10 Earth-Shattering Video Game Plot Twists You Didn't See Coming
When your human hero finishes the story as a different species.
Everyone loves - and hates - plot twists. The stunning reveal that leaves your brain spinning and your jaw on the floor, inflicting you with that cloying sense of shame as you wonder how on earth you didn’t spot the obvious.
It’s like a magician’s illusion - you love to learn the trick, but you can’t stand the fact it was so simple.
And yet, gaming has pulled off some absolute blinders. Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic’s stunning reveal of Revan, Bioschock’s inspired use of the phrase ‘Would you kindly?', and Resident Evil’s Albert Wesker turning out to be a traitor.
All have become iconic moments that cemented their place in gamers’ thoroughly bamboozled minds.
But there are other games with twists as good, if not better, that performed feats of sleight-of-hand that place them proudly alongside the best the medium has to offer.
--
Warning: MAJOR spoilers follow.
10. The Narrator Turns Out To Be A Devil - Icewind Dale
Being a narrator is a thankless job, providing important exposition to an impatient audience only to be forgotten as soon as the game ends. But Icewind Dale pulls a surprise twist, making sure its narrator will be remembered for a long time.
The game opens with a mysterious force tormenting the remote northern region of Icewind Dale. This being D&D a group of plucky adventurers answer the call, quickly finding themselves locked in mortal combat against Belhifet, a powerful devil looking to turn the citizens of the region into a demonic army.
Naturally, our heroes win. But, just as the player is basking in the glow of a battle hard won, the calm scholarly delivery we’ve grown accustomed to devolves into psychotic, snarling rage and we learn that the man telling the story is none other than Belhifet himself. Worse, his banishment is coming to an end, and he’s itching for revenge.
The shock is immense not only because there was no hint of his devilish identity, but also because you’re left wondering if the heroes truly won. It’s a great twist, proving that even the humble narrator can be used to outstanding dramatic effect.
9. You Are Not Who - Or What - You Think - Prey (2017)
On the surface the 2017 reboot of Prey appears to be a straightforward story of ethically dubious research gone badly wrong. Isolated research facility? Check. Containment breach of a hostile alien species? Check. A choice between heroic self-sacrifice or saving the research and inviting inevitable disaster down the line? Check.
Only one thing seems out of place, an opening segment where the protagonist, Morgan Yu, wakes up in what seems to be their apartment, only to later find that it is a well-disguised set and they are a willing lab-rat.
That last bit is important because it proves to be a Chekov’s Gun.
The protagonist is a lab-rat, and there was a containment breach, but the game’s events all happened in that past. In the present day, Earth has been completely overrun, the real Morgan is long dead and the person you’ve been playing as is not a person, but a thing – a captured alien - intended to be used as an ambassador between their race and the humans.
Sharp players might have had a lightbulb go off early, but for most, being an alien all along was novel and jaw-dropping way to end the game.
8. It's All A Simulation - Star Ocean: Till The End Of Time
Hand out the award for the most despised plot twist of all time and Star Ocean 3 would have the trophy shoved into its hands and told to get the heck out.
In order to save their universe from a race known as the Executioners, the protagonists set out to reach 4D Space, a separate dimension of existence from which the command to exterminate their reality originates.
They succeed...only to find a boy sat in a house messing around with a video game. As it happens their universe is a simulation, a form of MMO, and our heroes are what amount to advanced, sentient NPCs. Their response? A resigned shrug of the shoulders.
This went down about as well as you would expect. The seemingly lazy bit of meta commentary, along with the characters’ remarkably nonplussed reaction to learning that they’re not real, left fans feeling that the ‘twist’ invalidated everything that came before and reduced a much loved setting to a tired sci-fi trope.
But infuriating as it was it worked – no one saw it coming – and fast forward to today, where the Simulation Hypothesis is being taken very seriously, and the twist ends up being less lazy, and more eerily prescient.
7. The Polite Elf Is Not An Elf - Dragon Age: Inquisition
Dragon Age has a long history of successfully flirting with subtle and often entertaining twists: Origins saw the sobering revelation that only a Warden could kill the Archdemon, and Dragon Age 2 gave us the hilarious, ego-deflating framed narrative opening. But with Inquisition it produced something that left fans speechless.
When fan-favourite character Flemeth is revealed to be the elven god, Mythal, it comes as a shock, but one you can wrap your head around: she is, after all, an ancient, enigmatic being, a powerful mage, and can transform into a dragon. Learning that she is an elven god in human form makes sense.
What is difficult to wrap your head around is the revelation that Solas, the well-mannered, soft-spoken, scholarly elf who has been your companion, and perhaps even lover, throughout the game, is actually Fen’Harel, the elven god of betrayal.
Top this titbit of world-upending information with the fact the he is responsible for the games’ events, apparently kills Flemeth, and have the stones to stick all this in a post credits scene, and Bioware pulled off a first class WTF moment the likes of which will never, ever be matched.
6. Strelok Is The Marked One - S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Shadow Of Chernobyl
Shadow of Chernobyl wastes no time introducing its mystery, casting the player in the role of a half-dead survivor of a horrific crash, with no memory of who they are and the only clue to their identity an ominous command to ‘Kill Strelok.’
Over the course of the game the amnesiac, dubbed the Marked One (for the S.T.A.L.K.E.R. tattoo on his arm), learns that Strelok and his crew were the first to reach the ruined Chernobyl nuclear reactor. But, this meddling resulted in an emission that wrought havoc on the Zone, explaining the deathmark on his dead.
Eventually the Marked One learns the truth – they are Strelok. The emission knocked Strelok unconscious, and finding only one unmarked body among many the powers who wanted to stop him mistakenly, and ironically, sent him out to kill himself.
Once you know that the Marked One is Strelok the twist is obvious, but until you do the clues given are nothing more than simple, and stylish, exposition. It’s a slick bit of sleight-of-hand and a clever way to invest the player in a character who is both hero and villain.
5. Saren Is A Pawn - Mass Effect
It is the 2000’s and Bioware is on a roll. Jade Empire and Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic produced two of the best plot twists gaming will ever see and capped off the masterful performance with Mass Effect’s iconic introduction to the Reapers.
The game quickly and effectively establishes Saren, a rogue Turian Spectre, as its primary villain: we see him murder a fellow Spectre in cold blood, pursue a racist agenda against humanity and leverage his legendary reputation to cover his corruption. His personal spaceship, dubbed Sovereign, while powerful, is never presented as anything other than a simple spacecraft.
But there is nothing simple about Sovereign. In a chilling conversation with the eldritch beast it is revealed that it is the brains behind the operation – Saren is merely an indoctrinated puppet.
Worse, Sovereign is the vanguard of the Reapers, an advanced cybernetic species responsible for a perpetual cycle of galactic genocide, and now the clock is about to strike midnight.
It is a twist that jacked the stakes up to an existential level, transformed an already great game into the stuff of legend, and laid the foundation for a series that would define a genre.
4. The Gods Are Fake - Pillars Of Eternity
As a spiritual successor to the much loved Dungeons & Dragons Infinity Engine games, Pillars of Eternity faced many expectations, not least of which was the inclusion of a diverse and powerful pantheon. After all, gods meddling in mortal affairs is fertile story material.
And Pillars did not disappoint. You have the Hollowborn Plague, a curse attributed to the retribution of the god, Eothas; a shadowy organization centred around the worship of the exiled Woedica; and the obligatory unspeakable rituals, performed in the name of the evil Skaen.
So it comes as a big surprise when the question that drives the plot is ‘Are the Gods real?,’ and a proper eye-popper when the answer is a definitive ‘no.’ Instead, it is revealed that in the ancient past no gods existed. Afraid that this knowledge would lead to anarchy the Engwithans manufactured gods by fusing their own souls into magical constructs. The gods, are frauds. But, to add paradox to twist, they can still ruin you day.
Pulling this kind of shocking and subtle reveal is pure Obsidian, a clever subversion of expectation that, like all great twists do, sticks in your mind long afterwards.
3. The Flaw That Was Not - Jade Empire
With Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic Bioware treated gamers to the earth-shattering Revan reveal, and in Jade Empire the legendary masters of the RPG gave us another.
The story begins with the player character, the Spirit Monk, training under the wise and likeable Master Li. Then their home is attacked, Li is captured by the villainous emperor Sun Hai, and the Spirit Monk takes up their destiny to rescue him.
Throughout the game both opponents and admirers remark on the Spirit Monk’s technique, noting a ‘flaw’ that appears to be a weakness but is instead a deadly trap, one their opponents unwittingly fall into. But the trap works both ways and in a blindside to end all blindsides Master Li dismantles the iron-clad technique and kills the Spirit Monk in a matter of seconds.
As it turns out Master Li wanted to be emperor and you were his all too willing, and unwitting, stooge.
Gut punch though it is you can’t help but admire the genius of Bioware: dangling the truth under our noses without ever tipping their hand is a delicate balancing act, and one they pulled off with fiendish aplomb.
2. 'The Polito Form Is Dead, Insect.' - System Shock 2
Bioshock’s iconic ‘Would you kindly?’ may well be the greatest plot twist of all time, a brilliant piece of razor sharp misdirection that absolutely no one saw coming. But its spiritual predecessor, System Shock 2, produced a twist far more shocking – and terrifying.
Things have gone badly wrong aboard the starship Von Braun: something that definitely shouldn’t have been was brought board, unleashing a biological psychic hive-mind that promptly transformed the crew into a mob of moaning, mutated zombies. Emerging from stasis into the midst of this horror you are contacted by Dr Janice Polito, who saves your life and orders you to meet her.
Problem is, Polito is dead. Instead you find yourself confronted by SHODAN, an insane, incalculably dangerous AI, whose distorted, mocking voice and cold green eyes is the thing of nightmares. She reveals that she’s the one who created the biological plague ravaging the ship, and you are going to help her kill her unruly children.
And she’s not about to take no for answer.
With Bioshock chances are you don’t remember who was behind the famous twist. With System Shock 2’ reveal of SHODAN you will never forget. It is simultaneously a stunning twist and an equally stunning intro to one of the most frightening villains in gaming.
1. 2B Is An Executioner - NieR: Automata
If the game you’re playing casually drops the name of philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche then two things are guaranteed: it is going to mess with your mind, and it is going to get dark.
NieR: Automata tells the story of a group of androids fighting to reclaim Earth from a race of machines on behalf of humans who are believed to be sheltering on the Moon. But the fight is not going well, forcing the androids to make sacrifice after heart-breaking sacrifice.
However, the humans are long dead, knowledge deliberately concealed from the androids lest they loose their will to fight. It gets worse. We find out that the war between androids and machines is locked in an endless cycle: should the Androids ever gain the upper hand the system resets, restarting the conflict.
Worst of all it is revealed that 2B, the likeable android who is the game’s emotional core, is actually an ‘E,’ model an executioner whose purpose is to ruthlessly kill her fellow android 9S if he comes close to learning the truth about the humans. He remembers none of this, but she does, and it is slowly breaking her mind.
Mercifully the game can end on an optimistic note, but the toll of one hammer blow of a twist after another will leave you questioning the point of existence, just as the developers intended.