10 Incredibly Moving Scenes In Video Games Ruined By Player Input

These games actually had the nerve to ask us to "play them." Pfft.

I love cut scenes in video games, and many people do. Sometimes I just want to sit back and enjoy the talents on display from the designers, writers and voice actors. The technological advancements made in video game development over the last 15 years or so have allowed it to become a medium which is arguably an art form. People may disagree with this, but I have played video games recently with more engaging stories, better acting, punchier writing and nicer visual aesthetics than many films and TV shows I have seen. This is why it infuriates me when I'm really immersed in my gaming experience, watching everything come together in a gorgeous cinematic moment of emotion and beauty, and then - suddenly - I'm forced to do something in order for it to progress. Nothing breaks immersion quite like a giant control prompt being shoved in your face when you're just trying to soak up some atmosphere. So, without further ado, here is my list of 10 Incredibly Moving Scenes In Video Games Ruined By Player Input (massive spoilers ahead, you have been warned)...

10. Tomb Raider (2013) - All Good Things Must Come To An End

This year's Tomb Raider reboot was one of the best games I've played in a long while. Lara's reinvention as a more down-to-earth, realistic and less-sexualised character made her relevant in the modern-day gaming world. After ploughing through the single-player, being totally engrossed in the emotionally-charged story, I was ready for the final act. I was let down immensely. The ending of the game consisted of quick-time events and button-prompt based boss battles. It doesn't hold the game back at all but Lara developed emotionally so much in this game that this scene could have been so much more. Watching her struggle finally culminate had all emotional investment dashed by a boss battle that's a real slog to get through and a bad guy that requires rapidly tapping the triggers to dispose of. Thankfully, this ending does introduce the duel pistols Lara that we all know and love but it should have been a lot better in the feelings department.

9. Borderlands 2: Tiny Tina's Assault On Dragon Keep - Feed Butt Stallion

I appreciate this is simply a fictitious world that your character is in, but Roland WAS real and he DID die and Tiny Tina's denial of it was building to this. Tiny Tina's storytelling abilities are so damn awesome (mostly due to her being an excellently voiced and well-developed character), that watching her break-down and nearly cry because she must accept Roland's death is heart-wrenching (unless you're a sociopath). We all knew he was dead but we still wanted to see what would happen next, the big ending to seeing our favourite soldier survive was shaping up to be brilliant. That is until the Butt Stallion punchline. You have to spend the last playable segment of the game picking up Eridium to feed Butt Stallion, talk about an investment-breaker. I understand that these games pride themselves on their humour and I also understand that Butt Stallion is a clever reference to the villain in the main game, Handsome Jack. However making this be the last thing you get to do with your character after such a grind may have been a misfire. Some of you may have liked it, that's fair enough, but it just seems so cheap to me.

8. Fallout 3 - Tedious Escape

Taken and Fallout 3 established that Liam Neeson is pretty much the coolest dad ever, disagree? You're wrong. So, after going through one of the most difficult games ever made to find your dad and then seeing him sacrifice himself is one of hell of a heart ripper-outer. That is until you have to escape. Yeah, an escape was necessary, I appreciate that, but did it have to involve escorting NPCs as well? We all hate escort quests, BioShock Infinite's the only game that did it well. As if escorting some NPCs wasn't bad enough, one of them won't shut up, bonus. The temptation to pull out a Fat Man and nuke these guys is overwhelming.

7. Assassin's Creed II - Your Family Were Killed? Too Bad

I swear this whole "bereavement escaping" thing has become a trend in video games. Ezio's family friend has betrayed his family and had them hanged, what a prat. This tragic cut scene was tremendously well-done and a real highlight of the game's themes of secret societies and back-stabbing. Oh dear, we have to escape the guards. How about rather than force me to go free-running after watching my family essentially be murdered, you give me time to mourn my digital kin? They weren't real people but a video game protagonist is an extension of the player so their family is your family by association. Plus, there's a chance you can die and have to do it again, stupid Ubisoft.

6. Gears Of War 2 - It's Crunch Time, Carmine

Hey, Carmine was essentially useless as a fighter but the kid had heart and you owed it to his brother to protect him. After quite literally diving into the belly of the beast you'll find him being devoured by monsters, nasty. I'm always a sucker for inexperienced innocents who are out of their depth dying, I don't know why but it's a good way to make me weep. What a shame then that rather than getting to mourn over Carmine, we just push on and kick some more arse, it's what he would have wanted, right? Well, I imagine what he would have wanted was to have not been killed but I'm sure he'd appreciate his comrades actually giving a damn rather than continuing to be badasses, have a heart, Marcus, you emotionless shell.

5. Call Of Duty 4: Modern Warfare - Killing Zakhaev

Widely regarded as one of the best Call of Duty games, the first Modern Warfare's story is gripping and fraught with despair. After a long haul through the action-packed campaign, you and your team find yourself fighting off the enemy on a collapsing bridge. Outmanned and outgunned, you make your final stand against your attackers in one last hurrah. Knocked unconscious by an explosion, protagonist Soap MacTavish is forced to watch on helplessly once he comes to as his fellow soldiers are executed by primary antagonist Imran Zakhaev and his cronies. Out of nowhere, Russian loyalists attack Zakhaev's convoy, buying you enough time to be slid a pistol by your superior, Captain Price, who doesn't have a decent shot. You lift the pistol, take aim at your target and...it's a nightmare. What I'm sure was intended to be a straight forward "gun em down" becomes an exercise of trial and error. I found myself constantly dying because I wasn't able to kill everyone in time, I went from engagement to frustration as I kept trying to shoot Zakhaev and his bodyguards before they shot me. I experimented with various orders, from left-to-right, right-to-left, kill Zakhaev first, kill his men first. It should have been much more forgiving, instead the punch this scene was supposed to pack is diminished by restarts and anger as you fire your gun like a mad man and look like an idiot.

4. Far Cry 3 - Knife Fight With Hoyt

You know, poor old protagonist Jason's been through a lot to get to this point. In the lead up to this final showdown, you have been undercover in Hoyt's trafficking industry along with your new ally, Sam. So, when Hoyt reveals he knows who you are after stabbing Sam in the throat right in front of you during a game of poker, you are forced to play on and if you lose a hand (of poker, of course), then you lose a finger. After witnessing such graphic content it's time for the final boss battle, boy oh boy this should be good, such an epic game needs an epic finale, all of the emotions are running high here and it's so tense! Oh dear, it's a quick-time event knife fight. As if that wasn't bad enough, you've already had to go through this twice previously in the story, so it isn't even anything new. Instead of a final battle of passion and primal instincts we have to focus on what the next button we press is, and if you hit the wrong button then you die and have to go again. QTEs are a real pet-peeve of mine and really this entire list could be made up of them (but I'm not that lazy). The final boss battle should NEVER be a chore and I had much higher expectations from this game, such a waste of a scene with so much promising build.

3. Fable II - I'm Sorry, Did You Want To Kill Him?

Okay, Fable II isn't exactly highly acclaimed in the gripping story department, but this scene is an exception. Your dog was just shot (animal death is a way to make anyone cry, don't deny it) and you went through a psychedelic dream world to claim the ultimate weapon to stop Lord Lucien (which really is never explained but whatever, it's a fantasy game). Now you are able to stop your arch-nemesis, the man who killed your sister, your canine companion and has twice attempted to send you to an early grave. Yeah, about that. This scene had a solid build and could have been done much better, the player just kind of stands there as Lucien rambles and you can just shoot him when you get bored. If you leave it too long though, Reaver, the dastardly pirate voiced by the ever-eloquent Stephen Fry will do it for you. So if you actually want to hear what Lucien has to say, you can't. Why did this need to be interactive? This could have been a cut scene in which Lucien explains his motives and creates a highly memorable scene, sure, this scene is memorable, but primarily because it was one of the poorest excuses for a "boss" battle ever created. The game finally decided to start gripping the player in its final act and then threw it out of the window with a really poorly-worked end scene. There isn't even that much satisfaction in shooting him because the guns in this game are all pea-shooters.

2. Grand Theft Auto IV - Take Your Revenge

In my opinion, GTA IV tells the best story of all the GTA games. I also believe that this scene is the most powerful in the franchise's history and in fact, giving the player the ability to carry out the execution adds a more personal touch to it. So why is it on this list? It's on this list because of the freedom afforded to the player - it could just be as simple as shoot him or walk away, but instead you're allowed to mess about in what is supposed to be the emotional pinnacle of the game (well, depending on whether you choose to go through with the heroin deal or not later on, but let's not get into that). You can run around and act like and idiot and it just shatters the power of this scene. I didn't choose to go that way about it but the option is there and I'm willing to wager a fair few people took advantage of this. The biggest cardinal sin though is that if you choose to spare Darko's life, you can kill him as he runs away, and you can do it however you want. This includes, but isn't limited to: Running him over, blowing him up, punching him to death, stabbing him to death or shooting him in the unmentionables. Whilst GTA is a franchise that is all about player freedom, I can't help but feel like in this case, it could have just been a little bit more linear for the sake of the storytelling and not potentially turning this masterclass of writing, direction and voice acting into something comic.

1. Red Dead Redemption - Going Back For John

Red Dead Redemption is my favourite video game of all-time, and John Marston's death is my favourite video game death of all-time. I can't really remember whether I cried or not when John absorbed that hail of bullets from the men who betrayed him, but I honestly wouldn't be surprised if I did. It's a masterclass of Rockstar's ability to shock and throw curve balls at us. Unfortunately I feel like this scene is somewhat tainted. I'm not taking anything away from John's death, that was perfectly executed, it's the part just after where you take control of his son, Jack, and have to ride your horse back to the ranch that bothers me. Couldn't they have just arrived in the cut scene? I had literally just watched my character be murdered right before my very eyes, I'd put a lot of hours into Red Dead and I'd spent a lot of time with this character. When you kill that character, I need time to reflect on it, not to be thrown straight into a horse-riding mini-sequence between two excellent cut scenes. This doesn't in any way fault the game for me and it's still superb in every way in my eyes but having to ride back to the spot where my character had died just didn't sit too well with me. Well, there you have it. This list was ordered based around my own personal emotional investment and enjoyment of the games. The games that I really liked are more likely to be higher on this list so don't feel like I'm in any way diminishing the other games. What scenes would you include in your own list? Leave a comment and follow me on Twitter @TBroomey if you want to talk to me about video games and why they're so awesome.

Contributor
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling fan and film buff who consumes far too much caffeine. Currently working on a comic book and learning how to cook the perfect fried egg. Both of which are an ongoing process.