10 Most Frustrating Spells For Dungeon Masters

"Please don't cast it...please don't cast it....please don't cast it..."

dungeons and dragons
Wizards of the Coast

Dungeons and Dragons puts the world at the fingertips of players. In the ultimate fantasy, players can shape characters who can bend the world to their will through the use of a variety of physical and magical abilities. Whether you want to fly, be able to detect anyone telling a lie, or simply will a pile of gold into existence, there are very few things accomplished players cannot accomplish.

That doesn't mean, However, that every spell is a welcome sight. For Dungeon Masters, those dedicated individuals who craft adventures for the players to undertake, there are some spells which are whispered in hushed tones. Those that they can only wait with baited breath, hoping against hope they won't have their plans immediately ruined for yet again.

But then the inevitable happens. A complex series of situations, hazards, and obstacles laid before the party, guaranteeing an evening of challenging fun is off the table with a few simple spells. Good Dungeon Masters often prepare for such eventualities, but players are often so empowered its unlikely they can defend against all of them.

Here are ten spells guaranteed to keep poor Dungeon Masters up at night, cradling their stuffed Owlbear.

10. Create Food & Water

food spread
Library

Beginning the list is one of the most situational spells in Dungeons and Dragons, but the role that it fills is almost always that of a drama-killer.

While D&D is often a game of great power, it is possible to use the environment to the game's advantage in order to introduce some difficult survival mechanics. Setting it in a barren desert or a brutal tundra suddenly makes survival a difficult matter.

Shelter, fire, food, and water become far more than simply paying for a night at the local inn: they become a secondary layer of challenge that can become engrossing to players.

And here is where Create Food and Water comes into play. For the cost of a third level spell, players can create either 45 pounds of food or 30 gallons of water. Suddenly, all that struggle, all that clawing for the joy of living another day is utterly extinguished.

The spell similarly can ruin conflicts throughout towns adventurers might encounter. Towns suffering from a drought or a famine need no longer be an issue once someone with the spell rides into the village. In the end, the spell feels like it cheapens the experience of the game rather than enhances it.


9. Polymorph

American Werewolf in London - transformation
Universal Pictures

Make no mistake: Polymorph is an absolutely terrific spell. With this spell, an individual can change themselves, an ally, or even an enemy to a particular beast for an hour. Thinking of things in this capacity, Polymorph's reliability in non-combat situations is incredible.

Looking to conduct reconnaissance as a harmless fly that doesn't draw attention, or turning into a cockroach that's too light to trigger traps down a particularly nasty corridor, and Polymorph can be an amazing and versatile asset.

However, too often this spell devolves into turning allies into one of two creatures: a Giant Ape or a Dinosaur, typically a T-Rex. Both of these both deal and absorb a great deal of damage and...that's it.

Conversely, because the spell is so good and available to so many, players can pile onto a big bad in order to force them to make save after save until they ultimately fail and take them out of the fight by turning them into something harmless for an hour.

Ultimately, while it is typically an amazing ability, it tends to only have a handful of ways parties tend to implement it, which sadly limits the group overall.


8. Suggestion

Shadow Of Mordor Mind Control Brand
Monolith

Mind magics can be some of the potent in Dungeons and Dragons. Being able to coerce or command people or creatures to act at your discretion can completely upend an encounter towards the party's advantage. However, one might expect doing so to be a difficult task, given the potency of the impact. Suggestion packs a massive psychic punch for an incredibly low cost.

The primary issue stems from the vagueness of the spell's description. The caster can say a couple sentences, rationalizing a course of action for an individual to take. Then, if they fail a save, they simply do it. Not only that, but it lasts for up to 8 hours!

For the cost of a 2nd level spell, players can boss someone around for a full day. Now granted, victims of the spell cannot be told to do anything obviously harmful, but the open-ended nature of the spell leans in favor of game-breaking suggestions.

After all, maybe its a good idea to give the players that super-rare magical item? Or perhaps allowing them access into a forbidden area they shouldn't discover until far later in the narrative? Suggestion's potential to completely ruin a game in the hands of irresponsible players cannot be overlooked.


7. Banishment

dungeons and dragons
Wizards of the Coast

For those who have never run a game of D&D before, it's not easy. Dungeons masters craft plots, scenarios, settings, motivations, and must balance battles so that they are challenging without being unfair to players while also not making them so easy that players are bored.

With this in mind, few spells arouse such a sense of wasted time as Banishment. This spell, which forces a Charisma saving throw (which, surprisingly, many wretched horrible monsters are not strong against). If the monster fails its save, they are blinked to an entire plane of existence for one minute.

To make matters even worse, if that creature is not a denizen of the plane they inhabit - like if the party is fighting a demon, for instance - they are sent back to their home plane and don't get to return. That's it; fight's over.

Even if they get to come back, the party gets an entire minute to prepare. Once this thing pops back into existence, the entire group will get an entire free round to hit it with every big attack in their arsenal until the threat is dispatched.

It's a cool idea the first instance. But once it is shown to be effective, players will have a hard time resisting the urge to try this tactic every single time.


6. Conjure Woodland Beings

Blue fairy AI
Amblin

If you want a surefire way to irritate the everyone at the table, this is the spell to do it. Now, that shouldn't discount players from using it, but there is such an aura of disdain on it, that players need to be very careful in their approach.

Simply put, this spell lets nature-based spellcasters bring forth a whole host of extra fey creatures. Even worse, the books specifically says the Dungeon Master has the statistics, thereby making it their responsibility to provide you with every possible selection a player could make.

Used in combat, this slows down things enormously, with an additional 1-8 additional creatures requiring their own turns, turning a thrilling battle into an absolute slog.

Worse still is the infamous "Pixie/Polymorph" special. With this spell, players can bring forth 8 Pixies, each with the ability to cast things like Polymorph and Invisibility. As long as you keep those little flying critters safe, that essentially gives the entire group over 150 bonus hit points at no cost to themselves and the potential to move about unseen.

All of that at the cost of a 4th level spell. At that point, why even have a combat encounter?


5. Shield

X Men 1 Jim Lee
Marvel Comics

One huge downside of being a spellcaster is a paltry armor class. Simply put, if you aren't taking specific feats to help with this, you wind up being exceptionally easy to hit with lower hit points than virtually anyone else in the game. Attacking the wizard or sorcerer is a cause for extreme concern, because players know they're living on borrowed time.

As such, its almost impossible to create one of these characters without taking the Shied spell. With a simple reaction, the defense of a spellcaster is increased by 5 with only a first-level spell. All that planning and moving of forces to get at the heavy magic user at the back is negated when their armor winds up rivaling the burly Fighter in front wearing plate mail.

Its low cost and duration (the rest of an entire round of combat) means that one of the glaring vulnerabilities of a class is made inconsequential by this ability. Ask any set of Dungeon Masters and they'll be sure to regale you of the innumerable times in which they nearly laid a Wizard low, only to be foiled by this simple spell over and over again.


4. Find Traps

Admiral Ackbar - It's A Trap!
Lucasfilm

What are some of the hallmarks of Dungeons and Dragons? Besides...erm, dungeons. And also dragons. Okay, how about treasure? Beasts, for certain? Traps? Now we're talking.

When it comes to spells, few things is as frustrating as a simple spell that ruins a long-term plan in a dungeon. After all, traps are designed to test the planning and capabilities of several of your party members while draining some of their resources.

That all ends with this spell. Again, for only a second level spell, players can confirm or deny the presence of traps within 120 feet. Now while this spell doesn't inherently reveal what kind of traps or what giveaways there might be, more often than not, it tends to grind the game to a halt. Suddenly, exploration takes a back seat while players creep along bit by bit making rolls until they can find and disarm the trap.

There's nothing inherently wrong with using magical means to sniff out traps, but players wind up spamming this ability as many times as they can the first time they get burned on a trap in a dungeon, making a long, slow exploration into an absolute slog.


3. Leomund's Tiny Hut/Mordenkainen's Magnificent Mansion

Disneyland Haunted Mansion
Disneyland

"Adventuring" is supposed to be the most enjoyable part of an adventuring party. After all, that's what the game is designed for: the thrill of unknown peril and riches all at the tips of a ragtag group of heroes. But what if someone just decided to take all of the risk out of that?

That's the theme of both of these spells. Leomund's Tiny Hut and its big Brother, Mordenkainen's Magnificent Mansion are both designed to give players a reprieve from the dangers of the outside world. The Hut is designed as a dome of pure magical energy that is climate-controlled, indestructible, and can change its color so that people cannot see through it while those inside can look out.

The Mansion is an entirely different beast altogether. In essence a pocket dimension, a door appears out of nowhere and allows for an entire mansion to be created with whatever characters need inside. Spectral servants, food, luxurious rooms, all available at the very thought of its creator.

Meanwhile, those cool ambushes or plot hooks that the Dungeon Master had crafted for the night go entirely missed. These spells simply remove the players from the outside world, giving them ample time to lick their wounds, plan, and, otherwise, refuse to deal with consequences outside of their little magical plot of land.


2. Counterspell

Rowena spell
The CW

Dungeons and Dragons is, at its heart, a power fantasy. Players, and that includes Dungeon Masters, thrill at all of their amazing new capabilities. Whether that means resurrecting an ally from the dead as a Life Cleric, or incinerating a battlefield with Evocation Wizardy, there's a certain glee in getting to show off amazing otherworldly feats.

And that is why Counterspell is just the worst. This spell, cast as a reaction, interrupts any spell being cast, causing to essentially fizzle out. Now granted, there is a roll required if trying to cast a spell stronger than what you are using, but generally it isn't terribly difficult to achieve given a player's existing modifiers.

Now there is certainly some satisfaction in disrupting the plans of an enemy, but players will often find that a Counterspell often leads to disappointing combat. After all, it essentially wastes a villain's turn, leaving them forced to wait for the entire round of combat to reset before trying again.

By the time that rolls around, players have probably spent an entire round attacking, dodging, casting spells of their own, and generally forcing an entirely new strategy.

For a game that is built on the premise of being able to do anything, a spell that dictates that the Dungeon Master can instead do nothing is a real buzzkill.


1. Dispel Magic

Jace Magic
Wizards of the Coast

If Counterspell plagues Dungeon Masters for its ability to stop something before it can even begin, then Dispel Magic is its unbearable sassy cousin. Dispel Magic is, at its core, a magical off-switch. With this spell, players can end the effects of a creature, object, or magical effect.

While Counterspell is potent, its effects tend to be inherently limited to combat most of the time. Dispel magic can be used, as written, in virtually endless scenarios. Magic wards that prevent traversal through doors. Magical traps, spell effects meant to strengthen or weaken characters, all of them can now simply be removed, swinging things in the player's favor.

As has been the theme with most of these spells, the ability to circumvent plans rather than overcome them is present throughout. And with it being a key 3rd-level spell, its usefulness is so pervasive, similar to spells like Counterspell and Fireball, that few players go without it if they have the option, further narrowing the customized aspect of characters.

For a finely-constructed, optimized, meticulously crafted dungeon and its Dungeon Master, no spell strikes fear into the heart of plans quite like Dispel Magic.


Contributor

A former Army vet who kept his sanity running D&D games for his Soldiers. I'll have a bit of D&D, pro wrestling, narrative-driven video games, and 80's horror movies, please and thank you.