10 Most Shocking Video Game Plot Twists Of 2018

Did ANYONE see Far Cry 5's ending coming?

Far Cry 5 Nuke
Ubisoft

A quick tangent, but could Black Mirror: Bandersnatch be considered a video game?

The fact that it’s only available via Netflix would likely disqualify it in the minds of many, but it’s a question worth considering. Bandersnatch demands both attention and input from the viewer, and isn’t too drastically different from something like Night Trap or Her Story - both of which are broadly accepted as games.

This may not seem relevant to the topic at hand, but Bandersnatch, much like many of the games on this list, breaks boundaries and subverts audience expectations in a way that is inherently unique to gaming. Much like Bioshock’s unforgettable ‘Would You Kindly’ twist, Black Mirror: Bandersnatch allows viewers to revel in the freedom of choice until they discover that, in reality, they were the ones being played.

Netflix junkies may be new to these fourth-wall-busting plot twists, but they’re nothing new to gamers. Titles like Spec Ops: The Line, Silent Hill 2, and Heavy Rain have been at it since Netflix was in its infancy, and in 2018 that trend was continued as players were met with some of the most mind-twisting plot threads in recent history.

Note: Major spoilers ahead.

10. Vincent's Betrayal - A Way Out

A Way Out
Hazelight Studios

A Way Out seemed like an odd game from the very beginning; an ambitious project backed by EA, it seemed the sort of indie darling the publisher usually wouldn’t touch with a ten foot pole. That said, it turned out to be a triumphant—if somewhat flawed—success.

With such a heavy emphasis on co-operative gameplay, A Way Out asked two players to team up to escape a prison and eventually orchestrate a plot to reclaim a priceless heirloom from an antagonizing crime boss.

It would have been a compelling ending... were it not for one major twist.

Toward the end of the game it is revealed that Vincent - one of the two protagonists - was working with the police all along, and the game’s grand jewel theft was a P.D.-sanctioned mission from the get-go. In the end, it just goes to show that no one can be trusted.

It felt a bit Shyamalanian to some, but was a fantastic way of unseating players before the game’s conclusion. Though the prison escape sequence, a highlight of many of the game’s trailers, was well over by the time the halfway point rolled around, this unexpected twist was one of 2018’s best.


9. Edward Richthofen's Death - Call Of Duty: Black Ops 4

Richthofen Blood Of The Dead
Activision

The plot surrounding what is now known as the Aether storyline in Black Ops’ Zombies has become so dense and impenetrable over the past decade that it could rival a Tolstoy novel. What started as a narratively bereft horde mode has evolved into something so lore-rich that only the most dedicated of fans can claim to truly understand it.

Though it had its fair share of twists and turns in the past, the Aether storyline received its most eye-opening plotpoint at the end of Black Ops 4’s Blood of the Dead on-disc map. Following a relentlessly complex easter egg which is par for the course for Treyarch, series staple and plot puppet master Edward Richtofen sacrificed himself so his allies to escape Alcatraz Island.

That’s not all there is to it, of course. That wasn’t the only version of Richthofen floating around, and nothing is ever set in stone in CoD Zombies, but this was still a devastating conclusion for those who have stuck with the character and his trials over the past ten years.

Call of Duty’s Zombies went from debuting as a throw-away extra to a marquee feature presentation, and we wouldn't have it any other way.


8. The Post-Apocalypse Begins - Far Cry 5

Far Cry 5
Ubisoft

Far Cry 5’s explosive ending - one of two possible, provided the player refuses Joseph Seed’s peace offering during the game’s opening - was as climactic as it was controversial. A series known for its enigmatic antagonists and crazy plotlines, what we now know to be the canonical ending to the fifth Far Cry title may have jumped the shark.

That said, as far as plot twists go, this one was pretty great. During the course of the game’s campaign players are drip-fed small hints that political turmoil outside of Hope County may be leading the world to the brink of war. Yet, most players are too busy trying to capture or kill the leaders of Seed’s misguided flock to notice.

So, when the bombs dropped as the game came to a close, it was a real shock to the system. It turns out that this self-proclaimed prophet may have been on to something all along. We’ve heard of doomsday prepping before, but this is taking things to another level.

It may have been bleak, but those who saw Far Cry 2 to its conclusion know that the series usually doesn’t shy away from unhappy endings.


7. The Protagonist Is Evil - Unavowed

Unavowed Game
Wadjet Eye

Unavowed was a neat little indie game commendable for its attempt to revive the long-since forgotten point and click genre in 2018. Something of a cult icon in an era during which pixel-art indie gems are flooding the Steam store, Unavowed is an overlooked title which old-school fans of Sierra or Lucasarts may enjoy.

Opening on a protagonist freshly excised from the control of a demon, the player character eventually joins the New York branch of an eponymously-named spectral investigation group. They go around the city solving occult crimes and attempt to dig a little deeper into the main character’s mysterious possession.

In the end, it turns out that the character wasn’t possessed in the traditional sense - they actually invoked the demon in order to obtain its powers and knowledge. In a way, the protagonist more-or-less possessed a demon, and a spell used during the exorcism caused them to switch bodies.

At least, that seems like what happened. Anyone who missed out on this unique investigative experience may want to give it a play sometime in 2019 and draw their own conclusions. Plus, with four possible endings to experience, it’s a narrative worth revisiting.


6. Atreus' True Identity - God Of War

God Of War Atreus
Sony

Though an excellent series of games prior to what might be considered Santa Monica Studios’ magnum opus, the God of War titles weren’t usually known for their plotlines. Sure, the systematic extermination of ancient Grecian deities was amazing, but, aside from that whole accidental family murder bit, there wasn’t a lot of hard narrative.

2018’s plainly-titled God of War was a significant change for the franchise in that regard. Kratos was certainly keeping secrets, but so was his spouse. As it turns out, Faye was a Giant who foretold the adventures of her husband and son long before they first set out to spread their mothers ashes, and it only gets weirder from there.

The series didn’t have anything to do with Norse mythology until this year, but they certainly did an exemplary job of adapting the lore. While fans new Kratos’ son as Arteus, it turns out that his mother called him by her different name when among her people.

The reveal that Arteus is actually Loki—the Norse trickster God born of a Giant mother—was as puzzling as it was unexpected. God of War fans usually need no payoff aside from slaughter, and this was an unprecedented surprise.


5. Merging With Part Of Madeline - Celeste

Celeste Madeline
Matt Makes Games

Celeste is a challenging platformer which tasks the player with seeing Madeline, the title’s protagonist, to the top of Celeste Mountain. During her adventure she is haggered by her dark alter-ego, known as Part of Madeline, which prevents her from ascending to the top.

At the outset, Part of Madeline seems like a relatively standard antagonist—a twisted doppelganger which needs to be beaten. Yet, the narrative undergoes a bit of a twist when, near the game’s finale, Part of Madeline confronts the protagonist and essentially pushes her off of the mountain.

Upon waking up and finding herself back at the base of Celeste Mountain, Madeline encounters an NPC who tells her that, rather than fighting Part of Madeline, she should try to reason with her.

This is where the real narrative twist comes in: Part of Madeline isn’t beaten. Rather, the two come to terms and merge into one being. This is meant to be analogous to the struggles of those living with mental disorders like anxiety and depression, and it was a surprisingly in-depth narrative for such a gameplay-heavy title.


4. Playing As John Marston - Red Dead Redemption 2

red dead redemption 2 john marston
Rockstar

Those who played through 2010’s Red Dead Redemption will know that the series is all about revenge being payed post-mortem. Though audiences have twice seen John Marston attempt to settle down and leave his criminal activities in the past, there would be no ‘redemption’ in Red Dead Redemption 2 if certain scores were left unsettled.

Rockstar’s first dusty midwestern outing shocked audiences when, toward the end of the campaign, they actually got to see Marston transition into a family man and abandon his criminal past. All was seemingly undone when a corrupt official ended his life, but justice was subsequently served by his son, Jack.

Much the same occurred for Arthur Morgan, the protagonist of the game’s sequel (which is actually a prequel). No matter the outcome, Morgan meets his end, though he was able to ensure a better life for John before he bit the dust. All was made right by the end, of course, as the events of the original Red Dead game redeemed poor Arthur and his ill-fated efforts.

Stepping into the spurs of John Marston for the game’s lengthy final act was certainly a surprise, but, given the last game’s outcome, it wasn’t exactly unpredictable.


3. Meeting Kassandra Or Alexios - Assassin's Creed Odyssey

Assassins creed odyssey ending
Ubisoft

Plenty of games offer the ability to play as either a male or female character, but the unchosen character model in many of these games in almost never seen again unless it has been recycled for use as an NPC by time-crunched developers. Such is not the case in Assassin’s Creed Odyssey; rather than simply discard the unused character, they become a primary antagonist in the game’s plot.

The game essentially opens with both siblings being thrown from a cliff during an attempted sacrifice/execution. Despite this, the audience knows that the player character survives the fall and escapes to the Greek island of Kephallonia.

Following a long and drawn out series of events which includes the deaths of a few long-lost family members, the protagonist is tasked with dismantling the nefarious Cult of Kosmos lead by the mysterious Deimos. The plot thickens when it is revealed that Deimos is actually Alexios, the brother of possible protagonist Kassandra.

The reveal that neither sibling died as a result of that tragic cliff incident was pretty shocking. The Assassin’s Creed series seems rife with forgettable, hard-to-follow plots, and this was definitely more engaging.


2. The Fate Of The Obra Dinn - Return Of The Obra Dinn

return of the obra dinn
Lucas Pope

2018’s Return of the Obra Dinn only makes use of two colors: black and white. Conversely, that is absolutely not the case when it comes to the game’s narrative and ending scenarios, which can be vastly different depending on how much information the player collected during their investigation.

Brought to us by Lucas Pope, the indie developer behind 2013’s morally-mortifying hit Papers, Please, Return of the Obra Dinn has players stepping into the role of an insurance adjuster from the East India Trading Company intent on determining what exactly happened to the mysterious vessel. With the help of the Momento Mortem, players view the fates of deceased crew members and slowly peace together exactly what happened.

Hidden aboard the Obra Dinn is a tale involving mermaids, a kraken, and a cursed sea shell. The extent to which this is revealed is up to the player’s investigative abilities, but the full picture can’t be seen until the end of the game.

One year after the return of the ship, the protagonist receives a monkey’s paw in the mail which reveals that the crew made a deal with a mermaid to return the ship to port in exchange for the shell.


1. Alice Is An Android - Detroit: Become Human

Detroit Become Human Alice
Sony Interactive Entertainment

Directed by notoriously weird gaming icon David Cage, 2018’s Detroit: Become Human is the latest in his string of interactive cinematic experiences. There usually isn’t much in the way of gameplay in these games; instead, players are made to make decision which could heavily impact the narrative.

Cage’s games are relatively controversial among gamers—some love him, and some find him unbearably pretentious. Be that as it may, 2010’s Heavy Rain contained what might be one of the greatest video game plot twists of all time. It’s still a game worth experiencing eight years after release—just keep an eye on that quiet-type private investigator.

Most fans of Cage’s work went in to Detroit: Become Human expecting a Heavy Rain-caliber twist, and they were mostly rewarded. One of the game’s three primary narratives sees Kara and Alice, the former and android and the latter apparently human, caught in a struggle to emigrate to Canada after Kara becomes a deviant.

In the end it is revealed that Alice is actually an android replica meant to replace Todd Williams’ lost daughter. It wasn’t quite as earth shattering as other reveals in gaming, but it was tough to see coming for some.


In this post: 
Far Cry 5
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Sometimes I like to write in between sessions of Rocket League.