10 Most Rewarding Evil Playthroughs In Gaming
It feels so good to be this bad.
Although the spectrum of gaming is varied, every video game abides by specific rules. Depending on the title, the protagonist may have to abide by a moral code. Mowing down pedestrians in GTA is satisfying, but draws the attention of the police. There are many titles where killing a single civilian will result in an instant Game Over. Even if the hero has to perform a few questionable decisions, they'll try to do the right thing more often than not.
However, there are certain games where there are no consequences for embracing evil. Not only that, there are times where indulging in every vice and sin imaginable will bring about the greatest rewards.
Titles like Knights of the Old Republic offer the player a choice whether to give in to the Dark Side. Other games can only be completed by behaving like a bonafide psychopath. Either way, it's hard not to side with the devil when the benefits are so good.
Despite the fact some of the entries on this list can be played with honour and nobility, acting like an irredeemable tyrant is considerably more entertaining.
10. Detroit: Become Human
Quantic Dream's sci-fi saga centres around a robot revolution, which is told from the viewpoint of three androids, the peaceful Kara, the conflicted Connor, and the rebellious leader, Markus. Detroit: Become Home has many branching pathways, allowing players to steer the narrative in the direction they are most comfortable with.
However, getting your hands dirty is necessary to unlock all the endings. Players may initially perform the less ethical actions, purely to get that sweet 100% completion rating. But when you realise that performing deplorable deeds unlocks trophies, you'll probably wonder why you didn't give in to evil sooner.
With that said, some of the decisions you need to make it are downright diabolical. To save your metallic exterior, you may have to sacrifice your friends, sell out your allies, or destroy androids to repair yourself. In one scenario, you have to allow a family (including a child) to freeze to death for the greater good.
Also, playing the Good Samaritan is far from easy. When the authorities invade a peaceful protest and destroy countless androids (including your closest friends), retaliation isn't just justified, but necessary.
9. LISA: The Painful
Austin Jorgensen's post-apocalyptic RPG follows a middle-aged man called Brad who ventures through the wastelands of Olathe to find his adopted daughter, Buddy.
At a glance, it's obvious the 2D sidescroller's style, comic relief, and battle system was heavily modelled on Earthbound. Even though Earthbound contained plenty of unsettling characters, the heroes were pure of heart.
Unfortunately, the same cannot be said about Brad. Although playing nice is an option, LISA is dramatically easier if you don't remotely try to be a good person. When Brad has to pick between giving up a useless party member or lose all his items, ditching your teammate is logical. Other times, Brad must choose between losing his arms or dropping his party members. Even if Brad's companions are solid, trading his arms for their safety is a bit extreme.
Several playable characters, including the protagonist, are addicts who become stronger when exposed to the Joy drug. This mechanic doesn't just entice Brad to pick up junkies, but to feed their addiction so he can reap the benefits.
In a nutshell, breaking bad is the way to go, since being a saint will have Brad left without items, strong party members, or limbs.
8. Overlord
In Triumph Studios' real-time strategy title, seven plucky heroes vow to bring peace to the world by destroying the nefarious Overlord.
However, what makes Overlord different from most fantasy RPGs is the story is told from the bad guy's POV. Throughout the main campaign, the titular warrior must lay waste to everyone who crosses his path, often by summoning a destructive horde of minions (creatively called "Minions"). Unlike other entries on this list, being a goody two-shoes isn't an option. Being the overarching villain, your only choices are being evil or... really evil.
Even when there's an opportunity to perform a good deed, it rarely leads to a reward. In situations like this, it's rational to slaughter everyone in sight instead so you can claim their possessions.
Also, you shouldn't worry about your conscience getting the better of you. Considering the supposed heroes behave like total douches, it's hard to feel bad when you put them in the ground. In fact, it feels like you're doing the locals a favour when these self-absorbed cretins are defeated. The Overlord may be ruthless, but at least he knows how to run things.
7. Divinity: Original Sin 2
Morality systems in gaming are usually straightforward. Saving people and warding off evil should bring about rewards. You may receive greater gifts if you play without a conscience, but it often comes with a heavy price.
However, things are different in Divinity: Original Sin 2. Basically, there are consequences for committing misdeeds... but only if you get caught. If nobody finds out you stole a bunch of equipment or murdered a bunch of civilians, you should be in the clear. If somebody sees you performing indecently, it's not the end of the world so long as the witnesses are... dealt with.
Sure, it's rewarding to go about Original Sin 2 as a noble hero, but it's also tedious since you'll progress at a snail's pace and see the Game Over screen more times than you can count.
Instead, you should steal everything you come across and sell it. That way, you can buy the best items early on, allowing you to dominate the hardest enemies. So long as you're sneaky, you shouldn't suffer any repercussions for your wicked actions (apart from earning a spot in Hell).
6. Infamous
This PS3 exclusive opens with a bike courier called Cole getting involved in an accident, causing him develop electrokinesis (as you do). Throughout the playthrough, the chrome-domed protagonist can decide how to use his newfound abilities, which will alter his Karma path.
Much like Knights of the Old Republic, certain powers can only be unlocked by embracing good or evil. Also like KOTOR, accepting the dark side is a lot more fun. Try as you might to do the right thing, it's challenging to play the hero after getting a taste of the nasty stuff.
Behaving like a valiant superhero allows Cole to take enemies down non-lethally using controlled bursts of electricity. However, tapping into the darkness lets Cole shoot a constant stream of electricity, allowing him to topple structures and annihilate multiple enemies at once.
Not giving a damn about collateral damage or the needless lives taken doesn't just make things easier, but grants Cole a diverse range of abilities, making the playthrough more satisfying. Although Vent Dash helps Cole move quickly, Evil Karma will upgrade it to Vent Launch, allowing him to catapult himself across the city. As a good guy, Cole can summon an Angel. But by becoming the antagonist, he can conjure up three Demons. Basic math proves which of those choices is better.
Simply put, Evil Karma doesn't just provide different upgrades, but superior ones.
5. Ace Combat Zero: The Belkan War
The Belkan War mightn't be the best entry in the Ace Combat franchise, but it has a couple of mechanics that make it stand out, most notably the reputation system. Throughout this combat flight simulator, the fighter pilots are given strict commands on how to take down enemy aircraft. If the player carries out these orders to the letter, they'll be rewarded with a high rank.
However, attacking non-hostiles, destroying crippled jets, and ignoring allies will earn the player Merc points, which makes the main campaign harder. Unless you're looking for a challenge, it's more sensible to follow instructions.
At least, in theory. But since a high body count earns more cash, the best upgrades will be made available if you go on a killing spree. Accepting the Merc lifestyle will make the enemy aircraft tougher at first, but the later stages are a walk in the park since you should've unlocked everything the shop has to offer.
It sounds counter-intuitive but choosing the "hard mode" makes the gameplay noticeably easier. Also, it's significantly more satisfying to shoot and blow up everything in sight than abiding by the rule book.
4. Papers, Please
Papers, Please revolves around an immigration officer who must review traveller documents to decide who can enter the nation of Arstotzka. If any paperwork is missing or falsified, the client must be rejected. If the papers are approved, the client should be free to enter the country.
Now, an ordinary game would acknowledge and appraise the player if they helped out the unfortunate. If a client makes a minor mistake, you should sweep it under the rug. If one member of a couple has the necessary papers but the other is missing one, you should try to come to a reasonable understanding.
In an ideal world, that's what you should do. But in Papers, Please, you are rewarded for doing your job correctly, not fairly. More importantly, processing as many clients as possible keeps your pockets filled. As a result, travellers should be dismissed the instant the smallest discrepancy is discovered in their paperwork.
Behaviour like this sounds callous, but the main character is simply looking after his own interests, since he needs to afford food and medicine for his family. Also, disobeying protocol can have serious consequences, so it's better to do the job without a moral compass.
3. Fable
One of the features that defined Fable was Alignment, which affects how the Hero looks and how they're perceived. Excessive eating causes them to gain weight. NPCs find the Hero intimidating, noble, or attractive, depending on what clothing they wear.
But the most important aspect of this mechanic was how good and evil deeds affect the Hero's morality. You're rewarded with Good points by saving villagers and you're bestowed with Evil points by eating Crunchy Chicks or by forcing villagers to go to work. (Yes, really.)
The Morality system is very black-and-white, so it's obvious what should be done. But the faster the "Hero" gives evil a shot, the sooner they'll realise that being bad... isn't that bad.
Butchering innocent villagers offers more XP than the average monster, making levelling up a breeze. Dark magic is more powerful and can hit more targets, which is a godsend when attacked from all sides. If the Hero wants to wield the most powerful weapon in the game, all he has to do is murder his sister. (To be honest, they weren't that close.)
Also, there's no major disadvantage to being malevolent. Performing heinous acts will catch the authorities' attention, but it's nothing the Hero can't fight his way out of. And if you feel bad that the locals live in fear, you can always cheer yourself up with a good old-fashioned massacre before stealing their stuff.
2. Tyranny
In Obsidian's RPG, you play as a Fatebinder, who serves as a subordinate to Kyros, a godlike demagogue. After Kyros conquers the world, the Fatebinder is tasked with bringing about order across the land.
Naturally, the player can indulge in their primal urges the old fashioned way, obliterating everyone in sight. Although most games with a morality system offer an altruistic choice, selecting the less violent option in Tyranny often leads to further bloodshed in the long run.
Depending on what tasks are performed or what is said in conversation trees, the player can turn allies against each other, sentence Kyros' followers to death, or trigger a war. If you're smart, some grievous actions can be performed without wielding your weapon or directly taking a single life.
You are presented with many choices, but being the good guy isn't one of them. Whether you choose to be a tyrant on the battlefield or a manipulator behind the scenes, you're the villain, plain and simple. Even though the story culminates with the Fatebinder putting an end to Kyros' reign, an unspeakable amount of bloodshed must be spilt to achieve this goal.
1. Cult Of The Lamb
There are times during Cult of the Lamb where players can forget how immoral their behaviour is. After all, the titular character sounds like a messiah, since they opens their doors to strangers, feeds them, offers them gifts, and carries out their requests, no matter how demanding they are.
But at the end of the day, the sinister sheep is running a cult that does every culty thing imaginable.
The Lamb performs plenty of good deeds, but they're all a means to an end. Giving the followers gifts and food manufactures loyalty, making it easier to manipulate them. Letting them drink alcohol and embrace their carnal desires generates sin, feeding The Lamb's power. Once the cult leader has bent his subjects to their will, they'll gladly kill each other, sacrifice themselves, and literally eat their own crap to appease their so-called saviour.
Playing nice doesn't work in the long-run, since it causes The Lamb to level up sluggishly, cutting them off to the best items, upgrades, and Doctrines.
By cracking the whip and imprisoning a few dissenters, the commune will shower their woolly leader with devotion, allowing them to level up at break-neck speed. Once players realise the depraved lifestyle makes everything easier, they'll never want to be good again.