10 Most Disappointing Video Games Of 2022 (So Far)
So many sequels, so many disappointments.
Despite a string of delays and strangely quiet messaging from the major publishers, 2022 has been a banner year for video games. Between insanely high-quality titles like Elden Ring and Horizon: Forbidden West, to impactful surprises like Sifu and The Quarry, the first half of the year has had something for players to sink their teeth into every single week.
Of course, this is still the video game industry we're talking about, and with the sheer amount of titles that have dropped over the past few months, it's unsurprising that a chunk didn't quite hit the mark. Now, the following games aren't all bad (though there are one or two that are outright stinkers, undeniably), but they did fail to hit the high expectations fans had set for them in the run up to release. That doesn't make them unworthy playing, just that they all had the potential to be far better than they ended up being.
So, whether they were pushed out the door before they were finished cooking, prioritised the wrong features, or simply crumbled under the pressure, these games ended up being big disappointments.
10. Lego Star Wars: The Skywalker Saga
There have been so many games that have had reportedly nightmarish development process during the COVID pandemic. Already difficult working conditions in some cases haven't been helped by remote working leading to longer time spent on a project than intended, and as such it should be commended that these games released at all, thanks to the hard work of quality developers. That said, the extra time spent getting a game over the finish line hasn't always resulted in masterpiece.
Case in point: Lego Star Wars: The Skywalker Saga.
Now this is probably the one game on the list that's difficult to get too worked up about. The latest Lego Star Wars is a fine game. It is ok. It is inoffensive. It is a video game.
There's ambition at the heart of it. Adapting nine movies with hundreds of characters takes skill to not crumble under the pressure, and the dedication to the variety of gameplay scenarios on display is to be applauded.
It's just that this should be the ultimate Star Wars package, yet it's missing the magic found in the earlier Lego games. There's a lot to do here, but little drive for players to feel motivated to engage with much of it.
If it's your first Lego game, it'll no doubt be a blast. For longtime fans though, it's just another to add to the pile.
9. Shadow Warrior 3
For about two hours, Shadow Warrior 3 is one of the best surprises of the year. A graphically impressive, kinetic first-person shooter that'll appeal to all the Doom Eternal fans out there, this anarchic sequel is a turn-your-brain off spectacle. Sadly, it can't quite sustain that momentum for even its paltry five-hour runtime.
The initially-blistering firefights become tiresome when you realise the whole game can be boiled down to entering similarly laid-out arenas and fighting the same waves of enemies. There's some parkour platforming to connect these combat engagements, but even that is basic and rote after a while.
Shadow Warrior 3 can still be a fine time if you throw a podcast on over the top and just blast away (which I'd recommend because, while boasting some committed vocal performances, the game's attempts at humour come thick and fast and quickly become grating), but it's a shame to see it run out of steam so early when it makes such a strong first impression.
8. Rainbow Six: Extraction
Had Rainbow Six: Extraction, a three-player, PVE spin-off from Rainbow Six: Siege, released a few years ago, it probably would have received a warmer welcome.
Another game on this list that was inundated with delays (and even a name change), Extraction limped out the door all the way back in January of this year. Six months later, it's tough to remember it even happened.
Rather than fending off terrorists, this time around players team up to take on an alien infestation that's slowly taking over the human population. Sent into the quarantine zone, players are tasked with moving through the levels, using each specialist's unique skills to get out to the other side in one piece.
With a few friends at your side, Extraction can be fun enough. As far as PVE co-op games go, it's more polished and engaging than, say, Aliens: Fireteam from 2021. Still, that doesn't mean it's particularly good, and after so many years in development, it makes you wonder why Ubisoft didn't opt for a quicker turnaround to release it as an extension of Rainbow Six: Siege.
7. Gran Turismo 7
Like so many of the entries on this list, Gran Turismo 7's placement comes with a caveat. When I reviewed Sony's premier racer, I praised it for its astonishing level of detail, bevvy of content, and for having some of the most engaging, tactile driving sim gameplay options available right now. For the first week or so, things were hunky dory - Gran Turismo was back on top.
And then, those pesky microtransactions started to rear their ugly heads.
While the core progression of GT7 initially rewarded you with a healthy amount of in-game currency for completing circuits, allowing you to buy new cars and upgrade the ones you already owned at a satisfying frequency, post-release updates made this process a far larger grind by limiting the amount these races paid out.
Backlash ensued, as fans were furious that they were being pushed to buying in-game currency with real-world money in order to afford the title's top tier cars. While this kind of post-release microtransaction push is expected from the likes of Activision and EA, to see it in a Sony first-party title was a major disappointment.
6. Trek To Yomi
Trek to Yomi is one of the most divisive games of the year. This stunning black-and-white Samurai tale is one of the most graphically impressive 2022 releases, perfectly evoking the cinematic icons it takes inspiration from. Sadly, that beauty is all surface level, as Trek to Yomi is far more fun to look at than play.
Having the misfortune to come a few months after Sifu delivered a supremely tight and responsive take on parry-based action, Trek to Yomi's side-scrolling swordplay is lacking from the very first combat encounter. Admittedly beautifully animated, the gameplay lacks depth and satisfying feedback, quickly becoming repetitive and un-engaging.
Even worse, Yomi becomes a downright chore on hard mode. Instead of emphasising the methodical and precise strikes of the katana, combat at this level is simply an unbalanced, frustrating mess.
Trek to Yomi does have its merits - it's clear to see why some fans (including our own Scott Tailford) became enamoured with its subversive plot and gorgeous presentation - but it's a shame the gameplay throws up major roadblocks that stop you from actually appreciating them.
5. Dying Light 2
Dying Light 2 is far from a bad game. Its massive, detailed open world has been intricately crafted to compliment the game's first-person parkour; the zombie combat is as satisfying as ever; and the weapon variety is genuinely impressive.
However, this long-overdue sequel is only intermittently fun, as the developers put so much focus on the story this time around that it interrupts the free-flowing open-world anarchy. Part of the reason the game took so long to release was that the devs wanted to transform Dying Light into a fully-fledged RPG, with Bethesda-style branching paths, a whole host of side missions and so, so much dialogue.
Sadly, the game doesn't have the calibre of writing to match those ambitions, with many of the characters appearing one-note, the moral choices being blatantly obvious, and the central narrative devolving into bland tropes that are neither scary nor exciting.
Most story missions pit you against human enemies rather than the walking dead (a mistake Aliens: Colonial Marines also made), certain mechanics are incredibly dated (Dying Light 2 has the same lockpick mechanic as Fallout 3(!)), and graphically, the game doesn't look all that advanced.
There's fun to be had here, but it's buried under so much bloat that really, really wasn't worth the extended wait.
4. Ghostwire Tokyo
Ghostwire Tokyo was potentially always doomed for a life of obscurity. Initially revealed as a PS5 exclusive, its thunder was well and truly taken away when its developers were bought by Microsoft. As such, this title inevitably felt like a holdover, rather than the PS5 shifter it could have been.
Sadly, in its current state, Ghostwire Tokyo probably wouldn't been all that valuable to Sony as a killer app anyway. Despite boasting a tantalising setting in ghost-ridden Tokyo, alongside some visually spectacular spell-casting FPS combat, the game's repetition, bloated runtime and meandering story stopped it from living up to its potential.
Which is a true shame, because developers Tango Gameworks were coming off one of the best horror games of the decade in The Evil Within 2. However, if you put that incredible title side by side with this middling one, you might not even realise they were made by the same people.
3. Stranger Of Paradise: Final Fantasy Origin
Even more so than usual, Square Enix has been all-in on Final Fantasy recently. With Final Fantasy 16 and the second part of the 7 Remake trilogy both slated for next year, Squeenix has bolstered that slate with a string of high-budget spin-offs.
However, the first of note of these, Stranger of Paradise: Final Fantasy Origin, didn't inspire the kind of fan response the publisher probably wanted. Acting as something of a remixed version of the very first Final Fantasy, Stranger of Paradise pitches itself as a love letter to the franchise, with series-wide nods littered throughout. Sadly, these homages just make you wish for the creative ingenuity that defined those past games, which is sadly missing here.
This time around you play as Jack, a man who is definitely Some Guy, that's for sure, who courts a party of other powerful fighters to trawl through dungeons for higher-tier loot. Those other party members can this time around be controlled by real-life players too, with Stranger of Paradise dipping its toes into co-op antics.
Developer Team Ninja does a a serviceable job with the combat, mixing Final Fantasy 7's combat with the mechanics found in their own series, Nioh, but even that's buried over cumbersome inventory screens and bland map design.
2. Crossfire X
Now, there's probably more than a few people out there saying: "Josh, Crossfire X can't be disappointing, because everyone knew it was going to be a forgettable dud from the moment it was announced."
And yes, this generic FPS did look dead on arrival from its very first trailer, but it did have one element that raised expectations quite considerably: the fact that its single-player campaign had been developed by the always-reliable Remedy Entertainment.
Sadly, the Max Payne and Control makers couldn't salvage this mundane and monotonous military shooter. Lacking the spark of madness that defines even the studio's weakest efforts, Crossfire X's campaign feels like a contractual obligation, one knocked out for the money so the team had enough resources to make the stuff they really feel passionate about, like the upcoming Alan Wake 2.
Despite releasing straight to Game Pass, Crossfire X failed to find an audience, and at the time of writing is one of the most critically lambasted games of the year.
1. Diablo Immortal
How do you take one of the most beloved franchises and make a game with it that ends up the worst rated in the history of Metacritic? Well, you stuff it full of microtransactions of course!
Blizzard's biggest embarrassment since Warcraft: Reforged (which was only two years ago, to put how useless they've become in context), Diablo Immortal, the controversial free-to-play mobile and PC spin-off to the iconic dungeon crawling series, actually initially received rave reviews. Critics and players responded well to the game's addictive combat and progression, with the solid graphics being the icing on the cake. For a while, it looked as though Blizzard had turned a sinking ship around.
And then, after about 20 hours or so, the game started to show its true colours. Suddenly, the once-enjoyable experience became a hell of nickel-and-diming microtransaction storefronts with apparently shockingly stingy drop rates.
YouTubers began spending thousands of dollars on the in-game store, only to be rewarded with a handful of decent items thanks to the title's RNG system. Quickly, word spread that getting the top-tier gear would set you back potentially hundreds of thousands of dollars if you weren't prepared to grind out hundreds of hours.
At the time of writing, the backlash is only continuing to grow - no doubt cementing Diablo Immortal as yet another Blizzard-released stinker.