10 MORE Cruel Tricks Video Games Played On RPG Players

Scripted party wipes are never fun.

Final Fantasy 9 Beatrix
Square Enix

Role-playing games are in a league of their own where popularity is concerned, appealing to a huge swath of players across many demographics. After all, who doesn't love entrenching themselves in a living, breathing game world teeming with hundreds of hours of content?

But as much as most RPGs are focused on giving the player freedom to explore their lush worlds, sometimes, developers aren't strictly focused on catering to the player's desires, and will get a little more daring.

To that end, some RPGs tinker with player expectations in ways that aren't merely cheeky and mischievous, but generally ruthless, harsh, and even cruel.

From ambushing players with a brutal choice at the start of the game, to locking them out of content with pathetic ease, or punishing them for showing mercy, these RPGs all played nasty tricks on players for one reason or another.

Following up our original list on this subject, here are ten more video games that weren't satisfied to be exercises in wish fulfilment - they wanted you to feel despair, anger, and confusion too!

10. Make A Horrible Choice At The Start Of The Game - Fable III

Fable III
Xbox Game Studios

Generally speaking, most video games save their agonising player choices for the very end of the story, but Fable III said "Screw that" and forced you to make a gut-wrenching decision in its opening 15 minutes.

Fable III's protagonist is the younger brother of Logan, the despotic king of Albion, and at the start of the game after intruding upon one of his war room meetings, Logan punishes you by forcing you to make a horrific choice.

Logan is either going to execute your love interest, or the leaders of the protest against his corrupt rule - and you have to pick who. It's a genuinely tough choice with no "right" answer, and to rub salt in the wound, if you take too long to choose, Logan will just execute them all.

Given that players rightly expect to be eased into the tricky decision-making in any video game, Fable III surprised players by instead kicking things off with a stomach-churning jolt. Whoever you picked, this was harsh as hell.


9. Digimon Die Of Old Age - Digimon World

Digimon World
Bandai Namco Entertainment

If you played Digimon World as a kid, there's a good chance you ended up getting pretty attached to your Digimon, enough that you were left thoroughly traumatised when they started dying of old age.

That's right - while you might've expected to be able to hold onto your Digimon forever in the game, they have a finite lifespan, and eventually perish no matter what you do.

You're forced to watch as their life force shatters and they're transformed into an orb of brilliant light, before being informed that the Digimon has "faded away."

It's a genuinely heartbreaking revelation, though it is somewhat cushioned by the fact that dead Digimon also give birth to a "Digitama" - an egg which allows them to be reborn, albeit with players having to raise them to adulthood all over again.

It's a lesson in the ephemeral nature of existence that nobody expected to learn while playing a Digimon game, of all things.


8. The Zodiac Spear Is Unobtainable If You Open Certain Chests - Final Fantasy XII

Final Fantasy 12 The Zodiac Age
Square Enix

In the original release of Final Fantasy XII, the game's strongest weapon was the Zodiac Spear, but acquiring it was so much of a piss-take that most players surely didn't deem it worth the hassle.

To get the spear, you needed to not open four specific chests throughout the game, after which it could be found among a collection of 16 chests at the Necrohol of Nabudis.

It goes without saying that this is impossible to pull off without either blind luck or a strategy guide, enough that many fans maintain to this very day that Square Enix did it to try and sell more strategy guides.

Players who'd already poured countless hours into the game and were locked out of obtaining the Zodiac Spear due to opening one of the chests were (naturally) incredibly upset about it all, such that for the Zodiac Age re-release, Square Enix made it much easier to pick up.

However, because the developers evidently wanted to spite fans a little while doing so, the Zodiac Spear received a nerf in the re-release and was no longer the game's strongest weapon.


7. Losing The Ability To Hug - Pathologic 2

Pathologic 2
tinyBuild

Survival horror RPG Pathologic 2 imposes penalties on the player every single time they die, courtesy of supernatural theatre director Mark Immortell.

These penalties include debuffs like reduced immunity and maximum health, which can only be easily removed by restarting the game, yet one of the earliest penalties you receive seems hilariously frivolous - that is, until it isn't.

One of your first deaths will see you punished with the inability to hug, which sounds like a joke given that hugging isn't an apparent gameplay mechanic.

But as it turns out, this pays off quite ruthlessly near the very end of the game, when a crestfallen Lara falls into a pit of despair, believing herself to be useless and requiring comfort.

One of the player options is the ability to give Lara a hug, but if you've received the aforementioned penalty, you'll be denied the opportunity.

Completing a "hug run" of the game, where you keep your death count low enough to retain your ability to hug Lara, is a major badge of honour among Pathologic 2 players, and a seriously harsh challenge on the part of developers Ice-Pick Lodge.


6. Save The Suids And They Kill People Later - Xenoblade Chronicles X

Xenoblade Chronicles X Suid
Nintendo

Xenoblade Chronicles X offers up one hell of a 'damned if you do, damned if you don't' situation in its mission City Saviors, where a young man by the name of Carl tasks you with killing five suids - basically pig-like creatures - in Primordia's West Gate Plain.

Carl isn't particularly enthusiastic about the mission himself, and upon arriving in the cave and realising the suids are babies, the player is given the option to spare the critters.

Refusing to kill the monster-piglets is more-or-less framed as the "right" option, even if they are perceived as a potential threat to New Los Angeles, but doing so will come back to bite you in the proverbial.

Leave the suids to their own devices and another mission will be unlocked later in the game, aptly titled A Painful Lesson. Carl has been mauled and mortally wounded by the now-grown suids, and in his dying breaths he begs you to kill the adult creatures off.

Basically, you're forced to kill the creatures either way, so it just comes down to whether or not you want to do it when they're young, and save Carl. But on an initial playthrough, most players clearly thought they were doing the moral thing by letting the babies live. Yikes.


5. Losing Your Hand (Making Two-Handed Weapons Useless) - Summoner

Summoner Joseph
Volition

Cult classic RPG Summoner pulls off an especially cruel twist of fate for protagonist Joseph, when roughly half-way through the game his left hand is burned off at the behest of the evil Demon of Darkness, Machival.

It's a shocking moment, but more than that, it gives the player a distinct disadvantage for a large chunk of the game, given that you're no longer able to wield two-handed weapons or shields.

It's especially harsh if you've primarily invested in two-handed weapons, as now you're suddenly forced to change things up. Either way, it results in a significant nerf to both your attacking and defensive capabilities for many hours, until Joseph's hand is mercifully restored before the game's final act.

If you're fortunate enough to read about Summoner online before playing it, everybody will tell you not to get too reliant on weapons that require two hands - and with damn good reason.


4. The Forced Final Sacrifice - Fallout 3

Fallout 3 Fawkes Ending
Bethesda Softworks

The climactic twist in the original release of Fallout 3 isn't just cruel - it's cheap and unfair. Your final task is to activate a water purifier and save the local population, requiring you to access a radiation-filled room.

You're given two choices - either sacrifice your own life to enter the room, or send fan-favourite character Sarah Lyons in to do the job instead. Either way, one of you is dying for the "greater good."

This naturally pissed many fans off who were left baffled that they couldn't assign the task to Fawkes, a Super Mutant who has radiation resistance as a defining attribute.

If you ask him to enter the room, he'll retort with an unconvincing spiel about not wanting to rob you of your "destiny." It's awful, lazy writing in an attempt to contrive a last-minute dramatic sacrifice, and fell flat for most players.

The response was vitriolic enough that Bethesda later remedied the dilemma with the Broken Steel DLC, which allowed players to have one of their three radiation-resistant companions - Fawkes, Sergeant RL-3, or Charon - get the job done.

But Broken Steel wasn't free, so Bethesda managed to profit off the whole kerfuffle, forcing players to pay extra to get they ending they should've been able to access right out the box.


3. Game-Breaking Save Points - Baten Kaitos

Baten Kaitos
Bandai Namco Entertainment

It's extremely important that RPGs offer players save points which allow them to exit the area and return later.

Though this is a given in modern RPGs - a basic accessibility feature, really - games of yore have been considerably less thoughtful towards players' time, potentially resulting in them being unable to progress.

Two particularly infamous examples of this occur in the very same franchise - Baten Kaitos.

The first game allows players to save once boarding the Battleship Goldoba, after which they have to deal with one of the game's most difficult boss fights against a trio of foes - Giacomo, Ayme, and Folon.

Given that there's no way to grind on the ship, if you've only got one save file and aren't strong enough to defeat them, you're absolutely screwed and will be most likely forced to start the game from scratch, having wasted a couple-dozen hours in the process.

And despite the overwhelming outcry about this online at the time, prequel Baten Kaitos Origins repeated the same cruel trick. At the end of disc one, you're given a save prompt, after which the player is attacked by the Holoholobird.

This boss is fierce, and given that you face it right at the start of disc two without any grindable mobs in the area, if you're under-levelled you've got no chance of winning. And again, without any backup saves there's also no way to improve yourself.

There's probably a lesson here about creating a few staggered saves while playing lengthy RPGs, but all the same it's reasonable to expect the game not to lock you out of progress through no real fault of your own.


2. Scripted Party Wipes

Final Fantasy 9 Beatrix
Square Enix

Here's a trope that's felt tired for a good, long while now: scripted party wipes at the end of boss fights.

An unwinnable boss fight where you're quickly destroyed in a matter of moments as part of the story is one thing, but one where you actually have to put effort into fighting the boss to a pre-determined "win" point before the scripted death occurs is hugely frustrating.

Dying before this point will result in a genuine Game Over and will require you to keep fighting to reach the scripted moment where you can finally concede, which, beyond being rubbish game design, feels like a waste of the player's time.

Prepping yourself for a wild boss fight by grinding and stocking your inventory, and then realising it was all for the sake of a scripted defeat, is immensely unsatisfying. Looking at you, Beatrix in Final Fantasy IX.

If a game is going to pull this gambit, the boss fight in question needs to be short, and ideally, if you happen to be defeated anyway, it simply segues into the scripted sequence.


1. Yoshimo's "Betrayal" - Baldur's Gate II: Shadows Of Amn

Baldur's Gate 2
Interplay Entertainment

Opinion varies wildly on who the best companions are in Baldur's Gate II, though a sure fan-favourite is bounty hunter Yoshimo - up to a point, at least.

Yoshimo can be recruited to your party early in the game, enough that you'll probably grow rather attached to him by the time he's forced to betray the player under the control of the villainous mage Jon Irenicus.

This happens roughly two-thirds of the way through the campaign, and beyond the devastation of a character you've spent dozens of hours warming to being turned to the dark side, if you didn't know it was coming you've just lost everything he had equipped.

Those who know what awaits Yoshimo, however, will typically strip him of his wares before the betrayal takes place.

And because this isn't savage enough, Yoshimo will later ask you to kill him in order to set him free from Irenicus' enchantment, and he can only be granted peace in the afterlife by taking his heart to a priest.

Very cruel indeed.


Watch Next


Final Fantasy ALL GAMES Quiz: How Well Do You Know The Franchise?

Square Enix

1. I - Which Of The Following Is Not A Bonus Dungeon In Remakes Of The Game?

Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.