10 Incredible Video Games That Should've NEVER Worked

They shouldn't be this great but by jove, they are.

Snowrunner Game
Saber Interactive

It must be hard for a developer nowadays, either established or aspiring.

Gone are the days of wild experimentation being bankrolled. Now publishers are more wary about dishing out that big money to take a gamble on something.

Thankfully, as these examples show, those that did take the plunge have had that investment returned. Maybe not monetarily at first, but the praise and interest has propelled these wildcards into critical acclaim.

Games about long haul driving, or even rural community farming, don't sound great on paper. The mention of Rabbids is enough to kill a conversation. The words "walking simulator" are enough cause mild hysteria in some.

We're too stubborn, too set in our way to embrace change. It's too easy to fall into the embrace of the familiar, so that when something comes along that changes our normal we treat it with caution and trepidation.

So think of me as the mediator, the tour guide in this proverbial ride towards the outwardly weird but actually incredible games. Consider me the nerdier version of Willy Wonka as we look at ten examples of games that shouldn't work, yet are actually incredible.

Don't expect any musical numbers or singing though.

10. Mario + Rabbids: Kingdom Battle

Mario + Rabbids kingdom battle
Ubisoft

It would be a fair assessment to say that Ubisoft's Rabbids are an absolute blight on the gaming world. About as novel as Minions, these bunny-things should have disappeared as quickly as they came.

That being said, Nintendo took a gamble with Mario + Rabbids: Kingdom Battle, and it paid off.

Playing like a more kid-friendly, less-alien invasion-y version of XCOM, Nintendo and Ubisoft have done with the Rabbids what should have happened originally: made them supporting characters.

As the stars of the show, they grate. Yet putting them second fiddle to Mario and pals makes them... well I want to say "more endearing" and be polite about it.

As a game, it plays like most other grid-and-turn based tactical adventures. As an entry in the vast canon of Nintendo's favourite plumber, it also holds its own as a franchise "spin off".

For fans of XCOM, it's a lighthearted and less difficult take on the genre. For newcomers, it's a welcome introduction to a new style of game.

For Rabbids fans, as there must be some, presumably they're just happy to see the little sh*ts get more airtime.


9. Lonely Mountains: Downhill

Lonely Mountains
Thunderful Games

In a world of (mostly) 2D racers like Trials, Pumped BMX and Urban Trial Tricky, Lonely Mountains: Downhill might seem out of place.

It doesn't have loud, bright, in-your-face graphics.

It doesn't have a physics-defying trick system that sees you triple backflipping over canyons.

It doesn't have a soundtrack full of nu-metal bangers to spur you on.

What it does have, though, is that easy to pick up/hard to master attitude that some others lack.

You can play LM: D as serenely as you like, taking in the ambiance as you let gravity do its thing. Or, you can strive to be the very best in the world and beat every course in the fastest time feasible.

In a weird juxtaposition, it looks minimal but has so much to take in. Every course has multiple paths, every corner, bend and hairpin has some way of shortcut to shave off precious seconds.

Featuring that quick-fire Trials attitude of "Quick, do that again!" frustration, the reward in hitting times and targets is a thing of beauty when you get the hang of it.


8. Stardew Valley

stardew valley
Chucklefish Games

At the risk of sounding elitist or holier-than-thou, farmers are an integral part of our way of life and we salute them.

However, I don't want to get up at the crack of dawn and interact with farmyard animals.

So when Stardew Valley allows the proverbial you to trade your big city lifestyle for one of good ol' fashioned farming without the mess, count us in.

Wearing its inspiration from Harvest Moon on its rolled up sleeves, Stardew does one better than its predecessor by letting some friends become farmhands too.

Bringing that real "spirit of the community" feeling together with up to three friends, the real sense of accomplishment (despite being an open-ended game) can really be felt in this title.

It could easily be written off as a niche indie title, yet as of this year Stardew Valley has gone on to sell a staggering ten million units.

Admittedly you can't really compare it real world farming. But for a fun little simulation of it, you can't go far wrong with Stardew Valley.

But what about those that want the realistic experience...?


7. Farming Simulator

Farming Simulator 20 Switch
Focus Home Interactive

The yin to Stardew Valley's yang, Farming Simulator is to farming what Flight Simulator is to avionics. That is to say, it is as close to it without the faff as you can get.

A series running for close to twelve years now, Farming Simulator (as a franchise) has gone on to sell a combined total of 25 million copies.

And you're probably thinking, "...why and/or how?"

Consensus says that it's the sense of calm that you wouldn't get in something like, oh I don't know, Call of Duty. The only bombs being dropped on you are the cost of new equipment.

There's something so calming yet intrinsically rewarding about reaping what you sow, bringing in that business and pootling about in a combine harvester too.

It's certainly not going to be everyone's cup of tea, and we're not telling you to play them. But, should your wont take you, you'll find something so serene about managing your own realistic attempt at a farmer's life.

You know you're getting invested when you're actually looking forward to buying a new tractor.


6. Oxenfree

Oxenfree game
Night School Studio

Many were "over" the whole walking simulator genre before this, and like them, I wasn't convinced that this would bring anything new to the formula, 2D or otherwise.

And then many people played it.

Now many people, including myself, won't shut up about it.

To tell you what happens would ruin the experience for you, but safe to say that it subverted the entire genre entirely. So much that it opened the doors to play more games in this vein, like the phenomenal What Remains of Edith Finch.

Oxenfree isn't just a walking simulator, nor is it just a coming-of-age tale about some friends on an island. There's a plot that curiously baits you in, not to mention an unusual take on established sci-fi tropes and rules.

As I say, it's hard to recommend this without spoiling it. But it's the same as any decent movie you see: you want to give the bare minimum away, the bait, so when people do watch it you can both go, "I know!" about it.

Trust me, get some Oxenfree in your life.


5. Huntdown

Huntdown Game
Easy Trigger Games

When it comes to paying tribute or homage, games tend to go one of two ways. They are either subtle little nods to what came before, or they cram every throwback and reference possible just to constantly remind you.

Huntdown, however, gets it just right.

It doesn't bring anything remarkably new in gameplay, but like the old adage goes, "If it ain't broke, don't fix it".

Playing like an early 90's side-scroller yet chock full of tasteful homages, tight controls and nostalgic soundtrack, Huntdown should be on anyone's list.

The "it shouldn't work" of this entry is that it shouldn't be as incredible as it is. Retro-inspired games come and go, yet Huntdown doesn't want its five minutes of fame.

It wants you to take in the love letter to the craft that it is, whilst sticking out this challenging tribute in its massive glory.

It does for run and gun that Hotline Miami did for top-down puzzlers: adding that retro yet tasteful hyper-violence to a formula that needed shaking up.

Come for the addictive gameplay, stay for the Akira, Blade Runner and Terminator (to name a few) movie posters


4. Death Stranding

Death Stranding
Sony

Right, before you start screaming at me in the comments, I understand the ire about the ending. The "Princess Beach" bit had my eyes rolling so fast I temporarily went blind.

But that aside, there's no denying the craft that went into Death Stranding, resulting in such a unique and entrancing game.

Outside of the story, the world of broken America is a joy to just... be part of.

It strikes that perfect balance of beautiful hiking simulator interspersed with some faux-horror elements with its BT fight sections. If you go in expecting something based on Kojima's lineage, you'll set yourself up for a fall.

Instead, if you go in with a calmer and open-minded approach to it, you'll likely be pleasantly surprised.

Now I know people will either be scoffing or contemplating agreeing with me as they read it. Again, this isn't a "you must play these games" list.

Instead, this is just pointing out what makes this game incredible (even if the story gets a bit wonky at times). Traversing a beautiful and sparse landscape to some Low Roar in the background is pure bliss.


3. Thomas Was Alone

Thomas Was Alone
Bossa Studios

The pitch meeting for this one must have been a daunting one for Mike Bithell. Imagine trying to pitch a platform game with a geometric, four-sided shape as a protagonist.

Better yet, the whole cavalcade of player characters are all square/rectangular shapes. It must have felt like a hell of a gamble.

But then you play it, and you see the genius behind it. You are no ordinary cube. You are part of an AI programme, one that's experiencing self-awareness and some kind of existential crisis.

It's like if Tron had been written by Jean-Paul Satre.

On the surface it's just another platformer with some character swapping puzzle elements to it. And that's not a bad thing, really.

Yet what makes it more than that is the level of attention in the world and narration. Danny Wallace laying out Thomas and crew's progression is great to see, as is the fluidity and variation if you deviate from time to time.

Much like The Stanley Parable, the effort gone in to monitor the player's progression is staggering attention to detail. One that everyone should invest in when they play it.


2. SnowRunner

Snowrunner game
Mad Dog

Whilst it may not be the first in its series of haulage games, SnowRunner is certainly the best. Taking the Spintires and MudRunner template and expanding on it, as well as adding colour, SnowRunner deserves every bit of praise it gets.

Much like Farming Simulator, there's a massive sense of achievement to be found in completing any of SnowRunner's many tasks. On paper, these sound absolutely mundane.

Take some fuel to a truck stuck in a bog? Move a drilling rig across a portion of the map?

See, even typing them sounds boring.

But when you actually play SnowRunner, you'll get it. You'll feel that real sense of accomplishment as you lug all shapes and types of haulage and goods across treacherous terrain.

And like a new tractor, saving up for an absolute beast of a truck to make life easier is a joy to behold. Seeing your operation expand into moving massive haul, rescuing stuck trucks and essentially rebuilding commerce and communities is a thing to behold.

Teaming up with mates is even better. Getting a convoy going is sheer, unmatched joy.


1. Papers, Please

Papers Please
Lucas Pope

If I came into the office (or other hypothetical workplace) and told you to play a game that lets you be an immigration officer, you'd think I was mad.

Admittedly, I'd probably do the same, were it the other way around.

On paper, this sounds like an awful concept.

Sitting in a booth all day, stamping entry papers and turning away anyone that looks funny, or looks at you funny? Woo...

But sometimes it's nice to be proven wrong. Lucas Pope struck proverbial gold with this one (and then oil with his second effort, The Return of the Obra Dinn).

It's amazing how much detail has gone into Papers, Please as you tussle with your conscience more than one should in a game that looks so basic.

It starts of easily enough, but then the weight of your choices starts to get heavy as time progresses. Is this person genuine, are they trying to blag asylum... or are they going to bomb the embassy?

The choices that you make are staggering for a game that has a smaller colour palette than the Soviet Union.


Watch Next


In this post: 
SnowRunner
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Player of games, watcher of films. Has a bad habit of buying remastered titles. Reviews games and delivers sub-par content in his spare time. Found at @GregatonBomb on Twitter/Instagram.