10 Incredible Video Games Most People Abandoned At The Start

Most people tapped out of these brilliant games shockingly early.

Shadow of the Colossus
Bluepoint Games

With players having more gaming options available at their fingertips for less money than ever before, it's increasingly tricky for developers to actually keep eyeballs on their games for a sustained period.

Trophy data, while not an exact science, makes it clear that the vast majority of players don't actually finish most of the games they buy. 

Whether they lose interest, real life gets in the way, or they're lured away by the latest shiny hotness, the percentage of players who will actually beat even a relatively short game is insanely small, no matter how great it might be.

But what's more surprising is that there are many brilliant games out there which the majority of players bailed from early on. 

While it's more understandable that not all players will invest dozens of hours making it to the end of a great game, for them to lose motivation in the early going is certainly more peculiar.

In some cases these superb games might have slow prologue sections, or maybe the first boss is actually the most difficult in the entire game. 

Elsewhere, it's a little tougher to figure out precisely what made so many put these games down early and never return...

10. Returnal

Returnal Phrike
Housemarque

In Housemarque's face-melting roguelike third-person shooter Returnal, you can quite reasonably reach its first boss, Phrike, in less than two hours. 

Despite Phrike being the game's first major encounter, however, it offers up one hell of a challenge, enough that to date, 67.6% of players have never even beaten the boss at all.

Now to be completely fair here, players are absolutely supposed to spend many more hours building up their loadout before finally felling Phrike, but given that less than one-third of players ever made it past the boss, it's clear that folks hit a brick wall early on and quickly peaced out.

A month after the game's release, Housemarque even revealed that Phrike was the game's boss which killed players the most, indicating that the game's first boss is also its toughest, but that if players could prevail over Phrike, they had a much better chance of beating the rest of Returnal's tough-as-nails bosses.

On one hand it's a shame that so many bailed on Returnal so early, but on the other, the developer surely knew exactly what they were doing by making Phrike so tricky to put down.


9. Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Metal Gear Solid V Skulls
Konami

Even accepting that Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain is rather infamous for its tedious opening sequence, the majority of players didn't get much further through the game before calling it a day.

Trophy data has a whopping 55% of players not even beating the game's sixth story mission, "Where Do the Bees Sleep," and given that players sticking to the critical path will hit this mission about three hours into the 30-hour story, that means most players quit MGS V around 10% of the way through the cinematic campaign.

This is a little more understandable when you consider that this mission sees players having their first major encounter with the game's most feared recurring enemies, the terrifying Skulls.

Even so, accepting the Metal Gear Solid franchise's doggedly loyal fanbase and MGS V's best-in-class action sandbox gameplay, it's maddening that so many took early leave of it and missed out on everything else it had to offer.


8. Wild Arms 3

Wild Arms 3
Sony

Wild Arms 3 is a stone cold banger of an RPG that was widely lauded for its art style, rich story, and deep characters when it launched for PS2 way back in 2002.

And in 2016 it was finally re-released on PS4 through PSN, in turn offering a window into player habits after all this time.

The most startling stat? Most folk didn't even progress past the first proper boss after the prologue, Janus, with 65.9% of players packing up before defeating him. It's not without irony that the trophy for defeating Janus is called "Just Getting Started."

It's especially odd as Janus is a relatively easy boss compared to most other ones on this list, and is encountered only about an hour into the game.

Furthermore, given that a high percentage of those playing Wild Arms 3 on PS4 will be existing fans of the game and well equipped to deal with Janus, it makes even less sense that so many would stop short of this fight.


7. Call of Duty: Black Ops 6

Call of Duty Black Ops 6
Activision

Trophy data for Call of Duty games offers a fascinating expression of one simple fact - many players simply don't care about the series' single-player campaigns, opting to just dip a toe in before bouncing off and spending the rest of their time in the ultra-addictive multiplayer suites.

Even with that in mind, though, the stats for the FPS franchise's most recent entry, Black Ops 6, show that a stonking 84.9% of players didn't even get through the campaign's first level, "Bishop Takes Rook."

When you consider that the opening mission is only about 20 minutes long and incredibly straight-forward, that's pretty damning. 

From there the completion rates for each subsequent level naturally tumble further, enough that only 5.5% of players actually beat the five-hour campaign on any difficulty level whatsoever.

Considering that Black Ops 6's campaign was one of the series' most acclaimed in recent years, it's a damn shame that most didn't even give it a chance, either playing it for a cursory 10 minutes or just diving straight into multiplayer and Zombies instead.


6. Ōkami

Okami
Capcom

Ōkami is one of the definitive cult classic video games of the last 20 years - an action-adventure game so beloved that a sequel was recently announced no matter that the original flopped so catastrophically that it caused the closure of developer Clover Studio.

Even those who love Ōkami will generally concede that the game can be a bit of a slog in places, though, and never more than during its irritating opening sequence, where players can't walk more than a few feet at a time without being bombarded with a battery of text explaining something.

Though this didn't cause too many to quit the game, the majority of players only made it a few more hours before throwing in the towel. 

50.7% of players never learned to use the Vine ability, which is obtained from the Tsuta Ruins level about three hours into the game, give or take.

Bearing in mind that Ōkami is a 40-hour odyssey, that's barely scratching the surface of its story - like watching the first 10 minutes of a two-hour movie and turning it off.


5. Bloodborne

Bloodborne Gascgoine
Sony Computer Entertainment

Though FromSoftware games have a well-earned rep for their mighty difficulty, players also tend to know what they're getting into and won't hang up the controller eagerly.

But even with that in mind, Bloodborne is generally accepted to be one of the hardest SoulsBorne games to date, and as such even FromSoft's die-hard fans didn't get too far through it before taking off.

In fact, 55.7% of players couldn't even beat the game's first mandatory boss, Father Gascgoine, who can be encountered less than two hours into the story. 

Sure, Daddy G is basically a skill-check boss hurled at players while they're still acclimating to the early stages of the game, but considering the grit and mettle of your average FromSoft fan, the lack of perseverance on display here is genuinely surprising.

Even with such a low completion rate for its first proper boss, though, Bloodborne's platinum trophy still has a relatively high 6.8% for a game of this difficulty level, suggesting that if you can make it through the first couple of bosses, you're probably going to commit to the long, brutal haul.


4. 2064: Read Only Memories

2064 Read Only Memories
MidBoss

This might be the low-key most baffling entry on this list. 

Cyberpunk graphic adventure 2064: Read Only Memories was never going to be everyone's cup of tea, but the marketing was totally upfront about the type of game it was, enough that few were likely to be left alienated by its prologue section alone.

But alas, a staggering 70.7% of players never even made it past said prologue and started the game proper, meaning they'd had enough after playing for 45 minutes or less.

That's wild, though might partially be explained by the game being available as part of the PlayStation Plus subscription service many moons ago, whereby large swaths of players might've tried it out just for the hell of it, only to swiftly realise it wasn't their bag, like, at all.

Even so, that's a bounce rate that'd be impressive if it weren't somewhat depressing considering the game's quality.


3. Death Stranding

Death Stranding
Kojima Productions

Death Stranding is another game that certainly won't be for everyone, especially as it dials back Hideo Kojima's typically action-centric gameplay for something focused more on exploration and sheer vibes.

All the same, the world's most advanced walking simulator ended up with sky-high early DNFs, as 57.1% of those who started the game didn't even make it to the end of the second chapter.

Sure, you'll have to play around four-or-so hours to reach the end of chapter 2, but given that Death Stranding is a honking meal of a game with a critical path clocking in at around 35 hours, that's barely 10% of the mainline experience.

The game's first two chapters did admittedly receive their share of criticism for their sluggish pacing, enough that some critics even urged players to race through chapter 2 as fast as possible.

But evidently the more laid-back pacing of those opening hours was enough for some to turn the game off and never look back. 

It'll certainly be interesting to see whether or not the impending Death Stranding 2: On the Beach kicks off with a little more forward-momentum.


2. Shadow of the Colossus

Shadow of the Colossus Gaius
Bluepoint Games

Given that cult games tend to invite more loyal commitment from players to see them through to the end, it's a surprise just how quickly so many players pulled the ripcord while playing Bluepoint's remake of the masterful Shadow of the Colossus.

Though the majority of players defeated the first two colossi - who, in the interest of easing players in, are absolute cake - the third colossus, Gaius, marked the point at which many fell off.

55.1% of players didn't make it past Gaius, and even accepting that he really feels like the first "proper" boss after two easy-peasy tutorial bosses, it's still shocking how few persevered.

Given that Shadow of the Colossus has sixteen bosses to fight through, and most players can beat the first three colossi in an hour or less, one can infer that many just didn't vibe with the puzzle-as-boss-fight aspect of the Gaius battle.

It's their loss, ultimately, because Shadow of the Colossus is bloody brilliant, of course.


1. Sonic the Hedgehog

Sonic the Hedgehog Green Hill Zone
Sega

And finally an oldie but a goodie now, with Sonic the Hedgehog and a stat that truly defies comprehension.

Since the original 1991 game was re-released for the Xbox 360 and PS3 we've had access to trophy data, which even accepting the game's unforgiving old-school difficulty relative to contemporary platformers, has shockingly few players even getting past the opening Zone.

Green Hill Zone is one of the most iconic stages in video game history, but to date 55.9% of players haven't even cleared it. And if you assumed the sample size was small, think again - PSN Profiles took this data from more than 100,000 owners of the game.

Puzzlingly, Green Hill Zone doesn't offer much of a challenge at all compared to the stages that follow it, and can be breezed through in a mere matter of minutes. 

The perhaps more logical explanation, then, is that nostalgia-tinged players bought the game to mess around with for a few minutes, but actually never got around to playing through the rest of the game. 

It certainly makes more sense than thousands upon thousands of players struggling to get through Green Hill Zone.


Watch Next


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.