10 Great Video Game Sequels The Fans Rejected

Can we finally admit Resident Evil 6 was pretty awesome?

RESIdent evil 6
Capcom

Making a sequel is arguably much harder than making the first game.

Not only do you have to come up with ideas to advance the established formula, you also have to stay true to the original release and not jump the shark (we're looking at you, Saints Row).

Although there are plenty of gaming sequels that fans have hailed as all-time classics, there are also times when it goes completely south.

The more a sequel tries to differentiate itself, the more it risks being completely rejected by its fanbase and ending up like any of the following games.

It's not just about how the game plays, though. There can be a whole host of other factors that determine how fans will react to a game. Even something as simple as a graphical change can inspire the fans to revolt. Wind Waker, anyone?

Chances are you've missed out on one of these rejected sequels, and that's a big shame, because they're all genuinely brilliant.

10. Kingdom Hearts 3

KINGDOM HEARTS 3
Square Enix

Any game that has people looking forward to it for 10 years is bound to let some people down.

That would be a bit of an understatement for Kingdom Hearts 3 though, which garnered a surprisingly mixed response from fans.

Gameplay and post-game content were both cited as the biggest issues plaguing the release. There simply wasn't much interesting to do once you finished the main story, and gameplay differed quite heavily from the previous titles.

Another big problem was the pacing. Up until the final act, the story was practically none existent. For a series so focused on plot, this was a pretty big misstep in the eyes of fans.

If you can look beyond some of the issues that Kingdom Hearts 3 has, you'll find another great entry into the series, with a story that really hits hard when it gets going and gameplay that's pure, simple fun.

That critical mode really kicks things up too, but you can't deny such a notable mixed reception.


9. Max Payne 3

Max Payne Thumb
Rockstar

There's a reason this didn't sell so well.

One of the biggest points of contention from fans with Max Payne 3 was its massive tonal shift. The original two games had a pulpy, dark tone that was juxtaposed by bullet time and diving about with twin pistols, whereas Max Payne 3 went for a much more generic style.

Most of the game was spent in the sunny locale of Brazil, as opposed to the darkness of New York. Couple that with annoying graphical filters and long cutscenes, and you can see why some people were disappointed.

Beyond those issues though, Max Payne 3 is actually one of the more memorable games that Rockstar released in the previous generation. Extremely punchy and tight gunplay, amazing bullet time mechanics and a legitimately interesting narrative make Max Payne 3 one of the most confusing entries on this list.

It really does come down to the difference in style, and that's a big shame.


8. Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts

rare replay banjo kazooie
Rare

We all want nothing more than a traditional Banjo game, but that doesn't mean that Nuts & Bolts is as awful as everyone claims it is.

It should be pretty clear why fans rejected Nuts & Bolts - it’s not really a Banjo game. It’s got the same wicked sense of humour and style, but platforming is almost completely absent.

That obviously offended a lot of fans who had been waiting for a proper follow up, which has led to Nuts & Bolts being outcast.

The vehicle building system may seem like the game's biggest problem, but it’s actually its biggest strength. The things you can make in Nuts and Bolts are only limited by your imagination, and the creator itself is vast, yet easy to grasp.

Nuts & Bolts' physics system is especially fun to mess around with too, and some of the vehicles that people have created really show how great the mechanics are.

If this wasn’t marketed as a Banjo game, the reception would have been entirely different.


7. Hitman Absolution

Hitman Absolution
IO Interactive

Despite being one of the best-selling Hitman games, Hitman Absolution is routinely lampooned by... just about everybody.

Even though it carries the Hitman name, Absolution is probably the furthest from the formula the series has ever strayed.

In an effort to move things to the next generation, Absolution aimed for a much more broad playstyle. Rather than being pretty much forced into stealth, Absolution also allowed trigger-happy action gamers a chance at success.

That sounds like a good thing, but in reality all it did was confuse the true Hitman fans and give them a game that didn't know what it wanted to be.

The huge open-world missions of the past were pretty much gone, with more linear levels in their place.

All of this is a real shame, because Hitman Absolution can be a pretty fantastic game if you play it as smartly as possible. Although it's much more streamlined, there are still glimpses of the real Hitman formula there, and some of the levels are great fun to experiment with.

A lot of Absolution can be found in the later games in the series, so it's certainly not as bad as the fans thought.


6. Halo 5

Halo 5
343 Industries

The Halo games have had a rough time since Bungie left.

With their original developer moving on to make Destiny, Halo was left in the hands of 343 Studios. Halo 4 was received well but didn't set the world on fire like the previous titles, and Halo 5 was arguably even more disappointing.

Fans cited a lack of excitement in the single player campaign, a lack of split screen and a story that was more exciting in the trailers than the game.

Although all of these qualms are applicable to varying degrees, Halo 5 is still a fantastic shooter at its core.

Taking the fight online is where the most enjoyment can be found, as was the case with the older games. Multiplayer may have changed with the times, but it still feels distinctly Halo, and that's a very good thing.

Hopefully Halo: Infinite can find a good middle ground for both the old and the new.


5. Red Dead Redemption 2

Asssassins creed unity
Ubisoft

Whether or not you like to admit it, Red Dead Redemption 2 might be one of Rockstar's most controversial releases. Not in the same sense of things like Hot Coffee, I mean in terms of fan reactions.

Despite garnering critical and commercial acclaim, the fan reaction to Red Dead Redemption 2 has been one huge mixed bag. The main issue comes down to how the game actually plays, rather than the story being told.

Rockstar's mission design has seemingly reached its limit, as the missions in Red Dead 2 are slow, annoying, and so on-rails it might as well be at a theme park.

If you can get past Red Dead's bare bones mission design and intrusive gameplay decisions, you'll find one of the best stories of the generation, and a world that has such attention to detail it's almost too much.

Plus, it's worth it just to be around one of Rockstar's best characters yet, Arthur Morgan.


4. DMC: Devil May Cry

Devil May Cry DMC Dante
Capcom

Oh boy.

Whether you call it a sequel or a reboot, 2013’s DMC is arguably one of the most controversial games out there. It was met with heavy friction since its initial announcement, and arguably never recovered. People simply weren't happy with a new take on one of Capcom's most beloved characters.

The biggest problems came from the changes made to Dante. Not only did he look like a completely different character, but he acted like one. The rest of the cast didn't fare much better, with Vergil's characterization arguably being even worse.

Valid character concerns aside, DMC is a fantastic action game that really does justice to the genre. Combat is incredibly satisfying, and it’s complemented by a movement system that’s better than any other game in the series.

The release of the Definitive Edition even introduced things like 60fps that brought the original release down. It’s just a shame those characters are so toxic.


3. Mass Effect 3

Mass Effect 3
Bioware

It's funny just how much one part of your game can cause so much disdain.

This is a lesson that BioWare is fully aware of, having gone through it following the release of Mass Effect 3.

Literally the only glaring problem with the game is its ending, but it is a pretty big problem. For a series that is entirely based on making decisions, having the final scene of the game basically being a colour choosing sequence is pretty pathetic.

However, that doesn't mean that Mass Effect 3 doesn't accomplish plenty of other things. The combat is the best the series had seen up to that point, the characters were absolutely at their best, and there were plenty of other satisfying conclusions to be had.

Bioware did eventually try and patch a new ending for the game, but the damage was already done. Just pretend that didn't happen, and enjoy an otherwise amazing game.


2. Assassin's Creed Unity

Assassin's Creed Unity
Ubisoft

The hate that Assassin's Creed Unity got when it first released was pretty justified. Ubisoft clearly rushed the development of the game to make sure it came out as soon as possible, and it really showed.

By now, you've all seen the wealth of bugs that Unity is famous for, but beneath all of that is a fantastic Assassin's Creed game that introduces lots of new features whilst expanding on old ones.

Combat is classic Assassin's Creed in the best way, whilst introducing deep levels of customisation that made the experience feel personal to each player.

Parkour has also never been done better in the series, with the introduction of the option to travel both up and down changing momentum and exploration considerably. Playing Unity with friends was also a blast, although many people probably didn't even do that considering the fan reaction to the game.

By now, Assassin's Creed has gone in a completely different direction, so Unity and Syndicate are even more worthy of a replay.


1. Resident Evil 6

RESIdent evil 6
Capcom

Resident Evil may be on the rise lately, but there was a time when it looked like it wouldn't be around much longer.

This was most worrying with Resident Evil 6, which was lampooned by fans upon release for being nothing like the original games, and straying far too close to an action title. Basically, it wasn't scary enough.

Resident Evil 5 received similar complaints around its release, but to a much smaller and more manageable extent.

It's a big shame that Resident Evil 6 was so heavily criticized, because its actually an incredibly fun game if you don't take it too seriously. The complaint about a lack of horror can be true, but there are also some genuinely unnerving scenes throughout.

Gameplay is also a big plus, with Jake's campaign in particular playing more like a high-octane Uncharted, complete with some crunchy hand-to-hand combat.

Resident Evil 6 may not be the best game in the series, but it's certainly far from the worst.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Jumping through portals, swinging through cities, destroying beings made of darkness and occasionally shooting a gun or two. I also write about games.