10 Iconic Video Game Mascots (That Actually Suck)

Are all of these characters intricately designed with fascinating personalities? Of course not!

For as long as there have been video games, there have been video game mascots. Created through the extensive marketing of particular characters, mascots are used by companies to represent the qualities they want associated with their brand. It wasn't by chance that Sony ended-up using Helghast soldiers and Chimera in their marketing campaigns for the PS3, but rather a well-planned attempt to wash off the kiddie image with which they had been left by PS2 mascots Sly Cooper and Ratchet and Clank. Iconic mascots are those synonymous with a certain console generation or, in some cases, video games in general. But are all of these symbols of gaming deep, intricately designed characters with fascinating personalities? Of course not! This is a list of ten iconic video game mascots that are actually pretty rubbish when put under scrutiny, with our love for them being largely (and rather depressingly) built from extensive advertising campaigns rather than any real quality. So sit back and relax as we go through the Peter Andres and Snookis of the gaming world! We all know them... we're just not quite sure why.

10. Pac-Man

Where better to start than the original iconic video game mascot himself, Pac-Man. It makes sense he became such an icon of gaming, given he was the star of the world's most popular arcade game, while also being one of the first real video game characters to even exist. Back in the day it was rare to play as something more in-depth than a simple white line or a vaguely abstract shape, so when old Pacs came about he quickly became the face of the entire industry, largely because he was the only character in the industry with a face. In truth though, Pac-Man is a bit rubbish. Essentially he's just a gluttonous wad of cheese, going round and round in circles as he desperately tries to find more coins and cherries to eat. Well we say coins, those little yellow circles could be anything really couldn't they? The character is undeniably a great symbol of his age, representing true genius in simplicity. However, given a block of sliced Edam could replace him and nobody would notice the difference, it's hard to maintain he doesn't suck harder than a Katie Price vacuum cleaner.

9. Nathan Drake

From the oldest to the newest item on our list, we arrive at PS3 golden-boy Nathan Drake. Protagonist of the Uncharted series, Sony's uncharismatic front-man has been plastered across countless posters, given primetime advertising space, and even got a place in the Sony All-Stars (they bloody weren't) Battle Royale. There are a few problems with Drake. Firstly, both him and his games are massive rip-offs of sources such as the Indiana Jones films, meaning even when he's first encountered, the character is already thoroughly played out. Secondly, he's not even been ripped-off that well, keeping all the misogynism of his forebears but lacking even a trace of their charm or intelligence. There's also the issue of him being a white American who goes around murdering foreigners and destroying ancient temples, suggesting he's a psychopath as well as a crap mascot. Nathan Drake symbolises the push for video games to lose their interactivity and become more like films, while at the same time being one of the most uninteresting and unoriginal character to ever grace our screens.

8. Captain Falcon

Next up we have Captain Falcon, star of the F-Zero racing series and poster-dude for the GameCube. Although the Captain never quite took off as a leading man, he is still iconic in the sense he mirrored his console quite well (i.e. he was a failure) and most gamers over 18 know about him. Falcon is a character that tries to embrace the cool Boba Fett-type look, having a hard-ass backstory and a slick metal suit to match. Unfortunately, he was also another tragic victim of the 'cutesie bug' that infects so many Nintendo creations, forming a juxtaposition that really doesn't work. The effeminately costumed racer would look more at home as an extra in Dragon Ball Z than fronting a video game, his colourful yet muscular appearance making him seem either schizophrenic or sexually confused. Saying that, the character may have worked if his game corresponded to his appearance a bit more. He fronted a fairly uninspired (if teeth-pullingly difficult) racer, a far cry to the extravaganza his costume promises. So as it stands, he's a little dull. All pants and no trousers. All tongue and no teeth. All farts and no poop. All... oh you get the point.

7. Gex

Iconic? Gex?! You've got to be kitten me! No wait, that doesn't work... screw it. Gex is a anthropomorphic lizard who Crystal Dynamics desperately tried to make look cool. They did this by giving him sunglasses, a bad attitude, and even worse; jokes, which were often out-of-place pop-culture references only severe brain damage would make amusing. Gex was designed in a similar vein to Crash Bandicoot, in that they were both largely animal-themed and enjoyed platforming. The main difference between the two being that Crash had an array of interesting characters and levels, while Gex had bad 'jokes' and sunglasses. Inevitably he was dropped as a mascot by everybody on account of being terrible and nobody liking him.

6. Master Chief

A child of the first Xbox console, Master Chief is perhaps the only gaming mascot consistently synonymous with Microsoft since his creation. Others, such as Bioshock's Big Daddies and that bloke from Dead Rising, started out with similar exclusive roots, yet were quickly changed to be cross-platform and lost all their mascot capabilities. Now there are two ways of looking at old Chiefy. On the one hand he can be seen as a blank slate, allowing players to project themselves onto the faceless soldier in order to have a fully immersive experience. On the other hand he's a rather standard template character with zero interesting qualities or discernible features. We are more inclined to view him in this latter light, as there isn't really any basis for the former. Being a first-person shooter, the Halo series has no reason to give its main character absolutely no personality. When people are playing they are fully involved in what's going on, just like they would be in nearly any other first-person game. Consequently, the only time Mr Bland is actually seen is during cutscenes, which are done in third person. That raises an issue, as nobody is watching a third person video and maintaining the thought that they're looking at themself, so why not give the hero a bit of pazaz? In Resistance 3 (another FPS) the protagonist is a fascinating, multi-layered character. Even Team Fortress 2 gives its templates interesting personalities, and that's just an online multiplayer game Samus is another a great example of how it's easily possibly to allow projection and characterisation at the same time, wearing a face-covering suit during missions yet taking the mask off when the story demands it. Master Chief is a terrible mascot as he's SO boring. Microsoft may as well have a toaster as their poster-boy for all the engaging qualities MC owns. Actually we shouldn't have said that, we might give them ideas.

5. Spyro

Developed by the same people who made Ratchet and Clank, Spyro is a small purple dragon that spends most of his time beating up various anthropomorphic animals (both mythical and real). 'A dragon you say? Why, how can a dragon be a sucky mascot? Dragons are great!' Yes indeed, dragons are generally pretty great, yet Spyro is very much the exception. Here's why: Spyro is a whiny d**che. Presumably made to attract children, this young dragon had an obnoxious voice even back on PS1, adopting the sort of attitude middle-age cartoon designers mistaking think kids will find 'cool'. Few people finish any Spyro game liking the character, yet Sony still used him alongside favourites like Crash to shift console units. Looking at him goes a great way towards understanding why it is often silent mascots that prove the most popular, as they don't have terrible dialogue or a stupid tone of voice to damage their appeal.

4. Sonic

Sonic the Hedgehog (because apparently there's only one hedgehog) is a small blue animal capable of running at super speeds and jumping exceptionally high. Thinking about it he doesn't really look much like a hedgehog, given he's bright blue wears big red trainers. But Superman isn't a man either, so perhaps we're just not supposed to think about their names too much. Their creators clearly didn't. Originally Sonic was a kind of animal saviour, freeing trapped creatures that Dr Robotnik had imprisoned to power his machines (because video games). The whole thing seemed like a message about how animals and nature are mistreated by humans, with our magic hedgehog protagonist being their salvation. After his high commercial success things started going downhill for the poor blighter though. You see there's not much you can do with a character whose only abilities are jump and run. Sonic was designed to be fast, making complex platforming out of the question, as it would be impossible to avoid constantly slipping off ledges into Game Over. Making him a mascot caused him to be loved, which in turn meant he couldn't really be changed, as the thing about mascots is they have to be consistent or all effect is lost. This is why so many other characters, such as Big, Knuckles, and Rogue the Bat, were added to the games. SEGA weren't able to change Sonic, so they just built stuff around him to compensate. Sadly this doesn't change the fact Sonic himself is pretty crappy, trapped in his unchangeable role by the mascot status he so proudly wears. It's a classic example of success breeding misery, like Henry Winkler but with more spikes. Also, the spin-off Were-Hog doesn't make sense. That would be a man-cross-hedgehog, not a wolf-cross-hedgehog. Geez SEGA, can you guys not even speak Latin?

3. Chris Redfield

Iconic mascot of the Resident Evil series and zombie games in general, Chris Redfield has always been a pretty sucky character. The SAS style soldier is an archetypal horror protagonist. With his muscular American body, deep voice, and James Bond good looks, if he were in a horror flick you'd know within the first five minutes he'd be the one alive at the credits (probably alongside a fairly useless girl whose only discernible role is to fancy him). The reason he's such a terrible mascot is that he's a steroid-pumped bag of clichés, making everything he's associated with appear predictable to the point of ennui. This has become even worse in his last two games (Resi 5 and 6), as he was pushed over the final step from slightly buff obviously-the-one-to-survive guy to all out megamuscle-Schwarzenegger action-hero. He actually got the, 'I-am-a-soldier-but-my-friends-died-and-it-was-probably-my-fault' backstory in Resi 6, cementing him as the biggest movie rip-off character in history.

2. Pikachu

Mascot of the Pokemon games, Pikachu is possibly the worst chosen mascot of anything ever. It is a small, fat, rat-like creature with an uncanny ability to produce large amounts of electricity, which it can use to harm predators/prey/anyone it doesn't quite like. There are many fascinatingly designed characters in Pokemon. From dragons to strange pink blobs to a giant bipedal turtle with cannons on its back, there are literally hundreds of more interesting characters than Pikachu. Yet the yellow rat remains the character most heavily featured on Pokemon merchandise to this day. On some levels it make sense. Pikachu is a sexless colour and is cutesie enough to attract the effeminate type, though not too cutesie to detour a little boy's interest. Saying that, there are plenty of other options with similar universal appeal that could be focused on, so that's not really much of an argument. The key issue is that not only does Pikachu rarely get seen in the games, but when it does appear it's actually pretty rubbish. A dedicated player will be able to get the creature to be mediocre at best. Its attacks are largely unspectacular, usually involving a few sparks or a flash of lighting, and as we've already said its appearance is one of the most univentive designs around (excluding some characters from Pokemon Black onwards).

1. Mario

"Itsa me! A strangely racist stereotype!" Mario, or 'Jumpman' as he was originally called, is a small Italian plumber and the main mascot for Nintendo. When and why he became Italian we're not sure, but considering the plot of most of his games consists of a plumber battling turtles and jumping over lava to save a Princess, it's doubtful there was much in the way of logical thought when it came to making the decision. Now let's be honest, nobody's favourite character from Mario is actually Mario himself. Luigi, Wario, Princess Peach, and even Toad are often found higher in the echelons of popularity, as they all have personality traits far more interesting than those of the hapless hero. In fact, unless blue-overalls or sounding maybe-possibly-racist-nobody's-quite-sure are personality traits, Mario doesn't seem have any character at all. Some may argue he's a great frontman for Nintendo, very much encapsulating the surrealist themes many of their games seem to contain. Yet, when we look at the character himself, there's really nothing that interesting about him. Unlike Sonic, for example, Mario could be replaced by almost anyone else in his games and the experience would become more fun. This is becoming apparent with the exponentially increasing popularity of brother Luigi, who got an entire year dedicated to him by Nintendo in 2013. Luigi is also appearing more frequently on the covers of Mario games recently, which is done in a very provocative 'you might get to play as the interesting brother if you buy this game,' sort of way. Mario is a great mascot for the company he represents. But as a character, he's really not all that noteworthy. Are there any other mascots you think deserve to be on our list? Let us know in the comments below.

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Oldfield is a journalist, reviewer, and amateur comic-book writer (meaning he's yet to be published). He's a man who'll criticise anything, even this biog, which he thinks is a bit crap. For notifications on when new articles are up and game related news, follow him on his Twitter account @DunDunDUH