10 Most Hated Mobile Games From Great Video Game Franchises
Diablo Immortal isn't out yet, and already it's one of the most hated mobile games ever.
In November 2018, Lead Game Designer Wyatt Cheng stepped forward on stage, clad in Diablo merchandise to a rapturous reception from fans at that year’s BlizzCon, raising hopes of a long-awaited sequel to 2012’s Diablo III.
As it turned out, the audience was in for a slightly giddy pitch for a limp sounding multiplayer mobile game. It’s fair to say those in attendance were less than impressed, evidenced by a hostile question and answer session, and general widespread heckling that quickly went viral.
Now, the game is still in development, and tech demos are only just emerging on YouTube, but with the disastrous announcement already so firmly etched into gaming folklore, it would have to be an absolute masterpiece, beyond anything we’ve ever seen on the platform, in order to turn around the lack of goodwill towards the title.
This raises the question: what are some other great gaming franchises that have already fallen foul of the fans by releasing a mobile title that was a not up to the standard of the series, or with an uninspired cash grab to exploit an existing market desperate for a new major release?
Here are the 10 most despised mobile titles from otherwise brilliant lines of games.
10. Harry Potter: Hogwarts Mystery
Harry Potter: Hogwarts Mystery is undoubtedly one of the worst games on this list, and may have featured higher if it were from a more highly acclaimed series. The name Harry Potter isn’t the first thing that springs to mind when discussing great gaming franchises, but they actually consistently licensed good titles, including a memorable Game Boy Color release tied to the first movie, and a well regarded sports game in Harry Potter: Quidditch World Cup, amongst others.
The 2018 release was a first venture into the modern Android and iOS market for Potter, and was met with instant resistance for its slow gameplay and aggressive monetisation in a game largely marketed to children. The game was an uninspired RPG set as a prequel to the Harry Potter series, and delivered very little of what fans were looking for.
Things would improve for the J. K. Rowling series on mobile with the following year’s Wizards Unite, a Pokémon Go style game that players were generally more keen on.
9. The Elder Scrolls: Blades
We will be coming up on the tenth anniversary of The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim in 2021, with little indication of a sixth major instalment on the horizon any time soon. The frustrating thing for fans is that in the time since, publisher Bethesda did find time to release the disastrous Fallout 76, and this mobile title based in Tamriel.
Blades is not completely without its merits. Say what you want about the playability of some Bethesda releases, but the characters and narrative rarely disappoint, which they don’t here, given the limited hardware. However, the game was criticised for its generic grind-filled gameplay and lack of free roaming elements. Part of this was through the impatience of people not placated by an unfulfilling stopgap in the Elder Scrolls series, although it does have fans in its own right.
The game was also later released for the Switch, with a neat ability to cross save across platforms and access a saved game on either device, but was no better received on console.
8. Forza Street
The Forza series has had its ups and downs since hitting the scene in 2005, being established to rival the quality of PlayStation exclusive Gran Turismo as the premium racing simulation experience on the Xbox range.
Unfortunately, 2020’s Forza Street release for mobile did not follow the well-established recipe, moving away from their ForzaTech engine developed with the series, instead using an adapted version of an Unreal engine. The result was a disappointing racer that did not fit with the gameplay quality across the major Forza releases, with one Forbes writer describing it as a “stain” on the name of the series.
Frankly, there aren't many who would be willing to call that an unfair assessment, Street remains the most recent Forza game, with Forza Motorsport announced as the first upcoming title for the Xbox Series X/S. Fans will be hoping this is more in the vein of the recent successes in main series games, rather than this mobile misstep.
7. Tony Hawk’s Skate Jam
The Tony Hawk series began by riding the wave of the boom in interest in extreme sports at the turn of the millennium, converting this into console-defining early releases, and even a second generation, with the likes of American Wasteland and Project 8 still being very good games into the second half of the 2000s. The largely unplayable Tony Hawk Ride would release in 2009, and the franchise has still not really ever recovered.
Tony Hawk’s Skate Jam was unfortunately part of the latter group of games, releasing on mobile in 2018 to much the same criticisms the rest of the series had been receiving for almost a decade, including bad physics, and a dearth of new ideas for the license, with added microtransactions to boot.
At this point there have been so many failed attempted reboots of the series that it is difficult to see where they go next. With remakes of Pro Skater 1 & 2 a rare hit in 2020, it would not be a surprise to see them look at further remasters for current consoles, and with any luck, stay away from the mobile market for a while.
6. Tom Clancy’s Elite Squad
Some games have the ability to overcome a buggy release, or slightly bland gameplay, particularly when backed with an established audience and major games studio. Unfortunately for Ubisoft’s 2020 release, Elite Squad, making a success of a game that struggles with both issues may prove to be a lost cause.
The game appeared in a less than completely finished state and was derided for being a generic title with gameplay that largely passes the player by, complete with a Tom Clancy skin. The Tom Clancy series has been remarkably consistent on home consoles, but it does seem to struggle to translate into a portable format, with a number of mobile and handheld releases falling flat.
The Rainbow Six series is set to return in 2021 after a six year hiatus with the aptly named Quarantine, and fans will hope it takes inspiration from the successes of the Division games, as opposed to this attempt at a quick cash grab.
5. Ridge Racer Accelerated
In fairness, Ridge Racer may have long stopped being a premium racing series by the time of the release of 2009’s Accelerated. The franchise’s games had been a revolutionary arcade experience, before transitioning well onto various ‘90s and early ‘00s consoles. The series would not be able to keep up as Gran Turismo, Project Gotham, and Forza forged ahead to the next generations, but it certainly had its time at the top.
A common theme by this point in the series, the game would already be a little outdated by the time it came to market, for the most part being a port of 2006’s Ridge Racer 2 for the PSP, complete with all of the awkwardly recalibrated controls, and jarring gameplay tweaks that could be expected from jamming a portable game onto a touchscreen phone.
Ridge Racer Accelerated proved to be one of the final nails in the coffin of the franchise, with no current plans to follow up on the most recent release, also for mobile, in the four years since Ridge Racer Draw & Drift.
4. Pokémon Rumble Rush
Fallout 76 gets a second mention on a list it doesn’t even feature on here, but it is helpful to explain the issues with Pokémon Rumble Rush. Many Fallout fans were sceptical even before release. If the series had great stories, and well crafted worlds, but slightly ropey mechanics and gameplay, why would you release a largely story-free online game reliant on said dodgy engine?
Rumble Rush is another such miscalculation, offering a tweaked version of the gym battle system from Pokémon Go that has never sat particularly well with fans of the series, but with none of the fun of its more superior mobile cousin, or main series games. Even other mobile games like the endearingly stylised Pokémon Quest or the simple charm of Magikarp Jump are streets ahead in terms of entertainment value, leaving this one at the bottom of the pile in terms of Pokémon mobile games.
Whilst if the last 25 years have proved anything, it’s that you can slap Pokémon branding on pretty much anything and make money, too many games like this would eventually see the whole brand devalued.
3. RollerCoaster Tycoon 4 Mobile
Amusement park management sims have long been a surprisingly competitive slice of the games market, with RollerCoaster Tycoon battling it out with the Theme Park franchise across the decades, as well as a fair few branded entries, particularly under the Jurassic Park banner, operating in a very similar manner.
Sadly, 2014’s RollerCoaster Tycoon 4 Mobile can be described as part of the series in name only, with many bemoaning the lack of involvement from series creator Chris Sawyer. The game, which was confusingly not the fourth in a series of mobile games, nor an adaptation of the fourth game of the PC series, was always ill-suited for a format with in-built wait times, and much less in-depth management functions than had come to be expected in the franchise.
To make the anthology of mobile games in the series even more unclear, RollerCoaster Tycoon 3: Mobile would be released one year later, this time as a more or less straight port of the 2004 PC game RollerCoaster Tycoon 3, which was much better received.
2. Diablo Immortal
Number two on this list and not even released yet, the announcement of Diablo Immortal provoked such venom that it inspired this whole article. For a short period video game websites buckled under the weight of articles on the subject, and YouTube commentators picked through the carcass for days afterwards, but luckily for the team, Fallout 76 (yes, again) would release within a fortnight, taking the heat off for the time being.
The Diablo series had built up a dedicated fan base, with Diablo III still surprisingly active today. The games can probably be considered the pinnacle of dungeon crawlers, infused with uniquely engaging dark fantasy theme.
The message to Blizzard was clear, and a proper announcement for Diablo IV was made at the following year’s BlizzCon, with a release anticipated for 2021. Time will tell if Immortal has distracted the developer from its main series, or if the strength of feeling on display has given them even more impetus to get things right.
1. Final Fantasy: All The Bravest
The early Final Fantasy games look perfect for a reimagining on mobile, don’t they? The unmistakeable sprites, and turn based combat style would appear to be a perfect match for mobile hardware.
Unfortunately, Square Enix really dropped the ball with this one, producing the second lowest rated iOS game of all time according to Metacritic, runner-up only to a horrendous Kick-Ass tie-in. Cutting out the beautiful, interweaving, fantasy stories synonymous with the franchise, the game would focus on continuous battling with oversimplified combat, with the main aim seemingly to bait fans of Final Fantasy into paying out for collectible characters from the series, also available via loot box mechanics.
The 2013 mobile game came during a significant wobble in the quality of the Final Fantasy releases, coming on the tails of 2010’s Final Fantasy XIV, a game so disappointing it would take three years to completely rethink. Thankfully it does seem the series is now back on track, and we are unlikely to see the likes of All The Bravest again any time soon.