10 Mistakes That Led To WWE 2K's Downfall

This series was on the ropes long before 2K20...

WWE 2K Battlegrounds
2K Games

WWE 2K21 has been cancelled and 2K Games will throw their all into a new spin-off that'll launch later this year.

2K Battlegrounds, as it's being called, will see over-the-top character models (which look like something from MTV's old Celebrity Deathmatch gem) cartoon-ishly compete in arcade matches that are a million miles away from the simulation feel of the core series. It's a bold move, albeit one necessitated by the fact that 2K has P*SSED EVERYONE OFF.

2K20 was just the tip of the iceberg. No, really - this franchise has been spinning out of control for years now, and it's been obvious for long-timers to see that the developers had lost touch with what fans wanted to see from their WWE video games. They've made loads of mistakes since the glory of 2013's 2K14 on Xbox 360 and and PS3.

Things have been going downhill since then, and it sucks. It especially sucks to be the one to deliver this message when 2K has helped craft so many memorable experience over the years with other licenses like NBA and amazing originals like Bioshock, Borderlands and more.

Here's where it all went wrong...


10. The Sh*tty Jump To 8th Generation Consoles

WWE 2K15: Adrian Neville - Entrance, Signature & Finishers
2K Games

If 2K14 was everything that was right with WWE games, then 2K15 was everything that was wrong. The game, which was proudly trumpeted as WWE's first on eighth-generation powerhouses like the PS4 and Xbox One, was an empty shell that promised more in the future.

In other words, it was a lame first attempt on new hardware.

2K14 was the best of THQ's work, Yuke's assets and 2K's savvy. There was so much to like, and that only made it a bigger shock when fans flocked to pick up the next entry and found out that virtually everything they enjoyed had been stripped away. It was certainly jarring.

2K also made a mistake by trying to serve every master. Releasing NXT content onto old consoles as some sort of apology to those who hadn't bought into the PS4/Xbox One hype yet was silly, and the whole experience was a hollow one.


9. MyCareer

WWE 2K18 MyCareer
2K Games

MyCareer.

That one word should make any longtime fan of WWE games shudder. It's become the single-player experience 2K favour, and that hasn't done their series any favours. When it launched, gaming sites excitedly predicted that it'd mimic NBA 2K's thrilling, story-based nuts n' bolts. Not quite.

Instead, until 2K decided to repackage the entire idea in 2K19, MyCareer was a mind-numbing slog through matches, hokey cutscenes and some of the worst presentation decisions ever; honestly, who had the bright idea to make players literally jog (like they were running through mud) between their car and the Gorilla Position?

MyCareer in 2K20 might not be perfect to look at, but it's a million miles better than the hallway simulator 2K whipped up for years. This was not a good replacement for any WWE star-driven Story Mode, nor was it fun to play through.


8. Reversal Limits

wwe 2k16 counter button prompt
2K

At their best (Shut Your Mouth, Here Comes The Pain, No Mercy, Fire Pro etc), pro wrestling video games are arcade-ish in nature and allow players to have ridiculous reversal-fests. It's fun to get together with some buddies, grab a few drinks let the chaos flow.

Then, 2K decided that reversals should be limited to a handful in 2K16, and everyone cried.

On one hand, this choice was understandable. It'd add a tactical element to matches, and force players to pick between reversing that light punch or saving it for Brock Lesnar's F-5. The only problem here is that prior games had been perfectly fine. Nobody was really whining that their friends had mastered the humble reversal.

This was yet another step in the wrong direction for 2K's gameplay. They leaned too hard on simulation, added a bunch of senseless mini-games that had players looking at little dials rather than the action, and removed most of the fun factor in the process.


7. Ditching Showcase

Heyman My Career WWE 2K17
2K Games

Showcase became one of the better single-player modes in 2K's arsenal when they proudly revealed it in time for 2K15. The mode took the best parts of older retrospectives on things like '30 Years Of WrestleMania' and the Attitude era, and retooled things to focus on specific feuds such as John Cena vs. CM Punk and Triple H vs. Shawn Michaels.

It was a good laugh, and well done.

The Steve Austin feature in 2K16 was an improvement too, but Showcase was removed entirely from the game line up by 2K17. Why the f*ck would they even think to do that when the mode was earning rave reviews for nostalgic brilliance? It didn't make sense, and it meant fans had no major single-player modes beyond MyCareer and Universe to play with.

Neither of those captured the same production levels or weight of history like Showcase did. Thankfully, 2K saw sense and brought Showcase back (in a big way with Daniel Bryan) by 2K19. Those two years without it were painful.


6. 2K18 On Nintendo Switch

WWE 2K18 Nintendo Switch
2K Games

The Nintendo Switch is an excellent console that successfully marries couch play with on-the-go, and it's a must for anyone who needs to inject their gaming life with a sense of fun again. Meanwhile, WWE 2K18 on Switch was a miserable failure that occasionally dipped to frame rates most early-2000s mobile games would be ashamed of.

Yep, it was awful.

2K28 was the first WWE game to see release on a Nintendo platform since WWE '13 on Wii, and it'll probably be the last for a while unless Battlegrounds is coming to Switch. If it does, then it might be some sort of necessary healing tool for anyone who was burned into buying this dodgy port that should've had alarm bells ringing about 2K's stewardship of the series.

All those ads that showed cover boy Seth Rollins cheerily playing some WWE on Switch amounted to little more than false hope. The only 'on-the-go' experience 2K18 deserved was the game card being launched out of the bus window.


5. Focusing On Lighting

WWE 2K18 Triple H Mania
2K Games

2K18 fared better on other systems like PS4 and Xbox One, but there was a nagging doubt creeping around there too. Before release, 2K made a big deal out of their brand spanking new lighting engine - that, they said, would bathe character models in beautiful cascades of light and create the most realistic-looking WWE experience yet.

Sort of.

The truth is that 2K were trying to mask archaic inadequacies. Sure, several characters (like the Triple H model shown above) looked resplendent, but not everyone had the same care lavished on their character. In fact, a large portion of the roster seemed to hide behind the lighting in shadows rather than bursting from them with serious attention to detail.

It's almost like 2K started to rely more on lighting than proper graphics on the models themselves. They quickly realised that they could mask blemishes, dodgy-looking facial features, dead eyes and hair so stiff it looked like it hadn't been washed since SmackDown 2: Know Your Role.


4. Towers Mode

WWE 2K19 Towers Mode
2K Games

Your writer needs a slap on the wrist for once pontificating that 2K's Towers Mode could become the "Mortal Kombat-inspired game mode this series needs" before 2K19's release. When he actually got to play the thing hands-on, he realised (along with everyone else) that it was another empty single-player bone hurled at series veterans like scraps of food to a starving dog.

Towers is flat out dull.

No amount of golden AJ Styles bonus characters, million dollar giveaway challenges or legends can change that fact. It's boring, it always has been boring and it's another poor replacement tacked on to fool fans into thinking they're getting more bang for their buck. 2K may have had good intentions and thought they were adding value here, but they didn't.

Having to slog through some of the Towers on offer to complete them was a chore. The resources put into developing this mode should've gone towards a proper, WWE star-centric Story Mode, not some MK-lite b*llocks.


3. P*ssing Off Yuke's

Yukes WWE 2K
Yukes

2K's creative director Lynell Jenkins said before 2K19's launch that the series would make steps to mend fences with beleaguered fans who thought the games were too simulation-heavy. He said they wanted to make 2K19 "faster, more fluid" and that even he didn't think the previous few games were much fun to actually play.

This hinted at internal division, and that conflict was with Yuke's.

The longtime developers warned 2K that they needed more when senior vice president and producer Hiromi Furuta vented her frustrations to the media in May 2019. Furuta said Yuke's would be working on their own game to foster friendly competition - the relationship between dev team and publisher was shot to pieces after that.

Yuke's were blatantly cheesed off at the way 2K had handled the WWE license for years. They decided to challenge the company to come up with something better, but there was only one solution: Yuke's had to go, and they had to see if 2K (with new partner Visual Concepts) could cope on their own.


2. Releasing 2K20 As They Did

WWE 2K20 Glitch
2K Sports

As most know, they couldn't.

2K20 almost killed the entire series dead by launching with so many bugs and glitches it almost seemed like a masterclass in f*ck ups. The graphics were worse than 2K19, the game barely functioned, and 2K scrambled to patch things after already charging full-price for a game that was more tech demo than proper, workable product.

It was as though 2K and VC took a hammer and nail, rested the latter against their hearts and then used the former to smash it in. By releasing 2K20 in the state they did, they took a massive dump on any credibility WWE 2K had left as a franchise. There was no coming back after this one without some serious grovelling.

Instead of actually apologising, 2K has repeatedly made a mess of patches, and the game still isn't playable nearly seven months after first coming out. It's one of the worst wrestling games of all time. Somehow, despite all the bad press last October-December, January made things worse...


1. The 'Y2K20' Bug

WWE 2K20
2K Games

When on-board PS4 and Xbox One calendars turned to 1 January 2020, 2K20 couldn't handle it. Weirdly, the game had come pre-packed with a bug that rendered it unplayable. The glitch would become known as 'Y2K20' and get the game trending with unsavoury hashtags like '#FixWWE2K20' all over again.

What a disaster.

Basically, anyone who was gifted the game for Christmas couldn't play the thing a week later until 2K logged on to build another patch. By this point, they'd already put so many quick fixes on a broken system that it ate up HDD space like the second coming of Red Dead Redemption 2 (which, it's important to note, was so big because it was so complex; it also actually worked).

This was the last straw for some who had tried to soldier on though all the negativity. On New Year's Day 2020, 2K and Visual Concepts watched any remaining street cred they had disappear. They, Battlegrounds and all, might never recover from the fall.

Do you still have faith in the WWE 2K series? For more like this, check out 10 Things We Learned From Triple H On WWE’s After The Bell and 10 Major Stars Who Questioned Bad WWE Booking!


In this post: 
WWE 2k
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.