10 Most Unique Mystery Video Games Ever
Shove over, Agatha Christie. You're not the only mystery game in town anymore.
For the most analytical and questioning of minds, there's nothing quite like a good mystery.
Sure, there can be some excitement in trying to figure out how you misplaced your wallet, or what exactly you did after waking up with a pounding headache and several street signs scattered across the floor, but the sense of accomplishment when solving a real mind-breaking conundrum is a feeling we all love.
Not only is solving the mystery rewarding, but the journey is what makes or breaks the story. What good is a mystery without a little (or a lot of) suspense?
That very anxiety is what makes it so exciting.
Whether it be through movie thrillers or classic mystery novels, we're always trying to find the answers to the real questions. What happened here? Why did it happen? Who did it? Maybe it's an insightful metaphor for existence itself, but we'll talk about that another day.
Grab your camera, watch out for those twists, and remember to hold someone's hand as we talk about scores of games that present us with magnificently crafted mysteries.
10. Deadly Premonition
Holding a spot in the Guinness Book of World Records as the most "critically polarizing survival horror game," Access Games' Deadly Premonition truly lives up to its reputation.
Solving the mystery behind the death of an eighteen year old girl is the job assigned to Francis York Morgan, but you can call him 'York.'
Known as a talented FBI agent, York's strange behaviors and eccentric personality are what cements him as a truly endearing protagonist in the midst of this horror filled mystery.
Explore the fictional town of Greenvale, Washington in search of the girl, and come into contact with your normal, everyday supernatural beings living in the fog. Nothing out of the ordinary there.
Unfortunately, there's not too much else in the way of a synopsis for Deadly Premonition. It's a game that you will either love or hate, which is exactly why you should play it. Even if you end up disliking it, it's York's incredibly bizarre and unique journey that makes the game so memorable. Just be warned: you might not look at a tree in the same way ever again.
9. Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective
Here you are, a crumpled mess laying in the filth of the city dump. You must have had a bad day. Wait a minute...oh. You're dead. Hm, that's just terribly inconvenient, isn't it? Well, you can't just...float there all night. You need to find out what happened. How did you end up here? Who did this? And why can't you remember?
It's going to be a long night.
Written and directed by Ace Attorney's own Shu Takumi, Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective is one of the most aesthetically pleasing mystery games ever released.
Developed by Capcom, you play as Sissel, a ghost trying to figure out how he ended up dead. Armed with supernatural abilities the game describes as "ghost tricks," you only have one night to discover the events of the previous hours.
Praised for its beautifully rendered animation and extremely catchy original soundtrack, Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective puts a very different spin on how to go about solving mysteries. It's a brightly colored, gorgeously animated, underrated puzzle game that more people really should know about.
If you love Ace Attorney and want something slightly different and very unique, Ghost Trick is the game for you.
8. The Painscreek Killings
At first glance, this game looks like a walking simulator of a small sunny town reminiscent of Silent Hill (without all of the monsters and psychological nonsense). But what you'll discover when you start EQ Studios' The Painscreek Killings is one of the most immersive detective adventures you've ever seen in gaming.
Set in the fictional American town of Painscreek, you're tasked with investigating the cold-case murder of the mayor's wife. The residents have since left Painscreek and the land is going up for auction soon, so it's up to you to solve the murder before the evidence of the crime disappears.
Remove all of hand-holding from other detective games, and toss in a quaint semi-open world for the player to explore completely on their own, and that's what you'll find in The Painscreek Killings.
The beginning of the game advises you to keep a notebook handy and your wits about you. Puzzles and locked areas are have no hints. You must rely on your own deductive skills to solve the mystery.
If you find enjoyment out of detective themed games, The Painscreek Killings will provide you with the perfect challenge to test your skills.
7. Firewatch
To be clear, Firewatch is indeed a walking simulator, but it's a very unique one. Before the release of games like The Long Dark, Campos Santo's Firewatch gave us a completely new setting to explore and survive in - a remote American forest.
Seemingly filled with tame creatures and the occasional wolf who will only attack if provoked, the secrets of the forest don't seem to go too deep. The setting of the forest is different from the dark and mysterious jungles of Far Cry or the exotic thug-inhabited locations of Uncharted.
The kind of challenge you'll find in Firewatch is different. It's the solitude that can prove to be difficult depending on who you are. The feeling of safety that's non-existent in other games does exist in Firewatch, but there's a sense of fear and reverie that comes from living in the untamed forests of Wyoming. Reminder: it's not a survival game, it's a lesson.
Firewatch tells the story of Henry - a man escaping from his troubles by becoming a fire-watcher in the Shoshone National Forest in 1989. There is a mystery to be solved in this game, it's just not the one you were expecting.
6. Danganronpa Series
The thought of returning to a life of school sounds awful to most people. There were probably bullies, mean teachers, and tons of homework, but imagine being trapped there.
Not just trapped, but knowing that your only means of escape is to get away with murder. This all sounds confusing and nonsensical, but if you play the Danganronpa series, it'll soon become clear...well, sorta.
Developed by Spike Chunsoft, Danganronpa combines elements of classic Japanese visual novels, puzzle solving, and the now infamous Class Trial - the game where students debate to try to figure out who the killer is. Use your truth bullets and your powers of deduction to find the killer and put a stop to the evil killing game.
The entire mystery of Danganronpa is one that takes place over several games, but within each game, you'll have to take it upon yourself to solve the murders of your fellow classmates, while also trying to figure out how to escape without having to hurt anyone else.
The game's pop aesthetic doesn't take away from the suspense of it. You'll find yourself truly anxious as you walk around wondering if you're the next victim of the killing game.
5. Amnesia: The Dark Descent
Although the theme of the game is horror, there is a large mystery surrounding the events of Amnesia: The Dark Descent. Why did you wake up with your memory gone? Why is this castle so creepy? Where did these monsters come from? What's waiting in the Inner Sanctum?
Known for defining the horror genre with its unique mechanics that leave the player completely helpless and terrified, Frictional Games' Amnesia: The Dark Descent has you play as Daniel, a man with amnesia tasked with taking a dark descent through Brennenburg Castle on an order from his former self: "Find Alexander and kill him."
Since the development of Amnesia, many games have borrowed the mechanic of leaving the main character weaponless with only the darkness to hide them from threats.
Sanity meters are also a common sight in gaming. In Amnesia, and games since then, it's not so much about the gameplay itself, but the atmosphere of the game that gives life to the mystery and suspense the player feels while trekking through the darkness.
From the minute you wake up and find Daniel's note, you'll undoubtedly feel uneasy about completing this daunting task and solving the mystery of Daniel's plight.
4. L.A. Noire
The opportunity to solve a mystery as a hard boiled film noir detective is too good to pass up. Set in the Golden Age of Hollywood - when the noir mystery genre was born - LA Noire has you solving one of the most grisly and notorious homicide cases in history: The Black Dahlia.
In 1947, a young woman named Elizabeth Short was killed in a brutal fashion. Despite hundreds of suspects and years of police investigation, her killer was never found. In L.A. Noire, however, the Black Dahlia killer didn't stop with Elizabeth Short, he continued brutally murdering a number of women in the Los Angeles area. Along with a slew of other cases, L.A. Noire puts you in the shoes of Cole Phelps as he attempts to solve the case of the century.
Team Bondi's L.A. Noire is known for being one of the first successful motion capture games ever created. Although there is some disagreement upon whether or not it's a good game, the details of the story and the atmosphere can only count as positives. If you enjoy the feeling of nostalgia for post-WWII America, you should absolutely take some time to try L.A. Noire.
3. Murdered: Soul Suspect
Another story about a ghost solving his own murder, the theme of Murdered: Soul Suspect isn't so much about the murder itself, but the idea of moving on after settling your worldly accounts.
Set in one of the most unheard of locations in gaming, Airtight Games' Murdered: Soul Suspect has you investigating the circumstances surrounding the demise of Ronan O'Connor - a Salem, Massachusetts police officer. You'll uncover dark secrets about the history of the town and Ronan's own emotional story in this short, but very well done title.
A classic detective story with a supernatural twist, the game's atmosphere is perfect for those who enjoy Halloween and learning of the harrowing events of The Salem Witch Trials. You'll meet other ghosts in the game and even engage in some otherworldly combat while trying to figure out how Ronan was killed. Although brief and not incredibly challenging, Murdered: Soul Suspect is a tiny gem of a title that's worth the eight or so hours of play time.
Ronan is undeniably likable, and you'll feel the New England charm of Salem as you play. Become immersed in the short mystery and you'll find yourself having an enjoyable weekend.
2. Ace Attorney Series
Known for its witty humor, colorful sprites, memorable characters, and captivating mysteries, Capcom's Ace Attorney series is something you should definitely check out if you haven't already.
With more than six games in the line-up, Ace Attorney's story is much more interesting than your average detective adventure. Throughout the arcs of the series, you'll play as defense attorneys Phoenix Wright and Apollo Justice, as well as prosecutor Miles Edgeworth.
Each case has its own unique way of presenting the classic "who dun it" scenario, and turns the everyday job of being an attorney into an entertaining experience that will leave you on the edge of your seat. Not only is the story interesting, but every character is so full of charm and charisma that even your rivals will turn into some of your favorite people.
The villains are exceptional too, the locations you investigate are so fun to explore, and the overarching story is one that tugs at your heartstrings.
With a little bit of charm, a little bit of luck, and a whole lot of bluffing, you'll live up to that Ace Attorney name and always get the right verdict.
1. Zero Escape Series
It's a game that not many people talk about. The plot is nearly impossible to describe, but the main idea is simple: you're trapped in a locked place with no memory of how you got there, and have to rely on the other random people trapped with you in order to escape.
Between psychological puzzles and a constant sense of dread and suspense, Zero Escape's complicated plot will get your blood pumping and mind reeling.
Developed by Chunsoft, the "Nonary Games" will make you wonder how trusting you would be when death and punishment is just around the corner if you choose to put your faith in the wrong person. Lessons about historical events, behavioral experiments, and random facts about physics and math are littered throughout the game.
As you uncover the mystery of what the purpose of the twisted game is, you'll be able to experience many different endings that will altogether put the story in perspective. If you enjoy puzzles, suspense, mystery, and many twists and turns, it's a guarantee that you'll enjoy almost every minute of "Nine Hours, Nine Persons, Nine Doors," "Zero Escape: Virtues Last Reward," and "Zero Time Escape."