10 "Evil" Video Games Where Being Good Pays Off
Even the bad can be good sometimes!
Some video games don’t put you in the role of the hero. Their plot is deliberately written so that you play as the villain.
The game will often incentivize you to make bad choices and give you more opportunities to make other people suffer. However, just because the game is about a bad guy, it doesn’t mean you actually have to be one.
In fact, sometimes you might even get a reward for random acts of kindness.
Yes, even titles where the protagonist is evil can make good deeds pay off. Your character might be a ruthless tyrant, a monster, or a criminal, but if you look past their not-so-good profession and make choices that help the innocent instead of harming them, the game will secretly have a prize for you!
From hidden endings to helpful perks that can make your life easier, some evil games don’t always want you to be the bad guy. All you have to do is let your ominous protagonist show a little kindness, and you will be surprised by an amazing gift for the wicked!
10. Helping A Little Boy Is Better Than Scaring Him - Ghost Master
Ghost Master is an old strategy game about commanding a team of spooky spectres and scaring every mortal that dares to meddle with undead affairs!
Your goal is to mess with humans and scare them to the point of developing mental trauma, but if you want to unlock one of the most useful ghosts in the game, you will actually have to do the opposite and help a little boy reunite with his beloved plush rabbit.
Harriet is a unique type of ghost called a pookah that appears in the mission “The Phantom of the Operating Room.” Her unique abilities make her the perfect support character, but in order to recruit her, you need to help a little boy she is bound to.
The pookah will explain that she can’t leave until the boy stops crying, and the only way to do that is to return the toy his bully stole from him. To do this, you have to spook the bully near Harriet's child friend, causing him to drop the stolen toy, and then scare him off the premises before he can pick it back up.
Scare a kid, help a kid! Simple!
9. A Good Sith is a Loved Sith - Star Wars The Old Republic
Star Wars: The Old Republic is an MMORPG set in the world of the galaxy far, far away. The player’s character can either join the Republic or the Empire, and as you may imagine, being part of the latter faction involves some pretty messed up, evil things.
A member of the Sith Empire usually finds themselves torturing, killing, and exploiting people for their superiors. As a benefit, they accumulate Dark Side points that can help improve their abilities, but if you’d rather find a date than unlimited power, doing some good in the galaxy is the better alternative to violence!
The unique thing about the Old Republic as an MMO is that it comes with NPC companions for each playable class. Their main duty is to support you in combat, but some of them can be romanced, and among those companions, some can only be romanced if you prove to them that you are good (enough) to be a partner.
Light Side-aligned companions in the Empire include Vette, Ashara, Vector, and Mako. You can technically start being evil after you romance them, but you will have to do a lot of good deeds to raise their affection and even have a chance at love.
Show them not every Sith’s heart is black!
8. High Honor Matters - Red Dead Redemption 2
Most fans of Red Dead Redemption 2 agree that the game’s high honor ending is not only canonical but also the one Arthur deserves.
Although the game centers around a gang of criminals killing and robbing for personal gain, you don't have to act like an opportunistic scumbag all the time. In fact, you don’t really want to, because the game’s honor system will punish you for it.
Most actions in the game are judged by Red Dead Redemption’s honor system. You gain honor for acting good and lose it for causing wanton destruction.
Now, given that the outcome of missions is usually determined by your own decisions and not the amount of honor you have, you may feel like being bad and stealing as much money won't hurt. However, maintaining Arthur’s reputation as an honorable man leaves an impact on multiple things.
If Arthur dies with high honor, the people in the epilogue will speak more fondly of him, and his grave will be decorated with flowers and kind words engraved on the tombstone.
Meanwhile, the low-honor Arthur gets a completely bare tombstone and plenty of jaded comments, so if you don't want the cowboy to be a forgotten villain, you better turn him into an honorable outlaw.
7. A Romantic Getaway - Vampyr
Vampyr is an action RPG about, you guessed it, vampires. You play as a freshly transformed bloodsucker, Dr. Johnathan Reid, and while most people would assume this would involve using your undead powers right away, if you want to get the good ending, you actually have to do the opposite.
Although the game features an extensive system for using, upgrading, and unlocking new vampiric powers, you don’t actually have to use them. Since the powers are mostly used for killing innocent people and bleeding them dry, you can choose to limit their usage instead and feed only when necessary.
This may seem like taking fun out of the game, but you can still use your powers to help protect the people of London. This way you not only get a kick out of being an immortal creature of the night, but also your being a good vampire will secretly unlock the game’s best ending, in which Reid proves to his lover, Elisabeth, that he can control his vampiric urges, and the two happily move to America together.
Considering the other two endings involve killing Elisabeth and becoming a mindless blood fiend, it’s definitely better to be a good monster.
6. Working For an Evil Government Doesn't Mean You Have to Be Evil - Papers, Please
In Papers, Please you play as the inspector of a border checkpoint in the fictional dictatorship of Arstotzka. Due to the oppressive regime of your country, you have to be diligent with your work and make some really cruel choices to keep your family alive and well.
However, despite the fact that the game typically penalizes you for acting nice and showing compassion to other people, there is one event where choosing love over duty is the better choice.
At one point during your career at the checkpoint, you will be approached by a young soldier named Sergiu. The man will ask you for a favor, explaining that he wants you to let his lover Elisa cross the border, despite the fact she doesn’t have a passport and proper documentation.
Given that you receive citations and lose money for mistakes, you would think that this random act of kindness is only going to endanger you and your family.
But even though letting Elisa through does give you a monetary penalty, if she and her Sergiu are reunited and survive oncoming attacks on the border, Sergiu will actually visit you at the checkpoint again and thank you with triple the amount of money you’ve lost!
Love wins!
5. Why Kill Them When You Can Become Their God - Legacy of Kain: Soul Reaver
Legacy of Kain: Soul Reaver is the action-adventure continuation of the original Legacy of Kain, in which you play as the titular vampire’s renegade pupil, Raziel.
Your new protagonist is resurrected by the Elder God to kill his old master that has locked the world in eternal decay, but this said, you are far from being the good guy.
Raziel is a vengeful vampire, after all, and a lot of your actions in-game reflect on that, allowing you to do things like kill the last remaining humans and drain their life force to boost your abilities.
However, you don’t have to do that. You can leave the humans be too, and your act of non-aggression will actually yield even greater benefits.
It turns out that if you don’t kill any humans, their tribes will eventually begin worshipping you and stop attacking you. This may not sound like a big deal, but later in the game, if the humans are aggressive, they will send powerful vampire hunters after you, whereas if they worship you, you can completely avoid this difficult encounter!
As a bonus, you can still steal life force from the worshipping humans once they turn non-aggressive, because apparently, once you prove yourself to be good, they don’t care about losing their souls.
4. Helping Strangers Makes Criminal Life Easier - Grand Theft Auto V
Grand Theft Auto V is the first entry in the series that allows you to play as a completely unhinged psychopath like Trevor, justifying all the horrible things you might do to Los Santos’ civilians in and out of missions.
Still, the murderous, drug-dealing, “alleged” cannibal is only a third of the playable cast, and while Franklin and Michael aren’t saints either, doing a good deed with them every now and then can actually prove quite useful.
While you’re free-roaming in San Andreas, your character can stumble upon random encounters with strangers. Usually, these NPCs will ask you to do a simple task for a meager reward, and since you play as opportunistic criminals, it seems more profitable to just kill them on the spot and pick the “prize” off their dead bodies.
However, there are two random encounters where helping the strangers in need can yield genuinely useful rewards. The first involves helping Packie from GTA IV escape a heist gone wrong, and the second requires you to rescue a woman named Taliana out of a bad car crash.
If aided, both NPCs will join your heist crew as cheap but incredibly efficient specialists, so make sure to give them a helping hand!
3. Humanity Is Important (Especially With Mercurio) - Vampire: The Masquerade
Vampire: The Masquerade—Bloodlines puts the player in the role of a freshly turned bloodsucker.
Your curse demands that you kill and manipulate mortals to satiate the beast that shares your undead body with you.
However, letting your inner monster out isn't really the best way to blend in with regular people... Or getting the game's best weapons, as a matter of fact!
Your first mission as a newly turned lick is to blow up a rival vampire sect's warehouse using a bomb from the Prince's ghoul, Mercurio.
Upon visiting Mercurio, you discover that the man has been nearly beaten to death and lost the bomb, which forces you to go retrieve it on your own.
Although Mercurio is dying, the game will let you progress if you ignore his awful state.
However, if you find some medicine to heal the ghoul and then don't report him to his boss for failure, in the final act Mercurio will contact you and offer to sell you the best weapons in the game as thanks.
Since you can't get the weapons otherwise, helping Mercurio is a must! Even for the vilest and most crooked of vampires!
2. A Good Ending To An Evil Game - Overlord
Overlord is an early 2000s series of games about taking over the world as an evil fantasy tyrant. You’re clearly not the good guy of your story (even though the “heroes” who defeated you aren’t all that great either), but with this said, the game does secretly come with a morality system, and there is even a good ending for those who don’t go full evil.
Overlord features a corruption mechanic that tracks all of the good and evil things you’ve done. The corruption increases when you kill friendly civilians, steal things, and do other messed-up things.
Gameplay-wise, high corruption can yield benefits to your character, slightly boosting their abilities, but where it makes the most difference is the game’s ending.
If your corruption level is high, in the ending, your Overlord is described as an unhinged and sadistic fiend. However, if despite all of the opportunities to be evil, you’ve maintained low corruption, in the game’s ending the Overlord is portrayed as a harsh but just ruler of his newly conquered empire.
Let’s be real, there’s something satisfying about turning the bad guy of the story into its hero.
1. Agent Smith's Your Man - Hitman
If you are shocked to hear that a game series literally titled “Hitman” has you play as a terrible, murdering scumbag, then you must be really confused about what the word “hitman” means.
No, Agent 47 does not professionally hit on people—he hits their heads with heavy objects and then snaps their necks!
(Even if the alternative is pretty funny to imagine).
Now, since your job is to kill, you’d think that there’s little room for kindness in Agent 47’s line of work. And yet, one recurring character in the series shows that even a cold-hearted assassin can benefit from helping a man in need every once in a while.
Agent Smith is an incompetent CIA agent that has been an acquaintance of 47 ever since the very first game in the franchise. In each of his appearances, the US operative is in some kind of peril, such as being tortured or stuffed into a freezer, and 47 has the option to rescue him.
You might think it’s pointless, but helping Smith out usually unlocks a hidden assassination path or useful intel, so seeking the unlucky spy out and giving him a hand is definitely recommended!