10 Most Underrated Romances In Video Games

Sometimes, a held hand can mean more than a kiss.

When you think of gaming romances, you probably think of the likes of Mario and Peach, Link and Zelda, Nathan and Elena - the usual suspects. They're all great pairings in their own right, but I've always found them a bit simplistic. Think about it, both Mario and Zelda's franchises have always approached romance in the most archaic way possible; a hero rescues a princess, and for the most part... that's all there is to their entire relationship. Uncharted fairs a bit better, but Nathan and Elena's "Will they?/Won't they?" pairing is pretty much your standard Hollywood-style romance. Good fun, but nothing too deep. So, in the spirit of delving deeper at the more nuanced relationships in gaming, and with Valentine's Day once again upon us, here's a look at the ten most underrated romances in gaming. Note: As a rule, only one couple per franchise will get considered, otherwise half of this list would be Bioware games.

10. Professor Layton & Claire €“ The Professor Layton Series

With a character like Professor Layton, you€™d think that he wouldn€™t have time for a relationship. After all, he€™s far too focused on solving puzzles to get involved in such things. However, in The Unwound Future, the players are introduced to Claire, one of the most significant figures in the good Professor's life. Claire adds a great layer to Layton€™s backstory, though a very sad one seeing as she died and then has to die again in order to set that game's time stream right. She€™s an interesting character in her own right; Intelligent, independent, and with desires not entirely focused on her and Herschel€™s love. What makes their relationship so poignant is how it plays with the Professor as a character. The series has always gone to great lengths to show Layton as the level-headed, logical man who always keeps his cool even when things go topsy turvy. But, when he and Claire have to part once more, that mask shatters, the tears flow, and the player is left just as devastated as he is.

9. Jude And Milla €“ Tales Of Xillia

Most people have probably never heard of these two, which makes sense, considering the Tales series has never quite found its foot in the west like its contemporaries. Every Tales game follows a similar formula; a young man meets a mysterious young woman who pulls him out of his mundane life and into an epic adventure that usually ends up with copious dimension-hopping and the killing of some kind of deity. Tales of Xillia is no exception. Unlike others entries in the series however, the player gets both sides of the story, playing through the narrative from both the hero and the heroines point of view in a way that compliments both the overarching story, and the two€™s relationship to each other. Jude is a medical student unsure of what he wants, or what he believes, though he has a deep understanding of people, and cares deeply about those close to him. Millia is a deity, sent to Earth to save it from spiritual armageddon. She has unquenchable resolve, and is determined to fulfill her mission no matter the cost, but is cold, and doesn€™t understand the hearts of humans. The two of them ultimately learn from each other, growing into better people by getting to know one another, and somehow, it€™s made even better by the fact that despite falling in love, they don€™t get together, electing to prioritise their duty to the world. The Tales games have rarely seen characterful writing as good as this.

8.Jak And Keira - Jak & Daxter Series

Were this a list of most underrated game trilogies, Jak and Daxter would be up there. In the case of this list, it's Jak and Keira, the central couple of the series. Both deserve to be talked about so much more than they have. When the series begins, their relationship is quite straightforward. Jak is a strapping young lad on an adventure with his orange furry friend, Keira is the daughter of his mentor and the team mechanic, with whom Jak flirts with in that adorable young teen way. By the time second game comes around however, things have changed drastically. They're separated for two years, and when they meet again, Keira is less than impressed with his transformation from pure-hearted rapscallion to gun-toting, gruff-voiced anti-hero. From there, the two have their ups and downs, slowly growing back together as the story continues, and sees Jak's heart start to lighten, following the effects of being transformed into a semi-demonic super-soldier. The two do their own thing, pursuing other interests and even other people like Erol and Ashelin, before finally coming together in the end. It's a great, though disjointed, coming of age story.

7. Sly Cooper And Carmelita Fox €“ The Sly Cooper Series

There€™s something irrevocably charming about a hero and their roguish counterpart. It€™s why the interplay between Batman and Catwoman has remained compelling for so many decades, and honestly, have no idea why no one talks about this series anymore. Really, these two have so much chemistry it's amazing their games managed to stay E-rated. Raccoon thief Sly Cooper and police officer Carmelita Fox are a direct inversion of the standard dynamic, with Sly taking the role of a heroic thief, and Carmelita the role of the law officer determined to bring him in. Both are ultimately fighting for the common good, but from opposite sides of the law. Admittedly, most of their dynamic is rather antagonistic. Sly steals something, Carmelita shows up, and the two end up on a chase involving lots of jumping across rooftops and a ridiculously overpowered rocket pistol. After all, there€™s no better way to build a relationship than some light cardio exercises, acrobatic drills, and a sprinkling of death threats here and there, right?

6. Undyne And Alphys

Though discussed often in the Undertale fandom, this couple hasn't really gotten a ton of mainstream attention. Which is a shame, considering how impeccably written it is. Underneath all the crazy meta commentary, skeleton puns and talking flowers, Undertale is a game about relationships. They drive the whole story, and are ultiamtely the biggest motivation for the player, just seeing all the wacky monsters become friends and either die horribly or live happily ever after. One of the standout relationships is that between Undyne, the captain of the royal guard and lovably crazy fish-woman, and Alyphys, the royal scientist and shut-in anime fangirl. When first introduced, the two just seem like very good friends, often referring to one another in conversation, and calling one another across the underground on their phones. But as the true pacifist run of the game unfolds, you learn that their feelings run deeper than just friendship, and player helps set them up on what may be gaming's best date ever. Their romantic arc isn't so much about the two of them falling in love, they already cared for each other long before the story began, but rather the two of them maturing to the point where they are ready to actually have a relationship. Undyne learns to calm down and let go of her hatred of humans, and Alphys learns to get over her own self-hatred to open herself up to others. These two are just too precious.

5. Ico And Yorda - Ico

Often overshadowed by Mono and the Wanderer, this young pair may be the best example of a simply written romance in video games. Ico isn't a very verbose game. In fact, there's maybe a dozen or so lines of dialogue in the whole thing. So many would probably find it surprising that one of gamings most intimate, heartfelt relationships is one where one half never speaks. However, Ico sees the pair thrown together in an attempt to escape from a magical castle ruled by a dark queen. There are no dialogue trees, no half hours cutscenes where the two recount their backstories to one another, and no forced sex scene at the end of their romance path. All that happens between them are introductions, short one word exchanges, and most importantly, the holding of hands. It's a very simple, yet incredibly intimate gesture that, unlike many of gaming's imperilled princesses, makes you care about the person you're protecting. Sometimes, keeping it simple is for the best.

4. Zidane And Garnet

The story of Zidane and Garnet is the stuff of fairytales. Zidane, a ladies man, trickster thief with a heart of gold, takes on the job of kidnapping the princess Garnet, only to discover that she€™s already on her way out of the castle. She quickly recruits him to help with her €œkidnapping€ and the two are thrown on a world-spanning adventure involving warring nations, ancient magics and hilarious hijinks. There are many Final Fantasy couples that could go on this list; Cloud and Tifa/Aerith, Tidus and Yuna, the list goes on. But while those are nice, none of them have the simple charm and chemistry that these two have. Their interactions range from funny and dramatic, to sweet and innocently cute. These two go through a lot together, and though there€™s no kiss or outright statement of €œI love you€, the final scene spells it all out, coming together like a Disney-style ending done perfectly. A truly happy ending more than earned.

3. Shepard And Liara - Mass Effect Series

Okay, so this one might be a bit of a cheat. Liara isn't exactly an 'underrated' character to romance. But from what I've seen, most of the romance-related discussion goes towards Tali, Garrus or Miranda. And to me, that's overlooking the best companion in the whole franchise. What makes the Liara romance stand out from the others in the series, and from other Bioware romances, is how it forms a narrative through-line across the entire saga. Unlike many other characters, Liara can romanced in all three of the games, and is thus by far the best developed. She changes drastically, starting out as a shy, bookworm of a scientist in the first game, before then turning into a ruthless information broker in the second, and in the third manages to balance these two parallel opposite sides of her personality. It all serves as a great foil for Shepard, who, no matter whether you're male or female, paragon or renegade, or whether you follow her romance path, has feelings for them. Even after Shepard 'died' in ME2, she went above and beyond to retrieve their body and help them get resurrected, all whilst Shepard's other friends moved on. In fact, she€™s probably the closest thing the franchise has to a canonical love interest. After all, who can resist the charms of an Asari?

2. Max And Chloe - Life Is Strange

On the surface, Life Is Strange appears to be an adventure game about time travel, teenage drama and certain mysteries right out of Twin Peaks. At its core, however, Dontnod Entertainment have crafted a wonderful love story. Max and Chloe are best friends since childhood, reconnecting after five years apart. It€™s obvious from the get go that they care deeply about each other, meshing perfectly as a duo despite the ludicrous amount of emotional baggage both from the past and present. Probably the coolest thing about their romance is that it comes in the form of a revelation, both to the player and Max herself. There€™s a moment in the game€™s final episode where, after going through scores of alternate, splintering timelines in order to keep Chloe alive, Max breaks down, begging Chloe to stay safe. It€™s at that moment where it becomes clear to her, and to us, that she€™s fallen in love. Or alternatively, that she€™s loved her all along. It's a wonderfully emotional moment that puts the entirety of the last twelve hours of play in a new, emotionally devastating context. Life is Strange is far from a perfect game, but it perfectly captures the feeling of falling in love with your best friend, which just isn't an experience any other games can boast about.

1. Geralt And Yennifer €“ The Witcher Series

Geralt can romance many different women over the course of his trilogy, whether it be the medic Shani, the sorceress Triss or a slew of others. However, none can quite compare to Yennifer of Vengerberg. Many game fans probably prefer Triss, as she's been a core part of multiple games, but for those who've read the books the series is based on, Yen is the obvious choice. Most game romances depict the beginning of a relationship. Over the course of the story, the two parties will bond through adventure and shared dangers, and end by becoming a couple - you know how it is. In contrast, Geralt and Yennifer's relationship is one built on shared history. Each glance between the two of them speaks of their long and storied past together. They€™ve been on and off for the better part of two decades, during which time they€™ve battled innumerable monsters, become embroiled in political upheaval that shook the Continent, and even raised a 'daughter' together. One might just turn out to be the world's messiah. It€™s refreshing to see a game romance that shows the simmering, low burning love that forms after a long time together, and it goes without saying that these two have lived quite the life, with all the joy, sorrow, and needless drama that comes with nurturing a relationship alongside. Let us know in the comments what your most underrated video game romance is!

In this post: 
Ico
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

A creative writing student from Indianapolis, Joe loves games, fantasy novels and comics.