10 Mind-Blowing Theories About Batman: Arkham Knight's Identity
There's only one Knight around here, and he's the Dark Knight!

Honorary Mention - Someone Original

10. The Joker

9. Hush

8. Jason Todd
Like Hush, Jason Todd is considered the odds on favorite to be revealed as the Arkham Knight. In fact it's so obvious that Todd is practically guaranteed NOT to be the Knight. The second Robin was infamously beaten to death by the Joker in the Death in the Family story (he was such an unpopular replacement for Dick Greyson that fans actually voted for his death). However he was resurrected by Ra's al Ghul and he took on the mantle of the Red Hood, ironically the alias previously used by the Joker. Red Hood has since become DC's answer to the Punisher, an anti hero who targets villains but uses lethal force. Though Todd hasn't appeared in any Arkham games so far, fans will have obviously noticed that Dick Greyson was using his Nightwing alias in the DLC pack and the version of Robin we got was Tim Drake (the third Robin). There couldn't be a Tim Drake if Jason Todd hadn't already come and gone. Throw in the fact that Ra's al Ghul and the Lazarus Pits already exist in the Arkhamverse and we have the possibility of a revitalized and revenge-motivated Red Hood, literally gunning for our cowled hero. Further speculation arose earlier this year when a Red Hood DLC pack was announced. Some saw this as 100% confirmation that Jason Todd was the Arkham Knight, whereas others believed Red Hood would be a separate character entirely. All that is really set in stone is that Jason Todd is finally confirmed to make his Arkhamverse debut, and we for one can't wait to play as the character.
7. Azrael
The former cop, turned criminal turned supernatural crime fighter, Michael Lane stalks Batman throughout Arkham City, delivering cryptic message and referring vaguely to a prophecy. When Bats finally assembles all four clues and tracks him down to the Cathedral, Azrael has this to say: "I bring a message. Dark days are coming, Batman. The prophecy is coming true. You are the warrior who will close the gates of hell. You are the one who will save this day and in doing so events will occur that you cannot stop. From the ashes of Arkham, the fires will rage and Gotham will burn. And you, you will burn too." Ominous words to be sure! Batman shrugs it off claiming that he doesn't believe in fairy tales but Azrael insists that the two will meet again and vanishes. Could they meet again as foes? Though it sounds melodramatic, almost whimsical even, we have to admit his prophecy sounds awfully similar to what we've seen so far from the trailers. Batman indeed saved the city from Hugo Strange's Protocol 10. Yet one year later Gotham is in more danger than ever. The Scarecrow has returned and seems to have brought the city to the brink of destruction. And before Batman can stop him, he must deal with an armored super soldier intent on ending him. Could it be that Azrael is the Arkham Knight? Consider also that Azrael replaced Bruce Wayne as Batman after Bane broke his back in the Knightfall story arc. The Arkham Knight certainly bears more than a passing resemblance to Batman and this theory suggests that Azrael plans on taking out Bruce Wayne so that he may replace him as a more effective Batman (i.e. one who is willing to kill).
6. Deathstroke

5. Quincy Sharp
We promised that some of these theories were crazy, and this one is real loony bin territory (are we still allowed to say that?). The former warden of Arkham Asylum and former Mayor of Gotham Quincy Sharp has been pegged as a possible suspect for the Arkham Knight. Though he certainly doesn't match the Knights physical description, he does have valid motive (in his own mind) for targeting Batman and destroying Gotham city. Sharp is a schizophrenic who believed himself to be the spirit of Amadeus Arkham (the Asylum's founder) and actually spent much of the first game murdering many of the Asylum's inmates in the name of permanently curing their criminal insanity. Through the fascinating Chronicles of Arkham side mission, Batman discovers that Sharp planned on murdering many of his rogues' gallery and even attempted to kill the Joker. Sharp somehow manages to escape Arkham Island by the end of the game, but not before leaving a final message for Batman to carry on his work. In the second game, newly elected Mayor Sharp is responsible for the opening of the titular Arkham City and is actually being manipulated by Hugo Strange and Ra's al Ghul as part of their Protocol 10 plan to destroy the evil citizens of Gotham. Once Sharp has served his purpose he is then outed for his corruption and heinous atrocities and imprisoned within the City where he would have presumably been killed immediately had Batman not interfered. Now one year later, having lost his office as Mayor, his respected reputation and his beloved asylum, it is possible that Sharp may have fully succumbed to his split personality as the Spirit of Arkham and set his sights on Batman, for failing to protect Gotham City. It's crazy alright. But we're only getting started with the crazy theories.
4. Amadeus Arkham
Who better to take on the persona of the Arkham Knight than a member of the Arkham family? Amadeus Arkham is the founder of Arkham Asylum and he has a very dark and disturbing backstory (but then, who the hell doesn't in these Batman comics?). He euthanized his mentally ill mother, and after setting up the Asylum he discovered his wife and daughter raped and murdered by one of his first patients Martin "Mad Dog" Hawkins. Personally taking over the Mad Dog's treatment, Arkham murdered him with electroshock therapy, beginning his descent into madness. Ironically Arkham died as an inmate in his own Asylum. Though he has been dead for decades, we do discover that his grave has been dug up in the first game. Since Arkham already inspired Quincy Sharp to kill in his honor, it's easy to believe the Arkham Knight (the clue's in the name) could be a loyal admirer, or even descendant of Amadeus Arkham, if not Amadeus himself. It might seem ridiculous, but to date in these games we have seen a man with green scales convinced he's a crocodile, a woman who is more plant than person, a man kept alive by a robotic suit at subzero temperatures, a 600 year old man who continues to evade death, and an actual freaking zombie. Therefore, unlikely though it may be, we are prepared to let this game convince us that whoever is under that mask, doesn't necessarily have to be someone among the living.
3. Thomas Wayne Jr
It may be too recent to include in a game that has mostly paid homage to the classic Batman stories, but those who have read Zack Snyder's excellent New 52 Batman stories would welcome the inclusion of the Court of Owls. The secret society that has ruled Gotham from behind the scenes for generations were thought only to be myth until Bruce Wayne finds himself targeted by the their personal assassin the Talon. Hunting down the Court, Batman discovers to his horror that they are in fact very real and the Talon is none other than his long lost younger brother Thomas Wayne Jr. The Talon wears an armored suit similar to the Arkham Knight, except his is modeled after the owl (the natural predator of bats). He has a pathological hatred for his brother Bruce and very nearly defeated him. In the comic Batman is abducted by the Court and forced to fight his way through an underground labyrinth that would make for an awesome level should the Court find their way into the game. Unfortunately the presence of an underground cult controlling Gotham would require a lot of retconning of the established Arkhamverse. Given their influence in the comics, Rocksteady would probably have to find a way to rewrite the previous games stories to fit them in. The opening of Arkham City for example and Protocol 10 could end up being their doing and Hugo Strange would have to be rewritten as a member. This is all theoretical but our point is the game has enough going on already. With the impressive number of villains revealed so far, and the ones we still hope to appear, we're happy to let the Court of Owls sit this one out. That said, if the Arkham Knight really does turn out to be Bruce Wayne's brother, expect us to be among the first to lose our minds.
2. Damien Wayne
The son of Bruce Wayne and Talia al Ghul, Grandson of Ra's and the fifth Robin, Damien Wayne always comes up in every discussion about the Arkham Knights identity. Damien was born in an artificial womb after Talia - ahem - "procured" a sample of Bruce Wayne's... "DNA" and used it to create a genetically superior male heir for her father. After spending the first ten years of his life being trained by the League of Assassins, he arrived at Wayne Manor ready to aid his father in purging Gotham City of crime. Damien is more self-centered and ambitious than either Dick Greyson or Tim Drake and harbors a dark side that only his father Bruce can control. Though non comic book readers would be unfamiliar with the character, casual gamers may recognize him from Injustice: Gods Among Us, where he killed Dick Greyson and replaced him as Nightwing, serving under the evil Superman, who he considers more of a father than Bruce. In his personal epilogue, he defeats Superman, and joins the Sinestro Corps, due to his ability to inspire fear. Hey, he is the heir of the Demon after all. Though he could be too young to be the Knight, there have already been hints (okay, one hint) about his existence in the Arkhamverse. In Arkham City, Talia mentions sharing a night with Batman in Metropolis (which also confirms Metropolis exists in the Arkhamverse). Many believe this night could have led to Damien's conception (albeit more consensual than in the comics) and perhaps Ra's al Ghul has been training his grandson in secret. Now with Protocol 10 failed, Ra's may have one last surprise in store for Batman: pitting his own son against him under the guise of the Arkham Knight.
1. Thomas Wayne
