10 Most Evil Choices In Video Games

Narcissist, sadist, psychopath... or just curious. Which one are you?

star wars knights of the old republic
Bioware

Choice is highly regarded as a vital piece of storytelling in many modern story-based video games. Of any creative medium, video games are the most immersible as you are controlling the main character, as opposed to television or film where you simply watch them navigate their respective fictional worlds.

Whether it be lines of dialogue, whether to shoot someone or not or decisions that impact how a game ends, the modern player loves to be able to create reflections of themselves in the game. This trend emerged from MMORPG titles such as World of Warcraft and Runescape, where your character has no preset of defined narrative path or personality.

Players could play however they want.

This included role-playing as the villain of the narrative.

Many people enjoy wreaking havoc and chaos in the lives of others, murdering the innocent and being a genuine bad guy simply because they enjoy it more. In many single-player open-world RPGs, there are constant choices to be made by the player that can impact the entire world they inhabit, and not all are for the good of the realm.

In fact, quite the opposite.

10. Spoiling The Urn Of Sacred Ashes - Dragon Age: Origins

dragon age origins
Bioware

Just like many of BioWare's RPG titles, Dragon Age: Origins is a game built upon player choice. Whether it be off-hand interactions with shopkeepers or a decision that will affect the entire world your character inhabits, this first instalment of the Dragon Age franchise has you covered.

One of the worst things you can decide to do is spoil the Urn of Sacred Ashes. For those of you unaware, the urn contains the ashes of the Andraste; a prophet whose teachings form the Chantry, which is the presiding religion in the game world.

You are originally sent to Frostback Mountain in search of the ashes to retrieve some and heal the Arl of Redcliffe, who can be a huge help in the upcoming battle against the Archdemon. Once you reach the mountains, however, you meet a group named the Disciples of Andraste. The leader of the cult tasks you with destroying the ashes instead, as they believe that Andraste has been reborn in the form of a High Dragon.

Taking a pinch of ashes can help save the world. Defiling the ashes gains the player-character the reaver specialisation tree.

Choose the latter, and you've destroyed the most sacred artefact of an entire religion just to be able to scare your enemies.

Good job.


9. Killing A Family OR Spreading Malaria? - Assassin's Creed: Odyssey

Assassins creed odyssey
Ubisoft

Nothing from this decision will leave you feeling all warm and fuzzy inside in the long run.

On your travels you come across a village that has been razed to the ground, with the only survivors being a family of four. Two guards and a priest stand in judgement over them. When you approach, you discover that the village had been tormented by Malaria, and they had to resort to destroying it and killing everyone that was sick to prevent it from spreading.

From the pleading family with two small children to the implied threats by the priest, every interaction in this scene sets up saving the family as being the right choice. How could such nice people possibly harm anyone? If you choose to side with the family, they will flee and you will be forced to kill the guards, and you can leave the burned village feeling like a very good Samaritan.

Allowing the family to be killed turns out to not be as evil as it once seemed.

After they flee, they end up spreading Malaria to the entire island of Kephallonia, possibly damning hundreds of people to a slow and painful death. In what is a contorted adage to Philippa Foot's trolley problem, it seems the 'evil' choice was actually allowing the family to live.


8. Force Norman Further Into Addiction - Heavy Rain

Heavy Rain
Quantic Dream

There are many tough decisions to be made to save Shaun and uncover the Origami Killer, but one of the worst decisions you can actively make is forcing FBI Agent Norman Jayden further into his addiction to a fictional narcotic named Triptocaine.

Whilst there are a couple of instances in the game where he consumes the substance regardless, there are many cases where you can block him from indulging in this mind-altering drug. Norman initially began to use Tripto to enhance his focus whilst using ARI (Added Reality Interface) - an experimental technology used to help investigate crime scenes more effectively - but is constantly at risk of suffering withdrawals.

Norman becomes obsessed with catching the Origami Killer, but because of his over-reliance on ARI and his ever-closing window to uncover the true killer before Ethan is framed, Norman indulges in Tripto again in the mission 'Solving the Puzzle'.

Norman can die in this mission, as he suffers severe bleeding from his eyes and nose as a result of a combination of the ARI and Tripto.

Giving into or resisting his addiction does not affect the ending of the story, which makes the player forcing Norman to spiral further into addiction all the worse.


7. Sacrifice Your Friends - Far Cry 3

Far Cry 3
UbiSoft

Whilst holidaying on a beautiful remote island, brothers Grant and Jason Brody face capture by a savage group of pirates led by Vaas and Hoyt Volker. With the player assuming the role of Jason, the duo unsuccessfully attempt to escape with your older brother Grant being killed in front of you. Fleeing deep into the woods, you are saved by the island's natives named the Rakyat.

Jason learns that the rest of his travelling companions - including his girlfriend, Liza, and younger brother, Riley - are alive but scattered across the island. After the leader of the Rakyat, Citra, initiates Jason into their tribe, Jason works on liberating the island, gradually finding his friends in the process.

Together they begin to repair a boat in the hopes of escaping.

Jason and his allies kill Vaas and Volker, ending their drug and slave rings and finally liberating the Rakyat. Citra is not finished here though.

She captures Jason's friends, stating that Jason must kill them and remain on the island so that they may procreate and give birth to a legendary warrior that will lead the Rakyat to glory. Should Jason choose to kill his friends (whom he has just murdered literally hundreds of people to save) he will be stabbed to death by Citra in a ritual.


6. Execute An Android For Information - Detroit: Become Human

Detroit Become Human
Quantic Dream

Detroit: Become Human is designed to completely question your interpretation of society. As androids begin to develop self-awareness to the point of feeling emotions and forming attachments, should they be welcomed into the general public as equals of humans or be wiped out lest they usurp humanity at the most dominant species?

You play as three androids: Kara, Marcus and Connor. Kara and Marcus become 'deviants' (the name for self-aware androids) regardless of the player's decisions, but you may choose to play Connor precisely how the android had been programmed to operate.

Acting as an aid to the Detroit City Police Department, it is Connor's initial task to investigate the deviants and put an end to their uprising alongside the human police lieutenant Hank Anderson. Fairly late into Connor's story, he uncovers a new lead: Elijah Kamski, the creator of CyberLife.

Here, Kamski offers Connor a choice: he will answer Connor's questions if he executes another android named Chloe right then and there.

Depending on your interaction with the game and its themes, you may be starting to see androids as having the potential to function as humans, including having the capacity to feel pain and sadness. Should Connor kill Chloe to receive potentially useless information, it is not too far away from murder.


5. Murder The Rescue Team - Spec Ops: The Line

Spec Ops The Line Sad
2K Games

Gentlemen, welcome to Dubai.

You play as Lieutenant Martin Walker. Alongside your companions in Delta Squad, you must traverse a destroyed Dubai to track down the 33rd Infantry Battalion, led by Colonel John Konrad, who went rogue by defying orders and staying behind to try and save the civilians there.

With the 33rd having gone rogue, the CIA trying to cover up the USA's involvement and an uprising by the Dubai natives, Delta Squad are trapped in the middle, though their actions become more questionable as the plot progresses.

From executing unarmed prisoners to destroying Dubai's only water supply to dropping white phosphorous on a group of civilians, Walker seems to be becoming more and more unhinged as the story reaches its climax.

After finally finding Konrad, the player discovers that the Colonel has been dead this whole time, and it was, in fact, Walker that has been suffering from PTSD and perpetrating war crimes. If you don't kill yourself, you are found by a US military patrol and are presented with three options.

One of which is to cave into your own madness and kill the entire patrol, despite another option being to surrender peacefully and return home. A fantastic game for anyone looking for a military shooter that analyses the effect war has on a damaged human psyche.


4. Having Zaalbar Kill Mission - Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic

Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic KOTOR
Bioware

Set 4,000 years before the rise of the Galactic Empire, we are placed in the shoes of a young rebel who is fighting against the growing power of Darth Malak, a former Jedi turned to the dark side following his rise to power during the Mandalorian Wars.

Following Malak's attack on your Republic ship, you are forced to fight your way off of the soon-to-be-destroyed planet Taris. You gain many allies en route, including best friends Mission Vao (a Rutian Twi'lek) and Zaalbar (a Wookie).

After rescuing Jedi Knight Bastila Shan and beginning training to become a Jedi, the player's origin is revealed: you are Darth Revan, Darth Malak's former master, now brainwashed into serving the Jedi council. It is here that the player's alignment becomes vital.

Towards the end of the game you are presented with a choice: continue serving the Jedi or revert back to being a Sith Lord. Choosing the latter will cause many of your allies to turn on you, including Mission.

As Zaalbar owes the player a life debt (an extremely serious matter in Wookie culture) you can instruct the Wookie to betray and murder Mission, who will all the while scream 'no, please' and 'it's me, Big Z'.

A truly cruel act.


3. Harvesting Every Little Sister - Bioshock 2

bioshock 2 minervas den
2K Games

Returning to the haunting ocean city of Rapture once more, Bioshock 2 tells its story from a very different perspective. You play as an Alpha Series Big Daddy named Delta.

As a little history to this former paradise and its goings-on, the Big Daddies are biologically-enhanced humans exposed to a method named 'splicing'. This is when the chemical named ADAM is consumed to rewrite genetic material, or in other words, change their bodies.

The sole purpose of a Big Daddy is to protect their Little Sister. Each Big Daddy has their own, and Delta's is named Eleanor. The events of Bioshock 2 centre around Delta's attempts to find Eleanor, who was kidnapped by Sofia Lamb a decade before the game's plot.

As with many video games, there is a skill tree, and the quickest way of upgrading Delta's abilities is with ADAM. You can encounter many other Big Daddies throughout the game, and should you kill them, you are presented with a choice: you can either adopt their Little Sister or absorb them for their rich ADAM supply.

Don't let their odd appearance fool you; these Little Sisters are just genetically-modified children. Absorbing them for their ADAM kills them, meaning you are killing little girls to improve your abilities. It doesn't get much more heartless than that.


2. Choosing The Money - Fable 2

Fable 2 final choices ending
Lionhead Studios

Playing as a young boy named Sparrow, Fable 2 has you and your older sister, Rose, always dreaming of living in a castle. When offered a magical box for just five gold coins, the two young urchins become fascinated by the promise of something that may change their lives for the better.

They wish upon the box that they may live in Castle Fairfax, which oversees their small town, and sure enough, that night a guard comes to escort the siblings to see the ruler of the castle, Lucien. Not all is as it seems, however.

Lucien accuses one of either your or Rose of being a fourth 'Hero' from a prophecy of three, killing your sister and almost killing you as well. You are rescued by Theresa, and a decade later, you embark on your mission to stop Lucien before he can rebuild the Tattered Spire and gain unworldly power.

You and the other three heroes are successful in your mission, and with Lucien dead, Theresa offers you three choices. You can either resurrect the thousands of slaves Lucien used to reconstruct the Tattered Spire, resurrect your family (including your sister, dog and wife if you married) or receive one million coins.

Thousands of innocent lives? Nah. Your loved ones? Forget about them.

A stack of gold is clearly what Sparrow wants after his agonising and heartbreaking journey.


1. Destroying Megaton - Fallout 3

fallout 3 megaton
Bethesda

In the apocalyptic wasteland of America, following nuclear warfare between the USA and China over diminishing natural resources, we find The Lone Wanderer.

After emerging from the only home he had ever known in Vault 101, The Lone Wanderer ventures out to find his father, who mysteriously left the Vault without saying a word about his destination.

One of the earliest locations that you come across in the Capital Wasteland is a city named Megaton, aptly named after the un-detonated nuclear bomb resting in the heart of the oversized shantytown. A quest named 'The Power of the Atom' is given with two optional objectives: disarm or detonate the bomb.

Lucas Simms, a Megaton resident and the sheriff of its population, wants the bomb disarmed to ensure the ongoing safety of the city residents. Mister Burke wants you to detonate the bomb as his employer believes Megaton to be an eyesore on the horizon.

That's right. Burke wants an entire city and community wiped out because he thinks it's an ugly view from the Tenpenny Tower.

There are multiple routes that this mission can go, including the deaths of both Burke and Simms regardless of what happens to the bomb, but blowing up a city and it's people just because it's not pretty to look at is undoubtedly evil.


Contributor

Lover of all things zombie. Secretly wishing for the apocalypse, but only on easy difficulty. Top of the world leaderboards for a couple of songs on Pro Drums on Rock Band 4. Can name every world flag. Currently doing my MA in Creative Writing in an attempt to do something with my life.