10 Overhyped Game Mechanics That Were A Complete Disappointment

"256 endings"? Yeah right.

Until dawn game
Supermassive Games

The video game industry runs on hype. In order for a game to get good coverage upon release, it needs to excite a potential audience with something that sets it apart from other titles.

However, because capturing your interest is so important, sometimes developers sell their project a little too well, leading to general disappointment and many bitter outcries when expectations aren't met.

This is especially true in the case of overhyped game mechanics. Developers will promise that their games will include revolutionary new features that will completely change the way you think about certain genres, only to present you with something really generic, or worse, an unfinished mess that feels all the more insulting because of the promised potential.

At one point, these mechanics were the talk of the town. They were supposed to be the next big thing, but in the end, they delivered nothing but disappointment and resentment. If you fell for the hype back in the day, the following list will probably hurt all the more badly.

10. Realistic Interrogations - L.A. Noire

LA Noire
Rockstar Games

L.A. Noire is one of the more ambitious Rockstar projects when it comes to innovation. The game’s goal was to create a realistic 1940’s detective experience by making the witnesses and suspects express the most subtle emotions on their faces with the latest motion-capture technologies.

Well, “latest” by the standards of 2011, which is probably why this revolutionary feature ended up looking more comical than immersive. Instead of serving as a window into the suspect's psyche, the expressions your character’s interviewees made were either stupidly easy to read or so grotesquely contorted that you had to double check if you were still talking to a human being and not some sort of malfunctioning shapeshifter.

You can’t deny L.A. Noire's ambition but its core mechanics simply aren’t as impressive as its developers anticipated, especially when you come back to the game nowadays. It makes for an entertaining spectacle in the vein of a circus show, but if you’re looking for a proper interrogator simulator, you unfortunately need to search for it elsewhere.

Well, at least Detective Phelps’ drawings looked really good.


9. Hacking - Watch Dogs

watch dogs game 2014
Ubisoft

As far as Ubisoft’s franchises go, Watch Dogs is one of the most controversial ones. The series has a very vocal group of haters online, and most people would agree that its first installment is not nearly as impressive as the trailers made it out to be.

The core element of Watch Dogs’ gameplay is hacking. You play as a rogue hacker who’s capable of jacking into things like people’s phones and even Chicago’s entire traffic control system.

The 2013 trailers for the game made the hacking look as though it would make your character a digital god, capable of turning off electronic devices in the entire city with one click of the button and sowing wireless chaos wherever he went.

However, when the excited players finally got their hands on Watch Dogs, the reality definitely didn't match the expectations.

Not only were the hacking mechanics not nearly as cinematic and advanced as their trailer counterparts, but the game was also filled with bugs, which made even the most impressive of your abilities, like stopping and controlling cars, look like an absolute joke.

Maybe the developers should’ve learned how to fix software problems before trying to emulate hackers who create them.


8. Create Your Own Sonic Character - Sonic Forces

Sonic Forces Custom Characters
Sega

In terms of SEGA’s worst, Sonic Forces is definitely up there. After years of releasing mediocre Sonic games, it's hard to get too excited about the next without adding a caveat of "unless they screw it up". Forces manages to do very little to make a case against the argument that 3D Sonic had gotten stale to the point of soullessness.

The greatest testament to this is the most overhyped feature of the game: the character creator.

The 2017 announcements for Forces were proudly boasting about the title allowing the player to create their very own Sonic character, basically fulfilling the dreams of every Sonic fan out there.

However, the character creator in the game is done in such a lazy and lackluster way that even the most hardcore SEGA fan can’t get anything out of it. The game limits you to only one body type, a small handful of animal species to pick from, and then a pitiful selection of clothes that looks like a poor college freshman’s wardrobe.

Even when you try to recreate already existing characters with this creator, like Sonic or Shadow, your creations end up looking like cheap knockoffs.

It's actually a pretty good summary of how this character creator feels when compared to other modern creators.


7. Character Creation - Cyberpunk 2077

Cyberpunk 2077
CD Projekt RED

Although Cyberpunk 2077 has been trying to make up for its initial flop with patches and the new DLC, it's still undeniable that its original release was a huge betrayal of people's expectations. The most frequently lamented part of Cyberpunk is the game-breaking bugs plaguing the streets of Night City.

However, another big concern were the undelivered promises regarding the game's mechanics, one of which was the underwhelming character creator.

The teasers and previews for the game boasted about character creation being an incredibly expansive and immersive experience. Everything was supposed to be customizable, from the character's body parts and cybernetics to their life path and origin story. Not only that, the changes you made would greatly impact the gameplay by unlocking new features and special dialogue options.

Suffice it to say, the released version of the mechanics was severely watered down. The features were present in the game, but the appearance customization was reduced to basic sliders, and the cybernetics and lifestyle options barely made any difference, providing only a handful of minor changes to the game.

It's the type of uninspired experience that no Samurai would want to wake up for.


6. Settlement Building - Fallout 4

fallout 4 settlements
Bethesda

In 2015, Fallout 4 was one of the most discussed topics on the internet. You wouldn’t be able to come across a site that wasn’t talking about or hyping up the series' fourth installment in some way. Well, maybe, unless it was an old lady's Facebook page.

One of the most frequently teased mechanics that Bethesda couldn’t stop talking about was the new settlement building feature. The mechanic was supposed to allow the player to populate the barren wasteland of the Commonwealth and turn even the most desolate junkyard into a vital part of the region’s community.

However, as is usually the case with Todd’s sweet little lies, the end product left much to be desired. Though the system would allow you to populate select parts of the Commonwealth (emphasis on "select"), the building mechanics were very limited. You only had a few building materials at your disposal, and each building location had a restrictive limit on the number of objects you could place.

Not to mention the members of your new community were all generic, lifeless settlers with hobbies like clipping through walls and refusing to follow basic pathfinding.

In other words, your typical Bethesda NPCs.


5. 256 Endings - Until Dawn

Until Dawn 03
Supermassive Games

Every time a new major Supermassive release comes out, the same bold claim begins to circulate on the internet: the game includes a ridiculously high number of endings.

The Quarry supposedly has 186 endings, and Supermassive's original horror title, Until Dawn, has 256. But is this really true?

Well, anyone who's played these games can tell you, with full confidence and frustration, no. There are actually only three distinct endings: one for saving everyone, one for letting everyone die, and one for saving only a few people.

The big numbers actually refer to the combinations of choices that can lead to these endings. The combinations don't actually impact anything at all, however, as each survivor responds in the same exact way to their companions' survival or deaths, regardless of how many or how little you manage to save.

The hype surrounding Supermassive's endings is not only misleading–it also makes for a really disappointing experience once you decide to replay either one of their major releases.

The moment you realize you sunk another few hours just to get the same generic line of dialogue out of your characters is the moment when uninstalling the game is probably the most merciful thing you can do.


4. Going Full Open World - Dragon Age: Inquisition

Dragon Age Inquisition bears
Bioware

Dragon Age is a series that changes themes more frequently than some people change their bedsheets.

Starting off as a classic RPG with a slightly low fantasy angle, it transformed into an open-world high fantasy experience that is supposedly going to add God of War-style combat in the next instalment, Dreadwolf.

But for now, let's talk about the shift towards open-world gameplay. Mainly how it turned out to be a lot less fun than it should've been.

Before Dragon Age: Inquisition was released, many of the series' fans were quite excited by BioWare's announcement of adding open-world exploration to the title. It felt as though it would finally let players fully immerse themselves in Dragon Age's world, finding new exciting places to visit and discovering more about the famous regions in the game.

Unfortunately, the open world ended up being the weakest part of the Inquisition. The explorable regions were barely populated by anything, and aside from a few landmarks here and there, the landscape looked generic and boring.

It felt like the maps were put there to pad the game's runtime more than anything, preventing you from reaching the actually fun story parts of Inquistion.


3. Randomized Galaxy - No Man's Sky

no mans sky creatures
Hello Games/GamesBeat

In terms of levels of uncontained hype and the global disappointment that followed, No Man's Sky is easily up there with Cyberpunk 2077. Admittedly, the game has been releasing frequent updates over the years that majorly improve the experience, but it is still nowhere near the potential everyone expected.

Before its underwhelming release, No Man's Sky was seen as one of the most ambitious open-world projects, in large part thanks to the promised mechanics that were supposed to create a unique, one-of-a-kind galaxy for each and every player.

Every solar system, moon, and planet were supposed to be randomly generated, starting with the basics like planets' shapes and locations and ending with more specific parts like flora and fauna.

To say this didn't happen would be a big understatement. No Man's Sky's random generation actually turned out to be procedural, and pretty terrible procedural at that.

The planets all looked identical, barren, and generic, and the animals resembled improperly assembled Lego characters rather than actual creatures.

Instead of a boundless galaxy to explore, No Man's Sky ended up being a repetitive trek through empty dirt patches, with an occasional abomination of nature to laugh and cry about.


2. Morality System - Fable

Fable chicken
Microsoft

Over the years Peter Molyneux, the creator of Black and White and the Fable series, has gained a reputation as an overselling conman within the gaming community. His notoriety can be mostly attributed to his exaggerated promises of Fable's hyper-advanced mechanics.

If you were to trust Molyneux's words back in 2004, just like many other excited gamers had, Fable would have felt like an almost lifelike experience. The game was going to let you experience your character's life in its entirety, have children with your spouse, and have its world evolve right before your eyes, as showcased by Molyneux's infamous example of a tiny acorn growing into a tree.

But did any of that actually end up in Fable?

Well... no.

The game included none of the above-mentioned mechanics, and those that were present felt basic and gimmicky at best.

The game was still fun, of course, but when the producer promised you that you'd be able to see every wrinkle appearing on your character's face in real time and all you get is a bunch of lazy time skips and prerendered models, it's hard not to feel disappointed.


1. Species Evolution - Spore

Spore Tribal
Maxis

The lost potential of the god simulator Spore is one of the greatest disappointments in gaming history. The number of projects like Species and Thrive that try to revive Will Wright's original vision of Spore should be a good testament to that.

During the early development of Spore in 2004 and 2005, the game was going in a completely different direction than the final product. Spore was aiming to be a more realistic experience featuring more detailed graphics and game mechanics like additional evolution stages, more in-depth creature customization, and an actual exploration of planets during the space stage.

Eventually, however, a part of the development team came to the conclusion that the game would be more appealing to a wider audience if it adopted a more simplified and cartoonish approach to life simulation, in a similar vein to Maxis' hit Sims series.

This idea was later adapted by the rest of the developers, and Spore was turned into the watered-down, kid-friendly version of itself that became the final product.

This said, the footage of the original realistic Spore has not been forgotten, and to this day, many players wonder about what could've been.


Watch Next


Contributor

Video games enthusiast with a love for bizarre facts about his favorite titles. Really into old-school strategies and RPGs of all shapes and sizes.