10 More Great Video Games Nobody Bought

Sorry but Second Sight is STILL incredible.

Second sight
Free Radical

Looking at a game library of a friend is always a fun exercise. There are the obvious must-haves on every system that you expect to see some amount of but it's the oddities that are truly interesting.

The biggest games from major franchises will always make a certain amount of money based on brand familiarity. But, for every tentpole title, there are dozens of releases that appear in the marketplace and go by unnoticed. Standing in the shadow of the giants, it's very easy to be overlooked.

We've covered several of these cases in the past where video games just didn't sell despite the fact that they're strong or even brilliant titles in their own right. They just failed, for whatever reason, to get gamers to part with their cash.

There's a lot of things that go into making a game a financial success: good marketing to build hype, a perfect release window and even something as simple as making sure it has a big enough audience that are receptive to it. You can have the most incredible game ready to go but if the situation isn't right then it just might spell disaster.

10. Titanfall 2

Titanfall 2
EA

What made Titanfall 2 so good is that it was a clear demonstration of listening to your audience.

Whilst the core tenants of the IP remain the same, the rest of the game feels as though it's been put through rigorous testing in a way that made Titanfall 2 make its predecessor look like a tech demo. The mech-piloting FPS sequel was bigger, deeper and more rewarding in its progression system and just offered a more balanced and engaging experience.

More than just retooling the multiplayer of course though, Respawn Entertainment gave players another reason to stick with Titanfall 2 by including a single player campaign, something that the original sorely lacked. The short story was stuffed with fantastic set-pieces that in a way excused a shorter running time. Quality over quantity was clearly a general top-down idea for the sequel.

However, Titanfall 2 got totally stiffed by its publisher Electronic Arts. Not only did it release just a week after EA’s own Battlefield 1, it did so with the looming shadow of the next Call of Duty hanging over it. Its potential sales were cannibalised and the new kid on the block couldn’t contend with established names in the genre.

In the years since, Titanfall 2’s great experience has been complimented by numerous players who got it on sale or even for free.


9. The Wonderful 101

the wonderful 101
Platinum Games

Sometimes, games release into ecosystems that are already overstuffed. There's just too much going on in the industry, specifically on a particular console, and deserving titles are lost in the shuffle of players having too much choice.

The Wonderful 101 suffered a different but no worse fate. Not that Wii U owners weren’t distracted by better games - there were disparagingly few titles on the system as it was - there just weren’t many people with the console to even sell it to.

This particularly stings because not only is The Wonderful 101 a solid game in its own right, it also was one of the few to make great use of the console’s gimmicks. Players use the Gamepad to draw symbols for their groups of heroes to take formations, be that giant swords to smash down foes or ladders and so on to traverse environments. It was truly original.

The Wii U is Nintendo’s least successful home console of all time and because of this The Wonderful 101 is certainly one of Platinum Games’ worst selling titles. Estimates at the end of its first quarter put it at less than 80k combined across Japan and North America. Thankfully, the game has since gotten a remaster due to fan support to give it another lease on life.


8. Brütal Legend

brutal legend
Double Fine

Celebrity involvement in video games can be a great way to turn head and boost sales. Getting cold and cynical about it, the race to include known actors as starring roles in video games over the last decade or so has been all about marketing.

However, Brütal Legend found out that it can make very little difference... or, in fact, harm the end product.

That's not to say that Jack Black as Eddie Riggs - a roadie who gets transported to the world of heavy metal to fight demons - is a bad casting choice. If anything, it's perfect and JB brings his established charisma and expressiveness with clear enthusiasm. The game featured an exciting world (with several heavy metal cameos) and a stacked soundtrack of metal classics of the past and the 2000s.

Interestingly, Brütal Legend was one part God of War like hack and smasher and one part RTS-esque army management. It was a really refreshing and surprisingly solid combination of elements, that caught a lot of people unawares. Reason being, EA just didn't bother to market the game aspect of Brütal Legend and focused entirely on Jack Black and its heavy metal theme. Thus, actual gamers weren't sure of what they were getting into.

Like Double Fine's previous release Psychonauts, Brütal Legend sold abysmally and is now considered a cult hit.


7. Gravity Rush

gravity rush
Sony

For this one, you can take your pick of either game in the Gravity Rush duology. Given its sales numbers, it’s quite incredible that Gravity Rush even got a sequel at all.

The games were crafted by a small set of developers at Japan Studio who were once upon a time known as Team Silent. Yes, former maestros of horror put together a pair of high-octane and kinetic action games. Gravity Rush, as the name implies, allows players to use gravity as a tool to their advantage as they battle monsters and explore a unique, beautiful world.

The first game was hot out the gates, moving 100k copies in Japan in its first month but it failed to climb much higher. Being an exclusive for the PS Vita at the time - a console that was being outsold by the 3DS and even the PSP - put a ceiling on the game’s potential. It stumbled worldwide.

Despite Gravity Rush 2 coming straight to PlayStation 4 in 2017, it had almost the exact same stunted trajectory but without the excuse: a solid start that suddenly stopped. America and especially Europe just seemed to not care for the franchise, regardless of its larger marketing push and availability.

Both games are light-hearted action romps that we could do with more of in an industry that is often obsessed with realism and regurgitation.


6. Grim Fandango

Grim Fandango
Lucasarts

Out of the many reasons for a game to commercially fail, an entire genre going out of style is rather brutal way to go. Considering Grim Fandango was made for quite a hefty asking price at the time, it was going to struggle to make a profit. However, the era of the classic adventure game was well and truly out.

Grim Fandango is set in a film noir afterlife and stars Manny Calavera - a skeletal travel agent who winds up discovering a conspiracy in his world. This world, the Land of the Dead, oozed a distinct charm and housed an incredibly unique story as told by a brilliant voice cast.

In many ways, it's characters, humour and out-of-the-box puzzle solving so perfectly summarise what LucasArts had been known for for a long time. It made for a great game... that most players didn't care about as frenetic action had taken precedence within the gaming space.

Grim Fandango's sales were bad enough to convince LucasArts to call it a day with their adventure game past and move forward as essentially a publisher of Star Wars outings. As such, it's seen as somewhat of a swansong for the entire genre. Thankfully, the game's license was eventually picked up by DoubleFine's Tim Schaffer for a rerelease after years of fans clamouring a new way to play this classic.


5. Jade Empire

jade empire
Bioware

By the early to mid 2000s, BioWare had made a name for themselves crafting expert RPGs. Their usage of existing IP with Knights of the Old Republic and Baldur’s Gate tapped into existing fanbases and the quality of these titles had made their name worth keeping an eye on.

To release their first major original IP, the developers signed a deal with Microsoft to bring Jade Empire to the Xbox.

Based on Chinese mythology and martial arts, the game bowled many critics and gamers alike over with its incredibly unique combat system and a story that was way better than anyone was expecting. It was an underrated classic, despite graphical and power limitations presented by releasing for a system at the end of its life.

This, ultimately, was also what cut off Jade Empire’s legs. The Xbox was a system not particularly known for its RPGs and thus its strong showing at first saw it slip out of sight quickly. Moreover, the game was released in the spring of 2005, amidst talk that the Xbox’s sequel system was on the way which turned out to be revealed just shortly thereafter.

Gamers saved their money on this one which is a shame as it’s a real gem of the original Xbox and an interesting point in BioWare’s career before they found their Dragon Age and Mass Effect shaped groove.


4. Second Sight

Second Sight
Codemasters

In a previous list on the same subject, we mentioned the underrated gem that is Psi-Ops. However, you can't really mention that game without referencing Second Sight or vice-versa. Both just so happen be solid third-person action games with telekinetic protagonists that released around the same time in 2004.

However, neither game particularly won big when it came to sales.

Second Sight follows amnesiac John Vattic as he awakens and promptly breaks out of a medical facility upon discovering he has psychic abilities.

What made the game feel so good is that every development choice felt very deliberate. The team at Free Radical clearly had a strong vision in mind for the game's pace (since John can't sprint), with unique aiming systems and three camera settings. The game gave players an, at the time, unprecedented level of choice between third person, first person and fixed cameras (à la Resident Evil).

Considering the importance of stealth in Second Sight, having a sturdy base and these options were all key. Choice is everything in fact. Half of the game was open-ended arenas that give players a toolbox of powers - invisibility, telekinesis, possession - and let them solve encounters as they saw fit.

This level of emergent gameplay was almost unheard of in 2004 and it simply deserved better.


3. Viva Piñata

viva pinata
Rare

The story of Microsoft’s acquisition of Rare is a muddy one. Once Nintendo’s most prized allies, the team found themselves churning out stinkers like Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts and Bolts and arbitrary Kinect games for a long time.

However, in their early days of Xbox exclusives, Rare put out a new IP which is their slept-on masterpiece.

Like Jade Empire, Viva Piñata was a victim of the audience that it was put in front of. Xbox owners were eating good on gritty shooters like Gears of War and realistic RPGs like Oblivion. Rare’s colourful, unique gardening sim, by comparison, was so cutesy it had a tie-in animated children’s show.

That belies the game’s tougher, strategic edge as you juggle attracting certain Piñatas and rescuing your garden’s inhabitants from the nefarious Professor Pester. Both Viva Piñata and it's sequel were dripping with the kind of charm that only Rare could instil and offered much greater depth than they first appeared, making them highly addictive.

Although the games made full use of the power of the Xbox 360 and couldn’t have worked nearly as well on Nintendo hardware, it’s highly likely that with access to that audience they would’ve sold a lot more than they did. We can only hope that one day we can hit the Piñata of the Nintendo Direct and have a Switch port of Viva Piñata come tumbling out.


2. Snatcher

Harry Benson Snatcher
Konami

Hideo Kojima’s second game project as writer and director, Snatcher was a cyberpunk story inspired by Invasion of the Body Snatchers, Terminator and Bladerunner. It followed a twisting plot about androids killing and replacing humans in a society recovering from biological warfare. The game first launched in Japan in 1988 for PC-8801 and MSX2 and remains charming in a late 80s lo-fi sci-fi kind of way; a fully voice-acted cyberpunk visual novel that feels like a precursor of what the auteur would go on to create.

When Snatcher finally came to the West in 1994 it did so on the Sega CD, when what little light that the system ever had was waning. The game has been described as only selling a “couple of thousand copies” thanks to the Mega Drive peripheral having low sales numbers itself and Snatcher being six years old already by this time.

The game’s spiritual successor, Policenauts, never actually released outside of Japan and one has to wonder if Snatcher’s failure was one contributing factor.

It’s crazy to think about a Kojima game coming out and passing most people by but of course this was before he became the huge name that he is today. Interested players now have to seek Snatcher out via emulation or overpriced resales thanks to the game never having a rerelease in nearly 30 years since it first appeared in the West.


1. Vagrant Story

Vagrant Story
Square Enix

Rather incredibly, famed Japanese gaming magazine Famitsu rated Vagrant Story a perfect score of 40/40. This is not only a better score than any Final Fantasy game on the PS1… it’s actually the only PlayStation 1 game to hold this honour. And those who have played Vagrant Story tend to agree. It’s a game that if you love it; you truly, deeply love it.

When it comes to clever and immersive RPGs, Vagrant Story was cutting way above expectations in 2000. Weapons and equipment levelled differently depending on your style of play, gaining boons and downsides reactively as you explored the game’s many dungeons. The graphics were incredibly unique and the game had a rich socio-political story.

The game's strong start to sales petered off unfortunately quickly, especially as many Square fans were already content with Chrono Cross that had arrived a few months prior. Even more likely that they had money set aside for that summer’s Final Fantasy IX. A new IP like Vagrant Story was fighting an uphill battle.

Ironically, since this unsung gem was set in Ivalice - the same world as Final Fantasy Tactics - the game may have fared a lot better if Vagrant Story was a subtitle and the game was positioned as an entry in the Final Fantasy series.

Alas, this perfectly scoring Square game feels lost to time.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Second Sight
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Coming from a content creation background that now spans over two decades, Psy cut her teeth on personal video production and community radio. Originally joining the team as a writer and presenter, she added video editing duties to her responsibilities over time and became the longest-standing editor of the irreverent gaming show Tues Your Own Adventure. Psy has worked on many previews and reviews, long-form editorials (either her own, or supporting as an editor), as a frequent quizmaster and more. Praised for the two-pronged attack of her hard work ethic and light-hearted editing style, Psy is otherwise known as a font of retro video game knowledge which has caused her to rack up many gaming quiz wins. Outside of WhatCulture, Psy runs First Aid Spray Podcast - a long-running channel that focuses on Resident Evil in all of it's forms. You can follow her on BlueSky at http://psywhite.bsky.social and Instagram at http://instagram.com/therealpsywhite