10 Decisions That Killed Video Game Sequels EVERYBODY Wanted
These sequels were met with a terrible fate.
Video games tend to get cancelled more than you might realize. Sometimes a game is in development and we're not even aware of it until we find out about it's cancellation, at which point we mourn a project we never even knew existed. Sometimes, though, a game cancellation hurts more than it might otherwise.
Game sequels getting cancelled is nothing new, but sometimes you can trace the project's demise to a single and tangible decision. Worse yet, this often happens to sequels that are hotly anticipated. Be it a sequel to a cult classic or the next chapter in a long-running franchise, fans spend months and even years waiting for these games to arrive.
So when some behind the scenes disaster strikes or, worse yet, a studio goes belly up, often the first victim is the sequel that fans have been craving for the past 2-3 years. It's a bitter reminder that no game is safe, no matter how big it might seem.
So let's take a horrible stroll through memory lane and revisit the ten times when a highly-anticipated video game sequel met its end due to a few fateful decisions.
10. Perfect Dark Core & Perfect Dark Vengeance
After Rare was acquired by Microsoft in 2002, there were a lot of questions about what would happen to some of their franchises. The British developer had carved out a unique blend of character, humor and strong design that characterized their titles for years. This was never more evident than their work on Perfect Dark, a first-person shooter developed exclusively for the Nintendo 64.
Taking its cues from GoldenEye 007, then improving on it in nearly every possible way, Perfect Dark seemed like the perfect fit for Microsoft's more shooter-heavy console library.
Years later, work would begin on not one but two sequels; Perfect Dark Core and Perfect Dark Vengeance, with development on the first game leading to a faster turnaround for the second. This went on for some time, but the game eventually morphed into a first-person mech game and bore little resemblance to the Perfect Dark universe.
Additionally, Microsoft would decide that they had little interest in the sequel, as they saw franchises like Halo and Gears of War as being more profitable long-term. In all, Rare's time with Joanna Dark feels like it came to a permanent end with the death of Perfect Dark Core.
A sad end to a franchise that felt as though it had unlimited potential.
9. Dead Space 4
When the original Dead Space launched back in 2008, it was coming right off the heels of the game that redefined the survival horror genre; Resident Evil 4. Dead Space 2 launched in 2011 to critical acclaim, but then something happened that threw the franchise off course.
Dead Space 3 was largely considered the worst game in the series, being accused of taking the franchise off into a more action-heavy direction. Despite this, Dead Space 3 still shipped 4 million copies. This was a number that Electronic Arts wasn't terribly fond of, citing a requirement of five million units.
This, along with an apparent lack of interest from the EA higher-ups, doomed what promised to be a very ambitious fourth entry. According to creative director Ben Wanat, Dead Space 4 was intended to be more of a non-linear experience and feature some pretty startling revelations about who or what the Necromorphs really are.
Not only that, but series protagonist Isaac Clarke was scheduled to sit this one out and Ellie Langford was envisioned as the main hero of DS4. All of these elements pointed to a Dead Space 4 that was going to be very different, which could have been nothing but a good thing for the series moving forward.
8. Conker's Other Bad Day
Conker's Bad Fur Day began its life as Twelve Tales: Conker 64, a title that felt very similar to other 3D platformers on the market. This was something that developer Rare noticed rather quickly, completely overhauling the title from a cute, family friendly romp into a subversive send-up of the entire entertainment industry.
It was a game that cultivated a rabid and devoted fanbase that has been waiting for Conker's second adventure for nearly twenty years.
Known as Conker's Other Bad Day, the sequel was to be directed by creator Chris Seavor and see Conker begin his tumultuous reign as the King. This new adventure would see Conker have to escape from prison after spending all the treasury money on, what else, booze and parties. A full story was written, along with a few pieces of art and 3D renders.
Tragically, Conker's next adventure would be derailed when Rare was purchased by Microsoft in 2002. The new owners of Rare's cavalcade of IP's made it clear that they had no interest in a Conker sequel, thus the foul-mouthed little squirrel was put on ice for the next two decades.
7. Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic 3
Sometimes, a sequel is cancelled for reasons that require little to no explanation; money. Unfortunately, this is what derailed the development of Knights of the Old Republic 3.
The third, and presumably final, chapter in BioWare's beloved Star Wars RPG series was planned to be something mighty impressive. Writer John Stafford made it clear that KOTOR 3 had a completed story and was ready to go into full development, while designer Chris Avellone suggested that it would involve the player tracking Revan into the unknown regions.
KOTOR 3 was scheduled to enter development sometime in 2005, but publisher LucasArts ran into some financial trouble. A need for quick cash is likely the reason that LucasArts pushed developer Obsidian to release KOTOR 2 earlier than they had wanted to, further putting the publisher into a financial nosedive, as KOTOR 2 sold considerably less than the first title.
As a result of shifting priorities within LucasArts, KOTOR 3 was abandoned and the conclusion to the story that was started all those years ago remains in flux. According to a few rumors, there is some desire within Electronic Arts to bring the series back, but until we've got it in our hands, Revan's finale will sadly stay in the darker corners of the galaxy.
6. Star Wars: Battlefront III
Before Battlefront became a part of EA's ever-growing library of Star Wars projects, the series began under the stewardship of Pandemic Studios.
The first Battlefront game launched for the sixth generation of home consoles and PC in 2004, becoming one of the most critically acclaimed games of its generation. Meanwhile, Battlefront II launched one year later and eclipsed the first title in every way possible.
For Battlefront III, however, LucasArts called on developers Free Radical Design to bring the third entry to life. Made up of former Rare employees, Free Radical had made a name for itself with titles like TimeSplitters and Second Sight.
Development on Battlefront III continued as planned, with a former employee of the now defunct Free Radical claiming that the game was 99% complete and only needed a few more weeks of bug testing.
In 2008, LucasArts quietly cancelled Battlefront III. It was a game that no one knew even existed until footage was unearthed in 2016, while others noted that assets and story material from the axed title was repurposed into a PSP game called Star Wars Battlefront: Elite Squadron by Rebellion Developments.
5. Tom Clancy's Rainbow 6: Patriots
Rainbow Six Siege has become a staple of eSports since it first launched in 2015, but in order for it to truly become the game it was meant to be, another one had to die.
That was game Rainbow 6: Patriots, a single-player shooter set in New York City that saw Team Rainbow in conflict with a domestic terrorist group known as the True Patriots. Patriots was not concerned with being a tactical multiplayer experience, but rather a dark and sobering tale about morality and nationalism.
The intention with Patriots was fascinating, as it sought to cast domestic terrorists as the villains in a rather timely manner. This was going to be combined with a campaign where it would be seen from multiple different perspectives, as you would see through the eyes of both Team Rainbow and various civilians caught in the middle.
Despite a strong, favorable reaction to Patriots, the game was doomed by the arrival of the eight generation of game consoles. Patriots began development on the PS3 and Xbox 360, but the debut of the PS4 and XBox One shifted the game to new hardware. During this time, the team at UbiSoft decided that in the change to the new machines, that it would be better to start fresh.
4. Silent Hills
When Silent Hills was first revealed via PT, an interactive demo released on the PlayStation Store, it was a sign of great things to come. The Silent Hill franchise had been floundering for some time, with the painfully average Downpour being the last mainline release.
Spearheaded by Metal Gear mastermind Hideo Kojima and director Guillermo del Toro, Silent Hills starred Norman Reedus of The Walking Dead and was poised to bring the franchise back in a big way.
Rumors began to circulate on the internet that Kojima would leave Konami after development on Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain had completed, which left the future of Silent Hills up in the air. There was precedent for a title being handed over to a new team after the current director had left the studio, but Silent Hills was built upon being a Kojima-led SH title.
It all came crashing down for Silent Hills. A game that held so much promise, built to bring back one of the most beloved horror franchises of all time, was cast aside. Recent reports indicate that Silent Hills may return, either as a Kojima Productions title or even under the leadership of franchise creator Keiichiro Toyama.
However, Toyama recently left Sony and the reports of Kojima returning to the title are unsubstantiated.
3. Prey 2
When Prey first launched back in 2006, developers Human Head Studios really managed to create something quite special. It featured a Native American lead and unique, gravity-defying shooting. A sequel was announced in August of 2006, although the IP would eventually land with Bethesda in 2009.
Human Head Studios was not just aiming to create a sequel to a popular first-person shooter; they were going big, showcasing a sprawling, futuristic city in which their new tale would take place. Being a narrative sequel to Prey instead of a direct one, the character of Tommy from the first game would return in a new capacity.
As Prey 2 continued development under Human Head, rumors of Bethesda being unhappy with the game began to surface. Even worse, reports of something akin to a hostile takeover of Human Head by Bethesda also started to make the rounds. In 2014, Bethesda announced that Prey 2 was cancelled.
Prey did resurface in a 2017 reboot that was well received, but the sequel that promised the life of a bounty hunter on a hostile alien planet would never see the light of day. Prey 2 showed an incredible amount of promise, but internal strife and political positioning made sure that fans would never get the chance to experience it.
2. Mega Man Legends 3
These days, Mega Man is a franchise that appears on the rise once more. Mega Man 11 launched in 2018 and was met with a positive reception from longtime fans. That wasn't the case, however, when the franchise went silent for eight years.
The Legends branch of Mega Man differed from the mainline games in that it featured more of a robust, story-heavy experience and was played from a third-person perspective. Legends 1 is a cult classic and 2 featured a cliffhanger ending, with Mega Man and friends stranded on Elysium. The promise of Mega Man Legends 3 to resolve this cliffhanger was broken when, in 2010, longtime series producer Keiji Inafune departed Capcom.
Emotions are reported to have ran high, as Inafune's exit from Capcom was supposedly a dramatic one. Potentially sparked by Inafune's rather negative opinion on the state of the games industry in Japan, his departure meant that Capcom had little to no faith in Mega Man Legends 3.
Inafune's Mega Man-inspired Kickstarter project, the much-maligned Mighty No. 9, failed to capture the magic that made the series so special. It prompted Capcom to deliver Mega Man 11, but Legends 3 remains just that; a legend that might remain untold forever.
1. Sleeping Dogs 2
Sleeping Dogs began development under United Front Games as Black Lotus, an open-world action game that publisher Activision folded into their True Crime franchise. As a competitor to the Grand Theft Auto series, True Crime: Streets of LA was decent but barely made a dent into GTA's dominance of the open-world genre.
United Front continued to work on the game, known as True Crime: Hong Kong, until the rights were eventually purchased by Square-Enix. Now known as Sleeping Dogs, the game became something quite special.
Though its sales weren't mind-blowing, Square saw a lot of potential in the IP and put United Front to work on a sequel. Intended to be one of the most ambitious open-world games the industry had ever seen, Sleeping Dogs 2 took place in a real-life megacity known as the Pearl River Delta.
This protracted development lead to United Front leaving their magnum opus on the table, opting to put their budget into Triad Wars; an MMO developed for PC that entered a beta phase in 2015, but left the Sleeping Dogs fanbase feeling rather numb.
With no traction on the MMO side, United Front announced an abrupt closure and the end of Sleeping Dogs 2.