10 Cult Gaming Classics That Deserved Mainstream Success
Like most mediums, videogames can often hinge on the success of critical reception or the current outlook on market saturation. If there are already three tried and true platformer series on the market it is just common sense that newer ideas will struggle to make an impact. Sometimes you also have to just cope with the reality that certain great games just do not appeal to certain demographics. Every video game released is just another drop in the ocean unless an impossible scenario comes along where everyone can afford every video game released on some unlimited disposable budget. Until that fantasy scenario, just as in every medium, projects will get overlooked that sometimes are honestly hidden gems. These games often grow a cultish fanbase to spread the word but in reality, their time for mainstream success has flown by. This list will discuss 10 of the games that I feel deserved mainstream success but never found it due to varying circumstances.
10. The Parasite Eve Franchise
Resident Evil and Final Fantasy were both highly lauded back in the fifth generation and even today despite major design overhauls contain legions of dedicated fans. Squaresoft in their prime had an ingenious concept of a game that smashed what people liked from both series into one totally new franchise. Parasite Eve ended up a shortly lived franchise for the PS1 that placed players in the shoes of NYPD rookie officer Aya Brea against a form of viral outbreak. The twist is that instead of traditional clunky tank movement and aim and fire survival horror, Parasite Eve offered a turn based battle system that used up your ammo funds. The marriage between the two genres was inventive complementing fantastic stories, but it never caught on. RPG's were over-saturated at the time and this series is just one of many that did not catch on. Today the franchise lives on through handheld games, which is admittedly better than having the franchise completely wiped from the face of the Earth.
9. The Tomba Franchise
The PS1 including the fifth generation as a whole was overflowing with mascot platformers making it only logical although unfortunate that some get lost in the shuffle. Tomba never fully embraced the fresh and revolutionary 3D style which potentially worked against it, but it thrived on traditional 2D platforming with a twist. Outside of battling evil pigs, Tombas linear based levels featured objectives and hidden key items to find to help out various citizens. The artstyle and aesthetic design was also charming and colorful with luscious forests and feral jungle environments. Over-saturation of the market and dated design just held this one back.
8. Catherine
Catherine is a puzzle game where the player moves around blocks to navigate seemingly never ending towers of stairs. There are a plethora of awkward barriers to pass before getting sucked into Catherine though. The overtly present Anime presentation may turn people off just as much as the premise which essentially boils down to pinpointing how loyal the player would be as a lover. It sounds unquestionably creepy on the surface considering at points you enter confessional and are asked personal questions regarding relationships. Your answers are then factored into a poll stored on an online server. The story is inevitably gripping however as you mold the fate of an adulterer down a path of redemption or further through sleaziness. If you play the RPG aspects honestly you may just find some interesting things out about yourself too.7. The Getaway
Grand Theft Auto is unequivocally the king of sandbox crime but The Getaway still contains a better and more personal story than all of them. There may not be any citywide hijinks or side activities but its made up for with pulse pounding adrenaline as you control a father in a relentless rush to save his son from London's crime underworld. Upon reaching the second half, the game twists itself going in a different and even more exciting direction towards its climactic ending. The Getaway admittedly didnt offer much to do in London but the intensity of driving across it frantically while timed is still unmatched. Its healing was one of the pioneers in regenerating health and the shootouts were chaotically tense. The game did get a sequel but unfortunately it was awful encapsulating nothing that caused its predecessor to prevail.
6. System Shock 2
Before Rapture and Columbia there was Tau Ceti, a planet with eggs that infected the spacecraft crew of the Rickenbacker. System Shock plays highly similar to the original Bioshock complete with powers, RPG stat building, and an atmospheric horror vibe. The story is also full of twists and turns as to be expected from a Bioshock game though admittedly not as Earth shatteringly brilliant. System Shock never got off the ground completely but for those seeking a challenge or another Shock game check this hidden gem out. It was arguably held back from PC exclusivity and a steep learning curve that requires an understanding of how to effectively build your skills, otherwise you could back yourself into an unwinnable situation.
5. Psychonauts
Tim Schaefer has a very imaginative and vivid mind for creating charming worlds with colorful casts of characters. Psychonauts however is arguably the auteurs crowning achievement featuring an alive and wonderful 3D sandbox world for platforming. The summer camp setting offered a myriad of adventuring with an insane amount of collectables but the game really shines when Raz telepathically enters mini-worlds each representing another character's emotional baggage. Its definitely a strange game but coupling that with the already established PS2 platformers (that were much more accessible) including Sly Cooper, Ratchet & Clank, and Jak & Daxter it is understandable most people did not go for Psychonauts too. It was just another case of oversaturation.
4. Deadly Premonition
If you have seen and enjoyed David Lynchs short-lived television series Twin Peaks than it is a guaranteed bet you will enjoy Deadly Premonition. The game follows a schizophrenic FBI Agent investigating a brutal murder of a young woman and contains a plethora of idiosyncratic characters to investigate and a bevy of twists throughout the game. So what worked against it? Honestly speaking, a LOT! There was a shoestring budget featuring abysmal graphics depicting everything as fake and cardboard looking. The story is presented with B movie style cheese which split critics and players alike. The original Xbox 360 release had horrible controls while the traditional shooting segments (though very sparse) were boring. For some final perspective, Deadly Premonition is widely considered the most polarizing video game ever created receiving a 10 from Destructoid and a 2/10 from IGN. Year mileage may vary but the experience is one of a kind. This author personally finds it brilliant and is buying an Xbox One (along with a PS4) to play SWERY's next title D4 which is an exclusive.
3. Spec Ops: The Line
Military shooters are all the rave nowadays seeing as Call of Duty and Battlefield duke it out in sales regularly, so it naturally disappoints me that gamers skipped out on this one. The Line may not boast a complex and addicting myriad of online modes but it has one of the darkest, twisted, satirically smart, and mind bending stories in all of gaming. As Private Martin Walker your goal is to investigate Dubai from a natural disaster and rogue infantry squad. Whereas most military shooters go the ooh-rah macho hero route, The Line succeeds at making the player feel like garbage for their actions and drives their morals to the figurative line the title speaks of. Its gameplay is rote and generic, but its story is unforgettable and can only be described as Apocalypse Now marrying Fight Club.
2. The Zone of the Enders Franchise
Hideo Kojima struck an endless stream of gold with the renowned and infamous Metal Gear Solid franchise. His Zone of the Enders line of games offered something completely different; high speed robot action. The gameplay could occasionally feel repetitive but the typical Kojima characters and bosses were all plentiful and memorable. The short and sweet nature of the games ensured they never overstayed their welcome either. Of course bearing a heavy Anime and Japanese cultural influence worked against the series but at the time the gameplay was exhilarating. Maybe when Kojima is finished with Metal Gear Solid he can rehire Platinum Games (Metal Gear Rising: Reveangeance) to create something truly frantic, hectic, and reflective of how far action games have come.
1. The Witcher Franchise
Admittedly this franchise is on the verge of mainstream success but for now, it qualifies. When I sit down and play say Skyrim, I grow tired of the repetitiveness of it all. Are the quests fun? Sure. The worlds are always carefully concocted too. It does not do anything for me personally though without a strong narrative to drive my motives. The Witcher provides the best of both styles featuring ridiculously well written dialogue and mature plot points. You can shape major arcs of the medieval fantasy epic as you see fit too. It may not offer as much exploration as something similar to Skyrim but that overarching narrative sure as hell makes the environments much more thrilling to explore. The Witcher should finally receive mainstream success with The Wild Hunt, which will boast a world bigger than Skyrim without sacrificing the depth of its story. A simultaneous release on all next generation consoles will also help, whereas excluding the Enhanced Edition of The Witcher 2, the series is PC exclusive. Let me know what some of your favorite cult classics are below!