10 Most Shocking Roster Picks In WWE Games

Terminators and nu-metallers. Ok then...

WWE Cameos Terminator Fred Durst
2K Games

Inevitably, one of the most noticeable features of any fighting game is its roster, after all, it’s one of the first things sold to prospective buyers, and also one of the first things that they then encounter when the game boots. 

The WWE series is no exception, and yet, despite how important this aspect is, the series has a track record of being very hit-and-miss when it comes to the playable characters. 

Not so long ago, WWE 2K14 boasted one of the most impressive rosters ever, with 84 vanilla superstars - 36 of them being Legends or Superstar’s Retro counterparts - and well over 100 with DLC. But contrastingly, just one year later, 2K15 comparatively flopped with a reduced roster of just 62, with only 8 Legends/Retros.

And on top of that, throughout the years there's been a trend of unusual Superstars and Legends making the cut. From unnamed servants to celebrities who have never even been in a ring to Superstars working for WWE’s biggest competition, the oddities are never too far away with a WWE game roster.

With WWE 2K16 coming soon and promising the biggest roster of all time, we can only assume this trend will only grow as 2K fills up the 120-Superstar strong roster, and the inclusion of The Terminator seems to suggest odd things could be ahead...

10. Corey Graves (WWE 2K15)

Corey Graves (WWE 2K15)
2K Games

Both PC and console versions of 2K15 contained a unique feature to their generation: on the Next Gen version, there was the disappointing MyCareer mode and on the Last Gen version there was Who Got NXT - a series of exhibition matches to unlock certain superstars on the NXT roster. 

After completing that, you were given a new task named “Proving Ground” in which you use one the 5 NXT stars to defeat John Cena, much like 2K14’s “Defeat The Streak”. Completing this debut mode unlocked Sami Zayn, Adrian Neville, Corey Graves, Bo Dallas and Rusev and showcased 4 of their most important NXT matches.

That was a good addition,but Corey Graves stands out, however, by being the only retired superstar in the mode. In late 2014, the Saviour of Misbehaviour announced his retirement from in-ring competition due to “concussion issues” at NXT Takeover R Evolution and was offered a two year commentary contract by Triple H. 

WWE 2K15 was his first and, unfortunately, probably his last place in a WWE game.


9. Gangrel (WWE ‘13)

Gangrel WWE 2K13
THQ

Gangrel is definitely one of the strangest Superstars to grace a WWE ring. Debuting August 16th, 1998 on Sunday Night Heat, he was a Medieval Vampire, entering the arena through a ring of fire carrying a goblet of, presumably, blood. Alongside Edge and Christian, he also formed a gothic faction named the Brood (and later tried to start another vampire faction that was scuppered by his weight issues).

Though the game's Attitude Era mode unlocked the most prominent Superstars during the era, the DLC provided less celebrated Superstars, including Gangrel. Interestingly, whenever WWE ‘13 is loaded up with Gangrel installed, you will see a copyright notice on the load screen specifically for this superstar.

This was because WWE didn’t, and still don’t, actually own the name Gangrel. It was owned by a company named White Wolf, and leased to WWE for presumably a hefty price. On Raw’s 15th Anniversary, Gangrel returned without WWE having the rights to him, and the company was sued for several million dollars.

Although he was a very recognizable character, it is surprising that WWE put the money and effort into acquiring the rights to Gangrel, just for the sake of a 70p DLC.  


8. Goldberg (WWE 2K14)

Goldberg (WWE 2K14)
2K Games

This entry needs a bit of context.

WWE 2K14 was obviously 2k’s first time publishing a WWE game, and they obviously wanted to make a good impression and do something special. To that end, they presented the 30 Years of WrestleMania Mode, which showcasing the greatest matches in the event's history, including legendary matches like Hulk Hogan vs Andre the Giant, The Rock vs Stone Cold, The Undertaker vs Shawn Michaels and… Brock Lesnar vs Goldberg.

With a mode boasting some of the greatest matches of all time, why they would bring up possibly the worst received match in WrestleMania history is a mystery. With both men making it clear they weren’t returning, the crowd turned on them, filling Madison Square Garden with deafening boos and “you sold out chants”, which made the already apathetic performers care even less.

This match was built up to be an epic Clash of the Titans, two of the most powerful Superstars squaring off once and for all, but the end result was so horrible its shocking WWE wants anybody to remember it exists, let alone give it a place in a celebration of the best the company has to offer. 

It’s understandable that WWE wanted to include Goldberg in a newer game, but to do it through this appalling match was a shocking idea.


7. David Otunga (WWE 2K14)

David Otunga (WWE 2K14)
2K Games

When a Superstar’s inclusion into a WWE Game makes the player think “Wait, he’s still employed?” it probably means something has gone wrong. 

Before the release of 2K14, Otunga’s last televised match had been 7 months ago, when he lost to Ryback in 1 minute 41 seconds. His last victory of any kind was over 390 days ago, when he beat Tyson Kidd on WWE Superstars.

All this begs the question, why bother including him in the first place? Simply put, there was no reason for the A-Lister to have been included, especially when people like Big E Langston were only included in DLC.


6. Rob Van Dam (Smackdown Vs Raw 2011)

Rob Van Dam Smackdown Vs Raw 2011
THQ

During the WWE ‘13 Attitude Era mode, you had to play through the Deadly Game from Survivor Series 1998, a tournament for the WWF championship, which was won by The Rock. When showing the competition’s card, two names were blurred out - Al Snow and Jeff Jarrett -thanks to both men working for the competition at TNA.

However, two years earlier, Rob Van Dam was not only mentioned, but fully included in Smackdown vs Raw 2011. He was unlocked in Rey Mysterios’s RTWM, even though he had been wrestling in other promotions since 2007. Presumably the developers were just big RVD fans, considering it must have cost a hefty price to purchase a licence from TNA.

Bearing in mind WWE’s track record of trying to un-person other promotion’s workers, Rob Van Dam was a very surprising, but very welcomed, addition to the game’s roster.


5. The Masked Man (Smackdown Vs Raw 2009)

The Masked Man
THQ

And now into the really strange entries...

Chris Jericho’s RTWM was a strange one for a number of reasons: it was the only heel story in the game, it has only the second weirdest Battle Royal in Road to WrestleMania history and it had one of the strangest unlockable characters in WWE gaming’s history.

During the story, Christ Jericho is repeatedly tormented by a Masked Man (who looks suspiciously like one of Muhammed Hussan’s allies). From DQing you during matches to fighting you backstage, The Masked Man is a crucial part of the story, and the story branches out depending on who you interrogate about being the culprit, with a different set of matches for each choice.

At the end of the entire story, you fight in an Extreme Rules Fatal 4-Way between You, Randy Orton, John Cena and Mr Kennedy. And your reward for completing this story is… The Masked Man.

In the other Road to WrestleManias, you are rewarded with characters like Tazz and The Boogeyman, but in Jericho’s, you’re given what’s essentially an Alternate Attire for an already established characters. Nothing about the Masked Man is worth putting him in the game.


4. Tony (Smackdown Vs Raw 2009)

Tony (Smackdown Vs Raw 2009)
THQ

Another 2009 Road to WrestleMania, but this time it’s John Cena’s turn in the spotlight. This story involves fighting the “Better-Then-U-Topia”, a faction formed by MVP, Umaga and William Regal who plague Cena throughout the story, all culminating in an Iron Man match against MVP at Wrestlemania.

Tony is a soldier befriended by John and seen at the Tribute to the Troops show. He is assaulted by the Better Then U-Topia, prior to you and Jeff Hardy taking them on, minus MVP. And to unlock Tony, you have hit the FU on both your opponents and win the match.

Not only is Tony not, you know, a real person, but almost no effort was put into him: his look is generic, his entrance music is John Cena’s, the entrance itself is ripped right from Balls Mahoney and both his finishers and entire moveset are also the former Doctor of Thuganomic’s. 

Unrelatedly, he was voiced by the game designer himself, Bryan Williams


3. Green and Red (Smackdown Vs Raw 2010)

Create A Finisher
THQ

For many years, when editing a Superstar’s moveset or creating a unique finisher, the moves were demonstrated by two bald identical models, differentiated only by their body colours: Green and Red. The pair were creatively named Green and Red, with Red always being on the receiving end. They were replaced in WWE ’12 by two generic models, only differed by their Black and Red trunks, with the Red one still taking the beating.

For some reason, in 2010, both “characters” were made playable. They both had identical move sets, finishers, entrances, abilities and attributes. Both of their overall ratings were surprisingly high, at 90, higher than veterans like Big Show and Kane, as well as Legends like Ted DiBiase and Bob Orton.

In order to unlock them, during Week 3 of Randy Orton’s RTWM, refuse Cody Rhodes help, then reverse Batista’s attacks 3 times, despite this having nothing to do with Green and Red themselves. The way to unlock the characters is almost as baffling as their inclusions itself. 


2. Druid (Smackdown Vs Raw 2011)

Druid (Smackdown Vs Raw 2011)
THQ

The “VS Undertaker” Road to WrestleMania in 2011 was really, really strange: from time machines bringing back Jake Roberts, Jimmy Snuka and Masked Kane to the weirdest Battle Royal in Road to WrestleMania history. 

It ends with a match against Undertaker at, funnily enough, WrestleMania. What’s strange about the match is that it’s the only one that ends the story with a different outcome if you lose. A cutscene starts showing 4 Druids appearing, then attacking your character. A fight begins, but it is impossible to win. You lose, and another cutscene shows you being transformed into a Druid yourself.

The match is the last RTWM match, and completing it rewards you with the Druid as a playable character and the eerie Druid Arena.

You can choose from a CAW, Kofi Kingston, Dolph Ziggler, R-Truth or John Morrison. The story begins normally enough with a tournament to decide who will face The Undertaker at WrestleMania to attempt to end the legendary streak. Things begin getting strange about 9 matches in, when you fight in a 15 Man Battle-Royal, against 14 Druids. In an arena full of Druids. With a purple filter. With no commentary. And Druid chanting.

Oh, okay then...


1. Fred Durst (Just Bring It/RAW 2002)

fred durst summerslam
WWE.com

While a seemingly random singer’s presence in these two games would be worthy of the number 1 spot on its own, digging a little deeper the story regarding Fred Durst’s place began to get even stranger.

When these games were released, Undertaker was portraying his American Badass persona, using Limp Bizkit's “Rollin” as his entrance theme, as it suited his character at the time. Allegedly singer Fred Durst was included as part of the deal to allow the WWF to use their song in the product. Yup, Durst would only let WWE use his song if he was given a place in the games.

To unlock him, you have to use Undertaker in the Slobberknocker game mode and defeat at least 15 enemies. What else was strange was how much effort was put into such a novelty character. He had his own custom entrance, which was modelled after the music video for Rollin, with Durst driving down to the ring in a car, performing his signature dance moves. He had a custom move set, and is instantly put into a tag team with Undertaker, with the entrance theme, surprisingly, being "Rollin'". 

Did we miss any strange roster inclusions? Share your own in the comments thread below.


Contributor

Fred hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here. Maybe. It might be over there. We're not really sure.