10 Incredible Sequels That Came From Terrible Video Games

There's a very good reason people only ever mention Street Fighter 2...

Given the sheer amount of publicity games receive in the modern age, it€™s almost impossible to be surprised by new releases anymore. Whether it€™s a new game in an established franchise or an original IP from a well-loved studio, anyone with a modicum of interest in something can follow its progress along the way - but you'll still rarely find players just outright expecting something to be bad because of it. This huge amount of hype surrounding virtually every new release isn€™t always the healthiest when it comes to managing player expectations, and as a result it often leaves you feeling massively disappointed when whatever you've been following finally reveals itself as something less than incredible. On the flip-side to this, when a sequel to an awful - or otherwise not critically revered - game is greenlit, you can almost hear the snickering erupt across the internet (Titanfall 2, anyone?), but although some can be treated with hostility right out the gate for a number of reasons, when it comes down to it these sequels to bad titles can make for the best surprises. With no expectations for the game to be good, it frees up a respective developer to come out of nowhere and provide what could be one of the year's best experiences. On the back foot and against all odds, the following titles resisted crumbling to the critical kicking their first efforts received and came out swinging with epic, bombastic and hugely enjoyable sequels - but who did it the best?

10. Red Steel 2

In what was supposed to be the Wii€™s killer app for hardcore gamers, Red Steel's failure seemed to prove all of the Nintendo naysayers right. Releasing with poor controls and clunky gameplay, the original seemed to signal the demise of mature third party titles on a console that had come under fire for pandering too much to the casual market. But then Red Steel 2, after careful and worthwhile time spent in development, released to set the record straight. Attempting to solve all the problems of the original, this sequel not only addressed all of the previous game€™s shotcomings but found its own unique voice and a distinct personality that allowed it to stand out as one of the biggest and best must have Nintendo Wii titles. With RS 2, Nintendo finally had a crowning achievement that proved €˜real games€™ could be made for the console, and that the Wii could provide epic and exhilarating experiences that wouldn€™t be found anywhere else on the market.

9. 50 Cent: Blood On The Sand

It€™s almost unfathomable to think that you could go out to a store right now and buy a video game based around a gun-toting 50 Cent. But perhaps it's even more unfathomable to think that €“ shockingly €“ it actually wouldn't be a terrible experience. While the original title in the series, 50 Cent: Bulletproof, was an absolute travesty of video game development, its sequel Blood on the Sand proved to be a rather enjoyable and explosive third-person arcade shooter. Losing most of the €˜gritty€™ seriousness that sank the original game, this sequel instead focused on playing up just how inherently silly the idea of a 50 Cent video game is, and as a result Blood on the Sand felt less obnoxious than its predecessor. In a stroke of genius, it embraced cartoon violence and over the top mayhem completely to deliver an exciting and addicting shoot-em-up experience.

8. Just Cause 2

In another case of a bunch of great ideas being poorly executed in the finished product, Just Cause didn€™t quite live up to the pre-release promise of high-octane exploration and engrossing tropical sandbox action. Although the game-world proved to be actually rather expansive and gave players with a variety of ways to get around, the main drawback of the original was that the whole map felt lifeless and empty, and as a result the game just didn't feel like it had much depth to it. Fortunately for players, the second instalment arrived a few years later full to the brim with exotic places to see and cathartic things to do. With the addition of the grappling hook, it boasted some of the most frantic and fast-paced open world action ever seen in a video game. The immense scale of the title and the fluidity of the movement meant that the simple act of getting around was hugely enjoyable in itself, and when you were fully able to master all of the subtleties in the controls, some of the combos you could string together in simply had to be seen to be believed.

7. Spider-Man 2

It€™s a bit of a shame that over ten years since its original release, Spider-Man 2 is still considered the pinnacle of licensed movie tie-in games. But up until it released on the PS2, it's safe to say that the franchise had amassed a rather spotty set of games, and with the release of the original movie tie-in game the series had pretty much sank as low as it could possibly go. So it was a surprise then, when this official movie tie-in came out and everybody - fans of the series and newcomers alike - absolutely loved it. With the simple ability to swing around an open-world city as Spider-Man, games had finally faithfully created a version of the beloved superhero that felt true to the character, and even more impressively, the rest of the game wasn€™t bad either. Boasting most of the wall-crawler's rogue€™s gallery and the ability to deal spontaneous justice on the streets of Manhattan, Spider-Man 2, after numerous games had tried and failed to achieve the very same thing, finally made you feel like you were playing as everyone€™s favourite web-head.

6. Timesplitters 2

timesplitters2 Because of the classic status and immense nostalgia that the Timesplitters series has amassed since the release of the third and final game, it's hard to revisit the originals without being affected a little bit by those rose-tinted glasses. That's not to say the titles are bad by today's standards, but they're definitely not as flawless as you remember, and sadly the first attempt in the franchise actually plays more like a tech demo than a proper release. With an insubstantial single-player campaign and a multiplayer component that feels more like a test run for later games, the 'Splitters has nothing on its now-classic, fully-fledged sequel.

5. Saints Row 2

Starting off as nothing other than a rather bland GTA clone, the original Saints Row didn€™t particularly stand out as a title that pushed the open world genre forward. While the game functioned perfectly as an imitation of a better, more mechanically sound franchise, it wasn€™t until the release of the second entry that the series truly found its quirky identity. Around the same time GTA IV was adopting a super-serious tone, the Saints Row franchise brilliantly took the exact opposite approach and embraced the inherent silliness that sandbox games tended to revel in. And it was this move that ultimately allowed this second iteration to stand out as its own distinct entity, far away from the stigma that came with imitating a more popular franchise. With this hugely enjoyable new direction, developers Volition cemented the trajectory for the rest of the series in its commitment to embracing enjoyably frantic over-the-top gameplay in every respect.

4. Red Dead Redemption

When it first released, Red Dead Revolver didn€™t exactly set the world on fire. Not only were western period pieces a rare and virtually dead genre to find in games anyway, when Rockstar's first wild west title hit stores it did nothing to prove that this type of game could be made into a bankable franchise. A derivative and uninspired third-person spaghetti western, the original game in the franchise actually housed a decent amount of potential before it released, but unfortunately didn€™t quite make the most of its ridiculous and over-the-top setting. But a few years on the back-burner and a new focus on a more serious rework of the genre injected this stilted series with newfound life, and as a result, Rockstar's sequel Red Dead Redemption turned out to be one of the most revered games of the last generation. Improving wholeheartedly on the original by adding a dash of GTA gameplay to the mix, this iconic sequel is still considered the definitive video game depiction of the wild west to this day.

3. Assassin€™s Creed II

Sadly, while there was palpable expectation surrounding the original Assassin€™s Creed on its first release, the actual game itself turned out to be a rather underwhelming and repetitive experience. With simple combat and uninspired missions, it seemed that although the core concept of the title was an incredibly original one, Ubisoft's first effort in the series just couldn€™t execute and build these solid concepts into an interesting overall game, relying far too much on repetition to fill the hours in. Fortunately, for Assassin€™s Creed 2 Ubi took all of the criticisms of the first game to heart and went back to the drawing board. By hunkering down to flesh out the ideas that worked best in the original title, this sequel managed to improve on almost every aspect of its underwhelming predecessor. With a wider selection of tasks, a more expansive and diverse game world and an iconic hero in Ezio (who is still considered the face of the franchise, even though he hasn€™t starred in an Assassin€™s Creed title in over three games now), Ubisoft's epic sequel proved to be everything the original game was hyped up to be and then some.

2. Street Fighter 2

There€™s a reason why, although every subsequent game in the franchise has received re-release after re-release, there's basically only one version of the original Street Fighter product that exists. While the original arcade version of the game was adequate, the subsequent ports the title received became synonymous with awful video game design. With clunky combat and frustrating controls the original effort into the series - while providing some of the groundwork for future instalments - actually barely amassed to anything more than a forgettable experience when judged on its own merits Fortunately for players, soon after this disastrous release Capcom's sequel arrived on the scene to become the definitive arcade fighter among players, removing the lingering bad taste of the original release and signalling the true start of the Street Fighter series as a powerful and dominating gaming giant.

1. Grand Theft Auto III

Do you ever wonder why no one mentions any Grand Theft Auto titles prior to the third instalment? While the original top-down entries into the series provided the core ideas that would later cement the franchise as a gaming powerhouse, these primitive forays into 2D open world mayhem didn€™t exactly boast the same tantalising mix of violence and exploration that everyone expects from the series today. In fact, a lot of the gameplay itself wasn€™t even that particularly enjoyable. With clunky controls and only a very basic hook, sessions of earlier GTA games weren€™t exactly the hours upon hours of immersive murder-fests they are today. But with Grand Theft Auto 3, Rockstar essentially reinvented itself along with the entire series. Basically creating modern open world games as we know them, GTA 3€™s legacy simply cannot be overstated, as this seemingly innocuous and out-of-nowhere sequel established the single most successful video game franchise in history. What are your favourite franchises that came from awful first instalments? Let us know in the comments!

Watch Next


Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.