10 Greatest Western RPGs Of All Time
Is Fallout: New Vegas the western scene's greatest achievement?
The RPG is one of the most eclectic and varied genres in gaming history. If you ask five different people what image pops into their head when they think of the term, you'll walk away with five very different answers.
The west has done a lot to add variety to the genre too, to the point where it seems every game released these days has some kind of RPG mechanic to it. And, of course, it's the most popular form of online game out there with MMORPGs.
But which ones do it the best? There are many answers to this; many claims to the throne of the best western RPG, and with how scattered the genre has become in recent decades, the list has only grown.
Still, after giving it some thought, your scribe has managed to narrow it down to absolute best western RPGs of all time.
10. Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines
The Vampire: The Masquerade series is based on World Of Darkness, one of the most beloved horror tabletop role-playing game franchises out there, and Bloodlines is the title most folks think of when they think of the IP.
This is something of a miracle when you consider how much of a nightmare the development of this game was. To the point where patching is mandatory just to make sure you can actually play without The Masquerade being a broken mess.
Once you do patch it, however, you find one of the most multilayered and interesting CRPGs out there. You play as a random schmo who had the misfortune of getting busy with a vampire one night, who proceeds to turn you, presumably out of boredom.
You are both then captured by the vampire factions of Santa Monica, who kill the one who turned you and toss your sorry ass out onto the streets to fend for yourself.
The rest of the game is just you, the player, navigating the politics of the various vampire factions, either for self-gain, higher morality, or fun. The world-building is phenomenal, and the many gameplay modes (FPS, third-person RPG, branching dialogue etc.) are balanced shockingly well for a game whose development was this rife with problems.
While it may have had a rocky start, Bloodlines has earned a dedicated cult following in the years following its release.
9. Baldur's Gate
One of the most beloved RPG franchises of all time is without a doubt Baldur's Gate. Considered one of the foundations of how top-down RPGs are made, almost everything that you expect from the genre today can be found here.
Baldur's Gate starts off rather simply, with your character losing their home and father figure when ambushed on the road. In your quest to unravel the mystery of why your master was killed and who did it, you will find yourself embroiled in a conspiracy that has enveloped the entire land.
While a lot of the game has shown its age (30 years old at time of writing, so that's only natural), so much more of Baldur's Gate remains timeless.
The characters are beautifully written, the world-building is excellent - with literally every room telling you something about the place that room is and how people have lived in and interacted with it - and the combat, while definitely of its time, comes off a lot better than its contemporaries. While earlier CRPGs like Ultima 7 came off more like slap fights you had little to no control over, Baldur's Gate actually lets you have much more command over the flow of combat.
8. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
CD Projekt RED were, for a time, absolutely untouchable, and it all had to do with a single game - The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt.
The studio had been making Witcher games for years before this, but Witchers 1 and 2, while great in their own right, also had their own jank to deal with that held them back from the mainstream appeal 3 has been enjoying. Shoddy controls, user-unfriendly interface, and just plain archaic game design, got in the way of the excellent world-building and storytelling that the series has always had.
3 succeeded by tightening up the gameplay and polishing the UI, while still keeping the narrative and gameplay complexity the series was known for. Still a complex game, but things like, for instance, taking a single health potion, didn't take all damn day. But that wasn't all that drew folks to the game, as it expanded on what made the previous 2 games so fun: leaning into The Witcher as a sort of fantasy blue-collar job.
The Witcher 3 really makes you feel like being a Witcher is a full-time gig, rather than being some hero of destiny or whatever. This adds a layer of professionalism to Geralt's interactions with his clients, which gives the world its unique flavor.
7. Divinity: Original Sin 2
It can be difficult to reconcile the fact that the majority of video game RPGs simply are not built to accommodate the kind of freedom you'll find in your average tabletop equivalent. Choices you thought of will not be available, applications of powers won't work despite them offering a way to get out of a problem, and a ton of other things you thought of that the developers either didn't consider or didn't have time to implement.
But this makes the ones that think of everything all the more impressive, and Divinity: Original Sin 2 is one of those wonderful few.
Every inch of this game is fussed over like a swiss watch until it's just right. Every party member feels like they could be the protagonist, making it a legitimately tough choice on which one to pick. But if none of them strike your fancy, then the deep character creator will sate you just fine. Every single quest, down to the tiniest fetch quest, is rich with character and often carry heartbreaking plot twists of their own, completely separate from the main plot.
If you're itching for the kind of emotional storytelling you find in the best TTRPGs but don't want to sacrifice having a fun time with modern RPG mechanics, then Divinity is exactly what you've been looking for.
6. Neverwinter Nights
One of the first really big Bioware games, Neverwinter Nights is a DnD game that helped to put the company on the map, containing a lot of the tropes that Bioware fans are familiar with, but with some very nice bells and whistles that classic Bioware fans are definitely missing from their more recent work.
For example, unlike even the more complex modern Bioware games like Dragon Age Origins, in Nights, if a companion doesn't like a decision you've made, you can actually - gasp - EXPLAIN YOURSELF AND HELP THEM UNDERSTAND! What a bloody concept!
Like the best CRPGs, Neverwinter Nights' world is designed to be intricately complex, and the characters within it have layers to them that the player must go out of their way to discover since, in keeping with the above example, the writing is realistic enough that they aren't just gonna lay out their backstories in the first hour of knowing them. Or the 7th hour, for that matter. This brings me to the next big point about this game: it is LONG. One of the beefiest RPGs on the market at the time, in fact.
Fortunately, the gameplay is accessible enough, and the quests are fun and interesting enough to make you want to get through it all. Just be sure to bring a snack, you will be here for a while.
5. Dragon Age: Origins
Dragon Age: Origins holds the distinction of having one of the longest development times of any RPG, Bioware having begun development at the turn of the millennium and releasing the final game in 2008, almost a full motherhumping DECADE.
The way the coin flip of the universe works in these scenarios is that the game ends up being the best thing ever or an absolute train wreck. There is no in-between. But luckily, Dragon Age: Origins turned out to be one of the all-time great RPGs.
This dark fantasy epic takes you on a journey throughout the war-ravaged land of Ferelden, as you - the last of a great order of knights known as the Grey Wardens - must work to prevent the land from being consumed by the zombie-like horde known as the darkspawn. How many moral compromises you're willing to make to get there is entirely up to you.
What makes Origins so great is that it lets you be as evil, as good, or as grey, as you want. There are many ways to get the best ending in the game, as well as the worst. Or you can work in shades of grey to get to the most practical option. However much you accept the moral ambiguity of Dragon Age's world is up to you. Add onto that some of the best characters in gaming history to make up your party, and you get one for the ages.
4. Deus Ex
The immersive sim is one of the most venerated of western RPGs, especially among the hardcore classic crowd. While other RPGs may have player choice as a factor in how things turn out, what defines the immersive sim is that every choice the player makes, both in story and gameplay, plays into the experience overall. And among those, few stand as tall as Deus Ex.
Deus Ex is one of video games' seminal cyberpunk works, more or less everything that Cyberpunk 2077 wanted to be but wasn't. The story centers around protagonist J. C. Denton, an anti-terrorist officer who finds himself falling down a rabbit hole of conspiracies, uncovering a plot that encompasses his entire badass, neon-soaked, cyborg-infested world.
EVERY choice, every decision, and every word of dialogue you have in this game ties back into the larger storyline, and that is what sets this game apart from the rest all these years later. Well, that and the fact that it's pretty damn ugly. Sorry, it just is.
3. Knights Of The Old Republic
BioWare didn't need to go this hard on a tie-in game that was gonna make bank regardless of quality, but God bless them for doing so anyway, because KOTOR is a miracle of a game.
The story takes place hundreds of years before the events of the prequels, and centers on a young Jedi (that's you) working under Jedi Knight Bastila Shan, who has just come off the mission sure to put her in the history books: the capture of the infamous Jedi turned Sith warlord Darth Revan. A career achievement that I'm sure is in NO WAY relevant to you whatsoever!
KOTOR's gameplay is the gold standard of being easy to learn, but satisfying to master. The UI is crafted to help the player learn everything about combat and interaction right away while being deep enough to satisfy the more hardcore crowd. The world of the Old Republic strikes that perfect balance between being recognizably Star Wars, and yet also distinctly primitive compared to even the original trilogy.
if you haven't played KOTOR yet, honestly, what are you doing here? Go fix that immediately.
2. Ultima Underworld: The Stygian Abyss
One of the founding cornerstones of western RPGs, as we know them today, is the Ultima series by the tragically EA'd Origin Systems. And in that venerated series, few are more influential than Ultima Underworld: The Stygian Abyss.
You, the Avatar, are framed for aiding in the kidnapping of a princess in the mythical land of Britannia, and are thus thrown into the deepest dungeon in all the land - The Stygian Abyss, where the princess was taken. To earn your freedom, not to mention your life, you must travel to the bottom of this infamous hellhole and rescue her.
The larger narrative is unimportant, which is good, because the main story is kinda bad, not helped by REALLY bad voice acting. It's the sidequests and the world-building that make this game what it is. The abyss has been established throughout the series, as the single worst place in the land of Britannia. The last time your character went in there, you barely survived with endgame gear, and now you have to work your way through it with basically nothing.
What results is one of the finest immersive sim RPGs ever made, where you are expected to look out for yourself at every turn. From being able to take your own notes on the map, to having to scrounge for literally everything while interacting with the various clans and factions within the abyss, Ultima Underworld is a hardcore RPG of the highest quality.
1. Fallout: New Vegas
For this author's money, the greatest RPG the western world has ever produced remains Fallout: New Vegas. The Fallout series has had some great entries, but New Vegas feels like the culmination of everything great that had come before from both the Bethesda and Interplay eras, leaving behind everything that didn't work.
The story begins with you getting shot in the head and somehow surviving. This will soon not even make the top 20 list of the weirdest things to happen to your poor befuddled mailman of a protagonist, as their journey to figure out WHY they were shot in the head will take them across the madcap wasteland of the Mojave, and all the weirdos that inhabit it.
The gameplay introduced in 3 is polished in New Vegas to a mirror shine, the world of the Mojave is some of the most beautiful world-building in gaming history, every single quest is interesting, and all in all everything about this game just flat-out works. There can be no debate, at least in this author's mind, that Fallout New Vegas is the best western RPG of all time.