10 Obvious Video Game Plot Holes NO ONE Talks About

None of this adds up.

uncharted 4 elena
Naughty Dog

In the old days, video games like Space Invaders and Pac-Man didn't have anything that resembled a plot. Up until the 1990s, the storyline of most titles simply boiled down to "save the world".

But in recent years, world-building and character development in gaming has received more focus. Even though the gameplay of Undertale, Mass Effect, and Bioshock is phenomenal, it's the stories that make these games stand out.

But since the industry is highlighting the narrative more than ever, plotholes have become more apparent. If developers are making the tenth entry in a franchise, they can't be expected to know what happened in every previous title. In situations like this, it's not uncommon for the narrative to contradict elements from an earlier game.

When the developers want a sequel to go in a new direction, it might conflict or flat-out ignore details of its predecessor. More often than not, a plothole occurs in a game simply because the creative team behind it forgot the rules they established previously.

Even though the games on this list are awesome, it doesn't change the fact that the plot doesn't always make sense.

10. Snake Didn't Need To Enter The Microwave Room - Metal Gear Solid IV

Metal Gear Solid 4
Konami

In the climax of MSG4, Old Snake and Raiden reach the entrance to the server room, which allows them access to the GW AI.

To deter unauthorised personnel from entering, the corridor is lined with microwaves that can boil the water in a person's body. Knowing that passing through the hallway is basically a suicide mission, Snake strides through anyway to reach the server room.

But since Raiden is basically a machine at this point, it would've made far more sense for him to perform this dangerous task.

Now, you could rationalise this, since Snake was dying anyway and he wanted to go out with a bang, but Snake is so ill at this point, he can barely walk. His heart nearly gives out just before reaching the corridor.

If he had a heart attack halfway through, Raiden and the rest of his allies would've been screwed.

Raiden, on the other hand, can move at superspeed, so he can zip in and out of the server room before suffering irreparable injuries. It's obvious the writers made Snake perform this mission to depict him as the selfless hero, even though his reason for doing so didn't really add up.


9. Elena's Teleporting Skills - Uncharted: Drake's Fortune & Uncharted 4

uncharted 4 elena
Naughty Dog

In the Uncharted series, Nathan Drake is regularly assisted by journalist and tv personality, Elena Fischer. Although she hopes to join Nathan in his first treasure hunt, Sully convinces Nathan to abandon Elena in Panama, giving her no indication where they're going next.

But not only does Elena figure out Nathan is heading to Amazon, she finds him despite the fact the rainforest is over two million square miles! (By comparison, that's three times bigger than Texas and 20 times the size of the UK.)

You could forgive this leap of logic if it was a one-time thing. But she does it again in Uncharted 4! While Nathan finds himself stranded in Madagascar, Elena manages to find him simply by "following gunfire".

In Elena's defence, she is such an astounding journalist, it's possible she could've figured out Nathan was heading to Madagascar. And since she knows Nathan so well by this point and has a knack for adventuring herself, she would have some idea which regions he would be looking for treasure. But since Madagascar is the world's fourth largest island, the chances of being in the same neck of the woods as Nate are practically zero.


8. Big Daddy's Prototype Is Better Than The Official One - Bioshock 2

bioshock 2
2K Games

BioShock wasn't just a great game, but a work of art. 2K Games' masterful title had an Ayn Rand-inspired storyline filled with provocative characters, a relentlessly tense atmosphere, and breathtaking gameplay.

Even though many elements like the Little Sister and the "Would You Kindly?" mantra have now been immortalised in the gaming industry, one factor that grabbed everyone's attention was the Big Daddy.

This hulking brute was an instant hit with fans, inspiring the developers to make BD the main character in the sequel. Unfortunately, a Big Daddy isn't really "protagonist material" since they're too big to fit through a doorway, and have the agility of a dead tortoise.

To get around this, the team behind BioShock 2 had the story revolve around a prototype Big Daddy who is smaller, faster, and more agile. Even though the official Daddy could only attack with its drill arm, this chap is capable of using a large variety of weapons and plasmids.

Which begs the question: Why isn't the prototype the official Big Daddy? It's better in every way, so why did his designer, Dr Yi Suchong, make the final version bulkier, slower, and less efficient??


7. How Is Ada Alive? - Resident Evil 2

Ada Wong resident evil 2
Capcom

In Resident Evil 2, Leon S. Kennedy finds himself in the middle of a zombie infestation on his first day as a cop. While trying to escape the city, he bumps into a mysterious woman called Ada Wong. Despite evading his questions and repeatedly disappearing with little notice, Leon sees her as an ally.

But in the climax, Ada reveals she used Leon to locate the zombie G-virus. But during this revelation, Ada is shot by a third party, causing her to fall down a shaft. (This sequence is more heartbreaking if you play it the B mission, since Ada admits she loves Leon before drawing her final breath.)

However, this emotional scene is ruined since Ada appears later without explanation to help Leon against the penultimate boss.

When Leon runs into Ada again during the events in RE4, he is shocked to see her. However, the only reason he's surprised is because she's working with the nefarious virologist, Wesker. Really, Leon? THAT'S what shocks you? Not the whole... being alive part?!

What's more annoying is Capcom could've fixed this plothole in the 2019 version of RE2. But in this remake, Ada's fall has remained unchanged, meaning there's still no explanation for how she survived.


6. The Game Breaks Its Own Rules Immediately - Life Is Strange

Life is Strange Ending Max
Dontnod

Life Is Strange follows a photographer called Max who learns she can rewind time. When she sees a classmate kill her childhood friend in the school bathroom, Max instinctively using her powers for the first time, returning her to her classroom shortly before the murder took place.

However, this is the only time where Max returns to her original, physical position when she time-travels. Every other time, she stays exactly where she is. This inconsistency is extra confusing since this is the first time we've seen Max utilise her powers so we assume they'll always work like this.

Some players point out Max moved position the first time she time-travelled since she had yet to master her powers. However, being able to move in time AND space is a lot more handy, so it doesn't make sense why she loses this ability after she becomes more efficient with her rewinding skills.

You could forgive this irregularity if it was needed for the sake of the narrative. But it isn't. If her powers worked the same to begin with as they do for the rest of the game, it wouldn't have affected the opening sequence at all.


5. Rakghouls Can't Infect You - Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic

KOTOR Rakghoul
Lucasarts

While exploring the slums in Knights of the Old Republic, you'll be warned by the locals that the area is infested with mutants called rakghouls. If anyone gets bitten or scratched by these abominations, they will transform into a rakghoul within hours. Unless an infected gets their hands on an extremely rare antidote, there's nothing that can stop them mutating into these ghoulish creatures.

At least, that's what you're told.

In battle, you are guaranteed to be swiped at by the rakghouls on a number of occasions. Even though rakghouls are pretty hard to kill, (especially when they come at you in large numbers), it's impossible for your character to get infected by these little buggers.

At first, you might think you're immune to the disease because you're a Force wielder. But since your allies are also resistant to the infection despite not being attuned with the Force, this theory doesn't hold water.

Annoyingly, this inconsistency could've been cleared up if it was explained that some people have an immunity to the disease. But since nothing like this isn't mentioned, we are left with a blatant plothole.


4. Samus Keeps Killing "The Last Metroid" - Metroid (Series)

Metroid Dread Samus
Nintendo

In Metroid, galactic bounty hunter, Samus Aran, travels the galaxy to destroy the Space Pirates that murdered her parents. These creatures intend to create a biological weapon, using the DNA of a Metroid parasite.

In Super Metroid, the last Metroid in existence sacrifices its life to save Samus from the monstrous Mother Brain. Although the Metroid's sacrifice served a great cause, its actions led directly to the species' extinction.

Except... it totally didn't.

In sequel, Metroid: Other M, it turns out the Metroids are still around because... reasons. Later in the conclusion, Samus destroys the Metroid station, rendering them extinct... again.

But in Metroid Fusion, the sneaky parasites reveal they're still alive! Despite blowing them up in the climax (for the third time), it's revealed in Metroid Dread that... once again... they're not dead. Since Samus' life was saved with Metroid DNA in the past, she is technically considered a Metroid, meaning the creatures can never truly die while she lives.

Even though Samus "killed" the last Metroid a number of times, it's safe to assume these critters will keep popping up in future instalments.


3. Super Nova IS The Meteor Sephiroth Needs - Final Fantasy VII

Final Fantasy 7 Safer Sephiroth
Square Enix

In Final Fantasy VII, Sephiroth is driven insane after learning he was created from extra-terrestrial DNA for a genetic experiment. Consumed with rage, he summons a meteor that will collide into Earth in a matter of days, killing everyone.

But during the final battle, Sephiroth's plan seems a bit nonsensical once he performs his most iconic attack, Super Nova.

This magical spell calls upon a meteor to enter the Solar System, obliterating Pluto, Saturn and Jupiter, before causing the Sun to explode, because why not. The blast engulfs Mercury and Venus before devastating Earth, leaving your party with a fraction of health.

But if Sephiroth can conjure this spell any time he wants, why is he stuck conjuring a far slower and weaker meteor to destroy Earth? Of all the possible attacks Sephiroth could've had, why did the developers give him one that contradicts the entire plot?

It's also odd how this enchantment can't kill your party, despite the fact it destroys a chunk of the Milky Way galaxy. Super Nova may be epic and cinematic, but it doesn't make a lick of sense.


2. Unemployment Is A Serious Problem... Supposedly - Detroit: Become Human

detroit become human
Quantic Dream

Detroit: Become Human takes place in a future where androids have become commonplace. Being easy and cheap to manufacture, it isn't long before the workplace mostly consists of these lifelike robots. This inevitably leads to a serious social gap, causing unemployment in Michigan to skyrocket. With humans growing resentful and an android uprising looming, society looks like its ready to tear itself apart.

Even though Detroit has a fascinating premise, there's one crucial element in the plot that doesn't sit right.

The story emphasises how the dependency on androids has caused the city to experience an astounding 35% unemployment. But if you weren't told this, the player wouldn't notice over a third of the population is out of a job.

Even though The Great Depression was the worst financial period in US history, unemployment was never higher than 25%. If Detroit's unemployment was 35%, (and eventually increases to 40%) the city should be in absolute chaos.

You do see a few protestors and homeless people throughout the streets, but nothing to suggest the city was on the verge of economical collapse.


1. Why Doesn't Kronika Time-Travel To Kill Her Enemies? - Mortal Kombat 11

Mortal Kombat 11 kronika
NetherRealm

In Mortal Kombat, the God of Thunder, Raiden, has spent centuries safeguarding Earthrealm from hostile universes by taking part in a multiversal fighting tournament. But in MK11, Raiden learns all his actions have been manipulated by the time-weaving titan, Kronika.

Not only has Kronika masterminded the tournament for eons, she intends to restart all of reality when the current Mortal Kombat concludes.

Fortunately, heroes from multiple Realms and timelines come together to stop Kronika from undoing reality, defeating her once and for all. However, it doesn't seem feasible for Kronika to be defeated since she is basically a walking time-machine.

On a number of occasions, she showcases her ability to stop time. Why doesn't she reverse time when her enemies disrupt her plans? Why doesn't she go back in time and kill the kombatants when they were in babies?

At one point, she uses her chronological powers to freeze Earthrealm's champions in place. Instead of killing everyone then and there, she instead uses this opportunity to taunt Raiden.

Annoyingly, this is merely one of thousands of examples where Kronika could've effortlessly eliminated her enemies... but chose not to.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Uncharted 4
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

James Egan has been with Whatculture for five years and prominently works on Horror, Film, and Video Games. He's written over 80 books including 1000 Facts about Horror Movies Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about The Greatest Films Ever Made Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about Video Games Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts About James Bond 1000 Facts About TV Shows