10 Greatest Fighting Game Rosters Of All Time

When "Choose Your Fighter" is an impossible task.

It takes a lot to make a good fighting game; airtight mechanics, a great art department, and something that will ensure you stand out after twenty-plus years of innovation. And that's just to get off the ground. However, if you want to make a truly great entry in the genre, you need an impeccable roster. Without a stable of fighters that makes the player want to keep coming back for more, the rest of the experience doesn't matter. The roster is the very heart of the experience, and it above all else will ultimately determine a series' place in history. If you fall in love with the characters, you fall in love with the game. It's that simple. What is a great fighting game roster, though? Is it a game packed with as many characters as possible? Does it produce characters worthy of magazine covers and banner ads? Or is it maybe just striking a perfect balance between everyone on offer, so they each bring something to the experience and stand out in their own unique way? Truthfully, a great roster can mean a lot of different things, and has done over the years - but here is a definitive look at the true cream of the crop.

10. Tobal 2

Sheer roster size isn't the determining factor when trying to identify the best fighting game rosters, but when you've got a roster the size of Tobal 2 it's hard to go wrong. With over 200 fighters at your disposal, the character select screen of Tobal 2 can be fairly daunting. Now to be fair, not every one of those 200 characters are all-time greats and the game they are in isn't exactly the best fighter ever made either. But what is impressive beyond the absurd number of participants is the developers actually putting the effort into creating unique fighters, rather than colour-swapping the same base animations like many others in the genre with substantially smaller rosters have. I mean, how can't you love a game that makes a point out of pitting a triceratops and a surface-to-air missile launcher against each other?

9. Injustice: Gods Among Us

Building a fighting game roster mostly out of DC characters is a tough task. You either run the risk of leaving out someone's favourite, or you pack in as many as possible and end up with a hot mess. With Injustice, neither of those things happened. We definitely got the heavy hitters of the DC lineup such as Batman, Green Lantern, Superman, and The Flash, but what's really impressive is how some of the lesser names add to the game. From Hawkgirl's aerial juggling abilities to Solomon Grundy's brutish attacks, the developers did a fantastic job of combing through the DC mythology to find the perfect compliments to the obvious fighters. Because of their diligent selections, we got a game that is as much of a fanboy dream as it is a well-balanced fighter where every character is significant in some way. What more could you ask for?

8. Darkstalkers 3

The word to describe the brilliance of the Darkstalkers 3 roster is: "Unique." Every character on the Darkstalkers 3 roster feels like they were a lifelong passion project for each of the game's artists that they had intended to build an anime series around. It's the only possible explanation for how each of the game's fighters not only sport an entirely unique visual look and character trait (such as the demonic, skeleton punk rocker) but come complete with a series of stunning special manoeuvres that go far beyond the fireballs and closed fists of other fighters. As Jules Winnfield once mused in Pulp Fiction, "Personality goes a long way." Darkstalkers 3's roster is so loaded with personality that you could shave the character count in half and still have one of the most imaginative collection of fighters out there.

7. Skullgirls

Trying to make an all female fighting game like Skullgirls could have been a creative hindrance at best and a gimmick at worst. Instead, Skullgirls happens to sport one of the most creatively satisfying rosters ever devised. Every character has a unique trait that is immediately identifiable, but none of them feel like a one-note design. Most importantly, the developer's desire to create a roster of original and vibrant fighters in no way hindered their ability to balance the abilities of the fighters themselves. Every character plays perfectly off of each other and whether you are a newbie or expert you'll find that all of them are competitively viable. Far more than a gimmick, the roster of Skullgirls is a testament to the creative potential of the fighting genre.

6. Super Smash Bros. Wii U

Is Super Smash Bros. Wii U the best Smash Bros. ever made? Perhaps not. Does it have the roster that finally realised the full potential of the franchise's concept? Absolutely. The initial launch of Smash Bros. Wii U already gave players enough characters to last a lifetime, but it's the additions made through the game's DLC program that put it over the top. Even though Smash Bros. had long established a reputation for dream match ups, if you had told fans just a few years ago that we have a game where Ryu can take on Pac-Man, Sonic, and Cloud Strife in a Mushroom Kingdom-themed level, you would have been rightfully committed for insanity. But that is exactly what this roster is. Delicious, giggle-inducing insanity.

5. Mortal Kombat II

With only 12 characters available, there are most certainly larger Mortal Kombat rosters than the one found in Mortal Kombat 2. Most of them even contain every character found here. The thing about Mortal Kombat 2, though, is that there is no dead weight to be found on the selection screen. Every fighter on offer has something significant to contribute to the game and offers the player a unique way to battle. They do a tremendous job of improving over the one-note cast of the first game and never threaten to ruin the fun by being out of balance - such as Kabal's presence in Mortal Kombat 3. Even the three color-swap ninjas have a unique style of play and a compelling role in the game's mythology. If there were such a thing as the fighting character hall of fame, you could easily make the case for everyone on this game's roster making the cut.

4. Ultra Street Fighter IV

There obviously had to be a Street Fighter on here, but the question is, which one? Do you go with the all-time classic selection of Street Fighter II? The more obscure but creative roster of Third Strike? Who gets the nod? In the end, it has to go to Ultra Street Fighter IV. While it doesn't hurt that the game itself is in strong contention for the best that the series has ever produced, its cast of characters strikes that rare balance between size and credibility. Whoever is available on the character select screen that isn't a franchise mainstay was added to bring something to the game that the others did not. They're all visually well-designed, but the true strength of the game's characters are what they contribute to the gameplay itself. Each is deep enough to warrant mastering as a player and generally speaking worth the effort of doing so. A roster this size could have easily disrupted the delicate balance of the Street Fighter series, but instead they manage to form one of the franchise's greatest efforts.

3. Soul Calibur 2

The roster for the original Soul Calibur could also have easily made the list, but its sequel's is a case of more being better. Although only four new characters were added to the roster in Soul Calibur 2, the fact that each of them were inserted into the game without ruining the franchise's legendary balance is an impressive feat. Soul Calibur's weapon-based playstyle means it can be challenging to keep coming up with characters that have something to contribute that hasn't been seen before, but with this game the franchise found the perfect amount of original characters that are all viable in their own ways while still being fun to play. It certainly doesn't hurt that the character designs themselves tend to inspire either nightmares or fantasies. It's also hard to not love the game for its system-exclusive characters (Link, Spawn, and Heihachi for GameCube, Xbox and PS2 respectively) which is a tactic way more games should borrow from.

2. Tekken 3

If the Tekken series has fallen on hard times in recent years, it's at least due in small part to the franchise's tall task of having to somehow follow Tekken 3. It's one of the best fighting games ever made, and a big reason for that is the game's roster. There's a fantastic mix of series regulars and soon to be fan favourites. Even better, the developers managed to strike that perfect balance of standard fighting game caricatures (such as the karate expert) and the downright bizarre (a fighting log of wood) without ever really compromising the game itself for the sake of one over the other. It's a true joy to explore each character and discover their unique styles of play. Perhaps the most impressive aspect of the game's roster is how each character even has their own story that either plays off of the motivations of another character or contributes to the Tekken world at large. It's an accomplishment the series would never again equal.

1. Marvel Vs. Capcom 2

It shouldn't be a surprise that perhaps the greatest fighting game of all time also has perhaps the greatest roster of all time. However, what truly separates Marvel vs. Capcom 2 from the rest is that all these years later it still very much surprises gamers. When you first play Marvel vs. Capcom 2 there is that initial wow factor of seeing all of these characters come together in one game that you pray will never go away. The good news is that it doesn't. That's not only because the face value of the characters on display makes them so much fun to play with, but because they only start to reveal their full potential after spending dozens of hours exploring the game's team system. Finding that perfect combo attack only possible between Ryu, Spider-Man, and Doctor Doom is only slightly less satisfying than the realisation that there are a million other such combos waiting to be discovered. The depth of joy to be found amongst this game's roster is so complete, that it doesn't even sound cynical to doubt it can be beaten. What's the most expansive and impressive fighting game roster of all time? Let us know in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

An entertainment enthusiast living in Brooklyn, trying to make his way by slinging words at blank pages.