10 Fan-Demanded Video Game Sequels That Should NEVER Happen
Be careful what you wish for.
When it comes to the world of video games, you can guarantee your favourite titles are going to be turned into major franchises. This industry doesn't really work on one-offs, and there's a good chance that even a poorly received game will return for at least one more round.
Likewise, just because a franchise has ended, that doesn't mean it's gone forever, and more often than not these titles will be rebooted at some point down the line.
However, there are some games that, for whatever reason, haven't received a sequel or been revived. These are huge titles that once dominated the gaming landscape, and turn up on wishlists every single time a big event like E3 rolls around.
At one point, these follow ups would have been no-brainers. The previous instalments were excellent, and the fan demand has always been through the roof, but as the saying goes, you should be careful what you wish for. These are releases that will never stop being shouted about, but just like demanded sequels such as Mirror's Edge: Catalyst proved, the reality of what these projects would actually turn into is a far cry from the pitch-perfect versions fans have in their heads.
10. Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic 3

When it comes to Star Wars video games, Knights of the Old Republic will always reign supreme. Bioware's original RPG was a seminal title, and Obsidian's follow up, while clearly hampered by a limited production cycle, has come to be recognised as an incredible game.
Consequently, Knights of the Old Republic 3 has always seemed like a no-brainer; as close to guaranteed success as you can get in the video game world. Yet, despite constant demands from fans, and even the developers themselves, EA have been reluctant to revive the franchise outside of their MMO spin-off.
It would be amazing to see a proper third game announced - and there's no denying that there's passion internally to see it happen - but a release under current EA management would be a recipe for disaster.
When fans imagine KOTOR 3, they see an expansive, detailed RPG - something classically Bioware or Obsidian. Unfortunately, those kinds of games just aren't what EA are focused on at the moment, and you can bet that if it did come back, it would have forced live-service elements and multiplayer, essentially being Knights of the Old Republic 3 in name only.
A sequel in general isn't a bad idea - but in the current climate it's hard to imagine it ending up being anything other than a major disappointment.
9. Dino Crisis 4
While a lot of the other entries on this list would struggle to be revived thanks to their dated mechanics or gameplay philosophies, Dino Crisis' issue would be directly in its design. The original dropped in '99, and the series' aesthetic was rooted in that weird blend of late 90s and early 2000s over stylization, all PVC leather and sunglasses indoors.
That, of course, was part of its charm, and this weird mesh up of survival horror, Jurassic Park and The Matrix was why the game worked. The rudimentary graphics of the time actually worked in its favour; scary enough to evoke genuine tension but vague enough to not draw too much attention to the stylistic dissonance on display.
Consequently, while a return to the franchise would indeed be a nostalgic whirlwind, a true sequel would struggle to mesh its roots with modern game design. A remake/remaster though? That would be absolutely perfect, and Capcom need to make it happen.
8. Conker's Bad Fur Day 2
Conker's Bad Fur Day was a foul-mouthed, anarchistic platformer that released on Nintendo's otherwise family-friendly N64, an adult-orientated entry in a genre that was otherwise so neutered. It stood out (not always for the right reasons, such as its censored console ports), and the nostalgia fans have for this deeply funny game has always spilled over into desire for the sequel that never was.
While there's the argument that a self-referential, crass game wouldn't be anything special in a world where Deadpool reigns supreme at the box-office, the biggest major problem holding back a sequel is that the Rare of today simply isn't the Rare that devised Conker's Bad Fur day in the 90s. Sure, they're still talented, and Sea of Thieves (despite its lack of content at launch) showed that the spark of creativity that launched the company to success is still there, but they're hardly the underdog go-getters they once were.
Consequently, you could probably swap in any of the studio's franchises for Conker and the same issues would still apply. Rare have revisted their back catalogue over the years, but have never continued any of their past properties, and that's probably for the best. Whatever happened to the company after Microsoft bought them took some of the wind out of their sails, and a sequel to Bad Fur Day would no doubt only be yet another example of how that spark is no longer there.
7. Prince Of Persia
Prince of Persia was Ubisoft's premiere franchise in the 2000s. The original trilogy pioneered the kind of action-platforming that other games dreamed of having, with a distinctive setting and art style that made it instantly iconic. Unfortunately, once those games wrapped, the publisher struggled to find new ways to innovate, delivering an ambitious-but-flawed reboot in 2008, and then an interim sequel with The Forgotten Sands.
Both were decent efforts, but in the wake of Assassin's Creed's popularity (a game which itself was originally a Prince of Persia sequel that became its own thing), PoP felt a little archaic. It's for that reason why the franchise probably hasn't returned, despite constantly being requested at every Ubisoft press event.
Other franchises from the publisher are far easier to mould into different things, with the likes of Ghost Recon, Rainbow Six and Far Cry all being able to innovate and never feel stale. When it comes to Prince of Persia though, if you expand the core gameplay, you just get Assassin's Creed, and with that series still kicking, there isn't room for both.
6. TimeSplitters 4
The original Timesplitters trilogy is home to some of the finest first-person shooters ever put to disc and, for a lot of people, were probably their gateway into the arena of competitive multiplayer. There's a reason the second game was featured in Shaun of the Dead; it was good enough to turn everyone who played it into zombies always finding an excuse to have "one more match".
While the final game ended the trilogy on a slight downer, it didn't stop fans from looking forward to Timesplitters 4, a game which was announced all the way back in 2007. Sadly, original developers Free Radical encountered problems that would plague them for years, resulting in the sequel being cancelled, and the team being rolled into Crytek UK and then being laid off entirely.
Consequently, a Timesplitters 4 releasing today would lack the driving force that made the OG trilogy such a personality-driven set of shooters in the first place. The original devs are no longer around to bring it back, and its charms were arguably feeling a little dated back in 2005, with its arcade focus not having the depth or complexity to challenge more competitive FPSs at the time.
5. Gun 2
It's a bit weird that Wild West games never got popular. The two times Rockstar dropped their Earth-shattering Red Dead games, a surge in thinkpieces from journalists followed, wondering if a new boom was about to begin but, sadly, the audience's interest never really extended to other titles.
That is, with the exception of one little Western game released at the dawn of the Xbox 360 generation: Gun.
Though it wasn't the most technically-polished shooter at the time (and it wasn't exactly good looking either) there was something about the title - it had a certain charm to it that made it far more than the sum of its parts. It helped as well that there were few games at the time doing the Wild West gimmick or simply out for the Xbox 360 at all, which made Gun a popular choice amongst players.
Those two factors in particular are why a sequel would probably suck if it came out today. Gun was hardly a AAA title, and there's a good chance a sequel would be a download-only budget game than a full blown-sequel. It had neither the characters nor the world to support a franchise - especially in a post-Red Dead world - and is better off being remembered as an early hidden gem of the 360 era.
4. Black 2
Black was low-key one of the best first-person shooters of the PS2 generation. With production values that were absolutely mind-blowing at the time, the developers at Criterion were committed to making the most bombastic action game ever. The gunplay wasn't functionally all that different from similar releases at the time, but Black cranked everything up to 11 and made sure to not skimp on the finer details.
Firing a machine gun felt like firing a cannon at lightning speed, while grenades popped with the flair of a Michael Bay explosion which, combined with semi-destructible environments and great particle effects, made for ridiculously hectic firefights that never stopped being fun.
So, you might be thinking: "if it's so good, why didn't the developers make a sequel?". Well, they kinda did. The original game didn't sell well enough for a straight follow up, but the leads formed another studio to craft a spiritual successor, Bodycount.
Sadly, while their aims were pure, that game proved just how much of Black's success was lightning in a bottle. Although it improved on some of the first title's weaker aspects (like the uninspired visual design), the gunplay was completely botched. Even if they did manage to rectify that, the little details that made Black so memorable are standard practice today, so a sequel would just be another face in the crowd.
3. Bloodborne 2
Before you kill me for including this in the list, let me just preface this entry by saying that Bloodborne is my favourite of FromSoftware's games, and one of my favourite games of the entire generation, and that's exactly why it doesn't need a sequel.
While the world itself is rich and the combat is awesome, so much of Bloodborne relies on its sense of mystery and surprise to work. The original works so well because it starts off as seemingly nothing more than a simple Bram Stoker monster tale, but it unfolds into this eldritch, Lovecraftian nightmare about creatures from the beyond controlling reality itself.
After you've played that card though, there's kind of nowhere you can go without undermining what came before. Bloodborne works as such a solid, singular piece of work, and while of course everyone would play the hell out of a sequel, not everything needs a follow up, and From could be better off continuing to release spiritual successors instead.
2. Bully 2

Even though they created Grand Theft Auto, Red Dead Redemption and, er, Rockstar Games Presents Table Tennis, the one Rockstar game that never seems to leave the conversation is Bully. The title caused a storm back in the early 2000s, with its brand of playground hijinks causing a storm for both the right and wrong reasons.
It unsurprisingly came under fire for its name and the activities players were encouraged to partake in, with the most vocal detractors saying Rockstar were encouraging kids to be little s***s to their teachers and friends. Of course, it was far more tongue-in-cheek than that, and way too cartoonish to actually take seriously.
Still, it was very much of its time, and being able to craft a sequel in the same vein would be a difficult balance to get right today.
Plus, while Rockstar can still deliver irreverent and goofy humour in their games, in general their releases have expanded beyond the realm of Bully's cartoon goofiness, and they'd need to take a major step back away from their realistic, simulation-heavy worlds to deliver that arcade fun once again.
1. Half-Life 3
Half-Life 3, or Half-Life 2: Episode 3 or whatever its title turns out to be, is the most anticipated sequel of all time. Its reputation is so extensive it kind of seems dumb writing an introduction for it in this entry; you know how long overdue it is, you know the hype surrounding it, and you know the memes it's spawned.
But it's that insane level of hype which is why the game shouldn't actually ever come out.
At this point it's been built up so much, that even if it was the best game ever, it would still be a disappointment to half the audience. The time for realistic expectations has passed, and if Half-Life 3 is anything other than a top-tier 9/10, 10/10 game, it will be ripped apart, not viewed as being worth the wait.
Sure, it would sell like hotcakes, but would the sales be worth the potential dissatisfaction that would stick with Valve potentially forever if it's nothing other than the masterpiece players have built up in their heads? Absolutely not.