10 Exact Moments Video Games Should Have Ended (But Didn't)
The Last of Us Part II should've ended on the farm and we all know it.
There's no denying that value for money is an important factor when considering buying any game.
Nobody wants to drop £50 on a five-hour experience, but to the same token so many modern games are padded with outrageous bloat in a cynical attempt to justify their asking price.
And then there are more linear, story-driven games that just don't know when to end - they just keep going, and going, and going, until a large portion of players are utterly exhausted and eager for it to wrap up.
These 10 video games, all of them hugely acclaimed classics of their respective genres, all committed the cardinal sin of not knowing when to say farewell.
Perhaps they forced players through a lengthy, extraneous epilogue that really wasn't worth the time investment, or simply arrived at their natural climax hours before the end credits actually rolled.
In the final stretch, these games all distended themselves with extra bosses, tiresome exposition dumps, and so on that proved beyond any doubt that there truly can be too much of a good thing.
These great games would've been even better if they knew when to pack it up...
10. The End Of Chapter 1 - Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain
It's no secret that Metal Gear Solid V had an extremely troubled production due to internal struggles between director Hideo Kojima and Konami executives, causing the game to effectively be released unfinished.
The result is a game that doesn't have much in the way of a satisfactory ending, but does one worse by forcing players to slog their way through hours of copy-paste missions to unlock the "true ending," which contains a literally game-changing revelation regarding protagonist Venom Snake.
The Phantom Pain's campaign is divided into two chapters. The first is the main story missions that conclude with a boss battle against the new Metal Gear model, Sahelanthropus, while Chapter 2 consists of 19 extra missions, many of them recycled from Chapter 1, to unlock additional morsels of story and the big climactic twist.
And yet, it's such a chore powering through Chapter 2 to see out the remaining story scraps that many simply resorted to watching the pertinent clips on YouTube.
Clearly the game's dramatic crescendo comes when Skull Face dies and you battle Sahelathropus at the end of Chapter 1, and Hideo Kojima could've easily rolled Chapter 2's story elements into this part of the game.
Chapter 1's climactic cutscene is a far more effective stopping point for this story than the utter chore that is getting through Chapter 2 and reaching that wildly divisive big reveal.
9. Arthur Dies - Red Dead Redemption 2
A possibly controversial pick here, but Red Dead Redemption 2 is a classic example of a lovingly crafted game that's perhaps a bit too in love with itself and just doesn't know when to end.
No matter your actions throughout the game, protagonist Arthur Morgan's story ends with his demise, and given that you've probably been playing for a minimum of 30 hours at this point, this is a fitting end for a beefy AAA Rockstar experience.
Except, it isn't the end. Not even close.
The game then shifts to eight years later as players are handed control of the previous game's protagonist, John Marston, for an over-egged multitude of missions ranging from boring farm chores to mildly engaging shootouts.
The epilogue takes 6-8 hours depending on your urgency, almost half the length of the previous game in fact. While a short epilogue that gave players more time with John could've been fun, this was just way, way too much.
Developers need to know when to kill their darlings, and John Marston's mini-campaign probably should've been released as fanciful DLC later down the line.
8. Ryo Heads To Guilin - Shenmue II
Shenmue II will take most players around 20 hours to beat on a first playthrough, though per the game's nature playtimes vary wildly.
Even so, it's a classic case of a game that just doesn't know when to end, and drags on for a few more hours after it reaches a fitting end-point.
The clear climax of the game occurs when Ryo heads to the Kowloon Walled City and takes on the Yellow Head organisation, culminating in a thrilling battle with the outfit's leader, Dou Niu.
The real target of Ryo's mission, his father's killer Lan Di, ends up escaping by helicopter, and then Ryo learns he needs to travel to Bailu Village in Guilin to continue his pursuit.
This would've been a suitable cliffhanger ending after a riveting climactic boss battle, but at this point players are asked to insert the game's fourth and final disc before the story continues on for another few hours.
Ryo heads to Guilin and Shenmue II basically sputters to an unremarkable, momentum-devoid conclusion, when this would've made much more sense as the gentle opening to Shenmue III.
7. "Would You Kindly?" - BioShock
Sometimes a video game serves up a plot twist so brilliant that there's really nowhere else for the game to go, and so it makes sense to just tie things off as soon as possible.
That's absolutely true of BioShock, which drops a brain-explodingly incredible twist about 75% of the way through its 10-12 hour playtime.
Upon finally meeting Rapture founder Andrew Ryan, it's revealed that the phrase "Would you kindly?" has been used as a psychic trigger throughout the game by your apparent comrade, Atlas, to make you follow his orders without question. Atlas, in fact, is the game's real villain, Frank Fontaine.
Meanwhile, Ryan effectively commits suicide by using the trigger phrase to make the player beat him to death with a golf club. It's an astonishing, superbly executed rug-pull, and one that the remaining few hours of the game can't get close to matching.
The remainder sees the player working their way towards Fontaine for one of the most woefully underwhelming final boss fights in video game history.
Instead, ending the game on a mesmerising Empire Strikes Back-esque downbeat cliffhanger would've set the stage perfectly for a sequel in which players chase down Fontaine, with 2K Games hopefully taking the time to deliver a more worthwhile confrontation.
6. The Reactor Purge - Alien: Isolation
Though Alien: Isolation is a fantastic game for the most part, perhaps the most common complaint from critics and players alike is about its excessively overbaked length.
Depending on your skill and the difficulty level you play on, it can take anywhere from 12-20 hours to beat, but no matter how you play it, this is the definition of a very good game that nevertheless doesn't know when to quit.
While mileage might vary on precisely where the game should end, there's a strong argument to be made for the thrilling sequence in which Amanda Ripley initiates a reactor purge in an attempt to destroy the giant Xenomorph nest situated at the reactor.
While the purge eradicates a good number of the aliens, it doesn't take all of them out, and the game continues for another 3-4 hours as you deal with various malevolent humans and finally eject the remaining Xeno out the damn airlock.
It's just too much - Alien: Isolation has long become both exhausting and considerably less-scary by the time it finally ends, but curtailing it with the epic reactor purge would've resulted in a considerably more concise experience.
5. The End Of The Ship Section - Resident Evil 7
Even the biggest fans of Resident Evil 7 will surely agree that the game dips majorly in quality during its final third.
After traipsing around the ultra-immersive Baker household and surrounding areas for the first two-thirds of the game, the remaining few hours on both a wrecked ship and a mine mark a considerable decline in quality.
The ship is at least a more interesting environment than the mine and offers up the most action-packed segment of the entire game, while dropping some crucial morsels of story to boot.
But the mine is a deathly dull damp squib of a section on which to wrap things up - an endless trek through mostly copy-paste environments until you loop back to the Baker house for a final boss fight with Eveline.
Though the lab hidden within the mines does provide some juicy story revelations, it's nothing that couldn't have been made available onboard the ship.
Plus, a dynamic final boss battle against Eveline that spilled across the various floors of the ship could've been a lot of fun, rather than the generic shooting gallery battle we got instead.
4. Vaas Dies - Far Cry 3
Considering that Far Cry 3 was largely marketed on the strength of charismatic pirate lord villain Vaas Montenegro, it was a surprise to many players that he ended up killed off in a boss battle roughly two-thirds of the way through the game.
From here, slave trader and drug kingpin Hoyt Volker becomes the primary villain for the rest of the game, and few will disagree that he doesn't even begin to hold a candle to Vaas.
He has his sporadic moments, for sure, but most often feels like a garden variety action movie villain, and one whose concluding boss fight is a thoroughly naff QTE-fest.
Vaas, conversely, was the feature attraction - he was the guy on the box art and in all the trailers, so really the game should've climaxed with his defeat.
Perhaps more could've been done to expand Vaas' role pre-death, but the game takes a sharp nosedive in quality and interest once he bites it.
3. The Vietnam War Battle - Death Stranding
Hideo Kojima's Death Stranding is a much, much longer game than just about anyone expected, and even if you're rushing through the golden path you'll struggle to beat it in under 30 hours.
That's significantly longer than most of the games in Kojima's Metal Gear Solid series, and as wonderful a game as this is, it also represents peak indulgence on the part of a gaming auteur who has never once heard the word "restraint."
Now, Death Stranding's narrative is such an hilariously convoluted soup of themes and ideas that it isn't easy to decide precisely where it should all wrap up.
The epic boss fight with Higgs is a pretty solid possibility, though the third and final battle against a manifestation of Clifford Unger (Mads Mikkelsen) set during the Vietnam War is a far more thrilling showdown.
It's a tricky, dynamic fight with an affecting payoff, but of course the game ambles on for another three or four hours, culminating in a terrible battle against a giant whale BT and a two-hour ending that's as incoherent as it is ambitiously unhinged.
There's no denying that Kojima put a lot of work into those final hours, but that doesn't mean they weren't also completely exhausting to play through.
Closing things out with the more exciting and imaginative Clifford fight, and then stapling a more measured ending onto it, would've made more sense.
Then again, making sense hasn't ever really been Kojima's thing, has it?
2. The Farm - The Last Of Us Part II
The Last of Us Part II may be a phenomenal game, but it's also one that ends up outstaying its welcome, with its unrelenting bleakness proving genuinely tiresome over a 25-hour playtime.
Most players probably suspected that the game's climax would be the showdown between Ellie and Abby that we catch a brief glimpse of at the mid-way point and return to many hours later.
Having players control Abby and taking on Ellie as a stalker-type boss, not unlike David from the first game, was an ingenious subversion of expectations, and felt like the right time for things to start winding down.
After their fight, the scene shifts forward several months in time for what seems to be an epilogue, as Ellie and Dina live on a farm while trying to put their past behind them.
Tommy then arrives with information of Abby's whereabouts, and Ellie sets off for one more confrontation with her.
And so the game then continues on for another gruelling two hours, as Abby gets captured by the Rattlers, Ellie infiltrates their compound, and the two fight one more time.
This isn't to say that this extended finale isn't extremely well crafted from a technical and narrative perspective, but ending it at the farm would've felt so much more succinct.
There were two ready-made ending points here: either Ellie choosing to move on from her revenge, or leaving her decision ambiguous and wrapping up with the flashback to Ellie and Dina dancing.
1. The True Orochi Boss Fight - Ōkami
When you think of brutally overlong video games, there are few that can claim that title more egregiously than Ōkami, a visually stunning, ludicrously entertaining action-adventure game that needlessly clocks in at a ridiculous 30 hours.
Many players likely assumed the game was wrapping up during the first encounter with eight-headed dragon Orochi, though as anyone who's beaten Ōkami will know, this is really the end of the game's first act, and there are about 20 damn hours to go.
Yet there's a very clear point at which Ōkami should've come to an end - the second and final battle against Orochi in his true form, which occurs roughly 75% of the way through the story.
It's a thrilling, challenging fight that'd be a fitting final boss battle for sure, and yet once Orochi is defeated, the game drags on for another 7-8 hours as you pursue the all-powerful real enemy that is Yami.
Ōkami was already beginning to outstay its welcome at 20-something hours, and a rematch with Orochi felt like a totally reasonable place to go home, but this game just. keeps. going. It's proof perfect that there truly can be too much of a good thing.