10 Most Overrated Video Games Of 2016

Game of the Year? No chance.

Overwatch tracer
Blizzard

2016 was one hell of a year for video games on the whole: a ton of titles hugely surpassed expectations (Doom, Titanfall 2 and Watch Dogs 2 to name just a few), and VR gaming promised to change the way we play forever.

That said, there are a number of games that just didn't live up to the praise lavished on them by both the gaming press and the cult of fandom alike. While the majority of these games were still at least good, they largely didn't deliver enough to justify those 10/10 reviews and Game of the Year considerations, though in one case the title in question is legitimately quite terrible.

Of course, opinions are like you-know-whats, but even so, these are the titles from the last 12 months that had many players up in arms about their apparent "high quality".

Here are the 10 most overrated video games of 2016...

10. Gears Of War 4

gears of war 4 marcus fenix
Microsoft

You certainly couldn't call Gears of War 4 a bad game by any stretch of the imagination, but the 84 Metascore feels hugely overblown when you consider that this is an incredibly familiar, garden variety GoW game that brings almost nothing new or memorable to the table.

The campaign is a fun but forgettable blast-a-thon best played with friends for maximum entertainment factor, and the game's replay value is ultimately propped up by an enjoyable but, again, rather samey multiplayer suite.

Also, the new characters, namely Marcus Fenix's block-of-wood son JD, just aren't cutting it.

There are worse things to be than consistently average, but given that this was the first GoW game to release on the Xbox One, expectations were naturally set rather high. The end result is merely satisfactory.


9. Final Fantasy XV

Final Fantasy XV
Square Enix

After a decade-long development cycle, Final Fantasy XV finally hit stores this past November to unexpectedly strong reviews, scoring an impressive 82 on Metacritic and landing the series' fastest sales to date.

This is all the more frustrating when you actually sit down and play the game. Yes, the open world is fun (especially the dungeons) and the game's characters are surprisingly entertaining, but a terrible camera hampers the combat, and it goes totally off the deep end in its second half.

The latter half of the game largely removes the open world in favour of more linear, less-satisfying on-rails gameplay, including an infamous stealth-based section that's already infuriated millions, and an underwhelming final boss fight.

Also, though the plot was much simpler than most FF games, it still didn't really make a lick of sense, and felt oddly lacking compared to the cinematic bombast of most previous entries.

Critics were rather forgiving with FFXV, and while it's a relief for it to finally be in our hands, it's clear the game needed more time to be polished, and was blatantly rushed out in an unfinished state.


8. Street Fighter V

Street fighter v
Capcom

The gaming press en masse should be pretty embarrassed that they allowed Street Fighter V to land a 77 Metascore on release, considering that the game was essentially released as a full-price Early Access title.

SFV launched with numerous menus blurred out, no arcade mode, an hilariously spare excuse for a story mode, several iconic fighters missing from the roster, and forced players to grind incessantly to unlock new character colours.

Capcom did release free updates to sort-of-correct some of these issues many months later, but it's still a disgrace to gaming journalism as a whole that an incomplete game received such solid reviews upon release, especially as it was clearly rushed out in time for competition season.

At least the game sold 600,000 copies less than Capcom expected by the end of March, so they ended up paying heavily for their greed.


7. Batman: Arkham VR

batman arkham vr
Rocksteady

Batman: Arkham VR is one of the few indisputably AAA releases for PSVR so far, and while it's difficult to argue with the game's quality as an immersive VR experience, it also basically feels like an overpriced tech demo for the most part.

For starters, the game lasts 45-60 minutes unless you're into hoovering up collectibles, and perhaps most criminally of all, you don't even get to punch a single person while playing as Batman, which seems ridiculous considering the Move controller compatibility.

It's a game clearly designed to show off what PSVR can do, and while successful to that end, the gameplay isn't substantial enough to warrant paying more than a few bucks or just playing it round a friend's house.

Sure, it's fun to show off to your buddies, but the value just isn't there both in terms of length and content.


6. Firewatch

Firewatch 2
Campo Santo

Firewatch is an alternately interesting and frustrating "walking simulator" that touts a gorgeous art style, fantastic voice acting and an intriguingly unsettling premise... but doesn't do nearly enough with it.

Ultimately the gameplay is repetitive and uninteresting, and without the marvelous voice-over work, would feel a lot more mundane.

Just when it seems like the game might be going somewhere, it ends in highly anti-climactic fashion, and while it didn't necessarily need to go to a bombastic place to satisfy, its "minimalist" conclusion provoked more of a shrug than anything else.

It just doesn't live up to the strong reviews and cult of fandom that surrounds it. Overwatch is a curiosity, but in the end, it just doesn't meet the hype.


5. Call Of Duty: Infinite Warfare

Call Of Duty Infinite Warfare
Activision

The latest Call of Duty game didn't earn some of the series' best recent review scores, but it was still solidly acclaimed as another entertaining shooter well worth fans' time.

However, it's hard to see why. The campaign tried a few new things (such as side missions and a free-roam hub area), but was let down by incredibly repetitive mission objectives and a woefully boring villain as just-barely played by Game of Thrones' Kit Harrington.

The deal-breaker came with the multiplayer, though, which was hampered by a horrendous time-to-kill, making it immensely frustrating to play if you weren't a 13-year-old hopped up on Ritalin. Turn a corner and be peppered instantly with bullets, before the killcam shows you something completely different. It's beyond infuriating and a world away from the typical consistency of CoD's multiplayer.

At least Zombies was pretty sweet once again, but that's the only part of the game that truly succeeds at its goals.


4. That Dragon, Cancer

that dragon cancer
Numinous Games

Alright, nobody wants to dump on a game made by the parents of a boy who died from cancer, especially when that game chronicles the parents' heartbreaking experience of losing their child.

That said, That Dragon, Cancer is a game easier to respect and appreciate than it is to laud as a well-crafted work of art or entertainment.

The journey the game takes us on is undeniably powerful, but gameplay-wise it falls down hard due to poor mechanics that aren't enjoyable to play and ultimately just detract from what could've comfortably just been a solid walking simulator.

A Mario Kart-esque racing sequence, for example, both looks and plays horribly thanks to stiff animations, graphical clipping and poor controls. It's jarringly goofy compared to the emotionally devastating central narrative.

This is a case where less probably would've been more, and while certainly not a bad game, it's not the Earth-shattering masterwork that some proclaim it to be (and that 78 Metascore is about 10 points too generous).


3. Overwatch

overwatch tracer
Blizzard

Blizzard's hero shooter has become nothing short of a gaming phenomenon, racking up more than 20 million players by October and becoming a fully-fledged e-Sport in its own right. It also scored an insane 91 on Metacritic.

Overwatch is a fun game, no doubt, but is it really worth such rapturous praise when it's essentially a pretty simplistic multiplayer FPS?

Balancing such an array of characters must be challenging, sure, but outside of the heroes' personalities, the gameplay is pure FPS familiarity, with fairly unremarkable maps for the most part.

It's worth noting that the game's rather safe-playing art-style, bright and free of gore, is likely what made it so appealing to so many in the first place, even if it's more a 7/10 than the 10/10 CounterStrike killer that so many profess it to be.


2. The Witness

the witness
Thekla Inc.

The long-awaited puzzler from Jonathan Blow (Braid) racked up some of the year's best reviews (87 Metascore), but was it really that great?

Yes, the puzzles were exceedingly clever and it presented far better value-for-money than most likely expected, but there wasn't much more to it than its puzzles, with an obtuse narrative that ultimately didn't amount to much.

Should a game with so little of interest outside of its puzzles really have been in contention for Game of the Year awards? It was a compelling, often infuriating experience with some fantastic moments of realisation for the player, but didn't present nearly enough to earn so much praise from the gaming press in particular.


1. Uncharted 4: A Thief's End

Uncharted 4 Chase
Naughty Dog

Uncharted 4 was a tremendous technical achievement from Naughty Dog and a fitting end to Nathan Drake's story, but for the most part it's also a game that people played through once in a few days and then never really talked about again.

It's rare for games that score 93 on Metacritic to make such little impact in the months following their release, and this is perhaps because while mechanically the game is near-faultless, the core gameplay was a rather samey reprise of previous games, just polished to a higher level.

The game is obviously good, even great, but it doesn't seem to have the staying power with most players that would allow it to be regarded as a bonafide classic in the years to come.

--

Which 2016 games did you find the most overrated? Shout them out in the comments!


In this post: 
Overwatch
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.