10 Insane Ways Video Games Were Kept Under Wraps

These games went to extreme lengths to conceal the truth.

The Last of Us Part 2
Naughty Dog

No entertainment industry is more secretive than video games - while movies and TV shows are often shot on location where it's virtually impossible to prevent the general public snapping photos, games are more often than not made in secure, air-conditioned offices which aren't accessible to the average person.

And while it might seem like game developers therefore have a far easier time of keeping their projects under wraps, your average AAA game is worked on by hundreds if not thousands of artists, programmers, and marketing people before we even end up seeing a single shot of it.

As such, it's little surprise that gaming industry leaks are so commonplace, and to combat this developers are often forced to take drastic measures to protect their investment.

These 10 video games all went above-the-odds to preserve their biggest surprises, from fielding out misinformation to hungry fans, releasing extremely manipulative trailers, keeping only the most necessary personnel in the loop, and in one case even hiding the game's development from the parent company itself.

While many will argue that the gaming industry's excessive cloak-and-dagger approach actually isn't good for developers or customers, for these games it was at least effective in ensuring players' expectations were thoroughly subverted...

10. Its Codename Was "Rock Band: Nickelback" - Rock Band Network

The Beatles Rock Band
Harmonix

The Rock Band Network (RBN) was a DLC service for the Rock Band series launched in 2009, just before The Beatles: Rock Band hit stores.

Pre-release, developers Harmonix kept the RBN a top-secret project, knowing full well that it had majorly lucrative potential - by allowing music rights-holders to add their own songs to the game - if it was rolled out correctly.

To keep unwanted attention away from RBN during its developmental phase, it was reportedly referred to as "Rock Band: Nickelback" internally. The reason for Nickelback? The New York Times explains:

"The Rock Band Network is so potentially consequential that Harmonix went to great lengths to keep its development secret, including giving it the unofficial in-house code name Rock Band: Nickelback, on the theory that the name of the quintessentially generic modern rock group would be enough to deflect all curiosity."

That's some next-level genius right there, and considering the general disdain rock fans have for Nickelback, it worked perfectly.


9. Raiden Wasn't In Trailers & Reviews Were Strictly Embargoed - Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons Of Liberty

Metal Gear Solid 2 Sons Of Liberty Raiden
Konami

Hideo Kojima pulled off the bait-and-switch to end all bait-and-switches with Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty.

The highly anticipated sequel was aggressively marketed pre-release, with extensive trailers showing off Solid Snake battling soldiers on a tanker alongside the game's large array of colourful cast members.

Konami even packaged a demo of the game with Zone of the Enders, only further intended to conceal its surprise twist, that you only play as Snake for the first hour-or-so of MGS2.

After this, the perspective switches to new protagonist Raiden for the remainder of the game, which takes place in an entirely different location - the decontamination facility known as the Big Shell.

Though today it's practically impossible to imagine such a tectonic spoiler not leaking out ahead of time, MGS2 was locked down airtight pre-release, with Konami giving reviewers strict embargoes which prevented them from even hinting at the protagonist swap.

MGS2 of course had a number of things on its side - global Internet adoption wasn't nearly as widespread in the late '90s/early '00s when the game was in development, nor did everyone have a mobile phone in their pocket making it easy to anonymously capture spicy gameplay footage.


8. The Lead Writer Didn't Even Discuss The Game With His Family - Assassin's Creed III

assassin's creed iii 3 haytham kenway
Ubisoft

Plot leaks often occur when one in-the-know party casually reveals something to a friend or acquaintance who then decides to put the information online.

Though these "leaks" are easy to fake and therefore often dissected, debated, and debunked, there are many text-dump leaks which have turned out to be 100% accurate, as must be a major source of frustration for developers.

A few hours into Assassin's Creed III, apparent protagonist Haytham is swapped out for Connor, a hugely unexpected twist which Ubisoft and the game's key creative personnel went to concerted lengths to prevent leaking out.

The game's lead scriptwriter Corey May told Ars Technica that beyond co-ordinating with the marketing department to ensure promotional materials didn't inadvertently give anything away, he didn't even discuss the game with his family or friends, no matter how private the circumstances.

Considering the notoriously leak-prone nature of the franchise, it's an understandable stance to take, though given the years it takes to bring a game from concept to release, it must've been incredibly tough not to talk to anyone outside the development bubble about it.

May complimented the dev team on their commitment to not leaking the surprise, and noted that many team members themselves wanted to remain unspoiled until they played the final release, skipping over any portions of the game they weren't themselves actively working on.


7. A Fake Legend Was Created To Trick Dataminers - Apex Legends

Apex Legends Forge
Respawn Entertainment

One of the most reliable ways for games to get leaked is for players to datamine demos for references to story and gameplay, or in the case of a live-service game, datamine the existing game code for hints at future content drops.

But given the prevalence of datamining-related leaks in recent years, developers Respawn Entertainment got one step ahead of fans with Apex Legends, by deliberately including fake information in the game data.

Early last year, dataminers noted the existence of an apparently new character in the game code called Forge, but both the character information and concept art included in a game update was deliberately planted there as a misdirect by Respawn. Design director Jason McCord said:

"Honestly, it started as a fun way to misdirect data miners who, at the time, felt like they had solved our next legend and had ruined our surprise...We actually purposefully leaked fake concept art and details of Forge's kit in patches, so there would be a breadcrumb trail by the time we announced him. It's pretty insane, really. I can't think of any other game that has gone through such hijinks."

But Respawn weren't satisfied yet. They completed their trolling of dataminers in mesmerising fashion by releasing an apparent introductory video for Forge, which promptly ended with him being stabbed to death by Revenant, the real new legend introduced to the game.

Above all else, it taught everyone a lesson, not to believe everything they see. And like that, Apex's secrecy was safeguarded once more.


6. Keanu Reeves Was Disguised With Stand-Ins & Codenames - Cyberpunk 2077

Cyberpunk 2077 Keanu Reeves
CD Projekt RED

Back at E3 2019, CD Projekt RED made the shock announcement that Keanu Reeves would be appearing in Cyberpunk 2077 as the game's co-protagonist Johnny Silverhand.

It was a reveal so shocking that fans immediately began discussing how the company had possibly been able to keep such high-profile casting under wraps and away from leakers.

As it turned out, Reeves' involvement was on a strictly need-to-know basis, and even the creator of the original Cyberpunk tabletop RPG, Mike Pondsmith, was only clued into Reeves being hired a few short months before the E3 reveal took place.

Yet the real threat wasn't so much the game's own dev team but the notoriously leaky E3 weekend itself, which has often seen huge reveals leak out from rehearsals taking place mere days prior.

To combat this, Xbox boss Phil Spencer explained that Reeves was referred to by a codename among the show's crew, and a stand-in was used for him during rehearsals.

Reeves was only present at the Microsoft Theater from the morning of the show, never went out on stage prior to the live broadcast, and spent most of his time at the theater hidden in a green room backstage.

The secrecy was certainly worth it. The game itself, though? That depends on who you ask.


5. Keiji Inafune Developed Them Behind Capcom's Back - Dead Rising & Lost Planet

dead rising
Capcom

Unlike almost every other game on this list, Dead Rising and Lost Planet weren't developed in total secrecy to prevent leaks hitting the presses - but to conceal their development from publisher Capcom themselves.

In a 2011 interview, the creator of both franchises, Keiji Inafune, confessed that he was forced to take extreme measures to ensure his vision for the games was actually brought to market.

Inafune and his team had made prototypes for both games which were eventually cancelled by Capcom, who wanted to focus instead on developing sequels to existing IP.

But a frustrated Inafune wasn't one to be deterred, deciding instead to keep working secretly on both games.

And so, when he went back to Capcom bigwigs with a polished vertical slice of each title, on which he had spent considerable time and money, they didn't have much of a choice but to oblige him.

This was of course massively risky on Inafune's part, and by his own admission he was willing to be fired for his actions, but felt a deep desire to resist Capcom's sequel mandate.

It evidently paid off, as both Dead Rising and Lost Planet quickly became lucrative franchises.


4. Phil Spencer Rehearsed With A Fake Script - Xbox Series X

Xbox Series X Phil Spencer
Microsoft

The Xbox Series X received a shocking, totally unexpected announcement at the end of the Game Awards 2019, which stunned even industry analysts who had heard barely a peep about the console's unveiling.

Nothing in the way of rumours, prototype schematics or much of anything else had made their way online, and it was later confirmed that beyond the necessary personnel - namely producer-host Geoff Keighley - most of the production crew were kept in the dark.

Phil Spencer admitted that he actually read a "phoney" script about Xbox Game Pass during rehearsals, to ensure that any inquisitive ears hanging out while the show was being rehearsed didn't spoil the surprise early.

The subterfuge led to surely the most surprising, out-of-nowhere console reveal in modern times, so it was nothing if not a big win for the Microsoft camp.


3. QA Testers Were Put In Windowless Rooms - Mortal Kombat & Injustice

Mortal Kombat X Raiden
NetherRealm

The widening dialogue about "crunch culture" in games development in recent years has shone a light on the conditions under which games are created and polished.

There have been countless exposes about unreasonable, even illegal practises inflicted upon artists, programmers, and QA testers working on major AAA games, and in 2019 one such piece took aim at NetherRealm Studios, the team behind the Mortal Kombat and Injustice games.

The report from USgamer, released just days after Mortal Kombat 11 hit stores, included allegations from employees who worked on Mortal Kombat 9, X, and Injustice 2, that they were wildly overworked and underpaid.

One of the more curious claims refers to the QA department specifically, who per the delicate nature of their job - to comb through every aspect of the game - were put in a windowless room, a "box-like, renovated garage" to perform their duties.

Though it's common for AAA games to be developed within a contained environment to curb the potential for leaks, would it really have killed NetherRealm to put their testers in a room with one-way glass, so they could see outside but nobody could see in? Jeez.


2. Digitally Altering Character Models In The Trailers - The Last Of Us Part II

The Last Of Us Part 2 Ellie
Naughty Dog

The Marvel Cinematic Universe has gone to truly absurd lengths to prevent audiences from being spoiled, even cooking up fake footage for their trailers and using CGI to digitally edit spoilerific imagery.

Naughty Dog took a page out of Marvel Studios' book, then, during the marketing campaign for The Last of Us Part II, in order to keep fans from guessing the game's big twist, that co-protagonist Joel is killed about two hours into the 25-hour epic.

The game's 2019 release date reveal trailer showed a clip where Ellie is grabbed from behind by an unseen figure, who is then revealed to be Joel. But in the final version of the game, Ellie is actually grabbed by Jesse.

Additionally, other trailers were edited to imply that Ellie's girlfriend Dina would be killed rather than Joel, and Joel and Ellie's ages were digitally altered to prevent fans from figuring out which scenes were flashbacks and which were present day.

It was certainly effective in throwing fans off the scent that Joel would be absent from 90% of the game, though many were understandably left feeling misled, that they were "falsely advertised" a Joel-centric sequel that wasn't to be.

Whether you felt bamboozled or not, the immense effort Naughty Dog put into the deception was frustratingly upended by major plot spoilers leaked a few months prior to release, confirming to anyone who dared look that Joel would meet a grisly end early in the game.


1. It Was Developed Under The Working Title "Project Ogre" - Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Project Ogre
Konami

In November 2011, Hideo Kojima announced a new video game project by the codename of "Project Ogre," while tweeting out a work-in-progress gameplay screenshot from the title, and confirming the game would be a 100-hour open-world title.

Though Kojima is of course synonymous with the Metal Gear Solid franchise and the screenshot didn't look entirely dissimilar to the series, the game's open-world design and non-cinematic style sounded just different enough to convince many fans it was indeed an entirely new IP.

Kojima continued to drop cryptic hints about the game being centered on metaphorical "ogres," and declared it was quite a different venture compared to the Metal Gear Solid series.

He later insisted that it was unrelated to his Metal Gear Solid project Ground Zeroes, leaving fans to ponder for a time what the hell he was cooking up.

Roughly a year after the initial Project Ogre image was posted, Kojima dropped a trailer for the fruit of his labour - an apparently new IP called The Phantom Pain, which in a new trailer released a few months later was finally confirmed to indeed be Metal Gear Solid V.

The lesson here? Don't trust Hideo Kojima as far as you can throw him.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.