10 Features & Video Games That Could Have Saved The Wii U
Nintendo not negotiating to secure GTA V was cataclysmic.
It's never pleasant to watch a console fail. Each time it happens, the system is often fondly looked upon by hardcore fans who knew it best. The Dreamcast, PlayStation Vita, Wii U... all have great games if you look closely, and had a strong indie showing in their dying years. The Dreamcast in particular still has homebrew developers making games, more than a decade after its demise.
That being said, Nintendo had plenty of games and a fairly interesting concept behind the Wii U: A comfortable, tablet-style controller that could play selected titles away from the TV screen. It was also Nintendo's first ever HD console, and the first to offer onboard storage for games (beyond the 512MB on Wii, meant for Virtual Console).
The story behind the crash of the Wii U is a familiar one for Nintendo fans: not enough third-party support, an online suite of features that didn't match their competitors, and first-party software droughts that lasted months on end.
Yet the Wii U could have been saved, provided it had a few tweaks here and better game support there.
10. Get The Branding, Marketing & Messaging Right, First Time
Ever actually seen the UK and US television ads launching the Wii U? The UK one is confusing and badly focused: no explanation of the swap from Wii Remote to gamepad when playing, an overbaked explanation of each game's use of the pad, and a slogan that didn't get the message across with the vague, "A whole new way to play!"
The US advert is way better. At least you can see a range of ways the Wii U pad is used and the shots of the TV are closer so the link between pad and TV are clearer to the average Joe or Jane. The slogan is slightly better: "How U will play next", and the shots of the family with Wii U remotes and a gamepad shows the actual integration of pad and remotes.
But the name itself was confusing. Was this a Wii add-on? Were you supposed to buy the gamepad separately and use it with the Wii and Wii U (if you bought one?).
If Nintendo distinguished it and called it the Wii 2 HD or something totally different, there'd be FAR less confusion among consumers.
9. Having Continued Third-Party Support From Major Developers & Publishers
The Wii U enjoyed various ports from PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360 in their later years: Mass Effect 3, Assassin's Creed III and IV, Deus Ex: Human Revolution, Amazing Spider-Man 2, 007 Legends, Batman: Arkham City, and a few other notable titles. But the support from Activision, EA, Square-Enix and Warner soon dried up. Others like Take-Two never made an appearance on the console at all.
In 2012-3, various studio heads and CEOs including Strauss Zelnick and Todd Howard began publicly admitting they had no games on the horizon for the ailing Nintendo machine, and this was the beginning of the end.
If Nintendo could have engaged better third party support in the first few years and tried to maintain a parity with the 360 and PS3 - perhaps with games like Advanced Warfare, Dark Souls II, Shadow of Mordor and others - we might have seen a system selling closer to the GameCube's 22 million sales.
8. An Online Service That Thought Of Catering To Over-16s
Nintendo has always stood firmly by its limited online feature set when compared to its competitors. Limited by fiddly friend codes and a lack of voice chat across key online titles, the DS and Wii started a fairly steady trend whereby getting online matches sorted with friends was often more hassle than it was worth.
If Nintendo had sorted out some kind of age verification system that unlocked greater features for older teens, it might have worked out for the Wii U. Party play, party chat and full, unrestricted voice chat could have made Nintendo's online offering far more compelling and helped with the uptake of titles like Call of Duty and FIFA.
As it stood, the online service just wasn't the same in quality as Xbox 360 or PlayStation 3 and the Wii U suffered as a result. Thankfully there are changes afoot with the Switch online service but most fans have accepted Nintendo will never offer the same online service Sony and Microsoft do.
7. A Full Virtual Console Offering With FREE Transfers From Wii
The Virtual Console on Wii U was good, there's no doubt about that. Off-TV Play was great for stretching out on the sofa with a retro classic. But the games on offer were not as broad as the Wii - which enjoyed an extensive SEGA Mega Drive/Genesis library, plus other great curios from the past including the Commodore 64, Neo-Geo and dedicated arcade games.
For those who had already spent a few thousand Wii Points on the older system, the transfer to Wii U was cumbersome and slightly punishing.
For one, you had to retain Wii Remotes to access the Wii menu inside the Wii U. Then you could only use the Wii Remote or classic controller for those Wii VC titles, even when playing on the gamepad. If you paid a transfer fee per game then you could use them with Off-TV Play and control the games on the gamepad. Effectively, you were paying twice for the game you already owned.
Having the ability to play VC games on the gamepad should have been a given through a free update, no question about it.
6. Bundled In A Wii Remote Or Sold Additional Gamepads
During the lifespan of the Wii U, Nintendo Wii Remote Plus(es) retailed for £39.99. Nunchuks, thrown into Wii U branded packaging, retained their price of £14.99 a pop.
Bear in mind that these are products that are now coming into their twelfth year of existence. (Eight if you're talking specifically about the Wii Remote Plus.) This is a ludicrous pricing strategy from Nintendo as games released as early as Nintendoland in the consoles lifecycle had games that needed a Wii Remote and nunchuk! (That's 2012, at launch.)
Intrepid patent hunters and other curious online technophiles also discovered that the Wii U system could recognize the use of a second gamepad. But instead of taking advantage of this with independent map screens or the chance to play local multiplayer using the TV as a sports highlights reel, Nintendo stuck rigidly to the policy of one system, one gamepad.
Everyone else had to fight over who got the Pro controller and who'd be stuck with the Wii Remotes.
5. GTA V
GTA V would have sold on Wii U even without the presence of any DLC or GTA Online. Why? Because GTA V now sits comfortably in the top 5 best-selling games list of all-time, in esteemed company like Tetris, Wii Sports, Minecraft and the original Super Mario Bros. from the NES.
And it's not even plausible to come back with "Well, Rockstar never make games for Nintendo platforms." Rockstar have been supporting Nintendo in one way or another ever since the Game Boy had a rendition of 2D GTA. The Game Boy Advance also got a version of GTA, and the 3DS had Chinatown Wars. Other titles have made it to Wii too: Table Tennis, Bully: Scholarship Edition and, surprisingly, Manhunt 2.
Nintendo really shot themselves in the foot with this one. Not reaching out to Take Two and coming to an agreement was financially ruinous to the success of the Wii U. Minecraft launched late and still hit almost 1.5 million sales - a figure that GTA V would have dwarfed.
4. Off-TV Play For All Games
Off-TV Play was an excellent idea, and meant busy televisions could have some respite from marathon gaming sessions.
For many games though, it simply wasn't taken far enough or was handled badly. For every Nintendoland, ZombiU and Splatoon, there was a Star Fox Zero. There were also weird inconsistencies in its implementation: most games such as didn't even have Off-TV Play despite it being a fairly highly-rated feature among critics and gamers alike.
The range of the gamepad also had its own problems: moving more than 5 metres away from the console itself would drop the connection. If Call of Duty: Black Ops II could offer multiplayer and co-op modes using both the Wii U gamepad and the television, then there's no excuse for other games at all.
3. Played DVDs And Blu-Ray discs
Nintendo has never liked getting into costly licensing arrangements with other companies, or worse still, its competitors. So, when the GameCube launched in 2001 with its miniature 8cm discs, it took a partnership with Panasonic to deliver the legendary coveted Q-Cube which would play DVDs in a separate drive.
This was at the very same time that Microsoft and Sony were delivering systems with full-spec features: DVD players built in, ethernet ports added and online functions being the new standard. Nintendo have never bowed to consumer demand to play movies: the Wii ran DVDs but wouldn't play movies and so the Wii U continued this trend. Despite offering new optical discs, neither DVDs nor Blu-Rays played on the Wii U.
Now some might say the offering of Hulu, YouTube, Netflix, Amazon Video and the BBC iPlayer excused this. But every little feature helps when trying to get your console into living rooms and bedrooms of the world.
2. A Five Hour Battery Included From The Outset
Retailing for a fairly hefty £24.99, the Wii U Gamepad battery pack promised up to 8 hours of use, which was a vast improvement over the 3-5 hours of the original. The reality is that the original battery was never really capable of extended gaming sessions: various YouTubers have performed timed tests that show it running out at the 2.5 hour mark.
It's part of Nintendo's core business strategy to ensure parts in their machines are sourced as cheaply as possible - using so-called "last gen tech" - to ensure price points. The Game Boy Advance SP was the only system to really buck this trend, offering hours of gaming goodness before recharging was needed.
Call it a convenience feature if you will, but the Wii U definitely should have had the larger battery from the get-go. 2 hours flies by when you're deep into a game and is inexcusable given that the larger battery was then sold as an accessory. At the very least the premium battery should have come with the 32GB edition of the system, leaving the 8GB Basic pack with the smaller battery.
1. Download Play Away From The Console
The Nintendo DS, launched way, way back in 2004, had a nifty little feature called DS download play. Its primary function was to offer wireless local multiplayer with just one game card, instead of the Game Boy method of four cartridges, four link cables and the hassle of arranging enough hardware.
Demos could be downloaded through wi-fi from special computer stations in selected retailers, or the Nintendo Channel on the Wii, and would stay on the system until it was powered down.
But this was a major point where the Wii U stumbled: playing away from the console was limited to a short range of a few metres, and relied on the main unit staying on with disc spinning. Had the Wii U pad had download play, it would have revolutionised the console, essentially giving the Wii U the same popular unique selling point the Switch now enjoys.
The Wii U had some stunning first-party games from Nintendo, being their first HD machine, and limiting those to an audience of 14 million was a tragedy.