10 Mind-Blowing Theories About Batman: Arkham Knight's Identity

There's only one Knight around here, and he's the Dark Knight!

We're still six agonizing months away from the release of arguably the most anticipated superhero video game of all time, Batman: Arkham Knight. The third and final chapter of Rocksteady's trilogy of amazing Batman games, this promises to be the best of all time. Debuting on next gen consoles, we already know we will have an expanded Gotham universe 5 times the size of Arkham City, a return of several of Batmans most famous foes, and the long awaited debut of the legendary Batmobile. However the most hype has gone into the games titular villain, the Arkham Knight. An original character designed exclusively for the game, fans have been speculating for months about the mysterious figures identity. So far we know that he (if the Arkham Knight is indeed a he) appears to be an upgraded, weaponized version of Batman with allegiances to the infamous Asylum that inspired the series. He also seems to have some kind of vendetta against Batman, but of course it would be easier to count all the people in Gotham who don't hold a grudge against the Caped Crusader. Rocksteady has obviously remained tight lipped about it, so fans have naturally cooked up their own theories on who could be hiding under that mask, theories which range from logical to bat***t crazy (no pun intended - unless it was funny). Here are ten of our favorites.

Honorary Mention - Someone Original

The Arkham Knight is already an original creation, so is it really that much of a stretch to consider that the person inside the suit is also an exclusive character that only exists in the game? Fans have been so determined to figure out who the Arkham Knight is that they've paged through comics, rewatched their favorite batman movies and cartoons and replayed all the previous games searching for clues on who could possibly fit the characters MO. What if the character turns out to be someone entirely unheard of? It would be disappointing for sure, as much of the hype behind the game, as if it needed any more, has revolved around the identity of the Arkham Knight and fans are hoping for some kind of epic reveal. It would be uncharacteristic of Rocksteady to disappoint their fans, but even so, we must at least recognize the possibility that this guy could be someone we've never heard of. Some have even speculated that there is no one under the mask and that the Arkham Knight is actually a robot. Not a terrible idea we suppose, but still anticlimactic. If all that sounds a little disheartening, please read ahead for ten potential Arkham Knights who most definitely exist!

10. The Joker

Lets get this out of the way immediately because it's the one theory absolutely NOBODY wants to be true. All three previous games have featured the Joker as the primary antagonist and honestly, why wouldn't they have? The Joker is the most popular and iconic Batman villain of all time and arguably one of the most beloved fictional villains full stop. But after three games it's fair to say he's had his chance. That and the fact that the end of Arkham City (SPOILER ALERT!) makes this theory impossible. Rocksteady would have some nerve if they undid the stunning ending of the previous game. Bringing the Joker back after leading us to believe he died, would reek of desperation and laziness unbecoming of a company with their reputation. No, we're positive Joker is not the Arkham Knight. And there's plenty of evidence! Despite the obvious handicap of being dead, the Joker doesn't actually fit the Arkham Knights description at all. He is tall and wiry, with little experience in hand to hand combat. The Knight, as seen in the trailer, is clearly muscular with weapons training, and can take down Batman single-handedly. As the literal opposite of Batman, the Joker does not hide behind a mask. Where Batman wears black and hides in the shadows, Joker wears bright colors, and demands an audience. If he were the Knight he would make it public. It's entirely feasible the Joker would hire the Arkham Knight to take out Batman, but he is definitely not the Knight himself. Lastly the game is set only one year after the end of Arkham City, so unless the Arkham Knight is a time traveler, we can safely assume he is not the Joker's son!

9. Hush

Hush is heavily tipped as a fan favorite candidate to be revealed as the Arkham Knight. We know that he exists in the Arkham universe (hereby shortened to the Arkhamverse) due to the Identity Theft side mission in Arkham City. There we see the former Dr Thomas Elliot removing people's faces under the guise of Bruce Wayne. How? Because he performed plastic surgery on himself so that he literally looked like the billionaire playboy. When Batman confronts him, Hush warns us that he is coming to make Bruce Wayne's life a living hell. In a nutshell, "Tommy" is a former childhood friend of Bruce Wayne with similarly wealthy parents. Except he hated his parents and cut their breaks in order to inherit their fortune. His father was killed, but his mother was saved by the skilled hands of Dr Thomas Wayne. Since then he has made it his mission to destroy the Wayne family. Though Hush certainly has it out for Bruce Wayne, the Arkhamverse version is apparently unaware that Bruce is Batman. In the game he tells Batman to stay out of his way, but seems to have no quarrel with the Dark Knight. This makes it less likely that Hush is the Arkham Knight, who seems intent on destroying the Bat. Also it is doubtful that he would waste his time hiding behind the Knights armor when he already spent months preparing his Bruce Wayne disguise. Make no mistake, Hush is a dead cert to appear in the game, but probably not as it's main antagonist.

8. Jason Todd

Jason Todd Like Hush, Jason Todd is considered the odds on favorite to be revealed as the Arkham Knight. In fact it's so obvious that Todd is practically guaranteed NOT to be the Knight. The second Robin was infamously beaten to death by the Joker in the Death in the Family story (he was such an unpopular replacement for Dick Greyson that fans actually voted for his death). However he was resurrected by Ra's al Ghul and he took on the mantle of the Red Hood, ironically the alias previously used by the Joker. Red Hood has since become DC's answer to the Punisher, an anti hero who targets villains but uses lethal force. Though Todd hasn't appeared in any Arkham games so far, fans will have obviously noticed that Dick Greyson was using his Nightwing alias in the DLC pack and the version of Robin we got was Tim Drake (the third Robin). There couldn't be a Tim Drake if Jason Todd hadn't already come and gone. Throw in the fact that Ra's al Ghul and the Lazarus Pits already exist in the Arkhamverse and we have the possibility of a revitalized and revenge-motivated Red Hood, literally gunning for our cowled hero. Further speculation arose earlier this year when a Red Hood DLC pack was announced. Some saw this as 100% confirmation that Jason Todd was the Arkham Knight, whereas others believed Red Hood would be a separate character entirely. All that is really set in stone is that Jason Todd is finally confirmed to make his Arkhamverse debut, and we for one can't wait to play as the character.

7. Azrael

Azrael The former cop, turned criminal turned supernatural crime fighter, Michael Lane stalks Batman throughout Arkham City, delivering cryptic message and referring vaguely to a prophecy. When Bats finally assembles all four clues and tracks him down to the Cathedral, Azrael has this to say: "I bring a message. Dark days are coming, Batman. The prophecy is coming true. You are the warrior who will close the gates of hell. You are the one who will save this day and in doing so events will occur that you cannot stop. From the ashes of Arkham, the fires will rage and Gotham will burn. And you, you will burn too." Ominous words to be sure! Batman shrugs it off claiming that he doesn't believe in fairy tales but Azrael insists that the two will meet again and vanishes. Could they meet again as foes? Though it sounds melodramatic, almost whimsical even, we have to admit his prophecy sounds awfully similar to what we've seen so far from the trailers. Batman indeed saved the city from Hugo Strange's Protocol 10. Yet one year later Gotham is in more danger than ever. The Scarecrow has returned and seems to have brought the city to the brink of destruction. And before Batman can stop him, he must deal with an armored super soldier intent on ending him. Could it be that Azrael is the Arkham Knight? Consider also that Azrael replaced Bruce Wayne as Batman after Bane broke his back in the Knightfall story arc. The Arkham Knight certainly bears more than a passing resemblance to Batman and this theory suggests that Azrael plans on taking out Bruce Wayne so that he may replace him as a more effective Batman (i.e. one who is willing to kill).

6. Deathstroke

Deathstroke already appeared in Batman: Arkham Origins (and was arguably the best thing in it!), but Rocksteady does not consider that game canon. We have yet to see their version of the character. Already wearing a similar looking suit of armor and equipped with a whole plethora of weapons, the Arkham Knight is basically just Deathstroke with a Batman mask. With so many villains already having fallen to the Caped Crusader in both games, it is reasonable to assume that they would want to avoid facing him again, and hire someone else instead. Who better to hire than the worlds greatest assassin? Slade Wilson has always been a fan favorite, but he has only recently seen a resurgence in popularity after appearing in video games Arkham Origins and Injustice: Gods Among Us. Then there was Manu Bennett's charismatic and terrifying portrayal of the character on Arrow, and Warner Bros recent announcement of a Suicide Squad movie that could potentially see Deathstroke finally debut on the big screen. We don't know if Slade Wilson will be revealed as the Arkham Knight, but Rocksteady will miss out on a serious opportunity if he isn't included in some capacity.

5. Quincy Sharp

Batman Arkham Asylum We promised that some of these theories were crazy, and this one is real loony bin territory (are we still allowed to say that?). The former warden of Arkham Asylum and former Mayor of Gotham Quincy Sharp has been pegged as a possible suspect for the Arkham Knight. Though he certainly doesn't match the Knights physical description, he does have valid motive (in his own mind) for targeting Batman and destroying Gotham city. Sharp is a schizophrenic who believed himself to be the spirit of Amadeus Arkham (the Asylum's founder) and actually spent much of the first game murdering many of the Asylum's inmates in the name of permanently curing their criminal insanity. Through the fascinating Chronicles of Arkham side mission, Batman discovers that Sharp planned on murdering many of his rogues' gallery and even attempted to kill the Joker. Sharp somehow manages to escape Arkham Island by the end of the game, but not before leaving a final message for Batman to carry on his work. In the second game, newly elected Mayor Sharp is responsible for the opening of the titular Arkham City and is actually being manipulated by Hugo Strange and Ra's al Ghul as part of their Protocol 10 plan to destroy the evil citizens of Gotham. Once Sharp has served his purpose he is then outed for his corruption and heinous atrocities and imprisoned within the City where he would have presumably been killed immediately had Batman not interfered. Now one year later, having lost his office as Mayor, his respected reputation and his beloved asylum, it is possible that Sharp may have fully succumbed to his split personality as the Spirit of Arkham and set his sights on Batman, for failing to protect Gotham City. It's crazy alright. But we're only getting started with the crazy theories.

4. Amadeus Arkham

Batman Arkham Asylum 600x300 Who better to take on the persona of the Arkham Knight than a member of the Arkham family? Amadeus Arkham is the founder of Arkham Asylum and he has a very dark and disturbing backstory (but then, who the hell doesn't in these Batman comics?). He euthanized his mentally ill mother, and after setting up the Asylum he discovered his wife and daughter raped and murdered by one of his first patients Martin "Mad Dog" Hawkins. Personally taking over the Mad Dog's treatment, Arkham murdered him with electroshock therapy, beginning his descent into madness. Ironically Arkham died as an inmate in his own Asylum. Though he has been dead for decades, we do discover that his grave has been dug up in the first game. Since Arkham already inspired Quincy Sharp to kill in his honor, it's easy to believe the Arkham Knight (the clue's in the name) could be a loyal admirer, or even descendant of Amadeus Arkham, if not Amadeus himself. It might seem ridiculous, but to date in these games we have seen a man with green scales convinced he's a crocodile, a woman who is more plant than person, a man kept alive by a robotic suit at subzero temperatures, a 600 year old man who continues to evade death, and an actual freaking zombie. Therefore, unlikely though it may be, we are prepared to let this game convince us that whoever is under that mask, doesn't necessarily have to be someone among the living.

3. Thomas Wayne Jr

court of owls 2 It may be too recent to include in a game that has mostly paid homage to the classic Batman stories, but those who have read Zack Snyder's excellent New 52 Batman stories would welcome the inclusion of the Court of Owls. The secret society that has ruled Gotham from behind the scenes for generations were thought only to be myth until Bruce Wayne finds himself targeted by the their personal assassin the Talon. Hunting down the Court, Batman discovers to his horror that they are in fact very real and the Talon is none other than his long lost younger brother Thomas Wayne Jr. The Talon wears an armored suit similar to the Arkham Knight, except his is modeled after the owl (the natural predator of bats). He has a pathological hatred for his brother Bruce and very nearly defeated him. In the comic Batman is abducted by the Court and forced to fight his way through an underground labyrinth that would make for an awesome level should the Court find their way into the game. Unfortunately the presence of an underground cult controlling Gotham would require a lot of retconning of the established Arkhamverse. Given their influence in the comics, Rocksteady would probably have to find a way to rewrite the previous games stories to fit them in. The opening of Arkham City for example and Protocol 10 could end up being their doing and Hugo Strange would have to be rewritten as a member. This is all theoretical but our point is the game has enough going on already. With the impressive number of villains revealed so far, and the ones we still hope to appear, we're happy to let the Court of Owls sit this one out. That said, if the Arkham Knight really does turn out to be Bruce Wayne's brother, expect us to be among the first to lose our minds.

2. Damien Wayne

damien wayne The son of Bruce Wayne and Talia al Ghul, Grandson of Ra's and the fifth Robin, Damien Wayne always comes up in every discussion about the Arkham Knights identity. Damien was born in an artificial womb after Talia - ahem - "procured" a sample of Bruce Wayne's... "DNA" and used it to create a genetically superior male heir for her father. After spending the first ten years of his life being trained by the League of Assassins, he arrived at Wayne Manor ready to aid his father in purging Gotham City of crime. Damien is more self-centered and ambitious than either Dick Greyson or Tim Drake and harbors a dark side that only his father Bruce can control. Though non comic book readers would be unfamiliar with the character, casual gamers may recognize him from Injustice: Gods Among Us, where he killed Dick Greyson and replaced him as Nightwing, serving under the evil Superman, who he considers more of a father than Bruce. In his personal epilogue, he defeats Superman, and joins the Sinestro Corps, due to his ability to inspire fear. Hey, he is the heir of the Demon after all. Though he could be too young to be the Knight, there have already been hints (okay, one hint) about his existence in the Arkhamverse. In Arkham City, Talia mentions sharing a night with Batman in Metropolis (which also confirms Metropolis exists in the Arkhamverse). Many believe this night could have led to Damien's conception (albeit more consensual than in the comics) and perhaps Ra's al Ghul has been training his grandson in secret. Now with Protocol 10 failed, Ra's may have one last surprise in store for Batman: pitting his own son against him under the guise of the Arkham Knight.

1. Thomas Wayne

The final theory is one of the least likely (since Bruce's father is obviously dead) and yet one of the most overwhelmingly popular theories going. Yes, one of the leading contenders expected to be revealed as the Arkham Knight is none other than Thomas Wayne. The first trailer for the game featured the reading of his will, in which he entrusted the safety and improvement of Gotham City to Bruce. Though he urged him not to waste their money on "fast cars, and outrageous clothes and the pursuit of a destructive lifestyle". Um ... too late! So it has been reasoned that Thomas Wayne probably would not approve of Bruce's role as Batman and so may be hunting him down as the Arkham Knight, in order to put an end to his reckless vigilantism. Of course that is where the evidence ends, and we're being very generous calling it that. Nobody has yet speculated on how Thomas could return from the dead, short of a Lazarus Pit. And would he really be planning to end Bruce's life as Batman by killing him? You can see how this theory is full of holes, and yet despite it all, fans stand by it. They are more convinced of the Arkham Knights identity than they are of Batman's! We can't say much more on the subject, but if Thomas Wayne really is the Arkham Knight, you can be sure it will be a reveal for the ages! That's all we have on the Arkham Knight. Got any ideas of your own? We'd love to hear them below!

Contributor
Contributor

As a wrestling fan I've flown across the Atlantic for the last five years specifically to attend WrestleMania (28 and 30) as well as TNA, ROH, Evolve, Chikara and most recently PWG. I may have a problem! But if you're reading my work then you probably love wrestling too, so lets focus on that!