10 Epic Fails That Ruined The Wii U

There are 10 core, underlying facets that ensured the console was always destined to self-implode.

The startling announcement was made last week that Nintendo were anticipating an operating loss of $335.2 million for the financial year (ending in March), with their stock almost dropping one-fifth for a time as well. This has largely been attributed to the abject failure of their Wii U console, which launched in November of 2012 and has simply failed to gain much traction in the gaming market since. The popularity of both the PlayStation 4 and Xbox One in the last two months has made it clear that the Wii U has quickly been edged out of the eight-generation console war, and is going to likely be taking a place in history as a regrettably epic fail, alongside the likes of Sega's ahead-of-its-time Dreamcast. Unfortunately, the same claim can't be held to Nintendo's console however, which has been a victim of so much negative press over the last 14 months that its small victories have pretty much gone unnoticed. One could go on and on about the reasons why the Wii U has failed, but there are 10 core, underlying facets that ensured the console was always destined to self-implode. Feel free to chime in with your own reasoning, and if you're a Wii U owner, let me know what hopes you have moving forward!

10. Relying On Casual & Non-Gamers Too Much

Nintendo's Wii was a work of marketing and engineering genius, selling itself not just to the core Nintendo gamers who would buy every console as long as it featured Mario and Zelda, but also those who have never picked up a video game controller in their lives. I'm primarily talking about middle-aged folk who may want to just play a game for 20 or 30 minutes to unwind after work, or to entertain their friends at dinner parties. Promoting itself as a console for the whole family, the Wii ended up scoring roughly 100 million hardware unit sales, but the question that Nintendo never failed to adequately answer was - why on Earth would they buy another one? This is the problem with gearing yourself so far towards a casual market. They don't have a scrap of brand loyalty, and generally will purchase in a trend-based manner, going by what the mass media feeds them. The Wii was something unique and totally different, so it caught their eye, but would a middle-class family who plays their Wii for maybe 2 or 3 hours a week really feel the need to buy another console when they still get plenty of fun out of their current one? Do they really care about a fair graphical upgrade and the various other bells and whistles the Wii U boasts? Absolutely not. By relying so heavily on these audiences, Nintendo shot themselves in the foot, with market analysts predicting that the Wii U's lifetime sales will only reach 25 million, a mere quarter of the original Wii's.

9. Awful Marketing, Even In The Face Of Failure

You would barely know the Wii U was coming out in November 2012 unless you were already a core gamer with a fevered interest in it, because both in the general public and online, advertising just wasn't really anywhere to be seen. There was much confusion among casual and non-gamers about what the console was, with many assuming that it was merely an upgrade of some kind, and therefore not a new entity in its own right. The disconnect between Nintendo and these audiences was mind-boggling, and not something that the company appears to have rectified in the 14 months since. While the Wii's marketing campaign was fresh and appealed to the very market that Nintendo ended up nailing, the Wii U floundered in large part because, as I'll explain in more detail later, they just didn't have a lot to work with software-wise. What's the good in showing off these flash new features if there's nothing to try them out on? In 2014, the console's presence is largely in the form of derogatory articles online detailing their financial failures, or in the form of a desperate price drop they've issued.

8. Lack Of First-Party AAA Titles People Actually Want

Mario, Mario Kart, Zelda, Super Smash Bros, Metroid. These games should all be launch titles, or failing that, release window titles that would have units flying off the shelves. It's not really as though Nintendo needed to launch the Wii U as early as they did, and it would have made sense to wait until at least one AAA title was ready before giving it the green light. The pitiful launch line-up made the console difficult to sell from the starting gun, and this hasn't really eased up over a year on, with only a handful of acclaimed titles rising to the top (such as Pikmin 3 and Super Mario 3D World). Then there was the Rayman debacle. The game was widely hyped and shown off at trade shows leading up to the Wii U's release, boasting the revolutionary capabilities of the Wii U's controller, but then disaster struck. Firstly, the game was delayed until February 2013, and then when Ubisoft decided that they wanted to release the game on the PS3 and Xbox 360 as well, the game was delayed until September 2013, a whopping 10 months after the initially planned release, at which point the damage had already been done in terms of sales for the console (or lack thereof), despite how excellent the final Rayman product was. Many Nintendo fans felt stung by such a turn of events, and it's clear that Ubisoft saw the writing on the wall (that the Wii U wasn't going to sell very well) and changed their plan accordingly. As for the future, Mario Kart 8 is due out in the Spring, and the only new Zelda title we know anything about is Hyrule Warriors, a depressingly desperate crossover between Zelda and the Dynasty Warriors franchise. Metroid meanwhile reportedly begins development in February, and Super Smash Bros has an undetermined 2014 release date. Not exactly an encouraging slate for 2014, then, though Mario Kart in particular will likely give sales something of a boost.

7. Old Hardware That Barely Competes With PS3 & 360

The fact that the question even has to be asked is an embarrassment in of itself: is the Wii U more powerful than the PS3 and Xbox 360? The answer is yes, though this constantly comes up in debates online, with the point being that the Wii U's graphical capabilities to date have not really been shown to exceed anything we can play on the last-generation consoles. For all intents and purposes, though the Wii U was the start of the eighth generation of gaming, to many it doesn't really feel like it, because specs-wise it is so thoroughly outclassed by the PS4 and Xbox One. As with the Wii U, Nintendo may freely argue that graphics aren't as important as the console's features, and this is especially true when targeting the largely casual audience that they are. However, when that audience has been left largely apathetic about the Wii U, it means deferring to the more hands-on core contingent, who may eventually be compelled to buy a console for Mario and Zelda, but likely aren't going to slam down the cash for a sub-par platform (from a technical perspective) right off the bat.

6. EA Bails On The Wii U

A major blow was dealt to Nintendo last summer when EA shockingly announced that they had no games in development for the Wii U, indicating that they had abandoned the console altogether and were going to focus on games for the PC, PS4 and Xbox One. EA curtly commented that they were aiming to "be where the gamers are", though they didn't rule out working on Wii U games if the console managed to bounce back, which most now view as a distant possibility. Considering that EA is one of the largest third-party video game developers on the planet, this meant a wealth in lost revenue for the Wii U, which would have otherwise likely seen countless sports franchises such as FIFA and Madden on its shelves, as well as the recent shooter Battlefield 4.

5. Medieval Online Features

It's truly baffling that Nintendo has never really got the online aspect of their consoles in tune with Microsoft and Sony's efforts, and the Wii U only further highlights how positively behind the curve they are in this respect. Arguably the biggest problem players have is that the Nintendo Network ID can only be used on the console on which it was created, meaning that all of your eShop purchases are essentially tied to the system you purchase, creating a world of trouble if your console breaks down. You have to plead your case with Nintendo customer support to transfer data and IDs between consoles, when for Sony or Microsoft consoles, it would be as simple as logging into your new console and re-downloading your purchased content. Then there's the community policing service, where even the most mildly incendiary words (like "idiot") can have you chastised by customer support, and the fact that the console as a whole, aside from Miiverse, just isn't particularly enthusiastic or geared towards multiplayer gaming. Whether for better or for worse, a strong online presence has become a necessity and mainstay of modern gaming, and Nintendo desperately needs to realise this.

4. Continual Pricing Screw Ups

The Deluxe Wii U launched in November 2012 for $349.99, yet all gamers had to do was wait another 12 months and they could get a PS4 for a whole $50 more, a console which completely smoked it in pretty much every department. With its not-particularly-cheap launch price, Nintendo nevertheless held steadfast for the better part of a year, refusing to drop the price in spite of abysmal sales figures. They did eventually start to offer some price drops leading up to Christmas last year, but $299.99 for a Wii U with two games was apparently not enough to drive players to the console en masse. Just today, various outlets have dropped the UK price of the Wii U premium bundle to £179.99 from £249.99, which will surely be a tempting offer for many, and if this can't help prop sales up, then it's safe to say that Nintendo literally won't be able to give them away soon enough.

3. Rave-Reviewed Super Mario 3D World Doesn't Sell Very Well

The most tragic casualties of the Wii U's failure are those games that are well received by audiences and critics alike, yet end up disappointing commercially, as was the case with the recent Super Mario 3D World, which had the lowest week-one sales of any 3D Mario game in Japan. In addition to this, it's scored 1.63 million worldwide sales to date, and debuted in the UK at #14, behind PS4's widely slammed platformer Knack. The game has fared better in recent weeks, though will still need to pick up significant steam to catch up to the sales of the franchise's equivalent Wii titles (Super Mario Galaxy currently has 11.02 million sales in 6 years, Galaxy 2 has 7.17 million in 3 and a half years). It's not a totally disastrous state of affairs for the Italian plumber, just extremely underwhelming, and though those sales are sure to climb with the spate of first-party titles to be released in the next 18 months, expect it to trail severely behind the Wii's equivalent sales.

2. The Controller

The main issue with the Wii U's snazzy tablet-style controller is that it's an innovation that nobody really wanted or asked for. The idea of playing games on the tablet when a family member might be using the TV is very cool, but on the whole this is a device that completely alienates and confuses those casual audiences that Nintendo depends on. Marketing never really made it clear what the controller did, and next to the straight-up simplicity of the Wiimote, it seems like a step in the wrong direction. The Wii U's controller is also notoriously expensive to produce, and accounts for a large portion of the console's cost, yet wouldn't it have made more marketing and business sense to allow the Wii U to operate without this controller, and sell it separately? Granted, then casual gamers would probably see even less of a difference between it and the Wii, but at least cost would be less of a factor (and let's face it, it's usually the key factor).

1. Nintendo Has Admitted Its Own Failure

This is the worst of it. Nintendo President Satoshi Iwata seemingly admitted defeat by recently declaring that "the company appears to have failed to differentiate the Wii U from the Wii", and had the humility to admit that even his own 10-year-old son had shown little-to-no interest in the Wii U. It's refreshing in a sense to not see a gaming company repeatedly defend their ailing product against the tide of reality, though at the same time it's pretty depressing for big Nintendo fans and owners of the console, who will no doubt be hoping that Iwata comes flying out of 2014 with a plan to turn things around. Though Nintendo will be hopeful that some first-party titles will help turn things around in the next 12 months, this really feels like an admission of defeat, or more to the point, a throwing up of their hands and saying "We'll take third place". This isn't to say that third-place is a terrible way to end up in the console war (Microsoft and Sony both ultimately thrived as they fought for second place last-gen), but that with the Wii U's stagnating sales, it will be very unlikely to see anything more than a few sales spikes when a new heralded title arrives here and there. Regardless of what one thinks of the console itself, competition is a good thing, and so it's fingers crossed for Nintendo all the way. What do you foresee for the Wii U? Let me know in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.