechanics.
At one point in the game, Alex and Julia will find their way into a deserted crew quarters. And with there being no sign of any imminent danger, you're therefore free to explore at your leisure.
Examining objects is a fundamental component of this series. It's how the sinister secrets of the ship are uncovered, and by this point you'll have become used to picking up everything you can. Therefore, when taking a moment to inspect a small skull, you'll assume it's business as usual.
When placing the item back down, however, the developers deploy a fiendish jump scare as a ghostly hand reaches out to grab Alex.
After hiding an unexpected scare disguised as a core mechanic, trusting interactive objects after this point proved to be a difficult task.
7. Playing Fetch - Yomawari: Night Alone (2015)
Japanese indie horror Yomawari: Night Alone is a simplistic yet atmospheric outing from Nippon Ichi Software. Boasting a gorgeous hand-drawn art style and a soundscape comprised of bone-chilling ambience, this title sees you venture out into the dark and (almost) deserted streets of a quaint neighbourhood as the young protagonist searches for her sister when she fails to return home.
To survive, you'll need to avoid the many ghoulish spirits roaming the town that are only visible when illuminated by the protagonist's trusty flashlight.
Before setting out on this ghostly adventure, though, Yomawari begins on a more upbeat note as the youngster takes their adorable dog Poro home from a scenic walk.
It’s at this point where you're introduced to the basic controls. Alongside how to run and tiptoe, the tutorial teaches you how to interact with objects when Poro spies a pebble that he wants to play with.
But when the game tells you how to use the item, the girl throws it into the middle of the road. Before there's time to register what has happened, Poro excitedly runs after the rock and is immediately run over by a truck.
After seeing the blood smear on the road, you'll forever be emotionally scarred.
6. "Look Out The Window" - Resident Evil Village (2021)
Protagonist Ethan Winters is put through the worst ordeal of his life during the events of Resident Evil Village. In addition to seeing his wife killed and his infant daughter stolen by Chris Redfield at the start of the game, Ethan finds himself in a remote village that's become overrun with monstrous creatures.
Not only does the titular village have vampires and lycans for our unfortunate protagonist to face, but there's also a handful of puzzles which he must also overcome if he's going to find his daughter.
Not long after escaping Lady Dimitrescu's castle, one puzzle requires you find a jack to get past a vehicle blocking the path. This crucial item can be found in a small building to the east of the village; however, it's locked in a cupboard. Thankfully, though, the owner has left a handy clue on how to find the lock's combination on the back of a photograph: "Look out the window."
Upon following these instructions, some strategically placed numbers can be spotted outside. However, looking out the window also causes a lycan to materialise out of nowhere right in front of the window, giving us a cruel and perfectly timed jump scare in the process.
Thanks, Capcom.
5. Take A Closer Look - Condemned: Criminal Origins (2005)
Set in the grimy, crime-infested city of Metro, psychological horror Condemned: Criminal Origins saw us take on the role of FBI agent Ethan Thomas. He's on the hunt for a notorious serial killer known as the Match Maker, who likes to pose his victims with mannequins in gruesome tableaus. But when Ethan's framed for the murders, it's up to him to crack the case alone.
To help track the killer down, Ethan has an assortment of gadgets at his disposal used to identify and collect evidence. This is a main mechanic of the game, so when you stumble upon another of the killer's victims stuffed in a locker, you won't think twice when the trustworthy Lieutenant Rosa asks you to do some sleuthing. Equipping the camera, you aim it at the corpse and zoom in to take a close-up shot as requested.
However, it becomes apparent that this victim is still alive. Just as the photo is snapped, the man springs back to life and grabs Ethan, catching us completely by surprise.
While jump scares are often the least effective kind of video game tricks, Condemned's devilish antics are a prime example of how to do jump scares right.
4. The Trapdoor - The Quarry (2022)
Nothing good ever happens at a summer camp. Look no further than The Quarry when a group of councillors fell prey to a night of horror after getting stranded at Hackett's Quarry.
Alongside the various horrors terrorising the teens throughout the game, the cast of characters will likewise be faced with some difficult choices that will decide how fortunate their fates will be.
However, the developers saw their chance to have some extra fun at our expense with the outcomes of some of these choices. One such case comes when a scantily clad Emma makes her way into the treehouse alone while filming one of her vlogs.
The sound of something moving outsides prompts her to ask if she should look through some belongings or open the trapdoor “and die a horrible, painful death”, she jests to her viewers.
With a monster potentially moments away from bursting into the small room, it's understandable not to want to linger in here for long and decide to leave as soon as possible.
Choosing the latter option, however, proves to be a fatal error. Opening the trapdoor sees a creature brutalise Emma in one of the game's more violent death scenes.
You can't say you weren't warned.
3. Do As You're Told - Blair Witch (2019)
From developers Bloober Team (the horror masterminds behind Layers Of Fear and Observer), Blair Witch saw us return to the sinister depths of the notorious Black Hills Forrest. Set two years after the events of The Blair Witch Project film, this game saw you take on the role of former police officer Ellis who, alongside his canine companion Bullet, enters the woods in search of a missing boy.
It's not long before Ellis's search took a malevolent turn as he's led deeper into the witch’s domain. Strange entities emerge from the darkness to torment him while traumatic visions from his past begin to blur the line between past and present.
It becomes apparent that the witch intends to toy with Ethan's head. But this deception goes further than it seems. In a deviously clever twist, the witch has been manipulating you since the very beginning.
If you've as much as picked up any of the figurine collectables, killed an enemy, or followed any of the witch’s instructions, you'll have fallen for her trap. Without even realising that you've done anything wrong until it's too late, you'll have locked yourself into the bad ending of the game.
2. Mimics - Dark Souls (2011)
The Soulsborne series has become synonymous for the lengthy list of mean gotcha moments that they've played on us over the years. It just wouldn’t be a FromSoftware game at this point without the developers planting harsh practical jokes in them.
Whereas Elden Ring contains trap chests that teleports us to tougher areas and Bloodborne has the hilarious log trap, there’s no trick as quintessentially Soulsborne as the mimics from Dark Souls.
In the oppressive world of Lordran where every enemy would fit right at home in our nightmares, every resource we can get our hands on is vital. Every treasure chest we come across is therefore a sign that we’ve found something useful, whether it be a stronger weapon or piece of armour, which could help us get past the next boss.
But not all treasure chests are safe. Some, it turns out, are gangly limbed, toothy terrors known as mimics that will take a big bite out of greedy adventurers who don’t pay close attention to which way the chain is facing.
Moreover, these enemies don't appear until around halfway through the game in Sen's Fortress, meaning that you won't be expecting this nasty surprise when it finally arrives.
1. Dark Rot - Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice (2017)
Though it’s not an all-out horror game in the same way as the other entries on this list, Ninja Theory's critically acclaimed Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice nevertheless incorporates elements of psychological thrills to make the titular Senua's trip into the underworld as unnerving as possible.
As she travels into the depths of Helheim on a mission to save the soul of her deceased lover, the menacing voices of the Furies dominate the soundscape, constantly criticising and commenting on Senua’s (and our) actions throughout the game.
However, it’s when the game introduces the concept of “dark rot” where things get creatively mean.
After death, a black substance appears on Senua’s hand. This is the rot, and it will gradually spread up her arm after each subsequent death. If the blackness reaches her head, though, the game tells us that this will result in permadeath, meaning that failing too much will stop us from finishing the game.
What we won’t be aware of at this point is that this is a complete lie. Permadeath doesn't exist in this game. But by making us think it does, Senua’s Sacrifice ingeniously uses its game design to help put us in Senua's state of mind.