10 Divisive Video Games That Are Secretly The Best Entry

We REALLY need to get a handle on our expectations.

Batman Arkham Origins
Warner Bros.

Video game hype is the weirdest thing. Like yes, we'll all get carried away on a wave of screenshots, trailers, developer interviews and gameplay snippets, playing a mind's eye version of whatever game we're excited about until we can practically smell the power-ups.

Come launch though, everything either totally pays off or falls apart entirely; the rubber meeting the road... or the road not loading in whatsoever.

Opinion columns are written, Youtube videos are made - and that's pretty much that. A certain game is deemed terrible forever, or something capitalised on the hype, and it's positive reception is solidified as a must-play.

However, what about those games that received significant work post-launch, or for any number of reasons, were totally overlooked by the vast majority at the time?

For better or worse, games can be patched and changed after release, meaning all those initial impressions are just as subject to change as the games themselves.


10. Star Wars Battlefront 2

Star wars battlefront 2
EA

At launch it was a laughing stock; the poster boy for everything wrong with the gaming industry across the second half of the 2010s. And whilst there were still some highlights like the new Starfighter Assault mode and a fun enough campaign to blast through, the amount of sheer negativity that surrounded Battlefront 2 tanked sales, saw it the centre of a political storm about child gambling, and made millions of us look the other way.

Going forward though - and we're now in the game's third year of support - DICE have turned this thing around in a way not too dissimilar to No Man's Sky.

By focusing on free content updates, completely overhauling the progression system to remove paying for anything if you don't want to, and highlighting those exquisite large-scale battles, Battlefront 2 is EASILY the best Star Wars Battlefront game by a considerable margin.

Now comprising characters, voice casts, levels and costumes from all three main trilogies and the Clone Wars, if it wasn't for the first KOTOR, this would be the best Star Wars game, period.


9. Batman: Arkham Origins

batman arkham origins
Warner Bros.

Not taking anything away from just how seismic Arkham Asylum was, but if we're looking at the full franchise - the entirety of their scope, Batman's entire range of abilities and sheer bang for your buck - Arkham Origins just edges it out.

Why? Because although Batman was fine enough in the main trilogy, here he's a walking haymaker. Bruce Wayne's infancy as the Dark Knight is immediately engaging, and when he's not tussling with Alfred over the moralities of putting half of Gotham's criminals in the hospital, he's breaking into the GCPD to get answers for the next plot point.

Couple this with an ability system you'll only unlock if you experiment with Batman's entire arsenal, procedurally generated crimes where you save police and Gotham's citizens, and a Challenge mode where you can play as Deathstroke, and it's a mighty meaty package.

Oh, and DLC is actually genuinely worth your time in this one. "Cold, Cold Heart" does Mr. Freeze better than anywhere else, showing that whilst Origins' reputation is the 'odd one out', its execution was always stellar.


8. Watch Dogs 2

Watch Dogs 2
Ubisoft

The first game embodied the "meh" feeling that was the beginning of the generation, but Watch Dogs 2 got every last thing right, and then some.

The only problem? Nobody cared.

Still, right off the bat Marcus Holloway is a more energetic and memorable presence on-screen than the dour, mopey Adrian Pearce, and the game invests entirely in a caricatured version of San Francisco. "Tech culture" abounds, you can infiltrate a fake Google, and there's a manbun'd, yoga-posing CEO as the main villain.

The best thing was your ability to hack into literally every object. Whilst it's not exactly realistic, suddenly you could remotely tell cars to reverse into enemies, rig steam grates to send goons sailing across the map, or just pilot your remote RC car through a warehouse to complete the mission for you.

Watch Dogs 2 honed that sense of technology tipping the balance in your favour that the original lacked, and with some genuinely stunning graphics, this is a super fun cyber-infused romp you can pick up for hella cheap today.


7. Fallout: New Vegas

fallout new vegas
Obsidian

Obsidian have always been a stellar RPG developer, but even they couldn't turn around a full Fallout game in the painfully restrictive 18 month dev window they were given by Bethesda. The result was one of the most legendarily broken games of all time, but thankfully for those who could look past the rotating heads, there was a game with so many incredible ideas.

Thanks to handfuls of patches smoothing things over, New Vegas gets to shine even brighter. The way Obsidian designs RPGs just plays more directly into what the genre stands for: Role-playing.

Off the bat we have a character with history in the world, a number of factions to befriend and pit against one another, far more in-depth dialogue options, fail-able missions that change what happens next, a way more driven story and choices that directly impact your options for the rest of the game.

You can argue it out in the comments as to whether this beats Fallout 3 or the originals, but for me, it's not even close.


6. Rainbow Six Siege

Rainbow Six Siege
Ubisoft

Back when it first dropped in 2015, Rainbow Six: Siege was a shell of its expected self.

An Angela Bassett-fronted single player boiled down to a glorified tutorial for multiplayer, and whilst you could see something great was at the core, microtransactions and a lack of levels and characters dragged the whole production down.

Considering Siege was following on from the immaculate Vegas games, the common perception was that Ubisoft had messed things up yet again, and many moved on.

Thankfully, the following years saw massive overhauls to the game's monetary elements, dialling back microtransactions, introducing various "Starter" versions so you could play with a reduced roster, and giving the game some of the most satisfyingly intense maps in FPS history.

With a better progression system, so many approaches to a given scenario, a blink-and-you're-dead allocation of health and the feeling that the devs were actually being given the time they needed, Siege has now amassed a staggering 50 million players, and remains one of the most played games in the world.


5. Heavy Rain

Heavy Rain
Quantic Dream

Though not a numbered series of games, it's long been believed that all of David Cage's titles take place in the same timeline. Evidence such as the Origami Killer being mentioned in Beyond Two Souls, or various references to Fahrenheit/Indigo Prophecy in Detroit: Become Human are just two.

Point being: Dude is pretty much the M. Night Shyamalan of games, and though Heavy Rain's voice acting "JAY-SON!" scene became the stuff of meme-able legend, the game overall is his most solid work by a long shot.

Yes, Detroit attempts to address racial inequality, morality and civil rights through android analogues, but it's done with such a tone deaf, obvious approach, you're unlikely to come away with anything worthwhile.

Heavy Rain though, is practically a David Fincher detective thriller - or the nearest we're ever gonna get without him.

Trying to solve the case of the Origami Killer in rainswept Philadelphia, Heavy Rain mercifully doesn't fall back on a catch-all supernatural element to wrap everything up. Yes, the final killer twist can feel forced, but to me it always made enough sense to be satisfying, topping off a brilliant Saw-meets-Se7en story.

A bunch of different endings govern which of your four protagonists survive and which information gets out, making for some great replay value if you want to try it all again.


4. Assassin's Creed Syndicate

Assassin's Creed Syndicate gadget
Ubisoft

Need to make a slight distinction with this one, because having now been going for almost two decades, it feels like we need to talk about Assassin's Creed pre and post-AC Origins.

Now, depending on where you come down on the two newer titles vs. their more identifiable originals will determine whether Syndicate tops those too, but in terms of perfecting what Assassin's Creed used to be, that's where Syndicate soars.

After AC Unity, 2015's Assassin's Creed was the one where everyone threw up the middle fingers and walked away, but the problem with that, is Syndicate's story, array of abilities, graphics, gameplay variety and level of polish, makes it the best-playing AC of them all.

Headed up by twin protagonists Jacob and Evie Frye (an idea later popularised by AC Odyssey), the former is more of a bruiser leading gangs into battle, where the latter gets to play around with cloaking devices and pure stealth.

The pair get access to a grapple gun that was the last necessary evolution of traditional Assassin's Creed traversal, and the whole game world is rammed full of criminals to hunt, warehouses to clean out, and sights to see.


3. The Last Guardian

The Last Guardian
Team ICO

Another trilogy of titles that didn't get numbered as they rolled out - yet all form part of the same story, mythology and world ruleset - are ICO, Shadow of the Colossus and The Last Guardian.

Now, The Last Guardian always appeared to get short thrift. The victim of a 10 year development cycle that meant an entire generation of people were barely sentient when its first teases dropped, for the rest of us, it's one of the more unique adventure games you could ever play.

Centred in the boy-and-his-family-pet relationship of an unknown child and the large cat-dog-bird-like beast called Trico, the genius to the game's design comes through the very natural sense of bonding with the creature itself.

You'll start out struggling to get it to listen to commands, only to know exactly when to call for aid, so Trico can swoop in and wipe out an entire platoon of enemies with one claw swipe. If you're a dog or cat person, it's as rewarding as building that kinship with your pet, and remains the best digital version of that relationship in gaming history.


2. Wolfenstein II: The New Colossus

wolfenstein 2
Bethesda

Wolfenstein's second rebooted instalment has the weirdest reputation, in that for every person you find who adored it (like me), there are three more who can't put their finger on what felt "off".

And although I can totally concede that the game failed when it came to managing difficulty (just knock it down and enjoy what's here instead), there are so many high points throughout that made this a phenomenal ride from start to finish.

First up, it's absolutely stunning. Everything from character models to barrel explosions look stunning and really leap off the screen, but then you have the buildup and payoff of BJ Blazkowicz going from a down n' out wheelchair-bound soldier, to receiving a super suit of armour for the game's second half.

A notably bold script delves into how a Nazi-ruled America would force people to take sides, exposing ugly truths and comparisons with how white supremacists would be more than okay with that version of history.

Pulse-pounding gameplay, another beast of a Mick Gordon score, one of the best uses of Hitler - and an accompanying achievement - you've ever seen, and a perfectly-paced narrative that hits every beat with supreme confidence.

I never got the dislike of The New Colossus, and to me it's excellent from front to back.


1. Max Payne 3

Max Payne 3
Rockstar

Possibly the most unfairly treated game of Rockstar's back catalogue, and certainly of the 2010s. I too was more than guilty of screaming "What have they done?!" when that first batch of screenshots showed a Hawaiian shirted, totally bald Max, as it couldn't be further from what Remedy began in the originals.

Divorce yourself from those expectations though, and this is one of Dan Houser's best scripts. Max is every bit the wise-cracking noir machine of yesteryear, but iced off with some supremely dark comedic tones, a sardonic sensibility, and even a nihilistic edge that lets you know HE thinks his whole life is a joke.

It's the gunplay that excels above all else. Rockstar would put every ounce of their budget into developing a physics-heavy system where every bullet matters. Even Max's hulking frame has real momentum, and needs to be piloted through the chaos. Leaping into the air with twin pistols is a considered choice, as is playing the angles game and progressing more methodically.

Add gorgeous slow-motion toggles to show everything off and an up-close cam filled with enemy bodies being perforated with each shell, and you have an outstanding third-person shooter with a career-best performance from James McCaffrey.


Watch Next


Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.