10 Darkest Quests In Fallout History

Nuking an entire town is only the tip of the iceberg...

The Fallout series has always revelled in a certain brand of humour. Although on the surface its post-apocalyptic nature would've been perfect for a horror game, since the very beginning, Black Isle Studios and later Bethesda have used its weird and wonderful setup to create one of the silliest and charming properties to ever grace the medium. However, that doesn't mean the horror tropes aren't still lurking in there somewhere. After all, this is the apocalypse we're talking about, and the series' laudable moral decisions don't always end with ghouls riding rockets to space, or a post-apocalyptic superhero reigning supreme over an entire town. Hell, you're essentially introduced to the third game with an option to nuke one of the series' major settlements - a reminder that this world can take a turn for the worst at any moment. That said, although spooky moments and sinister implications run rampant in every game in the franchise, some quests can simply chill you to the bone. Unlike the option to nuke Megaton as mentioned earlier, it's often the more personal choices or revelations that hit the hardest, making for some of the darkest moments in the entire franchise.

10. Pickman's Gallery (Fallout 4)

I thought I had seen all of the depraved things that Fallout 4 had to offer until I found Pickman's Gallery tucked away in the heart of the lower city. Seemingly innocuous from the outside, once you eliminate a couple of raiders and head inside, you'll quickly discover that there's more to this than first meets the eye. Because as it turns out, the titular Pickman has been torturing raiders and using their blood to craft cult-like paintings that are hung over every inch of the place. Through a series of notes littered throughout the location detailing the final moments of a group of raiders it becomes clear that Pickman takes more than a little pleasure in creating his art, and there might even be a supernatural reason for his actions. Not only that, if you let him go after the confrontation in the cellar, he'll create a personalised picture for your Vault Dweller, leaving behind a specialised knife so you can create your own works to hang on the walls of his home. Erm... thanks?

9. Democracy Inaction (New Vegas)

In every Fallout game, the stories of the many safekeeping vaults you come across often provide more twisted tales than anything on the surface. New Vegas' Vault 11 is no exception, although at first it doesn't appear too out of the ordinary. As expected, the vault is deserted and decaying, and initially it doesn't look like anyone has used the safety of the underground sanctuary in years. That is, until you get to the Overseer's office. Unlocking the secret passage underneath the desk you're ushered into a peculiarly well-kept hallway. At the end you find a room and you're told to sit down to watch a short movie on a projector that fills you in on the location's secret past. As it turns out, every year the vault held a lottery, and the "lucky" winner was ushered into the same room as you before they were sacrificed. This happened every year like clockwork until only a few vault dwellers remained. As soon as the movie finishes you're ambushed on both sides, with your character eventually killing the remaining few psychopathic killers in the vault and stopping the yearly ritual for good.

8. Blood Ties (Fallout 3)

Everyone loved the vampires in Bethesda's Oblivion, so obviously when the developer moved into more "realistic" territory with Fallout 3, more than a couple of fans were a bit bummed that their favourite supernatural creatures wouldn't be making a crossover appearance. And while they don't actually show up in F3, one quest specifically paid homage to the toothy monsters of Oblivion's fantasy world. The mission "Blood Ties" has you attempting to solve a series of grisly murders and kidnappings that are taking place across various settlements in the DC Wasteland. Pretty quickly you link the murders to a group that refers to themselves as "The Family"; an underground-dwelling cult convinced that they're afflicted with vampirism. It sounds a bit silly on paper, but when you're investigating the brutal killings by the pack and talking to the leaders of the cult, getting to understand their twisted world-view, it's clear that there's a much more psychological and sinister undercurrent to the whole ordeal. Cannibalism is a pretty standard part of post-apocalyptic fiction, yet with this quest Fallout 3 managed to make it feel fresh again.

7. Oasis (Fallout 3)

You can say what you want about the world of Fallout 3, but a bit of colour here and there wouldn't have hurt. Yes, we know it's called the "wasteland" for a reason, but after a while the endless sea of grey rubble makes for pretty repetitive scenery. However, all of those artistic choices almost make sense when you find one of the few flourishing parts of DC left in game; all in the aptly-titled location, Oasis. Because you've spent your time so far trawling through the same barren landscape, finding a place with actual colour and living, breathing plant-life provides for a welcomed change of pace. At first everything seems hunky dory at Oasis, and, initially anyway, the location more than lives up to its namesake. Of course, then the quest kicks in. One of the first "people" you see upon entering Oasis is a talking tree named Harold, who, as it turns out, was a fan-favourite Ghoul that featured in all of the Fallout games previously. By the third game he'd developed a virus that had overtaken his body and rooted him to the ground, with a select few people treating him as a god and forming a cult around his seemingly majestic being. Had enough of his static immortality, he tells you to put him out of his misery. However, doing so would ruin one of the only flourishing places in the entire map, so it's up to you to decide which course of action to take. Combine this choice with the increasingly crazy cult handing out mind-altering sap from the tree and it makes for one of the most disturbing quests Fallout 3 has to offer.

6. Human Error (Fallout 4)

Fallout 4's Covenant is one of the only settlements in the game where you're aren't threatened with a machine gun as soon as you step onto the premises. Instead, you're greeted by some of the friendliest people in the entire game, and all you have to do is pass a test where you answer a seemingly random string of questions in order to gain access to the town. However, because this is the Fallout universe, it's pretty obvious that the overly-nice settlement is going to be hiding some kind of sinister secret. After a bit of digging and talking to another unconvinced hired merc who's been tasked with finding a missing girl, you eventually uncover Covenant's true nature; the town is really a screening zone for synths and a front to distract the outside world from a barbaric underground lab. As it turns out, the town has been kidnapping synths (or people thought to be synths) in order to develop a surefire test that can detect whether or not someone is a robot in disguise. However, to make the test a reality the town has been carrying out endless torturous experiments on both synths and humans alike - even children - in order to crack the code.

5. Vault 75 (Fallout 4)

Another case of Vault Tech being the worst people of all time, Vault 75 was designed as a way for the company to create a race of perfect humans for a post-war world. Hidden underneath a nearby elementary school, the vault was supposed to be a sanctuary for the children, parents and teachers in attendance - however, as soon as the bombs fell all the adults were swiftly taken aside and murdered, leaving the children to grow up alone with the help of a select few scientists. The plan was simple: weed out the weak links and alter the genetics of the survivors through a series of experiments, rinse and repeat until the tests were complete. That's not it though, while this was happening the children were also being brainwashed into hating those who survived the war on the surface above, being indoctrinated into a cult that justified the killings of kids. Of course, weeding out the now-teens proved to be a fruitless exercise, and the remaining survivors knew that the experimenters were never going to be 100% successful, surmising that the scientists would eventually sacrifice everyone in the vault. The remaining few rebelled, turning against their captors and destroying much of the vault in the process, rising to the surface in an attempt to win back whatever semblance of freedom they had left.

4. Our Little Secret (Fallout 3)

At first glance, the small settlement of Andale looks just like any of the few unremarkable towns in Fallout 3 that you stroll through, buy a few stimpacks from and quickly forget about. However, if you become friendly with the townsfolk you'll be offered their speciality consumable item, a Strange Meat Pie which offers a series of boosts for your Vault Dweller. Everything seems peachy, that is, until a mysterious character named Old Man Harris warns you to stay away from the town, begging the Vault Dweller to leave and never come back. If you do a bit of digging into the crazy guy's claims, unlocking a shack hidden away in the settlement that requires you to max out the locksmith skill, you'll be able to see for yourself just what ingredient makes those famous meat pies so special. It turns out that, shocker, the entire town is chopping up passers-by and turning them into the best item on the menu, Sweeney Todd style. While it's a classic cannibal tale, and pretty generic as far as Fallout goes, the amount of work you have to put into uncovering the truth, and the fact that you could be using the consumables from the town indefinitely as buffs without knowing what they're made of, makes the end revelation that much more disturbing.

3. Lonesome Road (New Vegas)

The downloadable add-on to New Vegas, the Lonesome Road DLC, sees you venturing to The Divide, a vast, once-flourishing area that has slowly been dying over the past few years. While there, you're attempting to find a Courier named Ulysses, a man who turned down the offer to carry the platinum chip that kickstarted the events of the main game. Throughout all of the separate DLC packs released for New Vegas you're essentially fighting through the aftermath of Ulysses' journey, dealing with the consequences of his actions. However, when you finally catch up to him in the wasteland of The Divide, it becomes clear just why the character hates your guts so much. Essentially, he sees your Courier as the person he should have been. He's been on a similar path as you the entire time - but making all the wrong decisions in the process. Likewise, it turns out that your character ironically aided the destruction of The Divide, a settlement that your actions in the main game actually helped make a reality. It's a rather convoluted story, yet the way it's weaved throughout the entire main game and its expansions makes for one of the most satisfyingly poignant endings to any quest in the Fallout series.

2. Hard Luck Blues (New Vegas)

Hard Luck Blues is home to one of the hardest moral choices to ever grace a Fallout game. When you're asked by a small settlement to sort out the small problem of their entire water supply being too irradiated to use, you eventually find yourself in the depths of Vault 34, one of the few vaults in the Mojave Wasteland that still has people living inside. At first, it doesn't appear that this will cause any problems in regards to your main mission, as all you need to do is make a few tweaks to a couple of terminals inside the vault in order to stop a leak from spreading to the nearby water supply. However, when you finally find a way to shut off the radiation, it's revealed that by doing so you'd trap the inhabitants of the vault inside the room they're in, sealing the doors and leaving them to starve. To complete the quest you have to choose whether or not to shut off the pumps, saving one group of people by dooming the other. Even worse, when you finally complete the mission and make the decision, you don't receive any Karma points for it. As a result, you'll never know whether you made the best choice, and you'll have to carry around the guilt of knowing that you doomed an entire group of innocent people for the rest of your playtime.

1. Tranquility Lane (Fallout 3)

One of Fallout 3's biggest left-turns came right near the end of its main story. On your way to find the G.E.C.K (one of Fallout's many long-standing McGuffins) you're forced into a simulation that transports you to a seemingly idyllic 1950's suburban neighbourhood and into the body of a young child. However, in order to free your father who's also trapped in the simulation you're told to perform a series of increasingly hostile acts to the neighbours living in the village. While this starts out as teasing others kids in the neighbourhood and breaking up marriages, it quickly devolves into cold-blooded killings - all while you're in the body of a child, remember. In a series of bloodthirsty tasks you're told to don a terrifying mask to hide your identity and bash in the brains of most of the innocent occupants of the estate. Although the acts themselves are rather dark for the game, it's the aesthetics that really sell the twisted nature of the quest itself. This isn't post-apocalyptic DC you're in any more, it's an even creepier, warped black-and-white version of America before the nuclear war. Easily one of the most memorable parts from Bethesda's first attempt at a Fallout game, Tranquility Lane remains one of the most talked about quests the series has ever seen. What's been your most macabre and twisted quest in Fallout history? Let us know in the comments!

Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.