10 Gaming DLCs That Surprised Everyone

Shadowbringers is the crown jewel of Final Fantasy XIV's revival.

Final Fantasy XIV Shadowbringers
Square-Enix

The concept of DLC seems to get increasingly tied up in conversations of the game industry's worst excesses as time goes on. From jabs about horse armour that have become so ubiquitous it's sort of painful even mentioning them, to increasingly predatory microtransactions by companies that seem to view the games themselves as secondary to how much money they can extract from customers, DLC has got lumped in with some truly naff practises.

Still, there’s nothing quite like the opportunity to revisit a game world you love for a new adventure, and when companies do DLC right, they deserve celebrating. It’s easy to get cynical, but then an expansion or piece of DLC comes along that’s truly remarkable in its scope, excellence, or clear passion on the part of the developers. DLC can also give devs room to experiment, resulting in some odd and unexpected outings.

Here are 10 DLCs that surprised everyone.


10. Blood And Wine - The Witcher 3

The Witcher 3 Wild Hunt Blood And Wine
CD Projekt Red

Kicking off with an auto-include here, but for good reason. Not only did Blood and Wine cap off Geralt’s sprawling adventures in a satisfying way, it did so in a huge piece of content comparable to the great RPG expansions of old, like Baldur’s Gate II: Throne of Bhaal. The gorgeous vineyards and palaces of Toussaint are more than just another location for Geralt to shake down for Alchohest coin - they’re a love letter to fans, and a celebration of everything that came before.

With so many ways the base game could have ended, CD Projekt had their work cut out providing satisfying conclusions for every type of player, and still smashed it. There are plenty of send ups to join the send offs, too. The writing adopts a more self-satirical tone, referencing everything from Monkey Island to RPG cliches to the many bugs involving Geralt’s faithful steed Roach.

The excellent Hearts of Stone DLC may have featured an actual party, but Blood and Wine deserves its status as a legendary after party.


9. Champions' Ballad - Legend Of Zelda: Breath Of The Wild

BOTW Champions' Ballad
Nintendo

While not the most substantial expansion compared to some of the others on this list, Breath of the Wild’s Champions' Ballad earns its place as a truly surprising DLC for the very simple reason that it looked at Breath of the Wild, and said: but what if - and hear me out - we give Link a motorcycle?

So much of the fun in Breath of the Wild comes from how satisfying Hyrule is to traverse - whether by steed, foot, or hang glider - and adding a motorcycle into the mix was the next logical step. Actually, scratch that, it was a completely illogical step that, in retrospect, makes perfect sense.

Breath of the Wild’s Hyrule is filled with ancient technology, so adding a motorcycle managed to even feel like it belonged in the world. Just don’t show Epona; obsolescence is a b*tch.


8. The Prophet And The Warlock - Total War: Warhammer II

Total War II Prophet and the Warlock
Sega

When Total War: Warhammer II added the Skaven ratmen as a playable launch faction, it missed out a huge chunk of their roster. Namely, the warpstone gatling gun firing, nuke-dropping science rats of Clan Skyre. After The Prophet and The Warlock DLC added rat Rick Sanchez Ikit Claw and his workshop of scientific abominations, it was easy to see why Clan Skyre had taken so long. Balancing a faction that routinely brings sniper rifles to a sword fight is, predictably, not the easiest job.

Clan Skyre were deliciously broken on launch, especially in campaign mode. They’ve been through numerous balance adjustments since, but they still stand out as having some of the most off-the-wall units and strategies available.

One overpowered faction means every other faction has to be balanced too, and the Prophet and the Warlock sent Total War: Warhammer II into a DLC arms race it never quite recovered from. It’s been a fun ride, though.


7. Minerva’s Den - Bioshock 2

BioShock 2 Minerva's Den
2K Games

Despite a lukewarm reception on release, Bioshock 2 has found a new appreciation from fans in recent years, with its much-improved gunplay aging more gracefully than both its predecessor and Bioshock: Infinite. While its narrative took few risks in its thematic retread of the original’s story, its DLC Minerva’s Den is fondly remembered as some of the best storytelling in the entire series.

Kicking off with a quest to find Bioshock’s central computer, the stakes become increasingly gripping as you lead Big Daddy Subject Sigma through the ruins of Rapture. What starts as a fairly simple expedition ends up becoming one of the series’ most heartfelt and personal story vignettes.

Minerva’s den does feature a few new additions to Bioshock 2’s best-in-series combat - like the Ion gun - but the real draw here is the excellent writing and moving storytelling. Bioshock is best when it’s about people, rather than ideas. Here, Minerva’s Den truly delivers.


6. Artorias Of The Abyss - Dark Souls

dark souls knight artorias
FromSoftware

The wolf knight Artorias was one of the original Dark Souls’ most enigmatic characters, and had many early fans speculating on exactly how this knight of Lord Gwyn fit into the game’s famously esoteric lore. They wouldn’t have to wait long, as the Artorias of the Abyss DLC contained some uncharacteristically direct plot revelations, allowing the chosen undead to travel back into Lordran’s past to uncover exactly what became of the legendary knight.

It wasn’t just a treat for lore fans. The fight with the titular knight built on everything FromSoftware had learned with Demon’s Souls and the base Dark Souls, and offered the speediest, most challenging encounter yet - and a solid blueprint for where Bloodborn and Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice would eventually take us.

Plus, you also got to meet Sif as a puppy, which should be good enough for anyone.


5. The Taken King - Destiny

destiny the taken king
Bungie

To call Destiny’s launch rocky would be like calling Activision Blizzard a friendly independent publisher. Years of hype and promises were eventually revealed to be little more than hot air, and Destiny saw one of the most legendarily disappointing launches in memory, until the (now excellent) No Man’s Sky would claim that crown a few years later.

For many players, The Taken King turned Destiny into the game it was always supposed to be. Altogether, the DLC added new narrative, PvP, and PvE content, as well as the bounty system. Alongside this came numerous tweaks and changes to how Destiny felt to play. They also got rid of Peter Dinklage’s much-memed performance as the player’s Ghost, replacing him with the ubiquitous Nolan North. You can’t really blame Dinklage, though, given what the Game of Thrones actor had to work with.

These were all great additions, but The Taken King's biggest achievement was helping Bungie regain the trust of players, which helped grow Destiny into what it is today.


4. Undead Nightmare - Red Dead Redemption 2

red dead redemption undead nightmare
Rockstar

The ‘zombies make everything better’ philosophy of the early 2000s didn’t take long to overstay its welcome, but these shambling pop-culture staples certainly made for some truly excellent DLC to Rockstar’s Red Dead Redemption. While the original game wasn’t afraid to have some fun, it was still somewhat constrained to its own Western homage. No such problems with the DLC, which throws reality out of the window to turn its open-world into a zombie-killing sandbox.

Borrowing gang territory mechanics from Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas, Undead Nightmare sees John Marston liberating map locations from the zombie threat. Alongside this, there’s plenty of story missions, side missions, and minigames.

If GTA5 and RDR2 are any indication, it seems like Rockstar have left the days of story DLC behind in favour of content for their ridiculously profitable online modes. It’s a shame, because Undead Nightmare is still fondly remembered by many.


3. Shadowbringers - Final Fantasy XIV

FFXIV Shadowbringers
Square-Enix

While not strictly a DLC, Final Fantasy XIV’s A Realm Reborn deserves special mention for revitalising an MMORPG many saw as DOA into one of the most popular in the world. Subsequent expansions Heavensward and Stormblood were well received, but last year’s Shadowbringers’ phenomenal storytelling reminded many why they fell in love with the series to begin with.

While the venerable RPG series has seen plenty of gameplay innovations over time, what draws fans in most is the epic, emotional storytelling. In recent years, the days of Final Fantasy being held up as a bastion of storytelling have seemed more and more like a distant memory. Shadowbringers changed that.

Shadowbringers isn’t so much a surprising DLC for showcasing FFXIV's excellent writing - that had already been done - but it was still a landmark for RPG storytelling in 2019.


2. The World Of Tomorrow - Hitman

Hitman 2 Sapienza
IO Interactive

IO Interactive’s 2016 Hitman really deserves a place on this list as an entity for its entire DLC model. When the episodic plan was released, it was easy to be cynical and see it as a continuation of some of the worst industry DLC practises. What we got, however, was a model that allowed IO to create the most in-depth, expansive contracts the Hitman series had ever seen, and a release schedule that encouraged players to spend time with each.

Two games on and a third one on the horizon, and ‘The World of Tomorrow’ mission remains one of the stealth/puzzle hybrid's best-loved locations. It doesn’t just feature the sprawling manse that contains your two assassination targets, but the entire Italian town of Sapienza around it. IO are the masters of packing their locations with dense puzzles and adventure-game style secrets, and Sapienza is no exception.

The Showstopper Paris level was a fantastic start for the new Agent 47, but The World of Tomorrow was truly surprising for how it cemented IO’s reputation as some of the finest level designers in gaming.


1. Citadel - Mass Effect

Mass Effect Citadel DLC
Bioware

As all Mass Effect fans know, literally no controversy has ever surrounded the series’ ending. Bioware ended the trilogy in a satisfying way, we all applauded, and the internet never mentioned it again. It was perfect. However, Bioware being the champs they are, decided to let Shepard have one last party with the crew we’d all spent three games falling in love with.

Revisionist history aside, whatever you thought of Mass Effect 3’s ending, there’s something to be said for Bioware providing closure to fans in a way that didn’t contradict their original vision. By setting the events of Citadel before the final mission, they managed to make fans feel heard and valued, while still sticking to their guns.

Citadel was, in many ways, the ending the trilogy deserved, and a fine farewell to a story that held a special place in a lot of hearts. At least, until we know if the upcoming Legendary Edition will make any changes.


In this post: 
Destiny
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Nic Reuben hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.