10 Gaming Industry Issues That Must Die With This Generation
Lack of unionization, crunch time, and manipulative systems must not outlive this generation.
No industry is perfect, but some are more flawed than others. And the gaming industry is one of the most flawed of all, even compared to the likes of film.
Sure, there's plenty to love about the state of gaming right now, but the things that ARE wrong with it are so huge, they negate pretty much all of them.
Every day you hear a new horror story about workers being abused, customers being taken advantage of, and the gaming industry generally being a prime example of capitalism's worst instincts made real.
Rampant greed and a lack of accountability has given way to a million smaller problems that need to be solved before we can get to those larger, more nebulous ones.
So, we're focusing squarely on the issues with the gaming industry that we can feasibly fix between the rest of this generation and the next - some of which might already be on their way out.
I doubt it, but they might be.
All new industries stumble when they first really get going, but the gaming industry has done more in less time than most others.
This has created a ton of fascinating talking points all of us have some stake in, but how will things pan out moving forward?
10. Moving Away From Physical Media
Physical media is by no means perfect, but it allows us to hold and own something that could otherwise just be taken away on a whim.
There's nothing quite like it, to be honest. Knowing that unless YOU damage, lose or sell the thing you own, no one can truly take it away from you.
And if you've recognised the above image, you know exactly where this is going.
Because recently, game companies have been releasing more and more games exclusively through their online stores. And PC games have all but abandoned physical media altogether in favor of selling online.
Of course, the main problem here is that if - for whatever reason - that store cannot sell that game anymore, pretty much everyone is screwed.
P.T. was set to be the demo for the next Silent Hill game, with an all-star dev team and voice cast. Then, completely on a whim, Konami shut down the project and rescinded the demo from online availability.
The move away from physical media is bad for pretty much everyone. You might love Persona 5, but if the apocalypse happens (which is unfortunately a LOT more likely than that hyperbole suggests) unless you got the actual disk, you're gonna be stuck with 4 and 3. Forever.
9. Half-Baked Online Stores
Running an online store for a huge company is a much larger gamble than it might seem from the outset. If you aren't 100% committed to it, then it'll inevitably fall apart and cost your company a LOT of money.
For a related example of this, this is why Disney is putting so much effort into Disney+, because they know that if you're entering this playing field, you'd better come out swinging and prepared to knock everyone else's teeth out.
But if the subject of the above image is anything to go by, this is not universal knowledge.
The Epic Games Store in particular has been seriously lacking in the one year that it's been out, even lagging on basic features that definitely do not take a whole year to figure out the implementation of. Things like - to pick something at random - a flippin shopping cart!
And now other game companies are starting to or at least thinking about getting in on the action, so this is one trend that needs to be bitten in the tail immediately. If you MUST have an online store, it cannot be one that's half cocked.
People are used to using Steam and MAYBE GOG if they need to, so if your store cannot give them a reason to switch, they won't. And sorry, but there's only so much exclusives can do for you in that regard.
8. An Obsession With Live Services
So, Dragon Age 4 is gonna be a live service game. Because THAT'S a good idea, right Anthem?
Yesterday it was MMO's, today it's Live Service games. What's the difference? MMO's were fun. And yet game companies are obsessed with putting the model onto games that really don't need it. The idea is simple: keep players playing this one game for as long as humanely possible so that they will eventually want to spend even more money on microtransactions (we'll get to THOSE later) and then continue the cycle as an endless stream of revenue.
Live service games have worked in the past, but only in the cases when the gameplay was solid enough to keep people hooked, and the microtransactions don't actually interfere with the playing experience. Two lessons that have clearly not been heeded, if Fallout 76 and games like it are anything to go by.
Live service games had their time in the sun, but it's time to retire them. It started out as an okay idea, but has quickly become just another predatory system for game companies to siphon people's money.
7. CEOs Hoarding All The Money
Isn't capitalism grand?
Not if you're working for a major video game company, because they're by far one of the most naked forms of rampant greed in the modern world.
While everyone else struggles to get by, the people at the top who work MAYBE half as hard as the various devs and designers do for them, make millions of dollars every time they so much as change their socks.
It's utterly unsustainable, of course, but greed has a funny way of making people lose sight of the long game, in favor of what they can gain now.
As such, more and more money comes in for the bosses, which makes them and their investors demand more revenue, demands which inevitably can no longer be met, and everything falls apart. You'd think they'd learn after the last several times this exact thing played out.
This cycle of greed and ruin needs to stop, for the industry's own sake. Because it's never the guys at the top who suffer when this pattern repeats itself.
6. Mass Layoffs
When game companies experience financial stress - or at least what they perceive to be financial stress - they have a lot of options available to them in order to get them through the next quarter. Some of them good, some of them bad, some of them downright heinous. Guess which one Blizzard, Activision, and a disturbing amount of other game companies go with.
Mass layoffs are the AAA game industry's latest favorite means of hoarding their money, even when they're actually doing pretty okay financially. Blizzard in particular reported that they were doing wonderfully in terms of revenue. And then immediately after making this statement, laid off over 200 employees.
And lest we forget our dear friends at Telltale games, who - before shutting down - laid off pretty much everyone working for them without any form of severance or insurance (despite doing so being required by Californian law), because the ones in charge wanted to hold onto as much of their money as they could keep their hands on.
Simply put, this needs to stop immediately, if the AAA game industry wishes to survive much longer.
After all, why should any game dev work for them if they know that they have so little job security?
5. Rushing Games To Launch
So, funny story about Sonic 2006. If it seemed unfinished when it came out, that's because it was. In fact, the dev team wasn't even halfway done with it. Oh sure, you COULD play it from start to finish, but as anyone who has ever played the game before will tell you, the difference between could (hypothetical) and CAN (realistic) is a harsher line than you might think.
The reason it was released this way? Well, 06 was the 15th anniversary of the Hedgehog, so Sega wanted it out in 06 or bust. the dev team working on it pleaded with their bosses for more time, but by now, Sega's self-destructive stubbornness is legendary.
This is but one - albeit very famous - example of publishers thinking they know better than the devs working under them, and rushing out a game to launch before it's anywhere close to ready.
See also, Knights Of The Old Republic 2, which was missing several parts of the game that you now need various mods to unlock.
And how could we forget our favorite punching bag, Fallout 76, which Bethesda admitted point blank that they deliberately and knowingly released in a drastically unfinished state, coining the term "Break-It Early Test Application" for their beta only a week ahead of release.
4. Microtransactions
It's only natural that one of gaming's biggest boogieman today would be on this list, and indeed it definitely deserves its spot. Microtransactions, when they first started back in the early 2010's with games like Star Wars: The Old Republic's Cartel Market and Overwatch, were deemed as kinda annoying, but overall harmless.
But then this story moved on to the same chapter as anything else the gaming industry sees as the next big thing: Then The Idiots Got Their Hands On It.
Microtransactions are now EVERYWHERE. If it's even slightly online, guaranteed it has microtransactions in there somewhere. And even if a game doesn't have microtransactions at first, like with the re-release of Crash Team Racing, companies will put them in once they think they can get away with it.
Microtransactions are, by their very nature, predatory. Very few games have ever implemented them in a way that got around the inherently greedy nature of the system, and frankly, we're better off without them.
3. The Lack Of A Proper Game Developer's Union
Unions aren't perfect, no organization run by human beings is, but they exist for a very good reason. They help up and comers in the industry they represent get access to jobs they normally wouldn't, and provide workers with legal protections that they wouldn't receive if they were flying solo.
A lot of the problems on this list come from the fact that game developers don't have a union of their own to actually hold their bosses accountable when they do something wrong.
Of course, accountability for the rich and powerful is something that's being beaten back more and more in today's world, so game companies have been doing more and more in recent years (conveniently coinciding with tales of their abuses leaking out into the press) to discourage their workers forming a union.
Despite what your smelly uncle you only ever see at Thanksgiving will tell you over and over, unions are indeed a necessary and very good thing for workers. And the fact that game developers have had to go so long without one is something that future generations are going to scratch their heads over.
2. Gambling Systems
What is the inevitable end point of microtransactions? Why, spending money for a random chance to earn a prize, of course. As seen in Overwatch, SWTOR's pack system, and definitely in Battlefront 2's crate system. You spend a certain amount of money, and you get cosmetic items, weapons, and even game changing upgrades as seen in Battlefront 2.
However, we could've sworn that this practice had a proper term to describe it. Oh yes, it's called GAMBLING!
While it always skirted the line between microtransactions and outright gambling before by not making any of the prizes items or power ups that could shift things to your favor, Battlefront 2 tipped those scales by locking off certain characters from the game unless you spent money on the chance that you MIGHT unlock them.
However you slice it, that's called gambling. And it needs to stop immediately.
These final three entries are not trends we can let escape into the next generation of gaming, because if they go on for too much longer, the industry might never come back. Which brings us, unfortunately, to our final entry.
1. Crunch
If the release deadline you have set for your game requires you to work your dev team to near death on a near constant basis, then that deadline needs to be reevaluated. No debate, full stop. Crunch is the worst gaming industry issue today, simply through its sheer universality.
Pretty much every major game release coming today has had to employ crunch time at some point, with no overtime pay given to the people working on the game itself, and very little benefits for the inevitable psychological and physical health problems that come from crunch.
Companies like EA, Rockstar, and TellTale games are notorious for these practices. And it's taken so long for these horror stories to come to light because the developers know that they have very little solid ground to stand on should they stand up to these companies.
Almost as if AAA game companies don't want their workers to unionize for that very reason, hm?
This isn't the first time crunch has been spoken of as a blight on the industry, and it definitely should not be the last. The only way that any of these problems get fixed is if we keep talking, and stay angry.