10 Most Unforgiving Checkpoints In Gaming History

Is there such a thing as "respawn rage"?

gears of war cole juice
Microsoft Studios

Not to get too dramatic, but dying is a part of life. More specifically, and certainly more commonly, it's also a part of digital life.

Thankfully, largely gone are the days of running out of lives and continues and having to start from scratch. The advent of autosaves and checkpoints has improved all of our lives! For players, this means not returning to the title screen when you make one-too many mistakes, and for developers, it means players are more likely to stick with and finish their games.

However, placing checkpoints is not an art form. In theory, it's very simple. In practice... well, the games on this list prove that that's not always the case.

Whether it's badly timed, infuriatingly placed, or just outright cruel, these games took something as simple as the autosave and turned it into something that haunted gamers' worst respawning nightmares.

10. Prologue - Nier: Automata

Nier Automata
PlatinumGames

We begin with a checkpoint that is quite literally the game’s main menu. Nier: Automata has a 45-minute prologue where, if you die at any time, it’s back to square one.

The abandoned factory section is an absolute tour-de-force for the game: a long, surprising shoot-em-up section to kick things off, some exciting battles, and then a showdown with a gigantic, imposing boss.

If you’re the type to turn your nose up at playing anything on Normal or below, then you’ll be asked to back that claim up. The whole game is brutal on Hard, and the prologue is no exception. A first boss that can one-shot you should really say it all.

To make matters worse, whether you are able to get through the prologue in one go is really important. If you fail, you’ll be going through each part again - complete with lots of dialogue sections - since the first save is three quarters of an hour into the game.

Although hilariously, if you want to get a 100% run of Nier: Automata, you need to die in the prologue at least once to get one of the hidden endings… just maybe do it as soon as possible and not right at the end of one of the most gruelling openings in video game history.


9. The Library - Halo

Halo The Library
343 Industries

You’ve probably heard this one before but the checkpointing system in Halo’s Library level can get onto a Covenant corvette and fly directly into the sun.

Unanimously agreed as the worst level in not just the first Halo game but also in the franchise’s 20-year history, The Library sees Master Chief attempting to traverse a large, winding stream of metallic hallways as he is constantly under attack from The Flood. It’s a painfully long level that basically stops the first Halo from being perfect.

The checkpoint system is the real issue because it causes this already long corridor to feel never-ending. The Flood are not just the infected monstrosities that come running at you, but there’s also some that are just irritating popcorn-shaped spores. These things can easily go amiss, lost in the dark and stuck in the geometry… and with an encounter not technically “over” if there’s one still out there, then a new autosave might not occur.

This is bad enough, but it gets worse because that’s not how every checkpoint in the stage works. Some only pop if the player reaches a certain point in the level, and Flood will spawn endlessly until they do.

It’s a damn mess. Do you want players to fight all of them or none of them, Halo? Pick one.


8. Phazon Mines - Metroid Prime

Metroid Prime Phazon Mines
Nintendo

Phazon Mines is the last major area of Metroid Prime and is the base on Tallon IV for the villainous Space Pirates. The first save station for the mines is right at the start, and the area is a long slog through 25 minutes of winding rooms filled with enemies and morph-ball traversal puzzles so it’s a must to use. Especially because that’s all you get before facing the Cloaked Drone.

This boss is one of the most hated enemies in the Prime series: an invisible sentry that throws out a lot of what the player has grown used to. The game has expressly told players to scan every new enemy and artefact to shoot for that 100%, but the Cloaked Drone can’t be scanned at all, so players who get here for the first time might wind up dying before even firing off a shot. Furthermore, the Drone’s invisibility means it can’t be locked onto by Samus’ gun like every other enemy in the title.

And if you do die? Well, have fun navigating the entire mine again.

Metroid Prime’s lack of checkpoints is definitely a “your mileage may vary” affair based on your difficulty preference, but at the very least, 2021’s Dread gave players an auto-save before bosses so they could jump right back in. This feature really should’ve been added to Metroid Prime Remastered, but instead, this sequence sets many Samus Aran veterans' nerves back on edge.


7. Evrae - Final Fantasy X

Final Fantasy 10 Evrae
Square Enix

The battle against Evrae on the airship Fahrenheit can become a kind of soft-lock for Final Fantasy X players who simply aren’t ready to take on this boss.

RPGs and “the grind” go hand-in-hand. Some players will over-level characters so they can cruise through a game, and some won’t put nearly enough time into it - and that’s fine, because for the most part, you can stop at any time to work on it.

It is possible to level up on the Fahrenheit thankfully, though it’s not ideal. But if you saved here before the battle then too bad! That’s all you’ve got. Of course, a first playthrough can really turn into a nightmare here since Yuna - the game’s healer - has just left the party and it leaves players struggling to fill that gap.

Evrae is no pushover either, having elemental resistance, status ailment inducing attacks, and the ability to move out of range, forcing players to command the airship closer or further to attack or defend.

Worst of all, beating the boss isn’t necessarily the end point, as the airship touches down in Bevelle and the party is thrown into a series of fights before you even have a chance to save. Die here, and it’s back to Evrae’s Poison Breath you go.


6. Tip Of The Iceberg - Gears Of War

Gears Of War Juice
Microsoft Studios

What does Augustus Cole say when he goes down the chilled drinks aisle at his local supermarket? “Look at all that juice!”

What does Cole Train say when pouring off the liquids from cooking a beautiful beef brisket? “Look at all that juice!”

What does Mr Cole say to gee up his friends when they’re looking good? “Look at all that juice!”

And what does he say over and over again when you die and have to start the same checkpoint ad infinitum? You probably get the picture right now.

The only disadvantage about game dialogue taking place outside of control-stealing full-on cutscenes is those moments where you have to hear it repeatedly. Gears of War unfortunately is heavy on this kind of in-game storytelling, and there are several conversations that players are likely to hear repeatedly, especially on higher difficulties.

Without a doubt, the worst is the pumping station in Act 3’s Tip of the Iceberg chapter, where players encounter a squad of Theron Guards with one-hit-kill-capable Torque Bows.

Hearing this phrase over and over didn’t just become a meme amongst fans but also other developers. Dead Rising 2 pays homage with an achievement titled Look At All That Juice and even quite recently Halo Infinite included a cheeky reference on a visor cosmetic called Juice… and it all began as one infuriating checkpoint.


5. Riku - Kingdom Hearts

Kingdom Hearts Riku
Square Enix

Hearing the same single line time and time again is bad enough, but truly, the first thing that comes to mind when thinking of bad checkpoints are those that are placed before cutscenes.

What appeared to be a cutesy JRPG with Disney characters on the surface, Kingdom Hearts turned out to be a wildly complex story about hearts, keys, friendship, and betrayal (and that’s just in the first game, which feels quaint compared to the bombastic nature of all the others).

A particularly important and human thread throughout Kingdom Hearts is the complex relationship between Sora and Riku, which comes to a head later in the game when they’re both fighting for different sides. The two face-off against each other in a Keyblade battle that’s one of the toughest bosses in the title, no question.

Which makes it particularly irritating when Riku beats your face in - as he is likely to do - and you have to sit through the setup once more.

Two minutes doesn’t sound like a long time, but no gamer wants to spend their precious free time being forced to watch the same two minutes over and over again. Thankfully, later reiterations made this boss battle much more manageable, and, perhaps more importantly, added the ability to skip cutscenes.


4. Central Yarnham - Bloodborne

bloodborne central yarnham
FromSoftware

FromSoftware games and bashing one’s head against a metaphorical wall until you break through have become part and parcel with each other. After all, Dark Souls and its community popularised the “get good” mentality that makes many players afraid to admit where they’ve struggled.

Especially if that’s in the early game.

Bloodborne, while generally agreed to be one of the more approachable releases from the so-called Soulsborne series, has a pretty challenging start once players get through the prologue. When they’re dropped into Central Yarnham, gamers must fight their way through enemies with very few checkpoints along the way. Meaning, when you die - which you are bound to do - you must trek quite the way back to your previous point.

It's certainly a lesson that players need to learn, but it seems extra cruel to tuck the checkpoint before Father Gascoigne’s boss fight out of the way, so that many players actually miss it.

As for the other boss, the Cleric Beast, the closest lantern is actually on the other side of the fight, so you might find yourself becoming very familiar with the layout of Yarnham, shortcuts or no.


3. End Of The World - Sonic The Hedgehog 2006

Sonic 2006 End Of The World
Sega

This revival of Sonic the Hedgehog was supposed to revitalise the franchise but instead nearly killed it. Most players will back out of it after very little time with this bug-laden affair, so getting to End of the World is a real test of patience (and probably masochism).

This final stage is similar to Cannon’s Core, the last hurrah of the legendary Sonic Adventure 2, where players cycle through taking control of every character. As the ultimate test, both stages are tough by design. The major difference is that Cannon’s Core has a checkpoint at least between each character. It’s hard, but ultimately doable.

End of the World, in keeping with the bulls*** of Sonic '06, has absolutely no checkpoints whatsoever. You can get to the final seventh section as Shadow, die, and go all the way back to the beginning. And of course, like the rest of the game, it’s plagued with glitches and nonsense meaning that you can play your hardest and still die via means outside your control.

It is the foul icing on top of the bland and festering cake that is Sonic the Hedgehog 2006 so in that way, it’s the perfect send-off for the game. But players who have gone through three already pretty bad campaigns get no respite when, at the end of the game, they’re faced down with a stinker like End of the World.


2. Magatsu Inaba And Mandala - Persona 4

Persona 4 Mandala
Atlus

With Persona 3 and 4 recently launching on modern systems, new fans of the franchise have been able to go back and realise just how good they had it in P5. As great as these games are, they are certainly products of their time. Persona 3’s one gigantic dungeon is tedious compared to Persona 5’s exciting locales, and Persona 4’s final area is extremely punishing.

The game’s final dungeons, stacked back-to-back, are home to some truly aggressive enemies. Exploring Magatsu Inaba and Magatsu Mandala isn’t too bad, just time consuming, taking probably around 90 minutes depending on how frequent and how long your enemy encounters are. However, the issue is that between these two different areas, there isn’t a single checkpoint. For whatever reason, if you die on the final floor of Mandala, then you’re sent back to the start of Inaba.

And you don’t even have to die… some enemies are just able to send you back to the start by touch.

Add in a few mini-bosses along the way and that’s bad enough, but it somehow gets worse. At the end of this trek is a ton of classic JRPG exposition spread around the two final battles… again, all with no autosave whatsoever. Fall here, and you go right back to several hours ago. Brutal.


1. Every Level - Resistance: Fall Of Man

Resistance: Fall of Man
Sony Interactive Entertainment

Over the last few decades, gaming's most prominent genres have been whittled down to a science. There are certain things you're expected to do when developing a title - things that are considered the bare minimum. For FPS games, it’s frequent autosave placement.

When Resistance: Fall of Man launched, it was met with decently high praise, but it might be time to argue that it hasn’t aged well. Still, it’s hardly Insomniac Games’ fault that Call of Duty 4 was just around the corner, which would play a huge hand in standardising FPS controls and practices.

However, there were issues at the time which are even starker in the harsh light of current times… the checkpoint system feels positively unfinished.

Each of Resistance’s 11 missions only have a couple of worthwhile checkpoints each, turning the 12-hour campaign into one fraught with stress. It’s so easy to find yourself playing massive sections again and again because you made a mistake or were overwhelmed by enemies, which is very likely due to the game dumping an entire military convoy's worth of baddies on you ad nauseum.

There are sometimes multiple autosaves in a row when nothing is occurring, and other times, you’ll fight for 40 minutes without one popping. Halo’s checkpoints were bad and confusing, but five years later, Resistance: Fall of Man wasn’t faring any better.


Watch Next


Can You Name The PlayStation Exclusive Game From ONE Image?

Until Dawn
Sony

1. Which Game Is It?

Contributor

Coming from a content creation background that now spans over two decades, Psy cut her teeth on personal video production and community radio. Originally joining the team as a writer and presenter, she added video editing duties to her responsibilities over time and became the longest-standing editor of the irreverent gaming show Tues Your Own Adventure. Psy has worked on many previews and reviews, long-form editorials (either her own, or supporting as an editor), as a frequent quizmaster and more. Praised for the two-pronged attack of her hard work ethic and light-hearted editing style, Psy is otherwise known as a font of retro video game knowledge which has caused her to rack up many gaming quiz wins. Outside of WhatCulture, Psy runs First Aid Spray Podcast - a long-running channel that focuses on Resident Evil in all of it's forms. You can follow her on BlueSky at http://psywhite.bsky.social and Instagram at http://instagram.com/therealpsywhite